History Headscratchers / FairyTail

28th Sep '16 6:47:48 PM deltanine
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Well I don't think Erza would be any better than Kyoka if she did all of that to her. Besides Erza is a knight who values good traits even when she hated the cult that tortured her she would never give them the same kind of treatment. In fact, when Jellal started torturing them, she strongly objected to it.

to:

** Well I don't think Erza would be any better than Kyoka if she did all of that to her. Besides Erza is a knight who values good traits even when she hated the cult that tortured her when she was a child, she would never give them the same kind of treatment. In fact, when Jellal started torturing them, she strongly objected to it.


Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Time Paradox]]
Okay, so, if Gray killing Frosch in the future was supposed to have sent Rogue over the edge, shouldn't his death have caused a time paradox during the dragon invasion? After all, without Gray alive to kill Frosch the next year, Rogue wouldn't have any motivation to go over the edge in the first place.
24th Jun '16 3:00:32 PM ilovehirohamada
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* It might have also been a way to terrify the shit out of them, and get them thinking "If he's capable of doing ''that'', then maybe we shouldn't screw with these guys anymore." I mean, if you were in their position, would you take something like Fairy Law lightly?
20th May '16 5:58:25 PM Fire
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Lisanna on Edolas]]
Why she said she had to hide her magic powers from others? How could she still use magic (eartland style) in first place, since she hadn't eaten any pill?
5th May '16 4:06:10 AM TheOneWhoTropes
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* [[AWizardDidIt Spiral]] [[TengenToppaGurrenLagann power]]. Sort of. Gray's ice make magic is relatively normal compared to Lyon's ice animals and [[spoiler: Ultear's]] ice flowers. It's not about ice, actually, make magic transforms wizard's magic power to material objects according to their personality, so they can do whatever they can imagine.

to:

* [[AWizardDidIt Spiral]] [[TengenToppaGurrenLagann [[Anime/TengenToppaGurrenLagann power]]. Sort of. Gray's ice make magic is relatively normal compared to Lyon's ice animals and [[spoiler: Ultear's]] ice flowers. It's not about ice, actually, make magic transforms wizard's magic power to material objects according to their personality, so they can do whatever they can imagine.
24th Mar '16 1:56:20 PM Willbyr
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* If the Lachryma are supposed to be solid spells, and according to Cobra humans shouldn't be able to normally learn Dragon Slayer, how are they made in the first place? Not only that, but they cheapen the Dragon Slayer's awesomeness. It's like how everybody and their mother have a Sharingan in {{Naruto}}

to:

* If the Lachryma are supposed to be solid spells, and according to Cobra humans shouldn't be able to normally learn Dragon Slayer, how are they made in the first place? Not only that, but they cheapen the Dragon Slayer's awesomeness. It's like how everybody and their mother have a Sharingan in {{Naruto}}''Manga/{{Naruto}}''.



* This seems to be an issue a lot of manga have, particularly so here as Gerard also has [[YouGottaHaveBlueHair Blue Hair]] and is of a darker shade than Happy in the manga. Meh, best I can tell is that they simply choose what's easiest to use consistently with characters more central to the story and just roll with it. Worst case I've seen thus far is with [[{{Naruto}} Kishimoto's]] completely random choice of shadings for Red Hair and similar coloration's, with Garra and Roushi being outright white while he completely flipped it all the way around with Nagato and Karin by making it freaking ''black'', so that for the longest time people thought their hair color actually was black until a color page of them was released.

to:

* This seems to be an issue a lot of manga have, particularly so here as Gerard also has [[YouGottaHaveBlueHair Blue Hair]] and is of a darker shade than Happy in the manga. Meh, best I can tell is that they simply choose what's easiest to use consistently with characters more central to the story and just roll with it. Worst case I've seen thus far is with [[{{Naruto}} [[Manga/{{Naruto}} Kishimoto's]] completely random choice of shadings for Red Hair and similar coloration's, with Garra and Roushi being outright white while he completely flipped it all the way around with Nagato and Karin by making it freaking ''black'', so that for the longest time people thought their hair color actually was black until a color page of them was released.



