Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / MeanGirls

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Damien most likely told Cady about Trang Pak and Coach Carr and she likely told the plastics. They did not know Trang pak was involved with the coach as in the scene where the burn book is introduced, the only thing said about Trang Pak is that she’s a ‘grotsky little byotch’.


* Lest we forget amid all the funny, Coach Carr sexually assaulted at least two sixteen-year-old girls.[[note]]And given that the Burn Book may have been made from the previous year's yearbook, since Regina hadn't even looked at it in forever, they might have been ''even younger'' when the abuse began.[[/note]]

to:

* Lest we forget amid all the funny, Coach Carr sexually assaulted at least two sixteen-year-old girls.[[note]]And given that the Burn Book may have been made from the previous year's yearbook, since Regina hadn't even looked at it in forever, they might have been ''even younger'' when the abuse began.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** As mentioned above, the students didn’t say anything about Carr’s relationships with underage students because teenagers have a very different view of minor-adult relationships to adults. It’s easy for teenagers to see these relationships as unproblematic because they see themselves as mature, whereas adults have the hindsight of being through teenagehood and knowing that they wouldn’t have been at the same maturity level as a fully grown adult at that point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n* Cady sabotaging Regina's "perfect body" by making her gain weight could have had far more severe consequences in real life. For someone as insecure about their body as Regina ends up shown to be, believing that just dieting wasn't making her lose weight, and in fact realizing that she had ''gained'' weight, could very easily have pushed her into developing an eating disorder.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The musical answers this as the girl was there for a track meet that was meeting the day the Burn Book got released and just happened to wander in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Perhaps she has a friend who goes to that school and they texted her about the riot/confession meeting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*Janus is the name of a Roman god with two faces. And “Cady” sounds like “catty.”



* Janus is the name of a Roman god with two faces.

to:

* Janus is the name of a Roman god with two faces.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Janus is the name of a Roman god with two faces.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Which drifts into a bit of averted FridgeHorror. Janis may have revealed her Lebanese heritage to her at that time best friend Regina in confidence because Arab heritage would have become problematic after 9-11. This movie did come out in 2004. While Regina innocently misconstruing Lebanese for lesbian sucked a lot for Janis, it could have been much much worse - as in Regina and the school ostracizing her as an “Arab terrorist”
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Even worse, the only reason Carr's crimes became public knowledge was because of Regina leaking the pages of the Burn Book. Aaron and Damian discovered the abuse and Damian presumably told Cady and Janis yet none of them said anything to any adults.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


!! FridgeLogic
* So, how ''did'' the girl that wanted to make a cake of rainbows and smiles get there? Did news of the riot and confession meeting get out somehow?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, [[TruthInTelevision a lot of real-life Jews externally celebrate Christmas with gentile friends or even relatives]] (as mixed religious marriages are increasingly common and accepted), especially those who grew up in mostly gentile public schools and neighborhoods, not private Jewish schools or neighborhoods.

to:

** Also, [[TruthInTelevision a lot of real-life Jews externally celebrate Christmas with gentile friends or even relatives]] (as mixed religious marriages are increasingly common and accepted), relatives]], especially those who grew up in mostly gentile public schools and neighborhoods, not rather than private Jewish schools or neighborhoods.




to:

* At one point, Gretchen mentions that Regina won't let her wear hoop earrings because Regina decided that they're ''her'' thing, yet Regina is never shown wearing hoop earrings throughout the movie. This is just another example of Regina controlling her friends by preventing them from having something she knows they want by claiming only ''she'' can have it even if she doesn't want it, like how she won't let Cady date Aaron even though she doesn't want him either (and cheats on him shortly after taking him back.)

Added: 319

Changed: 586

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, [[TruthInTelevision a lot of real-life Jews externally celebrate Christmas with gentile friends or even relatives]] (as mixed religious marriages are increasingly common and accepted), especially those who grew up in mostly gentile public schools and neighborhoods, not private Jewish schools or neighborhoods.




to:

* The teenager characters don't bat an eye at Coach Carr having sex with underage girls; at best treating it like an oddity, at worst praising how he managed to "score" some hot chicks. However, the adults all treat it with the horror and severity it deserves. This is probably because a lot of teenagers feel more adult than they really are, and might not see adult/teen relationships as a big deal. But with maturity and hindsight, most adults (hopefully) understand what a severe [[UnequalPairing abuse of power]] it is, and how it can mess up young people's psyches in the long run.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Natter, admits it doesn't count.


