Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / TheLordofTheRings

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Saruman's Uruk-Hai are a ''suicide cult.'' They were artificially created by him, and have no life or purpose beyond waging war in his name. He is essentially their ''God.'' When they adorn themselves with the symbol of the White Hand, they look almost ecstatic, receiving the blessings of their Creator. When the bombs are planted at Helm's Deep, the Uruk chosen to set it off is plastered head to toe with White Hands, and he is being cheered on by rows of his comrades. He's a suicide bomber, a sacrifice to their god, and he's probably ''thrilled'' to do it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* By all indications, Bilbo only rarely wore the Ring during the sixty-plus years he had it, although he kept it with him. The slowed aging was just a side effect of having it. You don't even have to ''put the thing on'' for it to affect you.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* At first glance, with it's ridiculous StoryBreakerPower, the Army of the Dead would've been handy at the Black Gate as the armies of Gondor and Rohan were devastated at the Siege of Minas Tirith. However, there are actually reasons why Aragon would only use them to save Minas Tirith instead.

to:

* At first glance, with it's its ridiculous StoryBreakerPower, the Army of the Dead would've been handy at the Black Gate as the armies of Gondor and Rohan were devastated at the Siege of Minas Tirith. However, there are actually reasons why Aragon would only use them to save Minas Tirith instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** At the very least, even if the Blue Wizards did do their jobs and Radagast is taking care of the plants and animals, he's certainly doing the job of two or three by himself. And Saruman is supposed to be the most powerful and leader of them all, it's no surprise he's upset.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** For that matter, Boromir's words to Frodo just before he tries to take the Ring from him in ''Fellowship'' are upsettingly true in retrospect: he was found by various enemies and antagonists (Shelob, the orcs, the men in Ithilien), Faramir came close to taking the Ring, and Frodo most certainly begged for death before the end (particularly during his speech on the slopes of Mount Doom, just before Sam carried him). He even almost did give the Ring to Sauron, when he offered it to the Nazgul in Osgiliath.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In addition to this wonderful and well-reasoned explanation, this also reveals ''why'' the Ring took so long to melt in the magma: as long as Frodo was both still alive and lost in despair, the Ring had a tie to power and existence through him. It's only after he hears Sam's plea and takes his hand that the Ring sinks and dissolves; without his despair and the hold it had over him, the Ring couldn't resist the fires of Mount Doom any longer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Typo


*** The fact that the Haradrum and Easterlings showed up on Sauron's doorstep as full unquestioning allies of his likely indicates that they failed in their mission. Sauron would have likely turned on them once Gondor and Rohan would have fallen; wise counselors would have managed to convince them of the folly of said alliance.

to:

*** The fact that the Haradrum Haradrim and Easterlings showed up on Sauron's doorstep as full unquestioning allies of his likely indicates that they failed in their mission. Sauron would have likely turned on them once Gondor and Rohan would have fallen; wise counselors would have managed to convince them of the folly of said alliance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The One Ring failing to corrupt Sam seems odd, but makes sense. Sam is such a humble person that the Ring had hard time trying to find something to corrupt him. The fact that the best the Ring had to tempt Sam is Mordor as a garden, show that the Ring run out of options and was just that desperate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Way back near the beginning of ''The Fellowship Of The Ring'', Sam mentions that one of his cousins saw what he swore was a walking tree up on the northern border of the Shire. After we learn of the Ents and the Entwives in ''The Two Towers'', it seems very likely that that was an Entwife, poking around the borders of the Shire. Treebeard did say that the Shire was just the kind of land they'd love...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Meanwhile, who is the one person who the ring has no power over? Tom Bombadil - a character who has no desires whatsoever. He has ultimate power in his own domain and no will to extend his power beyond the old forest. The ring has literally nothing to work with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Saruman preferring Sauron to the wizards in his own order makes more sense if you recall that both Sauron and Saruman had been Maiar of Aulë, Vala of technology and craft. The guys were easy to find common language, which went beyond just being tacticl allies: there is a common train of thought - as in, reliance on unusual technology - between Sauron's Grond and Saruman's gunpowder.
** Of course, on a meta level it rather reflects Tolkien's deep suspicion of modern industry, as most clearly shown in the Scouring of the Shire.

to:

* Saruman preferring Sauron to the wizards in his own order makes more sense if you recall that both Sauron and Saruman had been Maiar of Aulë, Vala of technology and craft. The guys were easy to find common language, which went beyond just being tacticl tactical allies: there is a common train of thought - as in, reliance on unusual technology - between Sauron's Grond and Saruman's gunpowder.
** Of course, on a meta {{Meta}} level it rather reflects Tolkien's deep suspicion of modern industry, as most clearly shown in the Scouring of the Shire.

