Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Advertising

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Advertisements work on a number of levels, and when you actually learn about all of them you're response will be somewhere between deep respect and further IJBM. Even those who think that they are most hardened against them are affected more than they think. Now, when it comes to soda, you seem to be under the impression that they are targeting every single person. While it might be nice to sway you, they're just targeting the tautological group of people they are able to sway. The sad part? In general, this group isn't really large enough to justify normal advertising costs (new products and promotions obviously alter this), but it is large enough that Pepsi letting Coke dominate the advertising realm would be significant to them. It's essentially a case study of the prisoner's dilemma.

to:

*** Advertisements work on a number of levels, and when you actually learn about all of them you're response will be somewhere between deep respect and further IJBM. Even those who think that they are most hardened against them are affected more than they think. Now, when it comes to soda, you seem to be under the impression that they are targeting every single person. While it might be nice to sway you, they're just targeting the tautological group of people they are able to sway. The sad part? In general, this group isn't really large enough to justify normal advertising costs (new products and promotions obviously alter this), but it is large enough that Pepsi letting Coke dominate the advertising realm would be significant to them. It's essentially a case study of the prisoner's dilemma.PrisonersDilemma.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** On the other side of the coin is the Lucky Charms leprechaun--"They're always after me Lucky Charms!" So, what's the problem? You're a ''leprechaun''. You can make more! In fact, you're probably the only being in the universe who ''can''!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Probably they're saying that the series in question won't feature a mid-season interlude of reruns, which is something some programs do to stretch out their new episodes' debuts across two sweeps-week periods and to allow for mid-season cliffhangers.

to:

** Probably they're saying that the series in question won't feature a mid-season interlude of reruns, which is reruns, That's something some an increasing number of programs do to stretch out their new episodes' debuts across two sweeps-week periods and to allow for mid-season cliffhangers.cliffhangers or a hiatus in their shooting schedule.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Probably they're saying that the series in question won't feature a mid-season interlude of reruns, which is something some programs do to stretch out their new episodes' debuts across two sweeps-week periods and to allow for mid-season cliffhangers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** His ''voice'' is also rather irritating.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**You all will love the new commercials. They're moving away from the "dudebro" market in a glorious fashion. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WzTSE6kcLwY
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**I think they're trying to create imagery that supposedly describes how it smells. It comes off looking more like an ad for recreational drugs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This has to do more with movie posters than any actual commercials on television, but here goes. Is there ANY film that's come out recently that hasn't used an [[OrangeBlueContrast overwhelming amount of orange and blue on their posters?]] It's ugly and makes them all look the same. Not to mention [[ViewersAreMorons insulting]], as the orange/blue contrast is supposed to be the most subliminally pleasing to our eyes, and is somehow more likely to make us purchase movie tickets. (Because you know, actual trailers/actors/directors don't generate any interest in said film, no sir) I'm a big collector of movie posters, and there's hardly any from the past decade I find worth owning because of this hideous trend.

to:

* This has to do more with movie posters than any actual commercials on television, but here goes. Is there ANY film that's come out recently that hasn't used an [[OrangeBlueContrast overwhelming amount of orange and blue on their posters?]] It's ugly and makes them all look the same. Not to mention [[ViewersAreMorons insulting]], insulting, as the orange/blue contrast is supposed to be the most subliminally pleasing to our eyes, and is somehow more likely to make us purchase movie tickets. (Because you know, actual trailers/actors/directors don't generate any interest in said film, no sir) I'm a big collector of movie posters, and there's hardly any from the past decade I find worth owning because of this hideous trend.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Has Revlon STILL not realized yet that their "women's nailpolished hands feeling up a man's face" ad campaign makes it look like a man is touching his own face with his own immaculately polished nails? I hope they never realize. I like the commercials/ads/product display banners better this way. I can pretend it's progressive.

to:

