Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / FrozenFever

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It doesn't matter how, we just can assume she did. The movie cuts from Anna grabbing the medicine from Oaken to a scene with Kristoff ("Dry banana hippy hat"), and by the time it cuts back to Elsa & Anna they are by the tower but we haven't seen how they got there from Oaken. So there was plenty of time/opportunity for Anna (during that time we weren't shown) to administer Elsa the medicine, whatever way she did it (probably covert). It's probable that Elsa ingested the medicine, because from that point on she isn't just sick but seemingly high (a common cough suppressant, even today, is Codeine, which is medically and chemically similar to heroin).

to:

*** **** It doesn't matter how, we just can assume she did. The movie cuts from Anna grabbing the medicine from Oaken to a scene with Kristoff ("Dry banana hippy hat"), and by the time it cuts back to Elsa & Anna they are by the tower but we haven't seen how they got there from Oaken. So there was plenty of time/opportunity for Anna (during that time we weren't shown) to administer Elsa the medicine, whatever way she did it (probably covert). It's probable that Elsa ingested the medicine, because from that point on she isn't just sick but seemingly high (a common cough suppressant, even today, is Codeine, which is medically and chemically similar to heroin).
***** ''Or'' Elsa was simply delirious from fever ("[[TitleDrop Frozen Fever]]") instead from taking the medicine (though that high a fever wouldn't be a simple "cold" anymore, but more like a serious flu or pneumonia)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**** It doesn't matter how, we just can assume she did. The movie cuts from Anna grabbing the medicine from Oaken to a scene with Kristoff ("Dry banana hippy hat"), and by the time it cuts back to Elsa & Anna they are by the tower but we haven't seen how they got there from Oaken. So there was plenty of time/opportunity for Anna (during that time we weren't shown) to administer Elsa the medicine, whatever way she did it (probably covert). It's probable that Elsa ingested the medicine, because from that point on she isn't just sick but seemingly high (a common cough suppressant, even today, is Codeine, which is medically and chemically similar to heroin).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She's so desperate to make up for years of missed birthdays to Anna that she nearly falls to her death. And then is *still* convinced she ruined Anna's birthday until told otherwise.

to:

** She's so desperate to make up for years of missed birthdays to Anna that she nearly falls to her death. And then is *still* ''still'' convinced she ruined Anna's birthday until told otherwise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** She's so desperate to make up for years of missed birthdays to Anna that she nearly falls to her death. And then is *still* convinced she ruined Anna's birthday until told otherwise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** LimitedWardrobe is the easiest answer. I'm sure she has a full wardrobe of clothing to wear that she's [[IncrediblyLamePun iced out]] to fit her new style. We just never see it because [[IconicOutfit the dress is iconic to her.]] Notice that Anna is still wearing the same clothes as before as well and Hans is shoveling manure in the same suit he was wearing to Elsa's coronation. The only recurring character to have an entirely new outfit from the movie is Oaken...well if you consider his [[NakedPeopleAreFunny state of]] [[CensorSteam dress]] to be an alternate outfit...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It seems like he would have warranted a much more drastic punishment, like exile.

to:

*** It seems like he his crimes would have warranted a much more drastic severe punishment, like exile.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It seems like he would have warranted a much more drastic punishment, like exile.

to:

*** It seems like he would have warranted a much more drastic punishment, like exile.exile.
** It's possible Hans's family didn't get the whole story, because his actions were only part of the film's main conflict - as everyone on the main page has said, Elsa fleeing the kingdom effectively meant she abdicated the throne to Anna, so she's not exactly the reigning monarch. Not to mention, she was the cause of the winter plaguing the kingdom, and Hans (as well as many others) figured that killing her was the only way to stop it, so he wasn't trying to kill her just with cementing his kingship in mind. Also, as informal as it was, Anna did initially accept his marriage proposal. There were a ''lot'' more details than just "Hans came to Arendelle and tried to kill Elsa to usurp her throne." What he did was still ''wrong'', mind you, but there were a number of reasons (and thus, potential defense arguments) he could've used to justify doing it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Maybe that was only part of his punishment?

to:

** Maybe that was only part of his punishment?punishment?
*** It seems like he would have warranted a much more drastic punishment, like exile.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why was Hans' punishment to clean up manuare? He tried to assassinate a foreign monarch and usurp rule of a country. Shouldn't he have had a more severe punishment due to taking actions that could incite a war?

to:

* Why was Hans' punishment to clean up manuare? He tried to assassinate a foreign monarch and usurp rule of a country. Shouldn't he have had a more severe punishment due to taking actions that could incite a war?war?
** Maybe that was only part of his punishment?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Isn't it a bit overdramatized to list Elsa as TheWoobie? I can understand in the original film, but the YMMV page seems to qualify her as one just because she gets sick. Since when did having an illness make you a Woobie?

to:

* Isn't it a bit overdramatized to list Elsa as TheWoobie? I can understand in the original film, but the YMMV page seems to qualify her as one just because she gets sick. Since when did having an illness make you a Woobie?Woobie?

*Why was Hans' punishment to clean up manuare? He tried to assassinate a foreign monarch and usurp rule of a country. Shouldn't he have had a more severe punishment due to taking actions that could incite a war?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A bit meta, I suppose, but why does ''Frozen Fever'' have its own Headscratchers page? It's not like there's such an abundance of information that it would necessitate having its own page - there's only a few questions here. Why not just add them to the page for the film?

to:

* A bit meta, I suppose, but why does ''Frozen Fever'' have its own Headscratchers page? It's not like there's such an abundance of information that it would necessitate having its own page - there's only a few questions here. Why not just add them to the page for the film?film?

* Isn't it a bit overdramatized to list Elsa as TheWoobie? I can understand in the original film, but the YMMV page seems to qualify her as one just because she gets sick. Since when did having an illness make you a Woobie?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** How? I know she was the one who took it from Oaken but how would she convince Elsa to actually drink it?

to:

*** How? I know she was the one who took it from Oaken but how would she convince Elsa to actually drink it?it?

* A bit meta, I suppose, but why does ''Frozen Fever'' have its own Headscratchers page? It's not like there's such an abundance of information that it would necessitate having its own page - there's only a few questions here. Why not just add them to the page for the film?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Anna did it

to:

** Anna did itit
*** How? I know she was the one who took it from Oaken but how would she convince Elsa to actually drink it?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's suggested Oaken's medicine was partially to blame for Elsa's delirium near the end. Yes, it probably did contain opium or some other narcotic given the time period, but why would Elsa take it to begin with when she was still in denial of her illness?

to:

* It's suggested Oaken's medicine was partially to blame for Elsa's delirium near the end. Yes, it probably did contain opium or some other narcotic given the time period, but why would Elsa take it to begin with when she was still in denial of her illness?illness?
** Anna did it

Added: 257

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{ClockDiscrepancy}} During the scene where Else almost falls off the clock tower, the time on the clock face (~4:50pm) is wrong for Arendelle's latitude on June 22 (Anna's birthday is the summer solstice). The sun is setting, which wouldn't happen to after 10pm that far north. If the minute hand and hour hands were reversed, it would be more appropriate.

to:

* {{ClockDiscrepancy}} {{Clock Discrepancy}} During the scene where Else almost falls off the clock tower, the time on the clock face (~4:50pm) is wrong for Arendelle's latitude on June 22 (Anna's birthday is the summer solstice). The sun is setting, which wouldn't happen to after 10pm that far north. If the minute hand and hour hands were reversed, it would be more appropriate.



** Either she does (maybe it's just ''really'' comfortable), or she made multiple copies. Or she was planning to do physical work (normal dresses are not great for that) and then magically transform her dress (which would destroy the original, but presumably wouldn't destroy an existing magic ice dress).

to:

** Either she does (maybe it's just ''really'' comfortable), or she made multiple copies. Or she was planning to do physical work (normal dresses are not great for that) and then magically transform her dress (which would destroy the original, but presumably wouldn't destroy an existing magic ice dress).dress).

