Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / StarTrekVoyagerTechnology

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** Tuvok was on a special assignment to spy on the Maquis, but still under Captain Janeway's command, making Voyager the ship that would go after him - witness how often that the respective crews of the other series set out to rescue their missing and captured crewmates. Tom Paris was picked as an expert because he'd actually been involved with Chakotay's cell before being sent to the penal colony - that's why he was IN the penal colony, he'd simply been discharged from Starfleet over the accident that killed his fellow cadets. And as for the distance between Earth and the Badlands... That distance is intentionally kept vague - DS9, Bajor, and the Cardassian border are meant to be on the edge of Federation space, but then we also have an episode like Homefront/Paradise Lost where the crew make it between the distance in a short period of time. It does help that runabouts, the primary mode of transportation in DS9's first two seasons, were said to have a maximum warp on the lower end of the spectrum, around warp three-ish. Meanwhile a ship like Voyager, capable of a cruising speed in the warp nine range, could make that journey much faster.

to:

** Tuvok was on a special assignment to spy on the Maquis, but still under Captain Janeway's command, making Voyager the ship that would go after him - witness how often that the respective crews of the other series set out to rescue their missing and captured crewmates. Tom Paris was picked as an expert because he'd actually been involved with Chakotay's cell before being sent to the penal colony - that's why he was IN the penal colony, he'd simply been discharged from Starfleet over the accident that killed his fellow cadets. And as for the distance between Earth and the Badlands... That distance is intentionally kept vague - DS9, [=DS9=], Bajor, and the Cardassian border are meant to be on the edge of Federation space, but then we also have an episode like Homefront/Paradise Lost where the crew make it between the distance in a short period of time. It does help that runabouts, the primary mode of transportation in DS9's [=DS9=]'s first two seasons, were said to have a maximum warp on the lower end of the spectrum, around warp three-ish. Meanwhile a ship like Voyager, capable of a cruising speed in the warp nine range, could make that journey much faster.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And Series/StarTrekEnterprise firmly established that a private dining area reserved for the captain and a small number of guests was included in the first proper Starfleet vessel sent into deep-exploration missions, so this is easily the kind of thing that could be considered a Starfleet design tradition. On the successive Enterprises, they may have gone for the more formal dining areas for diplomatic receptions, but on a smaller ship like Voyager, a private dining area would be the right size.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** And Series/StarTrekProdigy, set only a few years after the end of Voyager, would later establish that the USS Protostar is equipped with the vehicle replicator, essentially a 3-D printer for shuttles. Sure, Voyager itself didn't say they had one, but 3-D printing wasn't on the radar back with Voyager was in production, so [[TechnologyMarchesOn technology marched on]] and it's being retconned into use in that time.

to:

