Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Gattaca

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**** Like Detective Hugo said, it's unlikely for anything like an eyelash to stay for years in a place that is cleaned as frequently and thoroughly as Gattaca.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The biological process of DNA replication is buggy. Incredibly buggy. Errors/mutations happen all the time (which is why we still have life on Earth--if everything copied perfectly, then one disaster would have wiped it all out and there would be no separate species, etc). No matter how perfectly you engineer the parents, there's still a pretty good chance that the meiosis happening in their gonads would result in genetic "discrepancies" in their egg & sperm cells, which would keep the industry alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Much less likely but on the other hand more dystopian: the world of Gattaca is so obsessed with perfection and conformity that even astronauts on a mission have to wear business suites, possibly finding the very idea unthinkable that something could wrong on a mission where everyone involved is genetically optimized .

to:

*** Much less likely but on the other hand more dystopian: the world of Gattaca is so obsessed with perfection and conformity that even astronauts on a mission have to wear business suites, possibly finding the very idea unthinkable that something could wrong on a mission where everyone involved is genetically optimized .
optimized.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** I wouldn't call your point, a 'problem', at least not from the POV of valid society. The science shown in the film is sufficiently advanced that they are very confident that sickness and illness will not be a problem for the enhanced valid population. Thus, the only real 'need', or market for corrective surgery would be-guess who? Yes, the IN-valids. The movie is quite clear that Vincents society is highly discriminatory. Its no stretch to imagine the valids would feel providing resources and specialists to extend and correct defects in invalids, would be pointless. Although the movie does not directly state it, its hard not to get the impression the valids are just waiting for the in-valids to all die off, naturally of course. The sooner the better.

to:

*** I wouldn't call your point, a 'problem', at least not from the POV of valid society. The science shown in the film is sufficiently advanced that they are very confident that sickness and illness will not be a problem for the enhanced valid population. Thus, the only real 'need', or market for corrective surgery would be-guess who? Yes, the IN-valids. The movie is quite clear that Vincents Vincent's society is highly discriminatory. Its no stretch to imagine the valids would feel providing resources and specialists to extend and correct defects in invalids, would be pointless. Although the movie does not directly state it, its hard not to get the impression the valids are just waiting for the in-valids to all die off, naturally of course. The sooner the better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** Didn't the eyelash belong to someone who ''used'' to work there though? If so... loads of ways for it to have gotten there and remained there.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Urine is ''mostly'' sterile. Still it's a very poor choice for DNA testing compared to everything including non-invasive cheek swabs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** DIGESTIVE tract? Urine has nothing to do with digestion, they're two completely different systems.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The movie is not arguing that genetic engineering is bad. It is arguing that ''prejudice'' is bad, and that prejudice based on one's genetic makeup is no more justified than any other form. Vincent's society is a dystopia because it discriminates against genetic makeup the same way earlier societies discriminated against race.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** SelfFulfillingProphecy. Most of the other people who were diagnosed with early deaths did die early, either because they believed they would die and became risk takers who died in some other accident or because they actually developed the predicted conditions. The few who did survive were viewed as statistical outliers and not significant. Vincent is one of the few who refuses to accept the scientific prediction of his lifespan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The opening monologue makes no sense, they say they know the exact time and means of your death then list a bunch of probabilities. Was Vincent really the only person they know of who outlived their medical conditions, surely someone else must have exceeded expectations before, right?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Skin cells and white blood cells can easily be extracted from urine with current technology. With their advanced genetic screening tech, they could easily have better equipment.

to:

** Skin cells, sloughed-off cells from the urinary tract lining, and white blood cells can easily be extracted from urine with current technology. With their advanced genetic screening tech, they could easily have better equipment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renamed trope


** They're actually drug tests, but the movie's AppliedPhlebotinum is [[YouFailBiologyForever ubiquitous instant genetic screening]] - the computers analyze genetics at the same time just as a matter of fact.

to:

** They're actually drug tests, but the movie's AppliedPhlebotinum is [[YouFailBiologyForever [[ArtisticLicenseBiology ubiquitous instant genetic screening]] - the computers analyze genetics at the same time just as a matter of fact.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Skin cells and white blood cells can easily be extracted from urine with current technology. With their advanced genetic screening tech, they could easily have better equipment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It looked like an extremely large shelf, and the required amount for day to day is low. The blood pack looks to be about 10ml, easily covered by the rows of head-sized jars filled with blood. The skin... a human generates a surprising amount of waste skin and hair, although admittedly not ''that'' much, but the comb only needs a few of each, which again would cover him for a long, long time.

to:

** It looked like an extremely large shelf, and the required amount for day to day is low. The blood pack looks to be about 10ml, barely a couple milliliters, easily covered by the rows of head-sized jars filled with blood. The skin... a human generates a surprising amount of waste skin and hair, although admittedly not ''that'' much, but the comb only needs a few of each, which again would cover him for a long, long time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It looked like an extremely large shelf, and the required amount for day to day is low. The blood pack looks to be about 10ml, easily covered by the rows of head-sized jars filled with blood. The skin... a human generates a surprising amount of waste skin and hair, although admittedly not ''that'' much, but the comb only needs a few of each, which again would cover him for a long, long time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I attempted to make the article more neutral. I may be wrong, but I have done what I can.