* It's suggested Oaken's medicine was partially to blame for Elsa's delirium near the end. Yes, it probably did contain opium or some other narcotic given the time period, but why would Elsa take it to begin with when she was still in denial of her illness?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Does Elsa just wear that blue ice dress all the time now? I understand that it might be something of an iconic outfit for her, but wouldn't she ever consider seeing what other clothing designs she could create once she'd returned to Arendelle? The decision to keep her in it, from my perspective, really seems more like some sort of marketing gimmick than it does an actual representation of character... (And I know it's one thing to wear it during Anna's birthday festivities, but then she's also shown wearing it while ''preparing'' said festivities, even though I feel that even ''royals'' would have less fanciful attire that they would wear during such a time.)

to:

* Does Elsa just wear that blue ice dress all the time now? I understand that it might be something of an iconic outfit for her, but wouldn't she ever consider seeing what other clothing designs she could create once she'd returned to Arendelle? The decision to keep her in it, from my perspective, really seems more like some sort of marketing gimmick than it does an actual representation of character... (And I know it's one thing to wear it during Anna's birthday festivities, but then she's also shown wearing it while ''preparing'' said festivities, even though I feel that even ''royals'' would have less fanciful attire that they would wear during such a time.))
** Either she does (maybe it's just ''really'' comfortable), or she made multiple copies. Or she was planning to do physical work (normal dresses are not great for that) and then magically transform her dress (which would destroy the original, but presumably wouldn't destroy an existing magic ice dress).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There is also the fact that Frozen takes place when people though colds were actually by the cold, which doesn't bother Elsa, instead of by germs. You also should remember that for most of her life Elsa avoid contacts with others as much as possible thus not getting in contact with germs and not getting sick, though with a weakened immune system as a result.

to:

** There is also the fact that Frozen takes place when people though thought colds were actually caused by the cold, which doesn't bother Elsa, instead of by germs. You also should remember that for most of her life Elsa avoid contacts with others as much as possible thus not getting in contact with germs and not getting sick, though with a weakened immune system as a result.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** There is also the fact that Frozen takes place when people though colds were actually by the cold, which doesn't bother Elsa, instead of by germs. You also should remember that for most of her life Elsa avoid contacts with others as much as possible thus not getting in contact with germs and not getting sick, though with a weakened immune system as a result.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Does Elsa just wear that blue ice dress all the time now? I understand that it might be something of an iconic outfit for her, but wouldn't she ever consider seeing what other clothing designs she could create once she'd returned to Arendelle? The decision to keep her in it, from my perspective, really seems more like some sort of marketing gimmick than it does an actual representation of character...

to:

* Does Elsa just wear that blue ice dress all the time now? I understand that it might be something of an iconic outfit for her, but wouldn't she ever consider seeing what other clothing designs she could create once she'd returned to Arendelle? The decision to keep her in it, from my perspective, really seems more like some sort of marketing gimmick than it does an actual representation of character... (And I know it's one thing to wear it during Anna's birthday festivities, but then she's also shown wearing it while ''preparing'' said festivities, even though I feel that even ''royals'' would have less fanciful attire that they would wear during such a time.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Basically, a piece of fanon formed that Elsa having elemental powers meant she's some sort of PhysicalGod and therefore immortal. Immunity to cold meaning immunity to illness as well. There are fanfics where she outlives Anna and ends up becoming centuries old and WalkingTheEarth. Highly unlikely in retrospect, but with limited info about her powers in the film, people will fill in the big blanks their own way.

to:

** Basically, a piece of fanon formed that Elsa having elemental powers meant she's some sort of PhysicalGod and therefore immortal. Immunity to cold meaning immunity to illness as well. There are fanfics where she outlives Anna and ends up becoming centuries old and WalkingTheEarth. Highly unlikely in retrospect, but with limited info about her powers in the film, people will fill in the big blanks their own way.way.

* Does Elsa just wear that blue ice dress all the time now? I understand that it might be something of an iconic outfit for her, but wouldn't she ever consider seeing what other clothing designs she could create once she'd returned to Arendelle? The decision to keep her in it, from my perspective, really seems more like some sort of marketing gimmick than it does an actual representation of character...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Fevers are a defense mechanism. Getting rid of one before it runs its course would actually make the problem worse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Possibly worth noting is ''Frozen Fever'' was confirmed somewhere to have taken place a few months after ''Frozen'', which a line from Oaken suggests takes place in July, meaning the short would probably take place somewhere in fall or early winter. What this says about the exact date of Anna's birthday is unclear, but it could serve as a reasonable answer to this question.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This page is for plot questions, not complaints, but whatever, there\'s an answerable question here.