Added: 533

Removed: 456

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Saruman preferring Sauron to the wizards in his own order makes more sense if you recall that both Sauron and Saruman had been Maiar of Aulë, Vala of technology and craft. The guys were easy to find common language, which went beyond just being tacticl allies: there is a common train of thought - as in, reliance on unusual technology - between Sauron's Grond and Saruman's gunpowder.
** Of course, on a meta level it rather reflects Tolkien's deep suspicion of modern industry, as most clearly shown in the Scouring of the Shire.



* Saruman preferring Sauron to the wizards in his own order makes more sense if you recall that both Sauron and Saruman had been Maiar of Aulë, Vala of technology and craft. The guys were easy to find common language, which went beyond just being tacticl allies: Isengard under Saruman and Mordor under Sauron even look alike, and there is a common train of thought - as in, reliance on unusual technology - between Sauron's Grond and Saruman's gunpowder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Saruman preferring Sauron to the wizards in his own order makes more sense if you recall that both Sauron and Saruman had been Maiar of Aulë, Vala of technology and craft. The guys were easy to find common language, which went beyond just being tacticl allies: Isengard under Saruman and Mordor under Sauron even look alike, and there is a common train of thought - as in, reliance on unusual technology - between Sauron's Grond and Saruman's gunpowder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** What's more, Saruman despised Radagast precisely for the reason that Yavanna basically imposed his presence on Saruman. His contempt for Radagast's weakness could have eventually been transferred to all Yavanna's creations.

Added: 484

Changed: 117

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not really a spoiler, since the book's been out for 80 years.


** WordOfGod has it that the Hobbits did away with the formal diction of Westron, so Pippin essentially walked into Denethor's throne room and said something along the lines of, "Hey man, what's up?" The Gondorians heard him speaking to the Steward as an equal, leading them to believe he was of equal status.



* At ''The Return of the King'''s climax, we see [[spoiler: Frodo hanging over the edge of the Crack of Doom, exhausted and guilt-ridden for allowing himself to succumb to the Ring’s corruption; unsure if he still wants to live. Meanwhile, the Ring is not quite destroyed as it sits and shimmers on top of the magma. It would seem that the Ring is using the last bit of its power, of its very existence, to try to claim Frodo’s life (just as Galadriel had forewarned). For its influence lies not only in corruption but also making one give into despair. Frodo is at his weakest, so it would seem like he would give up all hope and fall. However, Sam would not have any of it as he pleads with Frodo to take his hand and not let go; to not give into despair. Hearing his best friend’s pleas, Frodo uses what little strength he has left to take Sam’s hand. At that moment, what sway the Ring had left over Frodo was no more as it then disintegrates into the magma. What makes this scene so brilliant is that it illustrates that no matter the influence of evil, no matter the weight of despair, love will always triumph and that hope will prevail. That strength can be found even at one’s weakest of times.]]

to:

* At ''The Return of the King'''s climax, we see [[spoiler: Frodo hanging over the edge of the Crack of Doom, exhausted and guilt-ridden for allowing himself to succumb to the Ring’s corruption; unsure if he still wants to live. Meanwhile, the Ring is not quite destroyed as it sits and shimmers on top of the magma. It would seem that the Ring is using the last bit of its power, of its very existence, to try to claim Frodo’s life (just as Galadriel had forewarned). For its influence lies not only in corruption but also making one give into despair. Frodo is at his weakest, so it would seem like he would give up all hope and fall. However, Sam would not have any of it as he pleads with Frodo to take his hand and not let go; to not give into despair. Hearing his best friend’s pleas, Frodo uses what little strength he has left to take Sam’s hand. At that moment, what sway the Ring had left over Frodo was no more as it then disintegrates into the magma. What makes this scene so brilliant is that it illustrates that no matter the influence of evil, no matter the weight of despair, love will always triumph and that hope will prevail. That strength can be found even at one’s weakest of times.]]times.
** An alternative explanation is that the Ring was keeping him from grabbing Sam's hand; once the Ring was destroyed, ''then'' Frodo was able to reach up and grab Sam's hand.



