Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 14 (click to see context) from:
* If you really think about it, even though she's not part of the family [[spoiler: Lillian invited Laura to kill her]]
to:
* If you really think about it, even though she's not part of the family [[spoiler: Lillian invited Laura to kill her]]her]].
----
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
!!FridgeBrilliance:
* Given the true identity of the murderer, it actually makes a bit of sense that a few possible deaths involve Laura being killed ''by'' the murderer. As mentioned, the mysterious figure doesn't even ''look'' at her - so it's not that hard to think [[spoiler: Lillian simply either mistook her for someone else (one of the ''intended'' targets), [[HeKnowsTooMuch was in the closet with a victim and thus Laura had seen and she had to kill her to keep her quiet]], or maybe as Lillian gets more and more unhinged, she lashes out at Laura]]. This still doesn't explain the shower death beyond simple EasterEgg / ShoutOut.
** It's also misdirection on the developers' part - one of the deaths is ''also'' in the secret passages. Obviously, the killer is ''also'' using the secret passages as well... so this not ''only'' can back up [[spoiler: Rudy's claim that it was the Colonel, in the Bad Ending]], but it also can foreshadow [[spoiler: that it is indeed Lillian - as Lillian basically grew up in the house, it's not unlikely to think she may have discovered the secret passages.]]
* Given the true identity of the murderer, it actually makes a bit of sense that a few possible deaths involve Laura being killed ''by'' the murderer. As mentioned, the mysterious figure doesn't even ''look'' at her - so it's not that hard to think [[spoiler: Lillian simply either mistook her for someone else (one of the ''intended'' targets), [[HeKnowsTooMuch was in the closet with a victim and thus Laura had seen and she had to kill her to keep her quiet]], or maybe as Lillian gets more and more unhinged, she lashes out at Laura]]. This still doesn't explain the shower death beyond simple EasterEgg / ShoutOut.
** It's also misdirection on the developers' part - one of the deaths is ''also'' in the secret passages. Obviously, the killer is ''also'' using the secret passages as well... so this not ''only'' can back up [[spoiler: Rudy's claim that it was the Colonel, in the Bad Ending]], but it also can foreshadow [[spoiler: that it is indeed Lillian - as Lillian basically grew up in the house, it's not unlikely to think she may have discovered the secret passages.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added to Fridge Horror
Changed line(s) 7 (click to see context) from:
* If you take a look at the instances in which Laura can be killed by the mysterious figure, [[spoiler: taking a shower, hiding in the attic, and hiding in the closet]], Laura is simply grabbed and killed without the murderer even looking.
to:
* If you take a look at the instances in which Laura can be killed by the mysterious figure, [[spoiler: taking a shower, hiding in the attic, the closet and hiding in the closet]], hidden passages]], Laura is simply grabbed and killed without the murderer even looking.looking.
** The shower thing makes no sense, as the killer would recognize Laura's blue dress even if they couldn't make out Laura herself, but the others do. We know that the killer's moving the bodies from the murder scene to the laundry chute. Maybe Laura saw [[spoiler:Lillian]] hiding in the closet with the latest victim. Laura's very last realization would be [[spoiler:that her best friend is a murderer and even she's not safe from her.]]
** The shower thing makes no sense, as the killer would recognize Laura's blue dress even if they couldn't make out Laura herself, but the others do. We know that the killer's moving the bodies from the murder scene to the laundry chute. Maybe Laura saw [[spoiler:Lillian]] hiding in the closet with the latest victim. Laura's very last realization would be [[spoiler:that her best friend is a murderer and even she's not safe from her.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed natter, fixed grammar
Changed line(s) 3,6 (click to see context) from:
* In the first game, there's several ways for Laura to get murdered by an unseen figure, even very very early in the game. But once you've beaten the game, [[spoiler:it's obvious that nobody had any motive to kill her, ''especially'' not the murderer, and certainly not that early in the night. She was actually the one person present who the murderer ''didn't'' want to kill.]]
** Possible explanation: The killer didn't want to be caught. Especially if she's killed in the passageways. Dead men/women tell no tales and since [[spoiler:Lillian more than likely used the passageways to carry out the killings]] makes sense.
** Another possible explanation, which admittedly works much better for the shower scene than for the closet scene: [[spoiler:Lillian]] didn't realize that it was Laura, and struck before getting a good look at the victim.
