Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / SleepingBeauty

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why ''couldn't'' Merryweather turn Malecifent into a toad. anyway? Flora and Fauna say that their magic can only bring happiness, but turning her into a toad ''would've'' made Merryweather happy, and probably a lot of other people, too.

to:

* Why ''couldn't'' Merryweather turn Malecifent into a toad. anyway? Flora and Fauna say that their magic can only bring happiness, but turning her into a toad ''would've'' made Merryweather happy, and probably a lot of other people, too.too.
** Because Maleficent is magical too, and much more powerful than them. She'd probably be not only able to turn herself back to normal, but to also return the favor considerably.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It appeared as if that were Merriweather's responsibility before to do cooking--but, yes, it's implied Aurora never got a splendid birthday before. After she leaves, the fairies exclaim "What she be surprised! A real birthday party! With a real birthday cake!". It's possible she just got a much more simple celebration, like a specially-cooked dinner and a new quilt for her bed. Flora says outright that it's Fauna's last chance to bake a cake--afterwards she'll have magic and no reason to. The simply assumed they'd be better at it then they were.

to:

** It appeared as if that were Merriweather's responsibility before to do cooking--but, yes, it's implied Aurora never got a splendid birthday before. After she leaves, the fairies exclaim "What she be surprised! A real birthday party! With a real birthday cake!". It's possible she just got a much more simple celebration, like a specially-cooked dinner and a new quilt for her bed. Flora says outright that it's Fauna's last chance to bake a cake--afterwards she'll have magic and no reason to. The simply assumed they'd be better at it then they were.were.
* Why ''couldn't'' Merryweather turn Malecifent into a toad. anyway? Flora and Fauna say that their magic can only bring happiness, but turning her into a toad ''would've'' made Merryweather happy, and probably a lot of other people, too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Flora and Fauna already blessed her that she would grow up with beauty and grace, so she was more or less protected from dying as an infant. Malificient more or less states this in the curse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A troper on the FridgeLogic page suggested that Malificent's magic, being more powerful than that of the good fairies, overruled everyones common sense and forced the events to play out as they did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The three good fairies have had Aurora/Briar Rose for sixteen years - but Fauna has 'never cooked'? What, did they order takeout for every meal? And have they just ignored all of Aurora/Briar Rose's birthdays up until now?

to:

* The three good fairies have had Aurora/Briar Rose for sixteen years - but Fauna has 'never cooked'? What, did they order takeout for every meal? And have they just ignored all of Aurora/Briar Rose's birthdays up until now?now?
** It appeared as if that were Merriweather's responsibility before to do cooking--but, yes, it's implied Aurora never got a splendid birthday before. After she leaves, the fairies exclaim "What she be surprised! A real birthday party! With a real birthday cake!". It's possible she just got a much more simple celebration, like a specially-cooked dinner and a new quilt for her bed. Flora says outright that it's Fauna's last chance to bake a cake--afterwards she'll have magic and no reason to. The simply assumed they'd be better at it then they were.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** See LargeHam for why she made the curse that way in the first place; more dramatic. As for why she didn't kill her herself; why do you think she had her mooks searching for Aurora for 16 years?

to:

** See LargeHam for why she made the curse that way in the first place; more dramatic. As for why she didn't kill her herself; why do you think she had her mooks searching for Aurora for 16 years?years?
* The three good fairies have had Aurora/Briar Rose for sixteen years - but Fauna has 'never cooked'? What, did they order takeout for every meal? And have they just ignored all of Aurora/Briar Rose's birthdays up until now?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So...why would Maleficent need Aurora to prick her finger on her 16th birthday? Why didn't she just try to kill her as a baby?

to:

* So...why would Maleficent need Aurora to prick her finger on her 16th birthday? Why didn't she just try to kill her as a baby?baby?
** See LargeHam for why she made the curse that way in the first place; more dramatic. As for why she didn't kill her herself; why do you think she had her mooks searching for Aurora for 16 years?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's never specified ''where'' they told the King and Queen. Or how.

to:

** It's never specified ''where'' they told the King and Queen. Or how.how.
* So...why would Maleficent need Aurora to prick her finger on her 16th birthday? Why didn't she just try to kill her as a baby?

