Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / GreekMythology

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Sadly ruined by the film adaptation, though. Jarring considering the author of the books actually knows his Greek mythology well, yet the damned filmmakers [[Main/TheyJustDidntCare. just didn't care!]] *facepalm*

to:

*** Sadly ruined by the film adaptation, though. Jarring considering the author of the books actually knows his Greek mythology well, yet the damned filmmakers [[Main/TheyJustDidntCare. just didn't care!]] TheyJustDidntCare! *facepalm*
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Sadly ruined by the film adaptation, though. Jarring considering the author of the books actually knows his Greek mythology well, yet the damned filmmakers JustDidntCare. *facepalm*

to:

*** Sadly ruined by the film adaptation, though. Jarring considering the author of the books actually knows his Greek mythology well, yet the damned filmmakers JustDidntCare. [[Main/TheyJustDidntCare. just didn't care!]] *facepalm*
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** So there you have it. Lesbianism: Worse than bestiality! [[ValuesResonance Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** SatanicHamster: Umm, ''XenaWarriorPrincess'' and ''HerculesTheLegendaryJourneys''? In those series, he's one of the more decent and respectable of the Gods.

to:

** SatanicHamster: Umm, ''XenaWarriorPrincess'' ''Series/XenaWarriorPrincess'' and ''HerculesTheLegendaryJourneys''? In those series, he's one of the more decent and respectable of the Gods.



** Because he '''can''' and to quote, HistoryOfTheWorldPartOne "It's good to be the king." Think about it: he gets credit for rescuing his siblings and kicking his dad's ass, he has the most powerful weapon in all of Greek mythology and the ''one'' time a revolt starts, it's only by chaining him in bed while he slept and despite being outnumbered, there was a collective OhCrap from the entire pantheon the second he got free. Face it, he is AsskickingEqualsAuthority and WishFulfillment incarnate.

to:

** Because he '''can''' and to quote, HistoryOfTheWorldPartOne ''Film/HistoryOfTheWorldPartI'' "It's good to be the king." Think about it: he gets credit for rescuing his siblings and kicking his dad's ass, he has the most powerful weapon in all of Greek mythology and the ''one'' time a revolt starts, it's only by chaining him in bed while he slept and despite being outnumbered, there was a collective OhCrap from the entire pantheon the second he got free. Face it, he is AsskickingEqualsAuthority and WishFulfillment incarnate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just trying to fix some borked text. Here\'s hoping.


*** There is not that much resemblance between Ares and Mars. Ares was the god of brute strength and love of battle with Athena being the Goddess of skilfully conducted military operations. As Mars developed into a God of War the aspects he took on were closer to Athena’s than Ares’ as those were more Roman.

to:

*** There is not that much resemblance between Ares and Mars. Ares was the god of brute strength and love of battle with Athena being the Goddess of skilfully conducted military operations. As Mars developed into a God of War the aspects he took on were closer to Athena’s Athena's than Ares’ Ares' as those were more Roman.



**** That ''is'' how you get demi-Gods like Hercules and Cúchulainn. Just be careful what you wish for. Zeus could show up as a giant bull.

to:

**** That ''is'' how you get demi-Gods like Hercules and Cúchulainn.Cú Chulainn. Just be careful what you wish for. Zeus could show up as a giant bull.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The ''Literature/{{Myth-O-Mania}}'' books present him as a decent, usually friendly guy (if a bit of a DeadpanSnarker) who made a couple of mistakes and got hugely slandered by his uppity little brother and the guy's [[IHateYouVampireDad unaffiliated]] [[LadyOfWar daughter]] and [[StopHelpingMe idiot mortal sons]]. It's a PerspectiveFlip, but still...

to:

** The ''Literature/{{Myth-O-Mania}}'' ''Literature/MythOMania'' books present him as a decent, usually friendly guy (if a bit of a DeadpanSnarker) who made a couple of mistakes and got hugely slandered by his uppity little brother and the guy's [[IHateYouVampireDad unaffiliated]] [[LadyOfWar daughter]] and [[StopHelpingMe idiot mortal sons]]. It's a PerspectiveFlip, but still...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I think the text from Metamorphoses about Iphis and Ianthe demonstrates why there aren't many lesbians in Roman myth, at least:

to:

** I think the text this excerpt from Metamorphoses about Iphis and Ianthe demonstrates why there aren't many lesbians in Roman myth, at least:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->'''Iphis:''' Hardly restraining her tears, she said ‘What way out is there left, for me, possessed by the pain of a strange and monstrous love, that no one ever knew before? If the gods wanted to spare me they should have spared me, but if they wanted to destroy me, they might at least have visited on me a natural, and normal, misfortune. Mares do not burn with love for mares, or heifers for heifers: the ram inflames the ewe: its hind follows the stag. So, birds mate, and among all animals, not one female is attacked by lust for a female. I wish I were not one! Yet that Crete might not fail to bear every monstrosity, Pasiphaë, Sol’s daughter, loved a bull, though still that was a female and a male. My love, truth be told, is more extreme than that. She at least chased after the hope of fulfilment, though the bull had her because of her deceit, and in the likeness of a cow, and the one who was deceived was a male adulterer.