** Possible explanation: The killer didn't want to be caught. Especially if she's killed in the passageways. Dead men/women tell no tales and since [[spoiler:Lillian more than likely used the passageways to carry out the killings]] makes sense.
** Another possible explanation, which admittedly works much better for the shower scene than for the closet scene: [[spoiler:Lillian]] didn't realize that it was Laura, and struck before getting a good look at the victim.
to:
* In the first game, there's several ways for Laura to get murdered by an unseen figure, even very very early in the game. But once you've beaten the game, [[spoiler:it's obvious that nobody had any motive to kill her, ''especially'' not the murderer, and certainly not that early in the night. She was actually the one only person present who the murderer ''didn't'' want to kill.]]
** Possible explanation: The killer didn't want to be caught. Especially if she's killed in the passageways. Dead men/women tell no tales and since [[spoiler:Lillian more than likely used the passageways to carry out the killings]] makes sense.
** Another possible explanation, which admittedly works much better for the shower scene than for the closet scene: [[spoiler:Lillian]] didn't realize that it was Laura, and struck before getting a good look at the victim.
** Another possible explanation, which admittedly works much better for the shower scene than for the closet scene: [[spoiler:Lillian]] didn't realize that it was Laura, and struck before getting a good look at the victim.
Deleted line(s) 10 (click to see context) :
** This is potentially a case of GameplayAndStorySegregation, as [[spoiler:the one suspect in the mansion who likes Laura and doesn't want her to die being the murderer and never killing her would actually give the true culprit away too easily.]] Although near the end of the game, [[spoiler: Lillian]] is so unhinged that she argues with [[spoiler: Laura]] and thinks she's "as bad as everyone else" [[spoiler: if you talk to her while she's writing in her diary.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 1,2 (click to see context) from:
FridgeLogic:
to:
Changed line(s) 7,8 (click to see context) from:
FridgeHorror:
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 3 (click to see context) from:
In the first game, there's several ways for Laura to get murdered by an unseen figure, even very very early in the game. But once you've beaten the game, [[spoiler:it's obvious that nobody had any motive to kill her, ''especially'' not the murderer, and certainly not that early in the night. She was actually the one person present who the murderer ''didn't'' want to kill.]]
to:
* In the first game, there's several ways for Laura to get murdered by an unseen figure, even very very early in the game. But once you've beaten the game, [[spoiler:it's obvious that nobody had any motive to kill her, ''especially'' not the murderer, and certainly not that early in the night. She was actually the one person present who the murderer ''didn't'' want to kill.]]
Changed line(s) 9,11 (click to see context) from:
If you take a look at the instances in which Laura can be killed by the mysterious figure, [[spoiler: taking a shower, hiding in the attic, and hiding in the closet]], Laura is simply grabbed and killed without the murderer even looking.
** This is potentially a case of GameplayAndStorySegregation, as [[spoiler: The one suspect in the mansion who likes Laura and doesn't want her to die being the murderer and never killing her would actually give the true culprit away too easily.]] Although near the end of the game, [[spoiler: Lillian]] is so unhinged that she argues with [[spoiler: Laura]] and thinks she's "as bad as everyone else" [[spoiler: if you talk to her while she's writing in her diary.]]
** This is potentially a case of GameplayAndStorySegregation, as [[spoiler: The one suspect in the mansion who likes Laura and doesn't want her to die being the murderer and never killing her would actually give the true culprit away too easily.]] Although near the end of the game, [[spoiler: Lillian]] is so unhinged that she argues with [[spoiler: Laura]] and thinks she's "as bad as everyone else" [[spoiler: if you talk to her while she's writing in her diary.]]
to:
* If you take a look at the instances in which Laura can be killed by the mysterious figure, [[spoiler: taking a shower, hiding in the attic, and hiding in the closet]], Laura is simply grabbed and killed without the murderer even looking.
** This is potentially a case of GameplayAndStorySegregation, as[[spoiler: The [[spoiler:the one suspect in the mansion who likes Laura and doesn't want her to die being the murderer and never killing her would actually give the true culprit away too easily.]] Although near the end of the game, [[spoiler: Lillian]] is so unhinged that she argues with [[spoiler: Laura]] and thinks she's "as bad as everyone else" [[spoiler: if you talk to her while she's writing in her diary.]]