* Has Revlon STILL not realized yet that their "women's nailpolished hands feeling up a man's face" ad campaign makes it look like a man is touching his own face with his own immaculately polished nails? I hope they never realize. I like the commercials/ads/product display banners better this way. I can pretend it's progressive.progressive.
* Who the hell watches "Paid Programming?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Technically the caveman was specifically for GEICO.com.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Since in the USA sales tax is set by the state/local governments, it's not technically false advertising because you aren’t paying more than $1 for the item. You pay your $1 for the item. You are obligated to pay sales tax to the state. McDonalds collects that on the state's behalf, but you aren’t paying it to them and it is not part of the official cost of the item. Simple way to see this in action is if you have ever bought a car from a friend. Say your friend sold you a car for $2000. When you go to register the car in your name, you'll discover that you have to pay the sales tax on the $2000 at that time, since the default assumption is that $2000 was the price of the car, not including tax.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***It's implied that the women thinks the guy is reading his friends book and is disgusted by it, which is the whole point, having a second to think and turn a bad situation into a good one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** A similar law was introduced some years ago, in the Uk. However, they exempted station promos from it. With the result that the ad blocks are now the same volume as the shows...but the five minutes of promos either side will blast your ears off if you fail to grab the remote quickly enough.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Brand recognition. The shape of glass Coke bottles has been an easy way to identify the product for years. When Pepsi first introduced larger "family" sized bottles, one benefit was that Coke couldn't produce the same iconic shape in that size (at least at first). Using the glass bottle remains a war to be distinct, with few if any other brands using similar materials. Also, glass bottles can seem more luxurious and imply a higher quality product.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** What if you ARE a professional driver on a closed course? It still says "do not attempt". Can I ask why they always depict their cars skidding uncontrollably? Is this supposed to inspire confidence?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They think they're funny by acting silly, I guess. Some kids will do anything for attention, for that matter.


Added DiffLines:

** {{Frivolous Lawsuit}}s. Nothing stops a person from driving to that intersection in real life and making a left turn, then crashing into someone and blaming the car company or the advertising company for depicting that exact same turn, especially if the commercial's talking about how safe the car is. I rarely see that fine print unless the car is doing something unusual or dangerous, however. There was a Scion commercial recently that poked fun at this kind of fine print though, with the car doing things that a normal car obviously cannot do, like [[GrindBoots grind on rails]] (complete with short sideways hop).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
cleaning Captain Obvious trope sinkhole use, project thread here; there\'s some bad Natter around, \"social justice\" (agenda edits) and This Troper violations; cut chained sinkholes along with one of \"Captains\"


*** I can understand how that would bug someone, but in the end [[http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2008/05/24/onslaught-dove-vs-axe/ money speaks higher than morals]],oh, and [[CaptainObvious Axe is targeted towards men while Dove is targeted towards women.]]

to:

*** I can understand how that would bug someone, but in the end [[http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2008/05/24/onslaught-dove-vs-axe/ money speaks higher than morals]],oh, and [[CaptainObvious Axe is targeted towards men while Dove is targeted towards women.]]



** One of the Target ads that's a bit cleverer than the rest (not that that's saying much) shows a boy standing by an open jar of Market Pantry peanut butter and an open jar of Market Pantry jelly that are on the kitchen counter. He reaches one hand into the peanut butter and gets a handful. He reaches the other hand into the jelly and gets a handful. He brings the two hands together and begins trying to eat the mess while jelly drips out of his hands. Scene switches to a picture of Market Pantry ''bread'' on a red background with the caption "80¢". Cue Target logo. [[CaptainObvious His mother ''really'' should have known to buy bread.]]

to:

** One of the Target ads that's a bit cleverer than the rest (not that that's saying much) shows a boy standing by an open jar of Market Pantry peanut butter and an open jar of Market Pantry jelly that are on the kitchen counter. He reaches one hand into the peanut butter and gets a handful. He reaches the other hand into the jelly and gets a handful. He brings the two hands together and begins trying to eat the mess while jelly drips out of his hands. Scene switches to a picture of Market Pantry ''bread'' on a red background with the caption "80¢". Cue Target logo. [[CaptainObvious His mother ''really'' should have known to buy bread.]]