Changed: 86

Removed: 238

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't they just wait until her 17th birthday to reveal Aurora's identity? We could have avoided this whole mess if they'd just waited until then. Or hell, even the day after her Sweet Sixteen would have broken the prophecy.

to:

* Why didn't they just wait until after her 17th 16th birthday to reveal Aurora's identity? We could have avoided this whole mess if they'd just waited until then. Or hell, even the day after her Sweet Sixteen would have broken the prophecy.then.



** It's never specified ''where'' they told the King and Queen. Or how.
* How come Merryweather didn't say as her wish retcon "And she will fall asleep for about five minutes, then wake up"?
** I assume she couldn't change Malificents curse that easily and there had to be some requirement for Aurora to wake up

to:

** It's never specified ''where'' they told the King and Queen. Or how.
* How come Merryweather didn't say as her wish retcon "And she will fall asleep for about five minutes, then wake up"?
** I assume she couldn't change Malificents curse that easily and there had to be some requirement for Aurora to wake up
how.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How come Merryweather didn't say as her wish retcon "And she will fall asleep for about five minutes, then wake up"?

to:

* How come Merryweather didn't say as her wish retcon "And she will fall asleep for about five minutes, then wake up"?up"?
**I assume she couldn't change Malificents curse that easily and there had to be some requirement for Aurora to wake up
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How come Merryweather didn't say "And she will fall asleep for about five minutes, then wake up"?

to:

* How come Merryweather didn't say as her wish retcon "And she will fall asleep for about five minutes, then wake up"?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's never specified ''where'' they told the King and Queen. Or how.

to:

** It's never specified ''where'' they told the King and Queen. Or how.how.
* How come Merryweather didn't say "And she will fall asleep for about five minutes, then wake up"?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

!!Disney version
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The three fairies lock themselves into a lantern to discuss their plans. This is so Malificent can't overhear. Then they reveal the whole plan to the king and queen, out in the open. What, Malificent didn't overhear that?

to:

* The three fairies lock themselves into a lantern to discuss their plans. This is so Malificent can't overhear. Then they reveal the whole plan to the king and queen, out in the open. What, Malificent Maleficent didn't overhear that?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The three fairies lock themselves into a lantern to discuss their plans. This is so Malificent can't overhear. Then they reveal the whole plan to the king and queen, out in the open. What, Malificent didn't overhear that?

to:

* The three fairies lock themselves into a lantern to discuss their plans. This is so Malificent can't overhear. Then they reveal the whole plan to the king and queen, out in the open. What, Malificent didn't overhear that?that?
** It's never specified ''where'' they told the King and Queen. Or how.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Maybe it was something her parents demanded because they betrothed her at birth. Chances are they had to pull her in ASAP because she met a guy in the woods and probably would have eloped because during those times, being 16 would have meant that she could technically do that.

to:

** Maybe it was something her parents demanded because they betrothed her at birth. Chances are they had to pull her in ASAP because she met a guy in the woods and probably would have eloped because during those times, being 16 would have meant that she could technically do that.that.
* The three fairies lock themselves into a lantern to discuss their plans. This is so Malificent can't overhear. Then they reveal the whole plan to the king and queen, out in the open. What, Malificent didn't overhear that?