* Aragorn throws apples to Merry and Pippin from over his shoulder and out of line of sight. Aragorn is descended from the line of the Kings of Arnor, the Northern Kingdom of the Kingdoms in Exile. Arnor encompassed much of what the Shire was by the end of the Third Age. Hobbits are known for their skill in rock-throwing.

to:

* Aragorn throws apples to Merry and Pippin from over his shoulder and out of line of sight. Aragorn is descended from the line of the Kings of Arnor, the Northern Kingdom of the Kingdoms in Exile. Arnor encompassed much of what the Shire was by the end of the Third Age. Hobbits are known for their skill in rock-throwing. Also, he's spent several decades as a Ranger. No doubt his hand-eye coordination and spatial awareness are amazing anyway!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Charge of the Rohirrim occurred in afternoon, not morning


* The flag of Rohan is a white horse upon a field of green with the sun shining behind it. What happens at the end of ''The Two Towers''? Gandalf, riding a white horse, leads the cavalry charge of the green-cloaked Rohirrim to Théoden's aid, with the [[{{CueTheSun}} sun rising behind them.]] Also happens in Return of the King, with Théoden, riding Snowmane, leads a mass of green cloaks with the sun rising behind them (albeit from the wrong direction).

to:

* The flag of Rohan is a white horse upon a field of green with the sun shining behind it. What happens at the end of ''The Two Towers''? Gandalf, riding a white horse, leads the cavalry charge of the green-cloaked Rohirrim to Théoden's aid, with the [[{{CueTheSun}} sun rising behind them.]] Also happens in Return of the King, with Théoden, riding Snowmane, leads a mass of green cloaks with the sun rising now setting behind them (albeit from the wrong direction).them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Haradrim & Easterlings & the Blue Wizards

Added DiffLines:

*** The fact that the Haradrum and Easterlings showed up on Sauron's doorstep as full unquestioning allies of his likely indicates that they failed in their mission. Sauron would have likely turned on them once Gondor and Rohan would have fallen; wise counselors would have managed to convince them of the folly of said alliance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Shortly after Pippin arrives in Minas Tirith, the Gondorians start a rumor that he's a "prince of the halflings," which he sees as a gross misapprehension. But even though all the specifics are wrong, the rumor [[AccidentallyAccurate is closer to the truth]] than it has any right to be. Pippin is next in line to become Thain of the Shire, so if anyone could be called "prince of the halflings," it'd be him.

to:

* Shortly after Pippin arrives in Minas Tirith, the Gondorians start a rumor that he's a "prince of the halflings," which he sees as a gross misapprehension. But even though all the specifics are wrong, the rumor [[AccidentallyAccurate is closer to the truth]] truth than it has any right to be. Pippin is next in line to become Thain of the Shire, so if anyone could be called "prince of the halflings," it'd be him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When relating his fight with the Balrog Gandalf says:"Far, far below the deepest delving of the Dwarves, the world is gnawed by nameless things. Even Sauron knows them not. They are older than he. Now I have walked there, but I will bring no report to darken the light of day." These are ancient abominations that Gandalf refuses to talk about. Even huorns were given some mention. The worst part is that unlike with the other monsters of middle earth it's unlikely that they were hunted to extinction. Meaning "they" could be still be there...waiting for us.

to:

* When relating his fight with the Balrog Gandalf says:"Far, far below the deepest delving of the Dwarves, the world is gnawed by nameless things. Even Sauron knows them not. They are older than he. Now I have walked there, but I will bring no report to darken the light of day." These are ancient abominations that Gandalf refuses to talk about. Even huorns were given some mention.explanation. The worst part is that unlike with the other monsters of middle earth it's unlikely that they were hunted to extinction. Meaning "they" could be still be there...waiting for us.

