Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Gargoyles

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They did. Owen upgraded the Steel Clan with some iron which was able to damage Oberon and Petros Xanatos managed to get a pretty good hit on him with an iron harpoon. The problem is, Oberon is far stronger than most of the Third Race, so they would need a "lot" of iron to put him down. As for why they didn't use another iron bell, well Owen and Xanatos didn't know about it, and Goliath didn't have the time to get another one. WordOfGod also says that even Oberon isn't so arrogant enough that he wouldn't have come up a contingency plan if somebody else tried to use an iron bell on him in the future.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Did Goliath and co forgot all about Oberon's weakness to iron when they fought him in "The Gathering"]]
Exploiting that weakness was the only chance they had of defeating [[PhysicalGod Oberon]], and yet they never thought of it.

to:

[[folder:Did Goliath and co forgot all about Oberon's weakness to iron when they fought him in "The Gathering"]]
Gathering"?]]
Exploiting that weakness was the only closest thing to a chance they had of defeating [[PhysicalGod Oberon]], and yet they never thought of it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Did Goliath and co forgot all about Oberon's weakness to iron when they fought him in "The Gathering"]]
Exploiting that weakness was the only chance they had of defeating [[PhysicalGod Oberon]], and yet they never thought of it.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The original Maggie looked like an old woman. They probably retconned her into being younger so that her relationship with Derek wouldn't come off as problematic.

Added: 159

Changed: 146

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Is Angela a Franchise/DisneyPrincess?]]

to:

[[WMG: [[/folder]]
[[folder:
Is Angela a Franchise/DisneyPrincess?]]



[[WMG:Why didn't Demona lead the other Gargoyles away from Castle Wyvern]]

to:

[[WMG:Why [[/folder]]
[[folder:Why
didn't Demona lead the other Gargoyles away from Castle Wyvern]]Wyvern?]]



[[WMG:What EXACTLY is Bronx]]

to:

[[WMG:What [[/folder]]
[[folder:What
EXACTLY is Bronx]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****I agree completely. That Gargoyles could develop as a species without names is entirely believable for me. That's why what I don't like about it is that this is seemingly not the case for the global gargoyles. It feels like it's only the Scottish clan who inexplicably lack names. And I don't really think "they interact with humans" is a decent excuse since Gargoyles have been interacting with humans since the dawn of time. We first see them in the show interacting with humans, yet it's clear that Goliath is a name bestowed purely for the human's convenience and not that of the Gargoyles. Yet whenever they go to any other country (or even just a few thousand kilometers south in the London case) suddenly it's "My name is X". Obviously it's because the writers want the characters to have names and it's just awkward and contrived to write around them not having a name, but that's the commitment they made when they had this as a specific aspect of the Xenofiction they were writing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

!!''WesternAnimation/{{Gargoyles}}''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Although not canon, that's one of the episodes this troper wishes were so. It was really really damn good despite no [[IncrediblyLamePun wise men]] at the helm. Also, we got to see Robbins again, whom I really wish would become an ascended extra. He could probably join Macbeth on the talk show circuit to defend Gargoyles.

to:

** Although not canon, that's one of the episodes this troper wishes were so. It was really really damn good despite no [[IncrediblyLamePun [[{{Pun}} wise men]] at the helm. Also, we got to see Robbins again, whom I really wish would become an ascended extra. He could probably join Macbeth on the talk show circuit to defend Gargoyles.



** Um the entire city was "always gargoyles" while it was probably beyond Puck's power to completely rewrite the entire architecture I'm sure wares and fashion were adjusted.
*** No, they obviously weren't. All the former humans are still wearing human clothing (a few girls even smirk at the normal Gargoyles, who are still in loincloths). And inanimate objects in general don't seem to have been affected; a statue (which really exists in New York, btw) looked the same as usual, without changing from human to gargoyle. And Demona's weapon, a high tech gun, certainly didn't become a sword or anything.

to:

** Um the entire city was "always gargoyles" while it was probably beyond Puck's power to completely rewrite the entire architecture architecture, I'm sure wares and fashion were adjusted.
*** No, they obviously weren't. All the former humans are still wearing human clothing (a few girls even smirk at the normal Gargoyles, who are still in loincloths). And inanimate objects in general don't seem to have been affected; a statue (which really exists in New York, btw) looked the same as usual, without changing from human to gargoyle. And Demona's weapon, a high tech high-tech gun, certainly didn't become a sword or anything.



** Xanatos mentions that he has to blow up the entire Steel Clan just to get the gas to ignite, and needs the help of the Gargoyles as well in spreading the gas around.

to:

** Xanatos mentions that he has to blow up the entire Steel Clan just to get the gas to ignite, ignite and needs the help of the Gargoyles as well in spreading the gas around.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Presuming the "death" was always intended, it makes more sense for Sevarius to look disguised temporarily when Derek meets him, then take off the make-up afterward so he looks normal. It's easier than the other way around -- looking normal at first, then having to wear a disguise constantly. It's like how they cast young actors for Marty's parents in ''Film/BackToTheFuture'': Have them in aged make-up for the handful of minutes they're onscreen in 1985, then just let them look natural for the 1955 scenes that make up the bulk of the movie.

to:

* Presuming the "death" was always intended, it makes more sense for Sevarius to look disguised temporarily when Derek meets him, then take off the make-up afterward so he looks normal. It's easier than the other way around -- looking normal at first, then having to wear a disguise constantly. It's like how they cast young actors for Marty's parents in ''Film/BackToTheFuture'': ''Film/BackToTheFuture1'': Have them in aged make-up for the handful of minutes they're onscreen in 1985, then just let them look natural for the 1955 scenes that make up the bulk of the movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* He found a way to make sure that his future self got the coin and knew what to do to send himself into the past. Chances are he could have found a way to get another message to his future self that he was stuck in the past, if he had been stuck in the past. "My past self didn't warn me about this, and he would have if it were worth worrying about, so I don't need to worry about it" is probably all the reason he needed to rest assured that he'd be taken back to the 20th century.

to:

* He found a way to make sure that his future self got the coin and knew what to do to send himself into the past. Chances are he could have found a way to get another message to his future self that he was stuck in the past, if he had been stuck in the past. "My past self didn't warn me about this, and he would have if it were worth worrying about, so I don't need to worry about it" is probably all the reason he needed to rest assured that he'd be taken back to the 20th century. It's certainly consistent with his combination of cleverness and arrogance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* He found a way to make sure that his future self got the coin and knew what to do to send himself into the past. Chances are he could have found a way to get another message to his future self that he was stuck in the past, if he had been stuck in the past. "My past self didn't warn me about this, so I don't need to worry about it" is probably all the reason he needed to rest assured that he'd be taken back to the 20th century.

to:

* He found a way to make sure that his future self got the coin and knew what to do to send himself into the past. Chances are he could have found a way to get another message to his future self that he was stuck in the past, if he had been stuck in the past. "My past self didn't warn me about this, and he would have if it were worth worrying about, so I don't need to worry about it" is probably all the reason he needed to rest assured that he'd be taken back to the 20th century.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* He found a way to make sure that his future self got the coin and knew what to do to send himself into the past. Chances are he could have found a way to get another message to his future self that he was stuck in the past, if he had been stuck in the past.

to:

* He found a way to make sure that his future self got the coin and knew what to do to send himself into the past. Chances are he could have found a way to get another message to his future self that he was stuck in the past, if he had been stuck in the past. "My past self didn't warn me about this, so I don't need to worry about it" is probably all the reason he needed to rest assured that he'd be taken back to the 20th century.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* He found a way to make sure that his future self got the coin and knew what to do to send himself into the past. Chances are he could have found a way to get another message to his future self that he was stuck in the past, if he had been stuck in the past.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** True, the Captain would likely be dead too, but that's still kinda his own fault for choosing to trust a murderous sociopath like Hakon. And given Katherine and the Magus contemptuous treatment of the gargoyles, the alliance wasn't going to last much longer. Demona was right in pointing out that the humans were treating them like garbage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's entirely plausible that Xanatos's company does extensive business in Europe and Asia, despite Xanatos himself living in New York. In which case, operating late into the night would allow him to conduct various international deals and phone-conferences on a schedule that's more efficient for his overseas subsidiaries and colleagues.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The Chick is now a disambig, dewicking


*** The male-to-female ratio has very little to do with any aspects of gargoyle biology and a hell of a lot to do with the fact that the show was an action series aimed at pre-teen boys. [[TheChick If only there was a trope for it...]]

to:

*** The male-to-female ratio has very little to do with any aspects of gargoyle biology and a hell of a lot to do with the fact that the show was an action series aimed at pre-teen boys. [[TheChick [[TheSmurfettePrinciple If only there was a trope for it...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Answering to myself, sort of: Goliath mentions that he fears what would leaving Xanatos behind do to the time stream; most likely both of them assume that [[EvilGenius a man of Xanatos's caliber]] would do remarkable things that would have changed the course of history had he stayed back in medieval times.

Added: 862

Changed: 19

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Sevarius using electric eels]]

to:

[[folder:Sevarius using electric eels]]eels in "Metamorphosis"]]


Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Xanatos knowing Goliath will take him back in "Vows"]]
Xanatos claims that he knows Goliath will take him back to the 20th century because [[StableTimeLoop he already did]]. Except Xanatos has no means of knowing this[[note]]unless there's another TimeTravel in a later episode, I have not yet watched the series all the way[[/note]]. He gave two items to the Illuminati that they should deliver to him: first the coin when he's a young man, and second the letter that describes the plan to ensure the StableTimeLoop. Had Goliath chosen not to return Xanatos to the present, the timeline would have remained largely the same: the Illuminati would have still delivered all items to Xanatos. Unless Xanatos assumes that, had he remained in the past, the history books would have kept the record of a genius mastermind in 10th Century Scotland...
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Sevarius using electric eels.]]

to:

[[folder:Sevarius using electric eels.]]eels]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder:Sevarius using electric eels.]]
Sevarius's theory is that gargoyles sustain their extremely powerful bodies by absorbing and storing solar energy in petrified form. He says that, unfortunately, there is no animal that does that, and chooses electric eels as the second best option for his LegoGenetics experiment to create gargoyles. There are two issues with this: 1) electric eels do not store external energy but produce their own, so giving the mutants electrophores would actually make them require even more energy; and 2) there's a whole kingdom of organisms whose entire physiology is based on absorbing and storing solar energy: plants. Why didn't he consider using plant DNA? Or symbiotic algae like corals and lichens do?
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Gabriel is with Ophelia, who was hardly offscreen.

to:

** Gabriel is with Ophelia, who was hardly offscreen. And in addition to her two more female members(a purple one with horns on her cheekbones,and a turquoise one with white hair) were seen in background shots, so the Avalon Clan had four female on-screen members. Word of God specifically gives the numbers of the Avalon Clan as 16 female members (including Angela and Ophelia), 17 male members (including Gabriel), 1 male gargoyle beast and 2 female gargoyle beasts (including Boudicca), which is almost a 50:50 split, far from a "3:1" ratio.

Top