Changed: 82

Removed: 319

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't they just wait until her 17th birthday to reveal Aurora's identity? We could have avoided this whole mess if they'd just waited until then, instead of thinking going back in the ''middle of the fateful day'' was safe. Or hell, even the day after her sweet sixteen would have broken the prophecy.
** Maybe it was something her parents demanded because they betrothed her at birth. Chances are they had to pull her in ASAP because she met a guy in the woods and probably would have eloped because during those times, being 16 would have meant that she could technically do that.
* So the three fairies have been living without any magic for sixteen years while they raise Aurora. How the hell do they not know how to bake or sew? Seriously, the scenes with them struggling with the cake and the dress would make much more sense if set during their first few days out, not after a decade and a half.

to:

* Why didn't they just wait until her 17th birthday to reveal Aurora's identity? We could have avoided this whole mess if they'd just waited until then, instead of thinking going back in the ''middle of the fateful day'' was safe. then. Or hell, even the day after her sweet sixteen Sweet Sixteen would have broken the prophecy.
** Maybe it was something her parents demanded because they betrothed her at birth. Chances are they had to pull her in ASAP because she met a guy in the woods and probably would have eloped because during those times, being 16 would have meant that she could technically do that.
* So the three fairies have been living without any magic for sixteen years while they raise Aurora. How the hell do they not know how to bake or sew? Seriously, the scenes with them struggling with the cake and the dress would make much more sense if set during their first few days out, not after a decade and a half.
that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Maybe it was something her parents demanded because they betrothed her at birth. Chances are they had to pull her in ASAP because she met a guy in the woods and probably would have eloped because during those times, being 16 would have meant that she could technically do that.

to:

** Maybe it was something her parents demanded because they betrothed her at birth. Chances are they had to pull her in ASAP because she met a guy in the woods and probably would have eloped because during those times, being 16 would have meant that she could technically do that.that.
* So the three fairies have been living without any magic for sixteen years while they raise Aurora. How the hell do they not know how to bake or sew? Seriously, the scenes with them struggling with the cake and the dress would make much more sense if set during their first few days out, not after a decade and a half.

Removed: 115

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Maleficent prophecy wasn\'t for a specific day. It was for a specific time period - 16 years.


** Maybe it was something her parents demanded because they betrothed her at birth. Chances are they had to pull her in ASAP because she met a guy in the woods and probably would have eloped because during those times, being 16 would have meant that she could technically do that.
* Why was she taken away for the full sixteen years when there is one specific day in which she would be in danger?

to:

** Maybe it was something her parents demanded because they betrothed her at birth. Chances are they had to pull her in ASAP because she met a guy in the woods and probably would have eloped because during those times, being 16 would have meant that she could technically do that.
* Why was she taken away for the full sixteen years when there is one specific day in which she would be in danger?
that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Maybe it was something her parents demanded because they betrothed her at birth. Chances are they had to pull her in ASAP because she met a guy in the woods and probably would have eloped because during those times, being 16 would have meant that she could technically do that.

to:

** Maybe it was something her parents demanded because they betrothed her at birth. Chances are they had to pull her in ASAP because she met a guy in the woods and probably would have eloped because during those times, being 16 would have meant that she could technically do that.that.
* Why was she taken away for the full sixteen years when there is one specific day in which she would be in danger?

