Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Gargoyles

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Word of God says Gargoyles have a very weak form of something like telepathy that allowes them to instantly tell which Gargoyle is spoken about even if they are referred to with vague descriptions like "our brother" and things like that. During development a discarded character concept was that of gargoyle twin sisters (an impossibility by later canon) that were supposed to illustrate that concept by having a stronger form of telepathy between the two of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* I suspect part of the reason was that gliding is easier to animate than true flight. In-universe the explanation would be that true flight takes a lot of energy, more than Gargoyles could come up with even with the solar power they gather during their stone sleep. Plus their wingspans in comparison to their (usually very muscular) bodies don't seem large enough for true flight eithe (and Gargoyles like Lexington really do just have membranes, like flying squirrrels do)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Right, I meant the Captain. And he definitely tried to stop Hakon, but Hakon overpowered him, and would have killed him if he hadn't folded.

Added: 836

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Some coincidences were being controlled. Sevarius said they had been allowing the mutate to escape for weeks in hope that the gargoyles would find one, which they did when Maggie escaped. Xanatos assumed the gargoyles would come to investigate the lab as a result, so he went to visit and brought Derek. Xanatos and Sevarius have their fake argument and Sevarius fires the mutagen dart at Derek(whom he was aiming at). Sevarius starts making his very real cure which will take 'awhile'. Then when Goliath and co. show up, the very real cure just happens to be done in time and then Sevarius intentional breaks it as soon as the gargoyles enter. And Goliath only threw Servaius into the tank because he grabbed his tail to save his 'creation'. As to how Servaius survived the eel tank...well nobody said those eels were real, did they?



* You're referring to the Captain who fought alongside the gargoyles. Hakon was the leader of the vikings. The Captain betrayed the castle to Hakon which in turn lead to the deaths of Wyvern clan. Sure you can argue that wasn't the plan, but not like the Captain tried to stop Hakon, did he? And he was, in essence, betraying Goloath since Goliath wanted to protect the castle and honor the bargain with the humans to them safe. And there is also the thing with the Magus.

to:

* You're referring to the Captain who fought alongside the gargoyles. Hakon was the leader of the vikings.Vikings. The Captain betrayed the castle to Hakon which in turn lead to the deaths of Wyvern clan. Sure you can argue that wasn't the plan, but not like the Captain tried to stop Hakon, did he? And he was, in essence, betraying Goloath Goliath since Goliath wanted to protect the castle and honor the bargain with the humans to keep them safe. And there is also the thing with the Magus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Elisa is in a unique position since she is a police officer. And if Goliath were human, he would be breaking the law with his actions and Elisa would have to arrest him. She usually lets things slide with the gargoyles due to there circumstance, but she has to draw lines in the sand somewhere when need be.


Added DiffLines:

* Demona is a different type of insanity depending on what day of the week it is. And Xanatos mainly wanted to see how effective the Steel Clan would be against the gargoyles. If they ended up dead, then spilled milk.


Added DiffLines:

* You're referring to the Captain who fought alongside the gargoyles. Hakon was the leader of the vikings. The Captain betrayed the castle to Hakon which in turn lead to the deaths of Wyvern clan. Sure you can argue that wasn't the plan, but not like the Captain tried to stop Hakon, did he? And he was, in essence, betraying Goloath since Goliath wanted to protect the castle and honor the bargain with the humans to them safe. And there is also the thing with the Magus.


Added DiffLines:

* Because it would be a violation of his deal with Xanatos. Puck offered Xanatos a single wish or a lifetime of service from Owen. Xanatos chose Owen. So Puck only serves Xanatos as Owen. This is why Xanatos never calls on Puck to do magic for him. Also, Owen cannot technically do magic either. When Puck becomes Owen, he becomes 100% human. The only power he has left to change back to Puck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The Gargoyles universe does have guys who can shoot lightning out of their hands, but those guys tend to be A) rare, and B) not as powerful as you'd expect. The Arcmage is dangerous, but most of that is due to the Grimorium Arcanorum- and even then, he can't fight off three gargoyles. Then you have guys like the Magus and Brother Valmont, who seek out patrons to protect them- and both of those mages were defeated by non-magic users- Hakon and Brooklyn, respectively. Magic may be impressive, but it's not as reliable as a well-equipped army and a well-built castle.