* The Coda's Aesop. Not only is it uncomfortably similar to the anti-abortion sentiment "but what if the fetus grows up to cure cancer!", there is a pretty big loophole in the moral. Yes, it's possible that many great historical figures would've never been born, but guess what, just as many terrible people wouldn't have been born either! For every Abraham Lincoln there's a Hitler (who had Parkinson's and also would've been spared existence had the Human Genome Project been started earlier- which is arguably a worthwhile trade-off). So yeah, in conclusion, genetic engineering is neutral; you lose some cool people like Vincent van Gogh, but humanity also gets to be spared some horrific mass-murderers.

to:

* The Coda's Aesop. Not only is it uncomfortably similar to the anti-abortion sentiment pro-life argument "but what if the fetus grows up to cure cancer!", there is a pretty big loophole in the moral. Yes, it's possible that many great historical figures would've never been born, but guess what, just as many terrible people wouldn't have been born either! For every Abraham Lincoln there's a Hitler (who had Parkinson's and also would've been spared existence had the Human Genome Project been started earlier- which is arguably a worthwhile trade-off). So yeah, in conclusion, genetic engineering is neutral; you lose some cool people like Vincent van Gogh, but humanity also gets to be spared some horrific mass-murderers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The movie clearly states that potential is predicted, but it's just that - an educated guess. Director Josef mentions that his profile states he doesn't have a violent bone in his body, yet he murders the Mission Director. Which ties rather nicely into the film's tagline that "there is no gene for the human spirit", i.e. it's how we react to the genuine challenges in life that defines us, not how perfect or imperfect our genetic structures are, and that playing it safe all the time might just keep us from greatness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The Coda's Aesop. Not only is it uncomfortably similar to the anti-abortion sentiment "but what if the fetus grows up to cure cancer!", there is a pretty big loophole in the moral. Yes, it's possible that many great historical figures would've never been born, but guess what, just as many terrible people wouldn't have been born either! For every Abraham Lincoln there's a Hitler (who had Parkinson's and also would've been spared existence had the Human Genome Project been started earlier- which is arguably a worthwhile trade-off). So yeah, in conclusion, genetic engineering is neutral; you lose some cool people like Vincent van Gogh, but humanity also gets to be spared some horrific mass-murderers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why does Jerome live in a house with stairs if he's in a wheelchair? The house was most likely provided by Tony Shalhoub's black marketeer - there weren't any single-floor apartments available?
** Probably because he was living in that house since before his paralysis and simply didn't move out. Tony Shalhoub's character does imply that nobody knows what happened to Jerome Morrow - which is, as told to us, because Jerome doesn't want his condition known. This means he didn't leave the house or rent/buy another one, playing the role of the shut-in Valid who is mad at the world for ever being second best at swimming.
** Also, RuleOfSymbolism. The stairs resemble a strand of DNA. [[spoiler:That means when Eugene was climbing up the stairs, it was a VisualPun]].

to:

* Why does Jerome live in a house with stairs if he's in a wheelchair? The house was most likely provided by Tony Shalhoub's black marketeer German - there weren't any single-floor apartments available?
** Probably because he was living in that house since before his paralysis and simply didn't move out. Tony Shalhoub's character German does imply that nobody knows what happened to Jerome Morrow - which is, as told to us, because Jerome doesn't want his condition known. This means he didn't leave the house or rent/buy another one, playing the role of the shut-in Valid who is mad at the world for ever being second best at swimming.
** Also, RuleOfSymbolism. The spiral stairs resemble a strand of DNA.the DNA helix. [[spoiler:That means when Eugene was climbing up the stairs, it was a VisualPun]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** Much less likely but on the other hand more dystopian: the world of Gattaca is so obsessed with perfection and conformity that even astronauts on a mission have to wear business suites, possibly finding the very idea unthinkable that something could wrong on a mission where everyone involved is genetically optimized .
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***Not to mention the short scene where we see a bunch of "Invalids" rounded up in the open and the cops apparently at random roughing one up.

Top