Changed: 12

Removed: 2384

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't they just wait until her seventeenth birthday to reveal Aurora's identity? We could have avoided this whole mess if they'd just waited until then, instead of thinking going back in the ''middle of the fateful day'' was safe. Or hell, even the day after her sweet sixteen would have broken the prophecy.
** Maybe it was something her parents demanded because they betrothed her at birth. Chances are they had to pull her in ASAP because she met a guy in the woods and probably would have eloped because during those times, being 16 would have meant that she could technically do that.
* No sequels? Really Disney? She's a DisneyPrincess for Pete's sake.. I'm sure Disney can think of an obscure idea.
** Considering the quality of most Disney Sequels, I'd say BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor. However, does anyone ever notice how [[EvilIsCool Maleficent]] [[SpotlightStealingSquad gets all the press?]] Not that that bothers me in and of itself...she ''was'' awesome...but the Good Fairies, and even Phillip, were enjoyable characters in their own right as well. I'd like to see more of them, too. Aurora as well, if she only had a brain. >.<
** Um, she ''did'' get a sequel. A half hour long one. And it was complete and utter rot. After getting married to a man she barely knows, and living with parents she never knew, she is abandoned to run the kingdom completely on her own for a while. Then she grabbed a magic wand and caused wacky hijinks, before learning that using magic is bad. When an angry mob shows up because she flooded the kingdom with cows, giant chickens, and green pigs, she solves the problem by saying "I will talk to each and everyone of you, but while you are waiting, who wants a free cow?" They then lift her up and sing praises of how she is the greatest princess ever. It was horrid.
** Sleeping Beauty is a fairytale, along with Snow White and Cinderella. Once you've told them, there's nothing left. The princesses get a literal Happily Ever After. As nice as that is, it means no conflict, and no conflict means no entertainment. Look how the sequels to Cinderella turned out. The 2nd movie was basically a bunch of short tales strung together, probably some failed TV series. The 3rd had to literally have time be turned back so Cinderella had to try and get the prince to fall in love with her again. That's now little these kinds of stories leave you to work with.
* It's a "Disgrace to the Forces of Evil" when the mooks reveal that they've been searching for a baby these sixteen long years. And that was Bad. Since Bad means Evil, Maleficent should have been reveling in the evilness of it rather than [[{{Understatement}} enraged]].
** Bad as in evil and bad as in low-quality are different concepts.
** Why in gods name would she be reveling about being unable to kill a baby? If "sucking at accomplishing anything" counted as evil, than her just sitting on her couch chugging a beer and watching tv all day would be the greatest sin possible.

to:

* Why didn't they just wait until her seventeenth 17th birthday to reveal Aurora's identity? We could have avoided this whole mess if they'd just waited until then, instead of thinking going back in the ''middle of the fateful day'' was safe. Or hell, even the day after her sweet sixteen would have broken the prophecy.
** Maybe it was something her parents demanded because they betrothed her at birth. Chances are they had to pull her in ASAP because she met a guy in the woods and probably would have eloped because during those times, being 16 would have meant that she could technically do that. \n* No sequels? Really Disney? She's a DisneyPrincess for Pete's sake.. I'm sure Disney can think of an obscure idea.\n** Considering the quality of most Disney Sequels, I'd say BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor. However, does anyone ever notice how [[EvilIsCool Maleficent]] [[SpotlightStealingSquad gets all the press?]] Not that that bothers me in and of itself...she ''was'' awesome...but the Good Fairies, and even Phillip, were enjoyable characters in their own right as well. I'd like to see more of them, too. Aurora as well, if she only had a brain. >.<\n** Um, she ''did'' get a sequel. A half hour long one. And it was complete and utter rot. After getting married to a man she barely knows, and living with parents she never knew, she is abandoned to run the kingdom completely on her own for a while. Then she grabbed a magic wand and caused wacky hijinks, before learning that using magic is bad. When an angry mob shows up because she flooded the kingdom with cows, giant chickens, and green pigs, she solves the problem by saying "I will talk to each and everyone of you, but while you are waiting, who wants a free cow?" They then lift her up and sing praises of how she is the greatest princess ever. It was horrid.\n** Sleeping Beauty is a fairytale, along with Snow White and Cinderella. Once you've told them, there's nothing left. The princesses get a literal Happily Ever After. As nice as that is, it means no conflict, and no conflict means no entertainment. Look how the sequels to Cinderella turned out. The 2nd movie was basically a bunch of short tales strung together, probably some failed TV series. The 3rd had to literally have time be turned back so Cinderella had to try and get the prince to fall in love with her again. That's now little these kinds of stories leave you to work with.\n* It's a "Disgrace to the Forces of Evil" when the mooks reveal that they've been searching for a baby these sixteen long years. And that was Bad. Since Bad means Evil, Maleficent should have been reveling in the evilness of it rather than [[{{Understatement}} enraged]].\n** Bad as in evil and bad as in low-quality are different concepts.\n** Why in gods name would she be reveling about being unable to kill a baby? If "sucking at accomplishing anything" counted as evil, than her just sitting on her couch chugging a beer and watching tv all day would be the greatest sin possible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe it was something her parents demanded because they betrothed her at birth. Chances are they had to pull her in ASAP because she met a guy in the woods and probably would have eloped because during those times, being 16 would have meant that she could technically do that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Why in gods name would she be reveling about being unable to kill a baby? If "sucking at accomplishing anything" counted as evil, than her just sitting on her couch chugging a beer and watching tv all day would be the greatest sin possible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Bad as in evil and bad as in low-quality are different concepts.