to:

*** The Gargoyles ''Gargoyles'' universe does have guys who can shoot lightning out of their hands, but those guys tend to be A) rare, and B) not as powerful as you'd expect. The Arcmage Archmage is dangerous, but most of that is due to the Grimorium Arcanorum- and even then, he can't fight off three gargoyles. Then you have guys like the Magus and Brother Valmont, who seek out patrons to protect them- and both of those mages were defeated by non-magic users- Hakon and Brooklyn, respectively. Magic may be impressive, but it's not as reliable as a well-equipped army and a well-built castle.



** In the Gargoyles universe all time is simultaneous and immutable. There doesn't need to be a first cause because the entire loop all exists together as a single event. it's like the old paradox of going back in time to meet Martin Luther king only to be dismayed because he's having trouble writing his "I have a dream" speech. So you write it from memory for him. So you got the speech from TV/school/books. but the TV/school/Books got the speech from him, but he got it from you.The speech didn't really come from anywhere. Gargoyles is 100% consistent on this too. When you get used to the way time travel works in the series this kind of thing makes a weird sort of sense. (Note: ''Comicbook/{{Watchmen}}'' and ''Film/TheTimeTravelersWife2009'' and ''Film/TheTerminator'' [but not ''necessarily'' its sequels] among others use this same model for time Travel.)

to:

** In the Gargoyles ''Gargoyles'' universe all time is simultaneous and immutable. There doesn't need to be a first cause because the entire loop all exists together as a single event. it's like the old paradox of going back in time to meet Martin Luther king only to be dismayed because he's having trouble writing his "I have a dream" speech. So you write it from memory for him. So you got the speech from TV/school/books. but the TV/school/Books got the speech from him, but he got it from you.The speech didn't really come from anywhere. Gargoyles is 100% consistent on this too. When you get used to the way time travel works in the series this kind of thing makes a weird sort of sense. (Note: ''Comicbook/{{Watchmen}}'' and ''Film/TheTimeTravelersWife2009'' and ''Film/TheTerminator'' [but not ''necessarily'' its sequels] among others use this same model for time Travel.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the Gargoyles universe all time is simultaneous and immutable. There doesn't need to be a first cause because the entire loop all exists together as a single event. it's like the old paradox of going back in time to meet Martin Luther king only to be dismayed because he's having trouble writing his "I have a dream" speech. So you write it from memory for him. So you got the speech from TV/school/books. but the TV/school/Books got the speech from him, but he got it from you.The speech didn't really come from anywhere. Gargoyles is 100% consistent on this too. When you get used to the way time travel works in the series this kind of thing makes a weird sort of sense. (Note: ''Comicbook/{{Watchmen}}'' and ''Film/TheTimeTravelersWife'' and ''Film/TheTerminator'' [but not ''necessarily'' its sequels] among others use this same model for time Travel.)

to:

** In the Gargoyles universe all time is simultaneous and immutable. There doesn't need to be a first cause because the entire loop all exists together as a single event. it's like the old paradox of going back in time to meet Martin Luther king only to be dismayed because he's having trouble writing his "I have a dream" speech. So you write it from memory for him. So you got the speech from TV/school/books. but the TV/school/Books got the speech from him, but he got it from you.The speech didn't really come from anywhere. Gargoyles is 100% consistent on this too. When you get used to the way time travel works in the series this kind of thing makes a weird sort of sense. (Note: ''Comicbook/{{Watchmen}}'' and ''Film/TheTimeTravelersWife'' ''Film/TheTimeTravelersWife2009'' and ''Film/TheTerminator'' [but not ''necessarily'' its sequels] among others use this same model for time Travel.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The reveal that Owen is actually Puck brings up the question of why he didn't use his powers to cure his stone hand. Xanatos knew he was Puck, so it's not like he had any reason to hide his powers from him.

to:

The reveal that Owen is actually Puck brings up the question of why he didn't use his powers to cure his stone hand. Xanatos knew he was Puck, so it's not like he had any reason to hide his powers from him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Owen's stone hand]]
The reveal that Owen is actually Puck brings up the question of why he didn't use his powers to cure his stone hand. Xanatos knew he was Puck, so it's not like he had any reason to hide his powers from him.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Actually he was, at that point. He told Elisa that he would never trust humans again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Saying to another man that they have a lovely daughter is far from "flirting". As said above, that was just a casual compliment to go with his AffablyEvil personality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Why does the show insist that the gargoyles were betrayed by humans in the first episode? We know that's not what happened. What happened was that Hakon betrayed the humans to the vikings for the gargoyles' sake, but was unable to stop the vikings from slaughtering the clan in an attempt at saving their own asses. Even in "Shadows of the Past", Hakon goes "I betrayed Goliath's clan", when "My plan backfired and I unwittingly caused the slaughter of the clan" would have been more accurate.

to:

Why does the show insist that the gargoyles were betrayed by humans in the first episode? We know that's not what happened. What happened was that Hakon betrayed the humans to the vikings for the gargoyles' sake, but was unable to stop the vikings from slaughtering the clan in an attempt at saving covering their own asses. Even in "Shadows of the Past", Hakon goes "I betrayed Goliath's clan", when "My plan backfired and I unwittingly caused the slaughter of the clan" would have been more accurate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Why does the show insist that the gargoyles were betrayed by humans at the beginning of the show? We know that's not what happened. What happened was that Hakon betrayed the humans to the vikings for the gargoyles' sake, but was unable to stop the vikings from slaughtering the clan in an attempt at saving their own asses. Even in "Shadows of the Past", Hakon goes "I betrayed Goliath's clan", when "My plan backfired and I unwittingly caused the slaughter of the clan" would have been more accurate.

to:

Why does the show insist that the gargoyles were betrayed by humans at in the beginning of the show? first episode? We know that's not what happened. What happened was that Hakon betrayed the humans to the vikings for the gargoyles' sake, but was unable to stop the vikings from slaughtering the clan in an attempt at saving their own asses. Even in "Shadows of the Past", Hakon goes "I betrayed Goliath's clan", when "My plan backfired and I unwittingly caused the slaughter of the clan" would have been more accurate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: "We were betrayed by the humans we had sworn to protect"]]
Why does the show insist that the gargoyles were betrayed by humans at the beginning of the show? We know that's not what happened. What happened was that Hakon betrayed the humans to the vikings for the gargoyles' sake, but was unable to stop the vikings from slaughtering the clan in an attempt at saving their own asses. Even in "Shadows of the Past", Hakon goes "I betrayed Goliath's clan", when "My plan backfired and I unwittingly caused the slaughter of the clan" would have been more accurate.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Xanatos and Demona in "Awakening"]]
Why did Xanatos and Demona try to kill the gargoyles, exactly?
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Why does Elisa reprimands Goliath for kidnapping Sevarious and forcing him to develop a cure for Derek and the others? She argued that "Even if it works, the ends can't justify the means". But Sevarious is the man who used human subjects as test experiments and turned them into mutants against their will! Compared to that, Goliath's actions were rather tame and understandable.

to:

Why does Elisa reprimands reprimand Goliath for kidnapping Sevarious and forcing him to develop a cure for Derek and the others? She argued that "Even if it works, the ends can't justify the means". But Sevarious is the man who used human subjects as test experiments and turned them into mutants against their will! Compared to that, Goliath's actions were rather tame and understandable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Elisa's reaction go Goliath's actions in "The Cage"]]
Why does Elisa reprimands Goliath for kidnapping Sevarious and forcing him to develop a cure for Derek and the others? She argued that "Even if it works, the ends can't justify the means". But Sevarious is the man who used human subjects as test experiments and turned them into mutants against their will! Compared to that, Goliath's actions were rather tame and understandable.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: No flying]]
How come the gargoyles are unable to fly despite having wings? I can't think of a single real life being that has wings yet can only use them to glide. Flying squirrels glide, but they have membranes instead.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Why exactly did manipulate the twins from The Pack into trying to assassinate him? Fox claimed it was to mess with Elisa, but wasn't he already messing with her by merely having Derek work as his bodyguard? All he accomplished was put himself in danger. What's more, they came mighty close to killing him toward the end. They were about to shoot him in the head when the gargoyles arrived and saved the day. If they had been a second late he'd be dead, and Elisa would no longer have to worry about Derek working for Xanatos.