* Why are people so perplexed over Elsa getting sick in this short? She's a normal girl with ice powers, not a goddess who's immune to illness.

to:

* Why are people so perplexed over Elsa getting sick in this short? She's a normal girl with ice powers, not a goddess who's immune to illness.illness.
** Basically, a piece of fanon formed that Elsa having elemental powers meant she's some sort of PhysicalGod and therefore immortal. Immunity to cold meaning immunity to illness as well. There are fanfics where she outlives Anna and ends up becoming centuries old and WalkingTheEarth. Highly unlikely in retrospect, but with limited info about her powers in the film, people will fill in the big blanks their own way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I'm not so sure that fevers work that way, but even on the off chance that they do, Elsa spends a majority of the short denying that she has a cold so they can proceed with Anna's party plans undeterred. She may not have the ability or the knowledge of how to cool herself down enough to ease her symptoms, if it is possible.

to:

** I'm not so sure that fevers work that way, but even on the off chance that they do, Elsa spends a majority of the short denying that she has a cold so they can proceed with Anna's party plans undeterred. She may not have the ability or the knowledge of how to cool herself down enough to ease her symptoms, if it is possible.possible.

* Why are people so perplexed over Elsa getting sick in this short? She's a normal girl with ice powers, not a goddess who's immune to illness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Wouldn't Elsa be able to cure her fever with her powers (IE, cooling herself down) pretty easily? I mean, it wouldn't cure all the symptoms, but I'm a little surprised they never thought of that.

to:

* Wouldn't Elsa be able to cure her fever with her powers (IE, cooling herself down) pretty easily? I mean, it wouldn't cure all the symptoms, but I'm a little surprised they never thought of that.that.
** I'm not so sure that fevers work that way, but even on the off chance that they do, Elsa spends a majority of the short denying that she has a cold so they can proceed with Anna's party plans undeterred. She may not have the ability or the knowledge of how to cool herself down enough to ease her symptoms, if it is possible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[AWizardDidIt Elsa's cold screwed up the weather. And the atmosphere. And the rotation of the earth.]]

to:

** [[AWizardDidIt Elsa's cold screwed up the weather. And the atmosphere. And the rotation of the earth.]]]]


* Wouldn't Elsa be able to cure her fever with her powers (IE, cooling herself down) pretty easily? I mean, it wouldn't cure all the symptoms, but I'm a little surprised they never thought of that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{ClockDiscrepancy}} During the scene where Else almost falls off the clock tower, the time on the clock face (~4:50pm) is wrong for Arendelle's latitude on June 22 (Anna's birthday is the summer solstice). The sun is setting, which wouldn't happen to after 10pm that far north. If the minute hand and hour hands were reversed, it would be more appropriate.

to:

* {{ClockDiscrepancy}} During the scene where Else almost falls off the clock tower, the time on the clock face (~4:50pm) is wrong for Arendelle's latitude on June 22 (Anna's birthday is the summer solstice). The sun is setting, which wouldn't happen to after 10pm that far north. If the minute hand and hour hands were reversed, it would be more appropriate.appropriate.
** [[AWizardDidIt Elsa's cold screwed up the weather. And the atmosphere. And the rotation of the earth.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* During the scene where Else almost falls off the clock tower, the time on the clock face (~4:50pm) is wrong for Arendelle's latitude on June 22 (Anna's birthday is the summer solstice). The sun is setting, which wouldn't happen to after 10pm that far north. If the minute hand and hour hands were reversed, it would be more appropriate.

to:

* {{ClockDiscrepancy}} During the scene where Else almost falls off the clock tower, the time on the clock face (~4:50pm) is wrong for Arendelle's latitude on June 22 (Anna's birthday is the summer solstice). The sun is setting, which wouldn't happen to after 10pm that far north. If the minute hand and hour hands were reversed, it would be more appropriate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* During the scene where Else almost falls off the clock tower, the time on the clock face (~4:50pm) is wrong for Arendelle's latitude on June 22 (Anna's birthday is the summer solstice). The sun is setting, which wouldn't happen to after 10pm that far north. If the minute hand and hour hands were reversed, it would be more appropriate.

Top