Added: 273

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sleeping Beauty is a fairytale, along with Snow White and Cinderella. Once you've told them, there's nothing left. The princesses get a literall Happily Ever After. As nice as that is, it means no conflict, and no conflict means no entertainment. Look how the sequels to Cinderella turned out. The 2nd movie was basically a bunch of short tales strung together, probably some failed TV series. The 3rd had to literally have time be turned back so Cinderella had to try and get the prince to fall in love with her again. That's now little these kinds of stories leave you to work with.

to:

** Sleeping Beauty is a fairytale, along with Snow White and Cinderella. Once you've told them, there's nothing left. The princesses get a literall literal Happily Ever After. As nice as that is, it means no conflict, and no conflict means no entertainment. Look how the sequels to Cinderella turned out. The 2nd movie was basically a bunch of short tales strung together, probably some failed TV series. The 3rd had to literally have time be turned back so Cinderella had to try and get the prince to fall in love with her again. That's now little these kinds of stories leave you to work with.with.
* It's a "Disgrace to the Forces of Evil" when the mooks reveal that they've been searching for a baby these sixteen long years. And that was Bad. Since Bad means Evil, Maleficent should have been reveling in the evilness of it rather than [[{{Understatement}} enraged]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
why were these deleted? As far as I can see they fit the description of \"it just bugs me\".

Added DiffLines:

* Why didn't they just wait until her seventeenth birthday to reveal Aurora's identity? We could have avoided this whole mess if they'd just waited until then, instead of thinking going back in the ''middle of the fateful day'' was safe. Or hell, even the day after her sweet sixteen would have broken the prophecy.
* No sequels? Really Disney? She's a DisneyPrincess for Pete's sake.. I'm sure Disney can think of an obscure idea.
** Considering the quality of most Disney Sequels, I'd say BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor. However, does anyone ever notice how [[EvilIsCool Maleficent]] [[SpotlightStealingSquad gets all the press?]] Not that that bothers me in and of itself...she ''was'' awesome...but the Good Fairies, and even Phillip, were enjoyable characters in their own right as well. I'd like to see more of them, too. Aurora as well, if she only had a brain. >.<
** Um, she ''did'' get a sequel. A half hour long one. And it was complete and utter rot. After getting married to a man she barely knows, and living with parents she never knew, she is abandoned to run the kingdom completely on her own for a while. Then she grabbed a magic wand and caused wacky hijinks, before learning that using magic is bad. When an angry mob shows up because she flooded the kingdom with cows, giant chickens, and green pigs, she solves the problem by saying "I will talk to each and everyone of you, but while you are waiting, who wants a free cow?" They then lift her up and sing praises of how she is the greatest princess ever. It was horrid.
** Sleeping Beauty is a fairytale, along with Snow White and Cinderella. Once you've told them, there's nothing left. The princesses get a literall Happily Ever After. As nice as that is, it means no conflict, and no conflict means no entertainment. Look how the sequels to Cinderella turned out. The 2nd movie was basically a bunch of short tales strung together, probably some failed TV series. The 3rd had to literally have time be turned back so Cinderella had to try and get the prince to fall in love with her again. That's now little these kinds of stories leave you to work with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why didn't they just wait until her seventeenth birthday to reveal Aurora's identity? We could have avoided this whole mess if they'd just waited until then, instead of thinking going back in the ''middle of the fateful day'' was safe. Or hell, even the day after her sweet sixteen would have broken the prophecy.
* No sequels? Really Disney? She's a DisneyPrincess for Pete's sake.. I'm sure Disney can think of an obscure idea.
** Considering the quality of most Disney Sequels, I'd say BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor. However, does anyone ever notice how [[EvilIsCool Maleficent]] [[SpotlightStealingSquad gets all the press?]] Not that that bothers me in and of itself...she ''was'' awesome...but the Good Fairies, and even Phillip, were enjoyable characters in their own right as well. I'd like to see more of them, too. Aurora as well, if she only had a brain. >.<
** Um, she ''did'' get a sequel. A half hour long one. And it was complete and utter rot. After getting married to a man she barely knows, and living with parents she never knew, she is abandoned to run the kingdom completely on her own for a while. Then she grabbed a magic wand and caused wacky hijinks, before learning that using magic is bad. When an angry mob shows up because she flooded the kingdom with cows, giant chickens, and green pigs, she solves the problem by saying "I will talk to each and everyone of you, but while you are waiting, who wants a free cow?" They then lift her up and sing praises of how she is the greatest princess ever. It was horrid.
** Sleeping Beauty is a fairytale, along with Snow White and Cinderella. Once you've told them, there's nothing left. The princesses get a literall Happily Ever After. As nice as that is, it means no conflict, and no conflict means no entertainment. Look how the sequels to Cinderella turned out. The 2nd movie was basically a bunch of short tales strung together, probably some failed TV series. The 3rd had to literally have time be turned back so Cinderella had to try and get the prince to fall in love with her again. That's now little these kinds of stories leave you to work with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sleeping Beauty is a fairytale, along with Snow White and Cinderella. Once you've told them, there's nothing left. The princesses get a literall Happily ever After. As nice as that is, it means no conflict, and no conflict means no entertainment. Look how the sequels to Cinderella turned out. The 2nd movie was basically a bunch of short tales strung together, probably some failed Tv series. The 3rd had to literally have time be turned back so Cinderella had to try and get the prince to fall in love with her again. That's now little these kinds of stories leave.