to:

Why exactly did Xanatos manipulate the twins from The Pack into trying to assassinate him? Fox claimed it was to mess with Elisa, but wasn't he already messing with her by merely having Derek work as his bodyguard? All he accomplished was put himself in danger. What's more, they came mighty close to killing him toward the end. They were about to shoot him in the head when the gargoyles arrived and saved the day. If they had been a second late he'd be dead, and Elisa would no longer have to worry about Derek working for Xanatos.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Xanatos' plan in "Her Brother's Keeper"]]
Why exactly did manipulate the twins from The Pack into trying to assassinate him? Fox claimed it was to mess with Elisa, but wasn't he already messing with her by merely having Derek work as his bodyguard? All he accomplished was put himself in danger. What's more, they came mighty close to killing him toward the end. They were about to shoot him in the head when the gargoyles arrived and saved the day. If they had been a second late he'd be dead, and Elisa would no longer have to worry about Derek working for Xanatos.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Xanatos' act in "Metamorphosis"]]
How on Earth did Xanatos and that doctor manage to pull that act on Derek? It required too many variants and coincidences to come in place, like the gargoyles breaking into the very room they were in the exact moment Derek was about to be administered his "antidote", accidentally destroy said "antidote", or Goliath tossing the doctor into that eel tank so hard the wall breaks (also by accident). And how did the doctor fake being electrocuted by eels anyway? We clearly saw them shocking him while he was completely wet.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This is actually a really complicated question.\\
According to Greg, in real history, Lu'''l'''ach ("Luach" was a typo that stuck around) was born during Gillecomgain and Gruoch's marriage. After Gillecomgain's death, Macbeth married Gruoch and adopted Lulach as his son and heir. However, there were rumors that Gruoch had been unfaithful to her first husband and that the real father was Macbeth, which would explain why he was willing to adopt him. [[https://www.s8.org/gargoyles/askgreg/search.php?qid=699]][[https://www.s8.org/gargoyles/askgreg/search.php?qid=3503]][[https://www.s8.org/gargoyles/askgreg/search.php?qid=7998]] A quick look at Wikipedia bears this out.\\
The way its presented in the series, it ''looks'' like Luach was conceived after Macbeth and Gruoch's marriage and Macbeth is portrayed as his biological father, and that's how the general audience is supposed to interpret it. But it's never actually ''stated'', and, according to Word of God, Luach was born during Gillecomgain and Gruoch's marriage and adopted later by Macbeth, just like in history. [[https://www.s8.org/gargoyles/askgreg/search.php?qid=3465]][[https://www.s8.org/gargoyles/askgreg/search.php?qid=9127]] Greg couldn't fit all the historical stuff in there (both because the epic "City of Stone" four-parter was already crowded enough and because he couldn't very well go and mention adultery in a kids' show) so he presented a simplified narrative that never actually contradicts the more complicated narrative that he considers canon.\\
So, in the end, Luach's parentage is deliberately ambiguous. [[https://www.s8.org/gargoyles/askgreg/search.php?qid=3464]] He ''could'' be Gillecomgain's legitimate son, or he could be Macbeth's illegitimate son from an affair he had with Gruoch during her and Gillecomgain's marriage, even though the show skipped all of this and presented a simplified illusion that Luach was conceived and born during Macbeth's and Gruoch's marriage with no reason to doubt that Macbeth was the father.\\
Two more things of note:\\
1. In the show, Macbeth and Gruoch are portrayed as marrying immediately after Gillecomgain's death. However, in real life there was always a mourning period before a widow was allowed to marry again, ''precisely'' to make it clear to everyone which husband fathered which child. Presumably, this was another implied simplification that was not actually canon.\\
2. Greg implies that Gillecomgain crushing Gruoch's rose in "City of Stone" Part Two is symbolic of him taking her virginity. [[https://www.s8.org/gargoyles/askgreg/search.php?qid=5904]][[https://www.s8.org/gargoyles/askgreg/search.php?qid=17989]] ''Ouch.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Foe Yay has been cut