]]
** This is potentially a case of GameplayAndStorySegregation, as
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
maybe a WMG on why she would is in order
Changed line(s) 10 (click to see context) from:
** This is potentially a case of GameplayAndStorySegregation, as [[spoiler: The one suspect in the mansion who likes Laura and doesn't want her to die being the murderer and never killing her would actually give the true culprit away too easily.]] Although near the end of the game, [[spoiler: Lillian]] is so unhinged that she argues with [[spoiler: Laura]] and thinks she's "as bad as everyone else" [[spoiler: if you talk to her while she's writing in her diary.]]
to:
** This is potentially a case of GameplayAndStorySegregation, as [[spoiler: The one suspect in the mansion who likes Laura and doesn't want her to die being the murderer and never killing her would actually give the true culprit away too easily.]] Although near the end of the game, [[spoiler: Lillian]] is so unhinged that she argues with [[spoiler: Laura]] and thinks she's "as bad as everyone else" [[spoiler: if you talk to her while she's writing in her diary.]]]]
* If you really think about it, even though she's not part of the family [[spoiler: Lillian invited Laura to kill her]]
* If you really think about it, even though she's not part of the family [[spoiler: Lillian invited Laura to kill her]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hiding spoilers.
Changed line(s) 5,6 (click to see context) from:
** Another possible explanation, which admittedly works much better for the shower scene than for the closet scene: Lillian didn't realize that it was Laura; she struck before she could get a good look at whom she was striking.
to:
** Another possible explanation, which admittedly works much better for the shower scene than for the closet scene: Lillian [[spoiler:Lillian]] didn't realize that it was Laura; she Laura, and struck before she could get getting a good look at whom she was striking.the victim.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 4 (click to see context) from:
** Possible explanation: The killer didn't want to be caught. Especially if she's killed in the passageways. Dead men/women tell no tails and since [[spoiler:Lillian more than likely used the passageways to carry out the killings]] makes sense.
to:
** Possible explanation: The killer didn't want to be caught. Especially if she's killed in the passageways. Dead men/women tell no tails tales and since [[spoiler:Lillian more than likely used the passageways to carry out the killings]] makes sense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 5 (click to see context) from:
to:
** Another possible explanation, which admittedly works much better for the shower scene than for the closet scene: Lillian didn't realize that it was Laura; she struck before she could get a good look at whom she was striking.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 4,5 (click to see context) from:
to:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
FridgeLogic:
In the first game, there's several ways for Laura to get murdered by an unseen figure, even very very early in the game. But once you've beaten the game, [[spoiler:it's obvious that nobody had any motive to kill her, ''especially'' not the murderer, and certainly not that early in the night. She was actually the one person present who the murderer ''didn't'' want to kill.]]
FridgeHorror:
If you take a look at the instances in which Laura can be killed by the mysterious figure, [[spoiler: taking a shower, hiding in the attic, and hiding in the closet]], Laura is simply grabbed and killed without the murderer even looking.
** This is potentially a case of GameplayAndStorySegregation, as [[spoiler: The one suspect in the mansion who likes Laura and doesn't want her to die being the murderer and never killing her would actually give the true culprit away too easily.]] Although near the end of the game, [[spoiler: Lillian]] is so unhinged that she argues with [[spoiler: Laura]] and thinks she's "as bad as everyone else" [[spoiler: if you talk to her while she's writing in her diary.]]
In the first game, there's several ways for Laura to get murdered by an unseen figure, even very very early in the game. But once you've beaten the game, [[spoiler:it's obvious that nobody had any motive to kill her, ''especially'' not the murderer, and certainly not that early in the night. She was actually the one person present who the murderer ''didn't'' want to kill.]]
FridgeHorror:
If you take a look at the instances in which Laura can be killed by the mysterious figure, [[spoiler: taking a shower, hiding in the attic, and hiding in the closet]], Laura is simply grabbed and killed without the murderer even looking.
** This is potentially a case of GameplayAndStorySegregation, as [[spoiler: The one suspect in the mansion who likes Laura and doesn't want her to die being the murderer and never killing her would actually give the true culprit away too easily.]] Although near the end of the game, [[spoiler: Lillian]] is so unhinged that she argues with [[spoiler: Laura]] and thinks she's "as bad as everyone else" [[spoiler: if you talk to her while she's writing in her diary.]]