to:

** Sleeping Beauty is a fairytale, along with Snow White and Cinderella. Once you've told them, there's nothing left. The princesses get a literall Happily ever Ever After. As nice as that is, it means no conflict, and no conflict means no entertainment. Look how the sequels to Cinderella turned out. The 2nd movie was basically a bunch of short tales strung together, probably some failed Tv TV series. The 3rd had to literally have time be turned back so Cinderella had to try and get the prince to fall in love with her again. That's now little these kinds of stories leave.leave you to work with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Um, she ''did'' get a sequel. A half hour long one. And it was complete and utter rot. After getting married to a man she barely knows, and living with parents she never knew, she is abandoned to run the kingdom completely on her own for a while. Then she grabbed a magic wand and caused wacky hijinks, before learning that using magic is bad. When an angry mob shows up because she flooded the kingdom with cows, giant chickens, and green pigs, she solves the problem by saying "I will talk to each and everyone of you, but while you are waiting, who wants a free cow?" They then lift her up and sing praises of how she is the greatest princess ever. It was horrid.

to:

** Um, she ''did'' get a sequel. A half hour long one. And it was complete and utter rot. After getting married to a man she barely knows, and living with parents she never knew, she is abandoned to run the kingdom completely on her own for a while. Then she grabbed a magic wand and caused wacky hijinks, before learning that using magic is bad. When an angry mob shows up because she flooded the kingdom with cows, giant chickens, and green pigs, she solves the problem by saying "I will talk to each and everyone of you, but while you are waiting, who wants a free cow?" They then lift her up and sing praises of how she is the greatest princess ever. It was horrid.horrid.
** Sleeping Beauty is a fairytale, along with Snow White and Cinderella. Once you've told them, there's nothing left. The princesses get a literall Happily ever After. As nice as that is, it means no conflict, and no conflict means no entertainment. Look how the sequels to Cinderella turned out. The 2nd movie was basically a bunch of short tales strung together, probably some failed Tv series. The 3rd had to literally have time be turned back so Cinderella had to try and get the prince to fall in love with her again. That's now little these kinds of stories leave.

Top