Added: 561

Removed: 561

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When relating his fight with the Balrog Gandalf says:"Far, far below the deepest delving of the Dwarves, the world is gnawed by nameless things. Even Sauron knows them not. They are older than he. Now I have walked there, but I will bring no report to darken the light of day." These are ancient abominations that Gandalf refuses to talk about. Even huorns were given some mention. The worst part is that unlike with the other monsters of middle earth it's unlikely that they were hunted to extinction. Meaning "they" could be still be there...waiting for us.



* When relating his fight with the Balrog Gandalf says:"Far, far below the deepest delving of the Dwarves, the world is gnawed by nameless things. Even Sauron knows them not. They are older than he. Now I have walked there, but I will bring no report to darken the light of day." These are ancient abominations that Gandalf refuses to talk about. Even huorns were given some mention. The worst part is that unlike with the other monsters of middle earth it's unlikely that they were hunted to extinction. Meaning "they" could be still be there...waiting for us.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*When relating his fight with the Balrog Gandalf says:"Far, far below the deepest delving of the Dwarves, the world is gnawed by nameless things. Even Sauron knows them not. They are older than he. Now I have walked there, but I will bring no report to darken the light of day." These are ancient abominations that Gandalf refuses to talk about. Even huorns were given some mention. The worst part is that unlike with the other monsters of middle earth it's unlikely that they were hunted to extinction. Meaning "they" could be still be there...waiting for us.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, the other rings are invisible, themselves. Frodo can only see Nenya because he's a Ringbearer. Sam can't see it, just notices a glint of light.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Frodo's pacifism after coming back to Shire is another face of this - he's experienced firsthand how easy it is to slip into evil, how hard it gets not to. Notice how he bristles against disguising as an orc. He's had the information to decide and stick to his decision, but is aware that others, like Gollum, hadn't. He's sorry for them.

Added: 213

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The two other wizards are said to have gone into the East, where they are fighting the Enemy on a different front (that was where the Garden of Eden was.) Radagast never had power to confront Sauron directly; his job was to nurture the spirits of plants and animals. and fight in a different way. Only one wizaerd left the fight,

to:

** The two other wizards are said to have gone into the East, where they are fighting the Enemy on a different front (that was where the Garden of Eden was.) Radagast never had power to confront Sauron directly; his job was to nurture the spirits of plants and animals. and fight in a different way. Only one wizaerd wizard left the fight, fight.
** Main/WordOfGod is that the Blue Wizards most likely got distracted and set up magical cults in the East with themselves as the heads, or perished at Saruman's hands when traveling alongside him during the same.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While the charge of the Rohirrim is one of the most epic movie moments ever, a lot of people thought it was slightly deflated by the ridiculous reaction shot of the stunned Orc commander. He couldn't really believe that three volleys of arrow fire would turn back the charge, could he? But from his position at the bottom of the hill, he couldn't see the vastness of the Rohirrim army. He couldn't imagine that Rohan could field a much larger force than the one Gondor sent to attempt to retake Osgiliath, which he had easily slaughtered. For Rohan to commit so many troops to the battle, they would have to leave their own lands undefended for the benefit of an ally, a risk that he couldn't imagine taking. So he's stunned not just by the fearlessness of the charge, but by the fact that so many Rohirrim are there at all!

to:

* While the charge of the Rohirrim is one of the most epic movie moments ever, a lot of people thought it was slightly deflated by the ridiculous reaction shot of the stunned Orc commander. He couldn't really believe that three volleys of arrow fire would turn back the charge, could he? But from his position at the bottom of the hill, he couldn't see the vastness of the Rohirrim army. He couldn't imagine that Rohan could field a much larger force than the one Gondor sent to attempt to retake Osgiliath, which he had easily slaughtered. For Rohan to commit so many troops to the battle, they would have to leave their own lands undefended for the benefit of an ally, a risk that he couldn't imagine taking. [[note]]The novel makes clearer that this is ''exactly'' what they did and they found out mid-march that an orc army was heading for Rohan, but happily they were fatally intercepted by Ents.[[/note]] So he's stunned not just by the fearlessness of the charge, but by the fact that so many Rohirrim are there at all!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
been watching Cinema Therapy and they missed this particular point, somehow