** Likely because Regina is [[BookDumb book dumb]]



* Not exactly FridgeHorror, but if Janis choreographed the sexy Jingle Bell Rock dance when she was still friends with Regina, that means that she, Regina, and the other Plastics were no older than 12 or 13 years old when they started performing it at school talent shows (and presumably wearing the costumes).
** To be fair, those costumes probably covered more back then...
** A lot of girls do tend to copy dancing they see their favourite pop stars doing. Dance is a bit suggestive on its own, so while it's a bit icky, it's unfortunately TruthInTelevision. It's already a bit icky that these are sixteen-year-old girls performing this dance.
** Yeah, let's not forget that BritneySpears was 16 when she filmed the video for ''...Baby One More Time''. You know, the one where she dresses in a sexed-up Catholic schoolgirl uniform and dances suggestively? And that came out in 1998. For 2004, this seems about on-par.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Lest we forget amid all the funny, Coach Carr sexually assaulted at least two sixteen-year-old girls.

to:

* Lest we forget amid all the funny, Coach Carr sexually assaulted at least two sixteen-year-old girls.[[note]]And given that the Burn Book may have been made from the previous year's yearbook, since Regina hadn't even looked at it in forever, they might have been ''even younger'' when the abuse began.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lest we forget amid all the funny, Coach Carr sexually assaulted at least two sixteen-year-old girls.

to:

** * Lest we forget amid all the funny, Coach Carr sexually assaulted at least two sixteen-year-old girls.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Lest we forget amid all the funny, Coach Carr sexually assaulted at least two sixteen-year-old girls.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fridge Logic goes on Headscratchers



!! FridgeLogic
* Why would the inventor of Toaster Strudels need to put his daughter in public school? Surely the resident RichBitch would be just one of many in some ritzy private academy?
** Plenty of kids with rich parents go to public schools. It might be because the parents do want to save money (even if you're rich, a good private school can still be rather expensive), though sometimes the kid goes to public school for the general environment. More exposure to different types of people and whatnot.
** In some areas of the country, public schools can be just as good (and just as expensive as, due to a combination of taxes and books) as private schools.
** This movie was apparently set in the North Shore of Chicago, an area known for very wealthy residents and some of the best public schools in the nation. Private schools in that area are not significantly better than the public schools, and if the parents don't want to ship the children off to boarding school...it makes a great deal of sense that Gretchen goes to public school.
** Many of the top schools in America are actually public schools--only 10% of American kids actually go to private schools (and not every who goes to a private school comes from a rich family) while 87% go to public schools (the remaining 3% are probably homeschooled or something). Also, statistically-speaking, public school teachers make way more money than private school teachers.
* Why does Cady speak English with a perfect American accent when she's spent her entire life in Africa?
** Cady didn't spend her whole life in Africa, just all of her school years. She could have been five or six when she went over, so English isn't a problem. As for the accent, she could have picked that up from her parents.
*** As a Britain-born OopNorth and raised in Spain for my schooling years, I can tell you people do tend to lose their original accent after a while. Just chalk it up to NotEvenBotheringWithTheAccent.
*** When she was in Africa she spoke the native language when talking to others. However she still spoke English with her parents at home. She learned how to speak English first and so she kept her accent from speaking with them.
*** But English is a lingua franca in South Africa and other parts of the continent, a dialect that is very different from Midwestern American English. If Cady spoke to ''anyone'' other than her parents, it would rub off eventually. NotEvenBotheringWithTheAccent, I say.
*** As a Filipino-born American, having come to U.S. at age 12, my accent actually changes depending on who I'm talking to. The natural accent I came with remains intact when I'm addressing family or other Tagalog speaking Filipinos. My accent becomes more Americanized when I talk to my friends out of habit, having forced a more Americanized accent when I first arrived. Because I managed to force my way into an accent, after the first few months upon my arrival, I naturally switch between the two accents, and now it's a subconscious thing with me. That being said, assuming Cady's parents had native English speaking coworkers, what could have happened was that she spoke a certain way with her parents' coworkers, while she spoke another way to the African children she played with. Or another possibility is that she mimics her parents' accents when they reached the United States, having caught on that her parents' accents are more common in the country than the South African accent she had developed. With that possibility, it could be that she naturally a South African accent, and then after forcing an American accent, it eventually would become her natural accent. While how long it would take to change her accent is difficult to pinpoint, as everyone's different, it is believable that she speaks with the accent she speaks with in the movie because it's probably a forced accent.
** Maybe she didn't have a lot of friends in Africa and she mainly spoke to her parents? If she spoke to them in English most of the time (and from what we see of them in the movie, we could assume that) then that's how. And she could have watched a lot of American television and movies and picked the accent up that way.
* How did the Plastics get away with wearing such short skirts in high school? I didn't go to a particularly conservative school, but we still had a dress code. (Moreover, how did all the girls get away with cutting cup-revealing holes in their blouses when most schools will call girls out for letting their bra straps accidentally slip down their arms?)
** I noticed that when Ms. Norbury asks who has felt victimised by Regina, the teachers and even Mr Duvall raise their hands too. So it might be that Regina is so effective as an AlphaBitch that even the teachers don't question her. As for the cut blouses, we only see them wearing the clothes like that for one afternoon - so maybe the teachers did forbid them. It's just that they didn't have replacement tops they could change into that day.
* Since the movie, Gretchen's "fetch" has gained some use as slang for a ForcedMeme. Does that mean she really ''did'' make "fetch" happen?