to:

->'''Iphis:''' -->'''Iphis:''' Hardly restraining her tears, she said ‘What way out is there left, for me, possessed by the pain of a strange and monstrous love, that no one ever knew before? If the gods wanted to spare me they should have spared me, but if they wanted to destroy me, they might at least have visited on me a natural, and normal, misfortune. Mares do not burn with love for mares, or heifers for heifers: the ram inflames the ewe: its hind follows the stag. So, birds mate, and among all animals, not one female is attacked by lust for a female. I wish I were not one! Yet that Crete might not fail to bear every monstrosity, Pasiphaë, Sol’s daughter, loved a bull, though still that was a female and a male. My love, truth be told, is more extreme than that. She at least chased after the hope of fulfilment, though the bull had her because of her deceit, and in the likeness of a cow, and the one who was deceived was a male adulterer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I think the text from Metamorphoses about Iphis and Ianthe demonstrates why there aren't many lesbians in Roman myth, at least:
->'''Iphis:''' Hardly restraining her tears, she said ‘What way out is there left, for me, possessed by the pain of a strange and monstrous love, that no one ever knew before? If the gods wanted to spare me they should have spared me, but if they wanted to destroy me, they might at least have visited on me a natural, and normal, misfortune. Mares do not burn with love for mares, or heifers for heifers: the ram inflames the ewe: its hind follows the stag. So, birds mate, and among all animals, not one female is attacked by lust for a female. I wish I were not one! Yet that Crete might not fail to bear every monstrosity, Pasiphaë, Sol’s daughter, loved a bull, though still that was a female and a male. My love, truth be told, is more extreme than that. She at least chased after the hope of fulfilment, though the bull had her because of her deceit, and in the likeness of a cow, and the one who was deceived was a male adulterer.
** So there you have it. Lesbianism: Worse than bestiality! [[ValuesResonance Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****** Also, Hecate, Erebus, and Nyx aren't actually evil, [[DarkIsNotEvil just a bit creepy]]. Hell, Hecate even did a few nice things for other people, which in this pantheon makes her practically a saint.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Reply to stoned atlas
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Reply to stoned atlas

Added DiffLines:

** Either it is talking mountains or the effects wear off in you are immortal. Also there is the practices of assimilating the local gods and stories into the main pantheon thus lots of contradictions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****[[http://www.theoi.com/Olympios/AresWrath.html Ares rarely screwed around with anybody outside of war.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Perseus used Medusa's head to turn Atlas into stone, [[JustSoStory creating the Atlas mountains]]. Perseus begat Alcaeus and Electryon, one of whom begat Alcmene, who begat Heracles. One of Heracles' labors involved talking to Atlas and covering for Atlas temporarily while Atlas fetched the Golden Apples. The continued presence of the Atlas Mountains indicates that no, he didn't ever recover from his stoning. So, how was he up and about to get involved in the Eleventh Labor, if Heracles' great grandfather turned him into a mountain?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheOdyssey: something always bugged me about the climax of the story. Odysseus proves he is the rightful king by stringing his bow, something apparently none of the other suitors can do. But something about that situation doesn't quite jibe with the rest of Odysseus's characterization. Odysseus is always characterized as TheSmartGuy rather than TheBigGuy; he's more about brains than brawn. He's certainly not a wimp - he was a warrior-king of Ancient Greece, after all - but he's not a superpowered bruiser demigod like Heracles or Achilles. He's probably not even the strongest mortal in Ithaca; at the very least, he's his late thirties when he finally makes it home, and many of Penelope's suitors are younger men in their physical prime. And yet, none of them can beat the old man in what is basically a classic "feat of strength". Did Odysseus have a custom bow, and there was some kind of trick to stringing it that only he knew?

to:

* TheOdyssey: Literature/TheOdyssey: something always bugged me about the climax of the story. Odysseus proves he is the rightful king by stringing his bow, something apparently none of the other suitors can do. But something about that situation doesn't quite jibe with the rest of Odysseus's characterization. Odysseus is always characterized as TheSmartGuy rather than TheBigGuy; he's more about brains than brawn. He's certainly not a wimp - he was a warrior-king of Ancient Greece, after all - but he's not a superpowered bruiser demigod like Heracles or Achilles. He's probably not even the strongest mortal in Ithaca; at the very least, he's his late thirties when he finally makes it home, and many of Penelope's suitors are younger men in their physical prime. And yet, none of them can beat the old man in what is basically a classic "feat of strength". Did Odysseus have a custom bow, and there was some kind of trick to stringing it that only he knew?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheOdyssey: something always bugged me about the climax of the story. Odysseus proves he is the rightful king by stringing his bow, something apparently none of the other suitors can do. But something about that situation doesn't quite jibe with the rest of Odysseus's characterization. but Odysseus's greatest strength was always his brains, not his brawn. He's certainly not a wimp - he was a warrior-king of Ancient Greece, after all - but he's not a superpowered bruiser demigod like Heracles or Achilles. He's probably not even the strongest mortal in Ithaca; at the very least, he's his late thirties when he finally makes it home, and many of Penelope's suitors are younger men in their physical prime. And none of them can successfully defeat him in a feat of strength? Did Odysseus have a custom bow, and there was some kind of trick to stringing it that only he knew?