Added DiffLines:

* Perhaps less fridge-y than all above, but how does Frodo empathise with Gollum while Sam doesn't? Because Frodo is going through the same thing Gollum has, and being both BookSmart and a generally honest person, he realises full well that there, but for the grace of Eru, goes Frodo Baggins. He sees himself in Gollum. Sam doesn't, since his five minutes as a ringbearer hasn't come yet. Being practical, Sam sees a threat to protect himself and his friend from - a liar, thief, murderer. An alien, disgusting, scary being he has nothing in common with, but knows it's dangerous.

Added: 994

Changed: 46

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Frodo has a bit of a dramatic streak in his personality (look at him going all "I wonder if I shall ever see this valley again" when he's preparing to leave Shire), possibly because, for a hobbit, he's been rather lonely most of his life - a orphan with no siblings, growing up as just another kid in his mom's (large, busy) family home, maybe he just had nobody close to him. He's definitely a dreamer - a well-read, educated person who lives in books more than he lives in the world around him (as much as any hobbit is like that). He's fairly introverted, but don't mistake that for timid. If Middle Earth had Internet, he'd be JustForFun/OneOfUs, for sure. Now, dear Troper, look carefully within yourself. Don't you ever want to be a hero? Don't you ever want the world to be a little bit cooler than it is, and especially to be, yourself, a little bit cooler and more admirable? Perhaps you indulge in a saving the world fantasy every once in a while? Frodo did. Look how he ended up...



* Creator/OrlandoBloom's performance is rather stiff, but he becomes much more expressive whenever Legolas is speaking Elvish. So it might be that Legolas himself is inexpressive because he's not very comfortable speaking Westron. (Elves are known to be very insular, and Elrond and Arwen might be better at Westron because they're leaders and expected to have contact with the outside world. Meanwhile, [[AWizardDidIt Galadriel is magic.]]) Now that ''Film/TheHobbit'' is out we know that he was raised away from the other races, was a bit racist towards Dwarves and later befriended a young Aragorn. That explains why he is so reserved all the time but gets emotional when Aragorn is insulted (the Council), presumed dead (the Cliff) or in danger (Mordor). He is more comfortable around Aragorn but not around the others because he doesn't know them ''at all''. He does start joking with Gimli once they start up a friendship. Everything is done for a reason.

to:

* Creator/OrlandoBloom's performance is rather stiff, but he becomes much more expressive whenever Legolas is speaking Elvish. So it might be that Legolas himself is inexpressive because he's not very comfortable speaking Westron. (Elves are known to be very insular, and Elrond and Arwen might be better at Westron because they're leaders and expected to have contact with the outside world. Meanwhile, [[AWizardDidIt Galadriel is magic.]]) ]] And a leader. And well-traveled in her youth.) Now that ''Film/TheHobbit'' is out we know that he was raised away from the other races, was a bit racist towards Dwarves and later befriended a young Aragorn. That explains why he is so reserved all the time but gets emotional when Aragorn is insulted (the Council), presumed dead (the Cliff) or in danger (Mordor). He is more comfortable around Aragorn but not around the others because he doesn't know them ''at all''. He does start joking with Gimli once they start up a friendship. Everything is done for a reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Another interesting little touch - everyone agrees that ''athelas'' smells nice, but what does it smell like? Look at the scene where Ararogn is healing Faramir, Éowyn and Merry - at each patient's bed the herb smells different (to everyone around, not just to the patients). It's "spring in Ithilien" for Faramir, "mountain air" for Éowyn, "orchards and heatherfields" for Merry. The respective persons' favourite places, most likely. Or possibly the places they consider their homes. Athelas smells like home.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To some, this idea is quite {{Narm}}y, with the StarWars trash compactor immediately springing to mind...

to:

** To some, this idea is quite {{Narm}}y, with the StarWars Franchise/StarWars trash compactor immediately springing to mind...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Possibly, the Rings work according to the wearer's nature...


Added DiffLines:

** Probably wouldn't, unless Sam tried to take the Ring off him...

Top