* From another series for a change, the first thing I thought when I saw Kageyama was "hey, evil [[{{Naruto}} Shikamaru!]]" Same hairstyle, similar powerset only stronger (but with less HeartIsAnAwesomePower potential)...

to:

* From another series for a change, the first thing I thought when I saw Kageyama was "hey, evil [[{{Naruto}} [[Manga/{{Naruto}} Shikamaru!]]" Same hairstyle, similar powerset only stronger (but with less HeartIsAnAwesomePower potential)...
15th Mar '16 10:39:27 AM Doug86
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* I think a bigger question here is why Makarov didn't stick all his aces on the one team. I do understand that that is kinda an "all your eggs" scenario but ([[spoiler: especially with the last minute Jellal addition]]) why he didn't go with [[spoiler: Jellal]], Laxus, Mira, Erza and then pick, say, Natsu or Gajeel, [[spoiler: then stick all his other top tiers in the B Team]] is completely beyond me. Let's be honest here, a team that stacked would have about as much a chance of losing as AlexanderTheGreat in Persia. [[spoiler: His B team would be pretty badass as well, Gray, Lucy, Wendy, Natsu/Gajeel and Juvia.]]

to:

* I think a bigger question here is why Makarov didn't stick all his aces on the one team. I do understand that that is kinda an "all your eggs" scenario but ([[spoiler: especially with the last minute Jellal addition]]) why he didn't go with [[spoiler: Jellal]], Laxus, Mira, Erza and then pick, say, Natsu or Gajeel, [[spoiler: then stick all his other top tiers in the B Team]] is completely beyond me. Let's be honest here, a team that stacked would have about as much a chance of losing as AlexanderTheGreat UsefulNotes/AlexanderTheGreat in Persia. [[spoiler: His B team would be pretty badass as well, Gray, Lucy, Wendy, Natsu/Gajeel and Juvia.]]
28th Dec '15 11:48:12 PM Ana0119
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* The thing about the key and the Dragon Cannon [[FridgeLogic don't make sense]]. If Edoras is planning on firing it at the lachryma, they said that it would fuse them together with the magic of Exteria. But Sugarboy told Gray that it would turn the people back to normal. I suppose we have to assume Sugarboy really was bluffing, but he seemed really serious about it, especially after the key was destroyed. But even if he WAS bluffing, then Gray went ahead and made a replica, so we can only assume he plans to use it.

to:

* The thing about the key and the Dragon Cannon [[FridgeLogic don't make sense]]. If Edoras is planning on firing it at the lachryma, they said that it would fuse them together with the magic of Exteria. But Sugarboy told Gray that it would turn the people back to normal. I suppose we have to assume Sugarboy really was bluffing, but he seemed really serious about it, especially after the key was destroyed. But even if he WAS bluffing, then Gray went ahead and made a replica, so we can only assume he plans to use it.



** The plan wasn't to aim it at the lachryma, the plan was to aim it at the floating rock the lachryma is on and then guiding it to crash into Extalia. As shown here: http://mangastream.com/read/fairy_tail/83663107/18

to:

** * The plan wasn't to aim it at the lachryma, the plan was to aim it at the floating rock the lachryma is on and then guiding it to crash into Extalia. As shown here: http://mangastream.com/read/fairy_tail/83663107/18
28th Dec '15 11:46:51 PM Ana0119
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Knowing [[{{Jerkass}} Aquarius]], I wouldn't put that last part by her.

to:

** * Knowing [[{{Jerkass}} Aquarius]], I wouldn't put that last part by her.
* I think she asked for two weeks real world time. If three months in the real world was only one night in the spirit world, then two weeks in the real world would be a few hours in the spirit world. That actually makes her request sound much more reasonable. The real question is, why do they ask for certain days of the week? How does that work out?
7th Dec '15 8:23:42 AM deltanine
Is there an issue? Send a Message


**** Erza outright ''told'' Kyouka at the start of Chapter 372 that she hopes to get revenge on her. She even had a SlasherSmile on her face while doing so! Since she didn't torture Kyouka, how was she planning to get her "revenge"? Also, OutOfCharacterIsSeriousBusiness.

to:

**** Erza outright ''told'' Kyouka [[http://www.mangapanda.com/fairy-tail/372 at the start of Chapter 372 that she hopes to get revenge on her.her]]. She even had a SlasherSmile on her face while doing so! Since she didn't torture Kyouka, how was she planning to get her "revenge"? Also, OutOfCharacterIsSeriousBusiness.
6th Dec '15 7:29:09 PM deltanine
Is there an issue? Send a Message


**** Erza outright ''told'' Kyouka at the start of Chapter 372 that she hopes to get revenge on her. She even had a SlasherSmile on her face while doing so! Since she didn't torture Kyouka, how was she planning to get her "revenge"?

to:

**** Erza outright ''told'' Kyouka at the start of Chapter 372 that she hopes to get revenge on her. She even had a SlasherSmile on her face while doing so! Since she didn't torture Kyouka, how was she planning to get her "revenge"?
"revenge"? Also, OutOfCharacterIsSeriousBusiness.
This list shows the last 10 events of 509. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.FairyTail