to:

* TheOdyssey: something always bugged me about the climax of the story. Odysseus proves he is the rightful king by stringing his bow, something apparently none of the other suitors can do. But something about that situation doesn't quite jibe with the rest of Odysseus's characterization. but Odysseus's greatest strength was Odysseus is always his brains, not his characterized as TheSmartGuy rather than TheBigGuy; he's more about brains than brawn. He's certainly not a wimp - he was a warrior-king of Ancient Greece, after all - but he's not a superpowered bruiser demigod like Heracles or Achilles. He's probably not even the strongest mortal in Ithaca; at the very least, he's his late thirties when he finally makes it home, and many of Penelope's suitors are younger men in their physical prime. And yet, none of them can successfully defeat him beat the old man in what is basically a feat classic "feat of strength? strength". Did Odysseus have a custom bow, and there was some kind of trick to stringing it that only he knew?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheOdyssey: something always bugged me about the climax of the story. Odysseus proves he is the rightful king by stringing his bow, something apparently none of the other suitors can do. But something about that situation doesn't quite jibe with the rest of Odysseus's characterization. but Odysseus's greatest strength was always his brains, not his brawn. He's certainly not a wimp - he was a warrior-king of Ancient Greece, after all - but he's not a superpowered bruiser demigod like Heracles or Achilles. He's probably not even the strongest mortal in Ithaca; at the very least, he's his late thirties when he finally makes it home, and many of Penelope's suitors are younger men in their physical prime. And none of them can successfully defeat him in a feat of strength? Did Odysseus have a custom bow, and there was some kind of trick to stringing it that only he knew?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Sadly ruined by the film adaptation, though. Jarring considering the author of the books actually knows his Greek mythology well, yet the damned filmmakers JustDidn'tCare. *facepalm*

to:

*** Sadly ruined by the film adaptation, though. Jarring considering the author of the books actually knows his Greek mythology well, yet the damned filmmakers JustDidn'tCare.JustDidntCare. *facepalm*
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Sadly ruined by the film adaptation, though. Jarring considering the author of the books actually knows his Greek mythology well, yet the damned filmmakers JustDidn'tCare. *facepalm*

Added: 152

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The story goes that Archimedes was asked by a king to find out if a certain crown was made of gold or not. (Without melting it down obviously.) Now the story of how he discovered displacement in the bathtub is well known, but does anyone know if the crown turned out to fake or not?

to:

* The story goes that Archimedes was asked by a king to find out if a certain crown was made of gold or not. (Without melting it down obviously.) Now the story of how he discovered displacement in the bathtub is well known, but does anyone know if the crown turned out to be fake or not?


Added DiffLines:

** According to [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archimedes#Archimedes.27_principle Wikipedia]] the test proved that the crown was not made of solid gold.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[{{Tradewinds}} Tradewinds: Odyssey]] Hades is a pretty cool guy and helps out the main character in one of the storylines.

to:

** [[{{Tradewinds}} [[VideoGame/{{Tradewinds}} Tradewinds: Odyssey]] Hades is a pretty cool guy and helps out the main character in one of the storylines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Probably not. Given what the discovery implied, Archimedes probably forgot all about the original request immediately after and decided to do more sciency things afterwards instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** GodOfWar, of all things, has this.

to:

** GodOfWar, VideoGame/GodOfWar, of all things, has this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Why didn't he swallow him? Would ''you'' want to do this twice? (HighOctaneNightmareFuel warning!) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_Devouring_His_Son

to:

** Why didn't he swallow him? Would ''you'' want to do this twice? (HighOctaneNightmareFuel (NightmareFuel warning!) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_Devouring_His_Son
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The story goes that Archimedes was asked by a king to find out if a certain crown was made of gold or not. (Without melting it down obviously.) Now the story of how he discovered displacement in the bathtub is well known, but does anyone know if the crown turned out to fake or not?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Genetics had not been discovered at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***** Is that actually in Greek myth?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
wicking to works page


** The ''Myth-O-Mania'' books present him as a decent, usually friendly guy (if a bit of a DeadpanSnarker) who made a couple of mistakes and got hugely slandered by his uppity little brother and the guy's [[IHateYouVampireDad unaffiliated]] [[LadyOfWar daughter]] and [[[StopHelpingMe idiot mortal sons]]. It's a PerspectiveFlip, but still...

to:

** The ''Myth-O-Mania'' ''Literature/{{Myth-O-Mania}}'' books present him as a decent, usually friendly guy (if a bit of a DeadpanSnarker) who made a couple of mistakes and got hugely slandered by his uppity little brother and the guy's [[IHateYouVampireDad unaffiliated]] [[LadyOfWar daughter]] and [[[StopHelpingMe [[StopHelpingMe idiot mortal sons]]. It's a PerspectiveFlip, but still...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Not really - maybe writers who are sloppy or like to box everything in neat little rehashy squares. Also, fyi 'rape' does not mean rape. It is an archaic word for kidnap. No legend ever says he raped her.

Top