* I've been seeing lots of commercials that advertise that shows are going to be new for the rest of the season. Aren't the episodes in the season supposed to be new? If the episodes are reruns, they obviously aren't new, and not part of the rest of the season, so saying shows will be new for the rest of their season [[CaptainObvious doesn't]] [[ShapedLikeItself accomplish]] [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin anything]]. The only other thing I can think of is the Earth's seasons (i.e. Shows will be new for the rest of Spring). If not, then what are these commercials going on about?

to:

* I've been seeing lots of commercials that advertise that shows are going to be new for the rest of the season. Aren't the episodes in the season supposed to be new? If the episodes are reruns, they obviously aren't new, and not part of the rest of the season, so saying shows will be new for the rest of their season [[CaptainObvious doesn't]] [[ShapedLikeItself accomplish]] [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin anything]].doesn't accomplish anything. The only other thing I can think of is the Earth's seasons (i.e. Shows will be new for the rest of Spring). If not, then what are these commercials going on about?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Often times, car commercials will have a warning saying "Professional driver. Closed Course. Do not attempt." For the most part, it makes sense; they're often driving pretty fast in some kind of desert for...some reason. But in the commercials taking place in a city, doing relatively normal things, why should you not attempt them? What's wrong with making a left turn? [[EveryCarIsAPinto Will the car explode if you do so?]]

to:

* Often times, car commercials will have a warning saying "Professional driver. Closed Course. Do not attempt." For the most part, it makes sense; they're often driving pretty fast in some kind of desert for...some reason. But in the commercials taking place in a city, doing relatively normal things, why should you not attempt them? What's wrong with making a left turn? [[EveryCarIsAPinto Will the car explode if you do so?]]so?]]
* Has Revlon STILL not realized yet that their "women's nailpolished hands feeling up a man's face" ad campaign makes it look like a man is touching his own face with his own immaculately polished nails? I hope they never realize. I like the commercials/ads/product display banners better this way. I can pretend it's progressive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Because he's constantly too ''happy'' with the idea of laundry. Well, he can do mine if he wanted!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Baby Bottle Pop. You know, those baby-bottle-shaped lollipops with the container of powdered sugar? What do those girls say near the beginning? "They look like babies!" Now, maybe I'm misreading the mindset of the target demographic, but isn't that the last thing they want to look like?

to:

* Baby Bottle Pop. You know, those baby-bottle-shaped lollipops with the container of powdered sugar? What do those girls say near the beginning? "They look like babies!" Now, maybe I'm misreading the mindset of the target demographic, but isn't that the last thing they want to look like?like?
* Often times, car commercials will have a warning saying "Professional driver. Closed Course. Do not attempt." For the most part, it makes sense; they're often driving pretty fast in some kind of desert for...some reason. But in the commercials taking place in a city, doing relatively normal things, why should you not attempt them? What's wrong with making a left turn? [[EveryCarIsAPinto Will the car explode if you do so?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And what about the new new commercials? Like... Right Side vs. Left Side? What??? No, like seriously, ''what''?? There is literally no point to this nonsense. No one thinks that the left side is any different than the right or that there are two factories, each making only one side. That just breaks any level of suspension of disbelief for me. And then there was the one that was a ripoff of Charlie and the Chocolate factory... Sigh. The whole thing is just nonsensical.

to:

** And what about the new new commercials? Like... Right Side vs. Left Side? What??? No, like seriously, ''what''?? There is literally no point to this nonsense. No one thinks that the left side is any different than the right or that there are two factories, each making only one side. That just breaks any level of suspension of disbelief for me.This Troper. And then there was the one that was a ripoff of Charlie and the Chocolate factory... Sigh. The whole thing is just nonsensical.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And what about the new new commercials? Like... Right Side vs. Left Side? What??? No, like seriously, ''what''?? There is literally no point to this nonsense. No one thinks that the left side is any different than the right or that there are two factories, each making only one side. That just breaks any level of suspension of disbelief for me. And then there was the one that was a ripoff of Charlie and the Chocolate factory... Sigh. The whole thing is just nonsensical.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I recall a Trix commercial where the rabbit bought some with his own money, and the kids stole it from him anyway. So, they don't buy it because [[KidsAreCruel kids are complete assholes]].

to:

** I recall a Trix commercial where the rabbit bought some with his own money, and the kids stole it from him anyway. So, they don't buy it because [[KidsAreCruel kids are complete assholes]].assholes]].
* Baby Bottle Pop. You know, those baby-bottle-shaped lollipops with the container of powdered sugar? What do those girls say near the beginning? "They look like babies!" Now, maybe I'm misreading the mindset of the target demographic, but isn't that the last thing they want to look like?

Added: 192

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why do cereal mascots in commercials waste their time trying to steal cereal from kids? Why not go to the local grocery store and buy it if they crave it so much? They can't be broke if they can afford costumes, wigs, and acme gadgets (which cost more than a box of cereal).

to:

* Why do cereal mascots in commercials waste their time trying to steal cereal from kids? Why not go to the local grocery store and buy it if they crave it so much? They can't be broke if they can afford costumes, wigs, and acme gadgets (which cost more than a box of cereal). cereal).
** I recall a Trix commercial where the rabbit bought some with his own money, and the kids stole it from him anyway. So, they don't buy it because [[KidsAreCruel kids are complete assholes]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why do cereal mascots in commercials waste their time trying to steal cereal from kids? Why not go to the local grocery store and buy it if they crave it so bad? They can't be broke if they can afford wacky costumes and acme gadgets.

to:

* Why do cereal mascots in commercials waste their time trying to steal cereal from kids? Why not go to the local grocery store and buy it if they crave it so bad? much? They can't be broke if they can afford wacky costumes costumes, wigs, and acme gadgets.gadgets (which cost more than a box of cereal).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I've been seeing lots of commercials that advertise that shows are going to be new for the rest of the season. Aren't the episodes in the season supposed to be new? If the episodes are reruns, they obviously aren't new, and not part of the rest of the season, so saying shows will be new for the rest of their season [[CaptainObvious doesn't]] [[ShapedLikeItself accomplish]] [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin anything]]. The only other thing I can think of is the Earth's seasons (i.e. Shows will be new for the rest of Spring). If not, then what are these commercials going on about?

to:

* I've been seeing lots of commercials that advertise that shows are going to be new for the rest of the season. Aren't the episodes in the season supposed to be new? If the episodes are reruns, they obviously aren't new, and not part of the rest of the season, so saying shows will be new for the rest of their season [[CaptainObvious doesn't]] [[ShapedLikeItself accomplish]] [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin anything]]. The only other thing I can think of is the Earth's seasons (i.e. Shows will be new for the rest of Spring). If not, then what are these commercials going on about?about?
* Why do cereal mascots in commercials waste their time trying to steal cereal from kids? Why not go to the local grocery store and buy it if they crave it so bad? They can't be broke if they can afford wacky costumes and acme gadgets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Are a lot of these people who make advertisements self-entitled narcissistic jerks who hate goody-two-shoes, [[DrivesLikeCrazy drive like maniacs]], and wished they could get away with everything they wanted with no consequences? And if male, they wished they could surround themselves with beautiful but shallow women 24/7 who fawn after them for no reason? Because there are a lot of commercials whose protagonists behave that way and get off scot-free at the end. It's so often, it goes beyond WishFulfillment for its target audience and becomes wish fulfillment for themselves.

to:

* Are a lot of these people who make advertisements self-entitled narcissistic jerks who hate goody-two-shoes, [[DrivesLikeCrazy drive like maniacs]], and wished they could get away with everything they wanted with no consequences? And if male, they wished they could surround themselves with beautiful but shallow women 24/7 who fawn after them for no reason? Because there are a lot of commercials whose protagonists behave that way and get off scot-free at the end. It's so often, it goes beyond WishFulfillment for its target audience and becomes wish fulfillment for themselves.themselves.
* I've been seeing lots of commercials that advertise that shows are going to be new for the rest of the season. Aren't the episodes in the season supposed to be new? If the episodes are reruns, they obviously aren't new, and not part of the rest of the season, so saying shows will be new for the rest of their season [[CaptainObvious doesn't]] [[ShapedLikeItself accomplish]] [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin anything]]. The only other thing I can think of is the Earth's seasons (i.e. Shows will be new for the rest of Spring). If not, then what are these commercials going on about?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Even more irritating: Why do all Coke commercials show people drinking Coke from glass bottles, when those bottles are difficult if not impossible to find, at least in the U.S.? You can find glass bottles imported from Mexico, and sometimes six-packs of small glass bottles, but they are far more expensive... and you certainly can never find glass Coke bottles in vending machines, or Diet Coke in glass bottles, both regularly pictured in commercials. I think it's false advertising.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's blacker comedy. The Snickers guys don't find it funny enough unless the victims get fleshed out (pun not intended). It's something like shock comedy: It was supposed to be funny in its audaciousness. Clearly, it didn't work with you.



** The video is out, but isn't parental favoritism common?



** Depending on the household, they may be marketing to families whose parents eat totally different things for breakfast than the kids (or don't eat breakfast at all). It is also possible that commercials like these (as well as a lot of other children's foods, most notably Trix cereal) are meant to feel empowering to children, that they can outwit and defeat even seemingly invincible authority figures like parents. They associate that feeling of empowerment with the food and want it.



** Clearly the existence of Spike TV and the like show that marketing people think young men ARE like that. Or impressionable ones, at least.



** The writers didn't think that far. Or it's absurdist comedy, that you're supposed to laugh because they made an illogical decision (which would work against the commercial).



** Two things: Advertising firms tend to be run by old white men who have lived through the Civil Rights Movement and may have quietly resented them, and men ARE depicted cooking in commercials, such as one during 2012 for Reynolds Wrap aluminum foil. They just aren't depicted cooking ''competently'' that often.



** The commercial you speak of seems to be aimed at people who feel guilty about being a dick and want to find something to alleviate that guilt besides apologizing and, well, acting decently.



** If he's that out of it in class, he probably doesn't know any better.



** One-upmanship. Insecure men who want to look manly have no limits.



* The Sprint phone "Framily Plan" commercials. To a point I can see what they're doing; showing how the plan can allow a bunch of very different people to all be in on one plan or whatever. What I don't get is.... ''why is the dad in the commercial a hamster?'' It takes the commercial out of "quirky" territory into "WTF is wrong with this universe?"

to:

* The Sprint phone "Framily Plan" commercials. To a point I can see what they're doing; showing how the plan can allow a bunch of very different people to all be in on one plan or whatever. What I don't get is.... ''why is the dad in the commercial a hamster?'' It takes the commercial out of "quirky" territory into "WTF is wrong with this universe?"universe?"
** They think randomness is inherently funny.
* Are a lot of these people who make advertisements self-entitled narcissistic jerks who hate goody-two-shoes, [[DrivesLikeCrazy drive like maniacs]], and wished they could get away with everything they wanted with no consequences? And if male, they wished they could surround themselves with beautiful but shallow women 24/7 who fawn after them for no reason? Because there are a lot of commercials whose protagonists behave that way and get off scot-free at the end. It's so often, it goes beyond WishFulfillment for its target audience and becomes wish fulfillment for themselves.

Top