Added: 322

Changed: 124

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Ms Norbury and Mr Duvall look like they're talking when Gretchen falls - so they didn't see the other girls backing away.


Added DiffLines:

** Maybe she didn't have a lot of friends in Africa and she mainly spoke to her parents? If she spoke to them in English most of the time (and from what we see of them in the movie, we could assume that) then that's how. And she could have watched a lot of American television and movies and picked the accent up that way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the musical, Karen's first music segment has this musical build that ends with a gag, "My name is Karen, I may not be awfully smart... that's it." But her breezy personality, and her later kindness to Cady, also immediately tells the audience that she has a big heart. And she didn't even need the explicit rhyme to say a lot about her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The scene where everyone refuses to catch Gretchen after her BackhandedApology is supposed to be funny, and is used as another instance of Karen being dumb. But if Karen had backed away like all the other girls, Gretchen probably would have died from that fall. And nobody seemed uncomfortable about almost letting that happen. [[AdultsAreUseless Even the teachers.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* -1 is actually entirely plausible as an incorrect answer to the limit at the end. If you mistakenly say sin 0 = 1 and cos 0 = 0, instead of the other way around, it evaluates to -1.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Gretchen mentions that she's Jewish. Her dancing to a Christmas song still makes sense because she'd do anything if Regina told her to do so.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There's also a difference between humiliating the Regina in front of the whole school, something most of the girls probably already dreamed of. But pushing her in front of a bus equals trying to kill her which is even for girls who were "personally victimized by Regina George" a tad bit too much. So Cady is treated as insane.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Likely because Regina is [[BookDumb book dumb]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Yeah, let's not forget that BritneySpears was 16 when she filmed the video for ''...Baby One More Time''. You know, the one where she dresses in a sexed-up Catholic schoolgirl uniform and dances suggestively? And that came out in 1998. For 2004, this seems about on-par.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added to Fridge Logic to explain accents

Added DiffLines:

*** As a Filipino-born American, having come to U.S. at age 12, my accent actually changes depending on who I'm talking to. The natural accent I came with remains intact when I'm addressing family or other Tagalog speaking Filipinos. My accent becomes more Americanized when I talk to my friends out of habit, having forced a more Americanized accent when I first arrived. Because I managed to force my way into an accent, after the first few months upon my arrival, I naturally switch between the two accents, and now it's a subconscious thing with me. That being said, assuming Cady's parents had native English speaking coworkers, what could have happened was that she spoke a certain way with her parents' coworkers, while she spoke another way to the African children she played with. Or another possibility is that she mimics her parents' accents when they reached the United States, having caught on that her parents' accents are more common in the country than the South African accent she had developed. With that possibility, it could be that she naturally a South African accent, and then after forcing an American accent, it eventually would become her natural accent. While how long it would take to change her accent is difficult to pinpoint, as everyone's different, it is believable that she speaks with the accent she speaks with in the movie because it's probably a forced accent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Some studies have shown that public schools are actually better than private schools--you also make more money if you work at a public school instead of a private school.

to:

** Some studies have shown that Many of the top schools in America are actually public schools--only 10% of American kids actually go to private schools (and not every who goes to a private school comes from a rich family) while 87% go to public schools (the remaining 3% are actually better than private schools--you also make more money if you work at a probably homeschooled or something). Also, statistically-speaking, public school instead of a teachers make way more money than private school.school teachers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A lot of girls do tend to copy dancing they see their favourite pop stars doing. Dance is a bit suggestive on its own, so while it's a bit icky, it's unfortunately TruthInTelevision. It's already a bit icky that these are sixteen-year-old girls performing this dance.P

to:

** A lot of girls do tend to copy dancing they see their favourite pop stars doing. Dance is a bit suggestive on its own, so while it's a bit icky, it's unfortunately TruthInTelevision. It's already a bit icky that these are sixteen-year-old girls performing this dance.P
dance.

Top