Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TooBigToFail

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ZillionDollarBill: John Mack refuses to consider merging Morgan Stanley with JP Morgan, because other investors, including Mitsubishi, are considering deals with him. In RealLife, Mitsubishi agreed to bail out Morgan Stanley; ordinarily the money would have been wire-transferred, but banks were closed on Columbus Day and Morgan Stanley was literally hours away from collapse, so Mitsubishi sent a courier with a physical check for '''$9,000,000,000.00''' (that's "billion" with a "b"). According to Sorkin's book, the Morgan Stanley executive who accepted the check nearly had a nervous breakdown (despite being fully briefed in advance on what he was receiving), and had to walk ''very'' carefully into the firm's Wall Street offices to deposit the check in the firm's secure vault.

to:

* ZillionDollarBill: John Mack refuses to consider merging Morgan Stanley with JP Morgan, because other investors, including Mitsubishi, are considering deals with him. In RealLife, Mitsubishi agreed to bail out Morgan Stanley; ordinarily the money would have been wire-transferred, but banks were closed on Columbus Day and Morgan Stanley was literally hours away from collapse, so Mitsubishi sent a courier with a physical check for '''$9,000,000,000.00''' (that's "billion" with a "b"). According to Sorkin's book, the Morgan Stanley executive who accepted the check nearly had a nervous breakdown (despite being fully briefed in advance on what he was receiving), and had to walk ''very'' carefully into the firm's Wall Street offices to deposit the check in the firm's secure vault.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheMatchmaker: Paulson and Geithner deprecatingly refer to themselves as "eHarmony", as they try to propose mergers between the major Wall Street firms that will prevent the entire financial system from imploding.

Added: 789

Changed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Paulson, Bernanke, and Geithner urge John Mack to consider merging Morgan Stanley with JP Morgan, Mack responds that the immediate consequence of such a merger would be the layoff of somewhere between 20,000 and 45,000 Morgan Stanley employees. When Bernanke suggests that such a sacrifice might have to be paid to preserve the system as a whole, Mack hangs up on them.

to:

** When Paulson, Bernanke, and Geithner urge John Mack to consider merging Morgan Stanley with JP Morgan, Mack responds that the immediate consequence of such a merger would be the layoff of somewhere between 15,000 and 20,000 and 45,000 Morgan Stanley employees. When Bernanke suggests that such a sacrifice might have to be paid to preserve the system as a whole, Mack hangs up on them.



--->''They almost bring down the U.S. economy as we know it, but we can't put any hooks on the $125 billion we're loaning them because... '''they might not take it?'''''

to:

--->''They almost bring down the U.S. economy as we know it, but we can't put any hooks on the $125 billion we're loaning them because... '''they might not take it?'''''it?'''''
* ZillionDollarBill: John Mack refuses to consider merging Morgan Stanley with JP Morgan, because other investors, including Mitsubishi, are considering deals with him. In RealLife, Mitsubishi agreed to bail out Morgan Stanley; ordinarily the money would have been wire-transferred, but banks were closed on Columbus Day and Morgan Stanley was literally hours away from collapse, so Mitsubishi sent a courier with a physical check for '''$9,000,000,000.00''' (that's "billion" with a "b"). According to Sorkin's book, the Morgan Stanley executive who accepted the check nearly had a nervous breakdown (despite being fully briefed in advance on what he was receiving), and had to walk ''very'' carefully into the firm's Wall Street offices to deposit the check in the firm's secure vault.

Changed: 422

Removed: 207

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GunboatDiplomacy: One of Paulson's early solutions is to ask Congress for temporary funding to bail out Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, reasoning that just having that authority will calm the markets without him actually having to use it: "''They need to think I've got a bazooka in my pocket.''"
** A few weeks later, in Beijing, a Chinese official points out to Paulson that Fannie and Freddie's stocks are still in freefall, and suggests that ''"carrying that bazooka around has not helped matters."''

to:

* GunboatDiplomacy: One of Paulson's early solutions is to ask Congress for temporary funding to bail out Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, reasoning that just having that authority will calm the markets without him actually having to use it: "''They need to think I've got a bazooka in my pocket.''"
**
''" A few weeks later, in Beijing, a Chinese official points out to Paulson that Fannie and Freddie's stocks are still in freefall, and suggests that ''"carrying that bazooka around has not helped matters."'' Back in Washington, over breakfast with Bernanke, Paulson admits that the federal government has to take more direct action, and Bernanke deadpans, ''"[t]urns out a bazooka is not that useful unless you fire it."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MemeticMutation: Happens InUniverse. Before the crisis, the phrase ''"too big to fail"'' was used to mean a bank or other company was so large and so well-capitalized that it might have a bad year, but it was all but impossible for it to collapse completely, and certainly not overnight, so it was an exceptionally secure investment. By the time of the crisis, the five largest investment banks on Wall Street have started to tip over like dominoes, beginning with Bear Stearns and followed shortly by Lehman Brothers. As Paulson and his staff acknowledge, the phrase ''"too big to fail"'' has taken on an entirely different meaning - the banks are holding the keys to millions of people's financial futures, which means they are so big they cannot be ''allowed'' to fail, and the government has no choice but to bail them out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lampshaded in the film's final lines: even as Bernanke and Paulson breathe a sigh of relief that TARP has passed, they admit to each other that they can do little except hope that the banks use the money the way the government wants them to. Paulson says, ''"of course they will"'' with a brittle smile; [[BlatantLies he's lying and he and everyone else in the room knows it.]]

to:

** Lampshaded in the film's final lines: even as Bernanke and Paulson breathe a sigh of relief that TARP has passed, they admit to each other that they can do little except hope that the banks use the money the way the government wants them to. Paulson says, ''"of course they will"'' with a brittle smile; [[BlatantLies [[BadLiar he's lying and he and everyone else in the room knows it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Dick Fuld makes a valid point that people bought houses they couldn't afford, and then leveraged those houses to buy ''additional'' things they couldn't afford, and now it's the banks that have to handle the fallout. This goes over like a lead balloon when you realize that banks bought ''loans'' they couldn't afford, and then ''leveraged those loans'' to make ''more loans'', in essence using assets they didn't really have to buy things they couldn't afford.
Tabs MOD

Changed: 30

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
dewicking disambiguation page


* JerkassHasAPoint: For all the blame the banks got for pushing subprime mortgages, the fault of the customers who overextended themselves financially can't be ignored. Dick Fuld's statement below may be [[JustForPun dickish]] but correct.

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: For all the blame the banks got for pushing subprime mortgages, the fault of the customers who overextended themselves financially can't be ignored. Dick Fuld's statement below may be [[JustForPun dickish]] dickish but correct.



** The Big 5 bank [=CEOs=] and the French Finance Minister Christine Lagarde lay into Paulson for forcing Lehman to declare bankruptcy. The bank heads are livid because a British regulator didn't unfreeze Lehman's assets, preventing their clients from selling off whatever Lehman stock they had. They blame Paulson for not handling this detail with the British before he made Lehman file. Lagarde rips him for allowing Lehman to fail in the first place, as many European institutions had invested in it. They are blaming the wrong person, as it was actually Lehman's job to negotiate these details of their own bankruptcy proceeding. Lagarde doesn't realize that multiple attempts were made to save Lehman, and they all failed due to [[JustForPun Dick Fuld's dickishness]] or their sheer financial weakness.

to:

** The Big 5 bank [=CEOs=] and the French Finance Minister Christine Lagarde lay into Paulson for forcing Lehman to declare bankruptcy. The bank heads are livid because a British regulator didn't unfreeze Lehman's assets, preventing their clients from selling off whatever Lehman stock they had. They blame Paulson for not handling this detail with the British before he made Lehman file. Lagarde rips him for allowing Lehman to fail in the first place, as many European institutions had invested in it. They are blaming the wrong person, as it was actually Lehman's job to negotiate these details of their own bankruptcy proceeding. Lagarde doesn't realize that multiple attempts were made to save Lehman, and they all failed due to [[JustForPun Dick Fuld's dickishness]] dickishness or their sheer financial weakness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Index wick removal


** Dick Fuld gripes about how bankers and Wall Street are always AcceptableTargets, but the real blame should lie with the ''"nimrod"'' homeowners who eagerly accepted credit to buy houses (and other things) they knew they couldn't afford;

to:

** Dick Fuld gripes about how bankers and Wall Street are always AcceptableTargets, acceptable to mark, but the real blame should lie with the ''"nimrod"'' homeowners who eagerly accepted credit to buy houses (and other things) they knew they couldn't afford;
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SadisticChoice: Paulson admits to his staff that the banks are at fault for the current crisis, but he has no choice but to bail them out because letting them fail will mean disaster for millions of ordinary Americans - even if the bailout will not only let the banks escape the consequences of their conduct, but likely encourage them to precipitate another crisis in the future.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SarcasmMode: Jim Wilkinson asks if the federal government intends to nationalize AIG (an international mega-corporation) and run it like it runs the Post Office, ''"'cause, you know, that works great!"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmericanDream: Jim Wilkinson explains to Michelle Davis that the current crisis came on after so many people ''"reach[ed] for the American Dream"'' (i.e. owning a house), believing that access to flimsy credit was the same thing as being able to afford these houses.