* A wild guess: Xanatos is [[FoeYay subconsciously attracted to Goliath]] - he wears gargoyle PoweredArmor shaped to have Goliath's face, and you could argue that Thailog is as much ''his'' son as Goliath's - and knows it, but he's still basically straight and devoted to Fox. And Angela is Goliath's daughter and has his coloring, and besides it would really bug Goliath, so... why not? Harmless fun.

to:

* A wild guess: Xanatos is [[FoeYay subconsciously attracted to Goliath]] Goliath - he wears gargoyle PoweredArmor shaped to have Goliath's face, and you could argue that Thailog is as much ''his'' son as Goliath's - and knows it, but he's still basically straight and devoted to Fox. And Angela is Goliath's daughter and has his coloring, and besides it would really bug Goliath, so... why not? Harmless fun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe being part feline gave him a very good hearing?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not nessecarily, The spell never said the castle had to be intact all at the same time. He ''flew'' the castle in pieces which "raised it above the clouds." As long as every piece traveled by plane that's enough to break the spell, especially since nearly every CurseEscapeClause in the series is also worked around rather than literally interpreted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It's an animation error but an in-universe has been given. Hudson only acquired his sword in one of the pilot episodes. Since he hasn't had it long, how much he considers it his varies from day to day.

to:

*** It's an animation error but an in-universe has been given.given by WordOfGod. Hudson only acquired his sword in one of the pilot episodes. Since he hasn't had it long, how much he considers it his varies from day to day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* She probably didn't get that many visitors, which may have contributed to why she would carelessly leave her gun in her jacket like that. But that of course is no excuse for a lack of gun safety which was part of the message.


Added DiffLines:

* Well gargoyles can fly, can't they? And they can also make claw marks in solid stone. So those would have to be some pretty elaborate costumes. And yes, some people ''did'' think they were just costumes. In Awakenings, one of the Commandos(who was actually voiced by Greg Weismen himself), says 'Nice mask' to Broadway, meaning he thought it was just a costume. It's also established in Hunter's Moon that they were so many gargoyle sightings over the last 2 years, that the public was more or less aware that they were real creatures before they were exposed outright. Some people may have still thought they were some kind of hoax, but there was live photograpic evidence of them. Even if people thought they were just costumes, they were still, in the public eye, very dangerous
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Out-of-universe answer, the animatiors just re-designed the Mutates to look better. In-universe answer, they were still mutating before they settled on their final forms.


Added DiffLines:

* They don't use names, so much as they use monikers. In the past, Goliath and Coldstone called Hudson 'mentor' since that is what he was to them. Demona sometimes called Hudson 'old solider' because that's what she views him as. Goliath would call Demona 'Angel of the Night' and Bronx was once called 'watch dog'. They given destinations based on their functions or characteristics. In Timedancer, one of the gargoyles in the Demona's second clan called Brooklyn, the 'Gargoyle of the Sword' because he was wielding a sword. Gargoryles were likely just adapt at making up distinguishable and respectful placeholder names for each other.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder: Derek's hearing in "The Cage"]]
* Derek found out that Sevarius was still alive when he overheard Elisa asking the security guard at Gen-U-Tech about Sevarius, and the guard telling her that she "just missed him." But the guard didn't say so particularly loudly, and it would be another minute or so before Derek arrived at Gen-U-Tech (far enough away from Elisa that she mistook him for Goliath); how could he have overheard the guard from such a distance away?
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Why are humans so quick to think the gargoyles are real monsters?]]
Whenever a human who doesn't know the gargoyles see them they're immediate reaction is to either run in fear or attack them but what we know of human behavior I doubt most humans would even believe the gargoyle was a real creature. People have a tendency to rationalize things that go against what they think to be true and as far as most people know gargoyles are just statues and not living beings, if a modern person saw a living gargoyle their reaction won't be "Ahh monster!" it'll be "Why is that guy wearing a costume?"
[[/folder]]

Top