*** And Series/StarTrekProdigy, WesternAnimation/StarTrekProdigy, set only a few years after the end of Voyager, would later establish that the USS Protostar is equipped with the vehicle replicator, essentially a 3-D printer for shuttles. Sure, Voyager itself didn't say they had one, but 3-D printing wasn't on the radar back with Voyager was in production, so [[TechnologyMarchesOn technology marched on]] and it's being retconned into use in that time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** And Series/StarTrekProdigy, set only a few years after the end of Voyager, would later establish that the USS Protostar is equipped with the vehicle replicator, essentially a 3-D printer for shuttles. Sure, Voyager itself didn't say they had one, but 3-D printing wasn't on the radar back with Voyager was in production, so [[TechnologyMarchesOn technology marched on]] and it's being retconned into use in that time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Tuvok was on a special assignment to spy on the Maquis, but still under Captain Janeway's command, making Voyager the ship that would go after him - witness how often that the respective crews of the other series set out to rescue their missing and captured crewmates. Tom Paris was picked as an expert because he'd actually been involved with Chakotay's cell before being sent to the penal colony - that's why he was IN the penal colony, he'd simply been discharged from Starfleet over the accident that killed his fellow cadets. And as for the distance between Earth and the Badlands... That distance is intentionally kept vague - DS9, Bajor, and the Cardassian border are meant to be on the edge of Federation space, but then we also have an episode like Homefront/Paradise Lost where the crew make it between the distance in a short period of time. It does help that runabouts, the primary mode of transportation in DS9's first two seasons, were said to have a maximum warp on the lower end of the spectrum, around warp three-ish. Meanwhile a ship like Voyager, capable of a cruising speed in the warp nine range, could make that journey much faster.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I believe the deciding factor in using the holodeck for either the sexual or combat solutions would be whether the Vulcan in question is able to get something genuine out of it or if they'd just be too aware of it being fake. It worked for Tuvok because he could use the image as a focus for his real wife but Voric couldn't even bring himself to try. The same would likely be true for the combat aspect, if was someone they genuinely saw as a rival/obstacle to mating with their selected partner then a holographic representation of them may provide the necessary emotional relief, but if not it'd likely fail. Ultimately it's all about achieving the emotional release to end the Pon Far.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Suppose they did make that change. What guarantee is there that it still wouldn't malfunction? What difference would "ignore this action" and "ignore this object" make as far as the holodeck's WeirdnessCensor is concerned? We have absolutely no idea what kind of code or hardware runs the holodeck, or any other 24th century technology, meaning we have no basis on which to hypothesize a technical solution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Bear in mind that, in the case of Neelix's holographic lungs, they had to actually function as anatomically correct lungs in order to keep him alive. Torres' fake baby was just that: a fake. It only needed to create the illusion of pregnancy, not simulate an entire working baby inside her body. Furthermore, it's a point that Talaxian lungs are more physiologically complex than those of other humanoids, which necessitated extreme precision that could not be achieved without keeping Neelix immobile. Torres' projection, on the other hand, could be off by a millimeter or two without being noticeable because, again, it's only superficial.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, regarding the last point about Picard still being able to hear the Borg post-assimilation, that has been explained in Season 3 of ''Series/StarTrekPicard''. Locutus was an experiment in assimilation on a genetic/biochemical level that caused him to still act as a receiver for the collective consciousness even absent all of his technological implants. That's why he's always been treated as "special" by the Borg Queen(s).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It could be a case of TechnologyMarchesOn, as Voyager and the Defiant aren’t Galaxy-class starships, nor were in existence at the time that episode took place. Materials that made the Enterprise may have been replaced by better material that made it resistant to baryon particles so that they’re not required as doing the sweep often (much like how PEEK and polyimide are resistant to gamma radiation and X-rays). Also, another thing to take into account is what is explained in the episode of “Starship Mine”: the Enterprise needed a stronger than usual sweep because it spent more time in war in five years than most ships did in ten. So, as long as Voyager isn’t constantly doing warp speed (as we’ve seen multiple times in the series’ run that they often had to run her sublight to explore, gather supplies, etc), Voyager was nowhere near the level of baryon particles that the D was, and they made it back in seven years, putting her three years back in the Alpha Quadrant before a sweep is needed to be done (not that it matters, as Voyager was decommissioned shortly after she got back).

to:

*** It could be a case of TechnologyMarchesOn, as Voyager and the Defiant aren’t Galaxy-class starships, nor were in existence at the time that episode took place. Materials that made the Enterprise may have been replaced by better material that made it resistant to baryon particles so that they’re not required as doing the sweep often (much like how PEEK and polyimide are resistant to gamma radiation and X-rays). Also, another thing to take into account is what is explained in the episode of “Starship Mine”: the Enterprise needed a stronger than usual sweep because it spent more time in war warp in five years than most ships did in ten. So, as long as Voyager isn’t constantly doing warp speed (as we’ve seen multiple times in the series’ run that they often had to run her sublight to explore, gather supplies, etc), Voyager was nowhere near the level of baryon particles that the D was, and they made it back in seven years, putting her three years back in the Alpha Quadrant before a sweep is needed to be done (not that it matters, as Voyager was decommissioned shortly after she got back).

Added: 176

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Considering the size of the area that is Neelix’s kitchen, it does seem big enough for the Captain, a couple of other people and a table to make this possibility plausible.



* In "Demons", Neelix was extremely fussy about sleeping conditions yet he jumped at the chance to seep in sick bay. Aren't sickbay consoles composed of glass or plexiglass like MRI machines? Maybe Talaxian anatomy is conducive to that but there were a lot of humans who followed Neelix into sickbay

to:

* In "Demons", Neelix was extremely fussy about sleeping conditions yet he jumped at the chance to seep sleep in sick bay. Aren't sickbay consoles composed of glass or plexiglass like MRI machines? Maybe Talaxian anatomy is conducive to that but there were a lot of humans who followed Neelix into sickbay
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It could be a case of TechnologyMarchesOn, as Voyager and the Defiant aren’t Galaxy-class starships, nor were in existence at the time that episode took place. Materials that made the Enterprise may have been replaced by better material that made it resistant to baryon particles so that they’re not required as doing the sweep often (much like how PEEK and polyimide are resistant to gamma radiation and X-rays). Also, another thing to take into account is what is explained in the episode of “Starship Mine”: the Enterprise needed a stronger than usual sweep because it spent more time in war in five years than most ships did in ten. So, as long as Voyager isn’t constantly doing warp speed (as we’ve seen multiple times in the series’ run, Voyager was nowhere near the level of baryon particles that the D was, and they made it back in seven years, putting her three years back in the Alpha Quadrant before a sweep is needed to be done (not that it matters, as Voyager was decommissioned shortly after she got back).

to:

*** It could be a case of TechnologyMarchesOn, as Voyager and the Defiant aren’t Galaxy-class starships, nor were in existence at the time that episode took place. Materials that made the Enterprise may have been replaced by better material that made it resistant to baryon particles so that they’re not required as doing the sweep often (much like how PEEK and polyimide are resistant to gamma radiation and X-rays). Also, another thing to take into account is what is explained in the episode of “Starship Mine”: the Enterprise needed a stronger than usual sweep because it spent more time in war in five years than most ships did in ten. So, as long as Voyager isn’t constantly doing warp speed (as we’ve seen multiple times in the series’ run, run that they often had to run her sublight to explore, gather supplies, etc), Voyager was nowhere near the level of baryon particles that the D was, and they made it back in seven years, putting her three years back in the Alpha Quadrant before a sweep is needed to be done (not that it matters, as Voyager was decommissioned shortly after she got back).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It could be a case of TechnologyMarchesOn, as Voyager and the Defiant aren’t Galaxy-class starships, nor were in existence at the time that episode took place. Materials that made the Enterprise may have been replaced by better material that made it resistant to baryon particles so that they’re not required as doing the sweep often (much like how PEEK and polyimide are resistant to gamma radiation and X-rays). Also, another thing to take into account is what is explained in the episode of “Starship Mine”: the Enterprise needed a stronger than usual sweep because it spent more time in war in five years than most ships did in ten. So, as long as Voyager isn’t constantly doing warp speed (as we’ve seen multiple times in the series’ run, Voyager was nowhere near the level of baryon particles that the D was, and they made it back in seven years, putting her three years back in the Alpha Quadrant before a sweep is needed to be done (not that it matters, as Voyager was decommissioned shortly after she got back).

to:

*** **** It could be a case of TechnologyMarchesOn, as Voyager and the Defiant aren’t Galaxy-class starships, nor were in existence at the time that episode took place. Materials that made the Enterprise may have been replaced by better material that made it resistant to baryon particles so that they’re not required as doing the sweep often (much like how PEEK and polyimide are resistant to gamma radiation and X-rays). Also, another thing to take into account is what is explained in the episode of “Starship Mine”: the Enterprise needed a stronger than usual sweep because it spent more time in war in five years than most ships did in ten. So, as long as Voyager isn’t constantly doing warp speed (as we’ve seen multiple times in the series’ run, Voyager was nowhere near the level of baryon particles that the D was, and they made it back in seven years, putting her three years back in the Alpha Quadrant before a sweep is needed to be done (not that it matters, as Voyager was decommissioned shortly after she got back).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It could be a case of TechnologyMarchesOn, as Voyager and the Defiant aren’t Galaxy-class starships, nor were in existence at the time that episode took place. Materials that made the Enterprise may have been replaced by better material that made it resistant to baryon particles so that they’re not required as doing the sweep often (much like how PEEK and polyimide are resistant to gamma radiation and X-rays). Also, another thing to take into account is what is explained in the episode of “Starship Mine”: the Enterprise needed a stronger than usual sweep because it spent more time in war in five years than most ships did in ten. So, as long as Voyager isn’t constantly doing warp speed (as we’ve seen multiple times in the series’ run, Voyager was nowhere near the level of baryon particles that the D was, and they made it back in seven years, putting her three years back in the Alpha Quadrant before a sweep is needed to be done.

to:

*** It could be a case of TechnologyMarchesOn, as Voyager and the Defiant aren’t Galaxy-class starships, nor were in existence at the time that episode took place. Materials that made the Enterprise may have been replaced by better material that made it resistant to baryon particles so that they’re not required as doing the sweep often (much like how PEEK and polyimide are resistant to gamma radiation and X-rays). Also, another thing to take into account is what is explained in the episode of “Starship Mine”: the Enterprise needed a stronger than usual sweep because it spent more time in war in five years than most ships did in ten. So, as long as Voyager isn’t constantly doing warp speed (as we’ve seen multiple times in the series’ run, Voyager was nowhere near the level of baryon particles that the D was, and they made it back in seven years, putting her three years back in the Alpha Quadrant before a sweep is needed to be done.done (not that it matters, as Voyager was decommissioned shortly after she got back).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** It could be a case of TechnologyMarchesOn, as Voyager and the Defiant aren’t Galaxy-class starships, nor were in existence at the time that episode took place. Materials that made the Enterprise may have been replaced by better material that made it resistant to baryon particles so that they’re not required as doing the sweep often (much like how PEEK and polyimide are resistant to gamma radiation and X-rays). Also, another thing to take into account is what is explained in the episode of “Starship Mine”: the Enterprise needed a stronger than usual sweep because it spent more time in war in five years than most ships did in ten. So, as long as Voyager isn’t constantly doing warp speed (as we’ve seen multiple times in the series’ run, Voyager was nowhere near the level of baryon particles that the D was, and they made it back in seven years, putting her three years back in the Alpha Quadrant before a sweep is needed to be done.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In addition, it's explicitly stated at the end of the Part 2 that the neural inhibitors that kept them from being integrated into the hive mind made the extraction process easier. Because Tuvok's inhibitor started to wear off, his recovery was more challenging.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[/folder


to:

[[/folder

[[/folder]]

Added: 9

Changed: 823

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n[[folder: Crell Moset hologram should not be defending the actions of the real Crell Moset]]
* In the episode "Nothing Human", when the doctor discovers that the real Crell Moset is a war criminal, the holographic program of Crell Moset tries to defend the actions of the real one. But why would he do that? The hologram is based on what the federation thinks of Crell Moset. The federation doesn't know Crell Moset is a war criminal, and neither did the doctor when he created the program. Therefore, the hologram he created of Crell Moset should not be defending the inhumane medical experiments carried out be the real Crell. The hologram should be just as horrified by them as the Doctor is, right? Why would the hologram defend the actions of the real Crell when he isn't programed to be in favor of such actions?
[[/folder

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Critical Research Failure is a disambiguation page


** Yeah, this was either a CriticalResearchFailure on the part of the writers, or complete contempt for the intelligence of their viewers. Deuterium is a common isotope of hydrogen, and hydrogen is the most ubiquitous element in the universe. Most high school chemistry students should be able to tell you that.
*** It's not CriticalResearchFailure, it's ScienceMarchesOn. The short answer is that Bussard Collectors don't actually work that way, it turns out that the energy lost to drag exceeds anything they could hope to recover.

to:

** Yeah, this was either a CriticalResearchFailure mistake on the part of the writers, or complete contempt for the intelligence of their viewers. Deuterium is a common isotope of hydrogen, and hydrogen is the most ubiquitous element in the universe. Most high school chemistry students should be able to tell you that.
*** It's not CriticalResearchFailure, a mistake, it's ScienceMarchesOn. The short answer is that Bussard Collectors don't actually work that way, it turns out that the energy lost to drag exceeds anything they could hope to recover.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n[[/folder]]

Added: 1026

Changed: 37

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[folder: Escort through Borg space]]
* Part of Janeway's arrangement with the Borg centered around the Borg taking Voyager through their space. Putting aside the answer "because that would end the show then and there," why does no one suggest that the Borg use their transwarp abilities to just drop off Voyager, rather than conventional warp travel? The transwarp corridor used in "Descent" would be known to Voyager, and the Borg could easily have dropped Voyager through their space, or given them a transwarp coil like Voyager would later seek to steal from the Borg directly. Obviously, the Borg were never going to uphold their end of the agreement and intended to assimilate Voyager as soon as Janeway gave them the information that they wanted, but there were faster methods of travelling through Borg space that Voyager and her crew never even seem to acknowledge than just relying on conventional warp. Why don't any of the Voyager crew mention these methods, particularly methods that they already knew about and later do seek to acquire from the Borg?

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added science details about bussard collectors

Added DiffLines:

*** It's not CriticalResearchFailure, it's ScienceMarchesOn. The short answer is that Bussard Collectors don't actually work that way, it turns out that the energy lost to drag exceeds anything they could hope to recover.


Added DiffLines:

**** Except that doesn't work either

Top