Added: 2260

Changed: 275

Removed: 335

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





* AmericanDream: Jim Wilkinson explains to Michelle Davis that the current crisis came on after so many people ''"reach[ed] for the American Dream"'' (i.e. owning a house), believing that access to flimsy credit was the same thing as being able to afford these houses.



* AppealToForce: Paulson says that if the Big 5 banks don't help Lehman by buying its toxic assets, "we will remember".

to:

* AnswerCut: At the end of his first meeting with his staff, Paulson asks in some exasperation, ''"So you're saying, with the full weight of the United States Treasury behind me, all I can do is call Warren Buffett?"'' Cut to him on the phone with...
* AppealToForce: Paulson says that if the Big 5 banks don't help Lehman by buying its toxic assets, "we will remember".remember those who were not helpful".



* CondescendingCompassion: As part of his pitch to convince the Korean investors to buy Lehman's worthless real estate holdings, Dick Fuld says that he ''"hate[s] to see you miss out on a great deal."'' The condescension practically dripping from his tone doesn't help, and no one in the conference room except Dick is surprised when the Koreans nix the deal and leave:
-->'''Ming''': We have looked at them.\\
'''Fuld''': Then you're not looking at them the right way!



* {{Greed}}: The root cause of the financial crisis, in at least three major ways explained by Paulson and his deputies to Michele Davis, who is supposed to explain this all to the press in a way they can understand:

to:

* {{Greed}}: The root cause of the financial crisis, in at least three major ways explained by Paulson and his deputies to Michele Davis, who is supposed to [[LaymansTerms explain this all to the press in a way they can understand:understand]]:



* KnightInShiningArmor: [=McCain=] wanted to be this (or at least present himself as this) when he suspended his Presidential campaign and rushed back to Washington, D.C. to ensure that TARP would pass. To the frustration of Neel Kashkari and Jim Wilkinson (both lifelong Republicans), ''"[=McCain=] wanted to swoop in and save the day, but doesn't have any idea how to do it."'' Since [=McCain=] is screwing up the delicate bipartisan negotiations at a moment when the government cannot lose a second, Paulson takes [=McCain=] aside to shut him up, then begs (literally on bended knee) the Democratic representatives not to abandon the negotiations. According to an interview published in ''Literature/GameChange'', one of [=McCain=]'s long-time friends summed up his actions thus: ''"If you're going to come riding into Washington on a white horse to slay a dragon, you better have the dragon tied up and tranquilized and ready to die. You don't come in and not slay the dragon and walk out with a whimper."''



* SpiritualSuccessor:
** To the Lionsgate film ''Film/MarginCall'', which was a fictionalized version of what Lehman did, before the events of this movie began.
** It also has a Spiritual Precursor (prequel) in the movie ''Film/TheBigShort'', which was about an investor who anticipated this crisis in 2005 and made a killing off of it.



*** In RealLife (according to an interview published in ''Literature/GameChange''), Jim Wilkinson (a lifelong Republican) was so aggravated by [=McCain=]'s antics, and his lack of preparedness during his limited participation in the TARP negotiations, that he wrote the Senator's campaign, asking for his contribution back, ''and'' cast his vote for Obama.

to:

*** In RealLife (according to an interview published in ''Literature/GameChange''), Jim Wilkinson (a lifelong Republican) was so aggravated by [=McCain=]'s antics, and his lack of preparedness during his limited participation in the TARP negotiations, that he wrote the Senator's campaign, asking for his contribution back, ''and'' cast his vote for Obama.Obama.
** Michelle Davis perfectly sums up the end result of all their hard work to get TARP passed, when the banks refuse to accept conditions on how they use the money the government is loaning them:
--->''They almost bring down the U.S. economy as we know it, but we can't put any hooks on the $125 billion we're loaning them because... '''they might not take it?'''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalVillainy: Dick Fuld is easily the least sympathetic character in the story, and the viewer might conclude that he preferred to let Lehman Brothers collapse rather than cede his control of it, or else that he was happy to let it fall as long as he could secure his own golden parachute. However, the book emphasizes that Fuld worked for Lehman for over forty years, and earnestly wanted to save a company he truly loved; it was just his misfortune that his decisions were disastrously ill-informed.

Top