Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / SchindlersList

Go To

OR

Added: 183

Changed: 255

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut/ToShakespeare: Amon Goeth tells Helen Hirch, "Hath not a Jew eyes?", a quote from Shylock (a Jew himself) from ''TheMerchantOfVenice'' (III.i) before making his AlmostKiss.



* ShoutOut/ToShakespeare: Amon Goeth tells Helen Hirch, "Hath not a Jew eyes?", a quote from Shylock (a Jew himself) from ''TheMerchantOfVenice'' (III.i) before making his AlmostKiss.

to:

* ShoutOut/ToShakespeare: Amon Goeth tells Helen Hirch, "Hath not a Jew eyes?", a quote from Shylock (a Jew himself) from ''TheMerchantOfVenice'' (III.i) before making his AlmostKiss.TranslationConvention: Applied haphazardly. Sometimes everyone speaks "English," while other times, it is in unsubtitled German or Polish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BadassBoast: ''This storm is different. This is not the Romans. This storm is the SS'' - also rather weird to be said in RealLife [[AnachronismStew during the Polish Campaign]], as the 1939-1940 SS-Verfügungstruppen comprised only a small percent of the German armed forces, had not yet proven themselves in battle, they were poorly equipped and hardly the poster boys to fill the newspapers and newsreels. The legendary Waffen-SS grew after the invasion of the Soviet Union.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FanDisservice: The film contains male and female full frontal nudity, but this is during the concentration camps entrance process, thus lacking any eroticism. This being despite the actors having normal healthy bodies, visibly clean, trimmed and hairless - the image of RealLife exhausted and starved prisoners naked and full of lice would be as horrible as traditional depictions of Hell.

to:

* FanDisservice: The film contains male and female full frontal nudity, but this is during the concentration camps entrance process, thus lacking any eroticism. This being despite the actors having normal healthy bodies, [[AcceptableBreaksFromReality visibly clean, trimmed and hairless - hairless]] in the scene with the trainload of women being sent to the showers. They did not recreate realistically the scene ''to avoid scaring the viewers to the verge of heart attack'', as the image of RealLife exhausted and starved prisoners naked and full of lice would be as horrible as traditional depictions of Hell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MessianicArchetype: Oskar Schindler
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InterruptedIntimacy: Schindler is having sex with his mistress when he's informed that Stern has been mistakenly put on the train that takes Jews to the death camps.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrokenAce: Goeth
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*BrokenAce: Goeth

Added: 148

Removed: 581

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fridge Logic doesn\'t go on the main page. Also, adding Lima Syndrome


* FridgeLogic: Also DidNotDoTheResearch, but absurdly. They chose a motorcar which could not have been owned and used by Schindler in 1944 (a Daimler DE36 - in the scene where Schindler rode full speed towards Auschwitz to save the trainload of women mistakenly send to death) for the simple reason it has been '''designed in 1946''' in Britain. All other cars are appropriate for the time and country: the other Schindler car, a Horch, the car Goeth rides in Plaszow, a Mercedes-Benz etc. No explanation is given why this car has been hired for a film so meticulously researched .


Added DiffLines:

* LimaSyndrome: Goeth, to the limited extent to which he is capable of such a thing, falls in love with Helen by the time she is to go to Auschwitz.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Topping it all, in RealLife she called him with a [[FluffyTheTerrible childish nickname]], "Monny". [[TheMoreYouKnow This is why]] she named his (posthumous) daughter "Monika".

to:

** Topping it all, in RealLife she called him with a [[FluffyTheTerrible childish nickname]], "Monny". [[TheMoreYouKnow This is why]] she named his (posthumous) thier daughter "Monika".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeLogic: Also DidNotDoTheResearch, but absurdly. They chose a motorcar which could not have been owned and used by Schindler in 1944 (a Daimler DE36 - in the scene where Schindler rode full speed towards Auschwitz to save the trainload of women mistakenly send to death) for the simple reason it has been ''designed in 1946'' in Britain. All other cars are appropriate for the time and country: the other Schindler car, a Horch, the car Goeth rides in Plaszow, a Mercedes-Benz etc. No explanation is given why this car has been hired for a film so meticulously researched .

to:

* FridgeLogic: Also DidNotDoTheResearch, but absurdly. They chose a motorcar which could not have been owned and used by Schindler in 1944 (a Daimler DE36 - in the scene where Schindler rode full speed towards Auschwitz to save the trainload of women mistakenly send to death) for the simple reason it has been ''designed '''designed in 1946'' 1946''' in Britain. All other cars are appropriate for the time and country: the other Schindler car, a Horch, the car Goeth rides in Plaszow, a Mercedes-Benz etc. No explanation is given why this car has been hired for a film so meticulously researched .
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeLogic: Also DidNotDoTheResearch, but absurdly. They chose a motorcar which could not have been owned and used by Schindler in 1944 (a Daimler DE36 - in the scene where Schindler rode full speed towards Auschwitz to save the trainload of women mistakenly send to death) for the simple reason it has been designed in [[strong: 1946]] in Britain. All other cars are appropriate for the time and country: the other Schindler car, a Horch, the car Goeth rides in Plaszow, a Mercedes-Benz etc. No explanation is given why this car has been hired for a film so meticulously researched .

to:

* FridgeLogic: Also DidNotDoTheResearch, but absurdly. They chose a motorcar which could not have been owned and used by Schindler in 1944 (a Daimler DE36 - in the scene where Schindler rode full speed towards Auschwitz to save the trainload of women mistakenly send to death) for the simple reason it has been designed ''designed in [[strong: 1946]] 1946'' in Britain. All other cars are appropriate for the time and country: the other Schindler car, a Horch, the car Goeth rides in Plaszow, a Mercedes-Benz etc. No explanation is given why this car has been hired for a film so meticulously researched .
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeLogic: Also DidNotDoTheResearch, but absurdly. They chose a motorcar which could not have been owned and used by Schindler in 1944 (a Daimler DE36 - in the scene where Schindler rode full speed towards Auschwitz to save the trainload of women mistakenly send to death) for the simple reason it has been designed in [[strong:1946]] in Britain. All other cars are appropriate for the time and country: the other Schindler car, a Horch, the car Goeth rides in Plaszow, a Mercedes-Benz etc. No explanation is given why this car has been hired for a film so meticulously researched .

to:

* FridgeLogic: Also DidNotDoTheResearch, but absurdly. They chose a motorcar which could not have been owned and used by Schindler in 1944 (a Daimler DE36 - in the scene where Schindler rode full speed towards Auschwitz to save the trainload of women mistakenly send to death) for the simple reason it has been designed in [[strong:1946]] [[strong: 1946]] in Britain. All other cars are appropriate for the time and country: the other Schindler car, a Horch, the car Goeth rides in Plaszow, a Mercedes-Benz etc. No explanation is given why this car has been hired for a film so meticulously researched .
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FridgeLogic: Also DidNotDoTheResearch, but absurdly. They chose a motorcar which could not have been owned and used by Schindler in 1944 (a Daimler DE36 - in the scene where Schindler rode full speed towards Auschwitz to save the trainload of women mistakenly send to death) for the simple reason it has been designed in [[strong:1946]] in Britain. All other cars are appropriate for the time and country: the other Schindler car, a Horch, the car Goeth rides in Plaszow, a Mercedes-Benz etc. No explanation is given why this car has been hired for a film so meticulously researched .
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Topping it all, in RealLife she called him with a [[FluffyTheTerrible childish nickname]], "Monny". [[TheMoreYouKnow This is why]] she named his (posthumous) daughter "Monika".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FanDisservice: The film contains male and female full frontal nudity, but this is during the concentration camps entrance process, thus lacking any eroticism. This being despite the actors having normal healthy build - the image of RealLife exhausted and starved prisoners naked would be as horrible as traditional depictions of Hell.

to:

* FanDisservice: The film contains male and female full frontal nudity, but this is during the concentration camps entrance process, thus lacking any eroticism. This being despite the actors having normal healthy build bodies, visibly clean, trimmed and hairless - the image of RealLife exhausted and starved prisoners naked and full of lice would be as horrible as traditional depictions of Hell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FanDisservice: The film contains male and female full frontal nudity, but this is during the concentration camps entrance process, thus lacking any eroticism.

to:

* FanDisservice: The film contains male and female full frontal nudity, but this is during the concentration camps entrance process, thus lacking any eroticism. This being despite the actors having normal healthy build - the image of RealLife exhausted and starved prisoners naked would be as horrible as traditional depictions of Hell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It goes further in real life. Schindler escaped arrest but his entire life was ruined. His later business' were all failures and by the end of his life, he was living on donations from Jewish charities. This arguably makes his actions even more meaningful.


Added DiffLines:

* OnlyInItForTheMoney: Schindler could care less about Political ideaology, seeking only immense wealth.


Added DiffLines:

* Screw The Money, I Have Rules: This is Oskar Schindler all over at the end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It\'s Göth or Goeth, but not Goethe.


* EvilCannotComprehendGood: When Schindler is having German soldiers hose down the Jews that have been stuffed into deathly-hot cattle cars, Goethe and the other Nazis initially laugh at what is apparently one of their own tormenting the Jews with a little taste of water, but Schindler ''keeps'' hosing the cars and even has drinking water and food brought to the train for the guards to give to the Jews every time they stop. By the end of the scene Goethe is staring at the scene with blank incomprehension; he has gone through humor, exasperation and boredom, and has now reached a point where ''he really cannot figure out what the hell Schindler is doing''. The idea that Oskar is trying to help the Jews just ''does not fit''.

to:

* EvilCannotComprehendGood: When Schindler is having German soldiers hose down the Jews that have been stuffed into deathly-hot cattle cars, Goethe Göth and the other Nazis initially laugh at what is apparently one of their own tormenting the Jews with a little taste of water, but Schindler ''keeps'' hosing the cars and even has drinking water and food brought to the train for the guards to give to the Jews every time they stop. By the end of the scene Goethe Göth is staring at the scene with blank incomprehension; he has gone through humor, exasperation and boredom, and has now reached a point where ''he really cannot figure out what the hell Schindler is doing''. The idea that Oskar is trying to help the Jews just ''does not fit''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The video linked to had been taken down.


* SamaritanSyndrome: Causes a HeroicBSOD for Schindler [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uvGu3Y9e8y0 towards the end]].

to:

* SamaritanSyndrome: Causes a HeroicBSOD for Schindler [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uvGu3Y9e8y0 towards the end]].end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PsychopathicManchild: Goeth. He has tantrums like a child, does things on a whim, and likes to break his toys. Unfortunately, in this case, his toys are human beings being starved and worked to death, who he kills on the merest whim. Accent on the "merest" part (e.g., because they exist).

to:

* PsychopathicManchild: Goeth. He has tantrums like a child, does things on a whim, and likes to break his toys. Unfortunately, in this case, his toys are human beings being starved and worked to death, who he kills on the merest whim. Accent on the "merest" part whim (e.g., because they exist).he wants to kill someone). Accent on the "merest" part.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PsychopathicManchild: Goeth. He has tantrums like a child, does things on a whim, and likes to break his toys. Unfortunately, in this case, his toys are human beings being starved and worked to death, who he kills on the merest whim. Accent on the "merest" part.

to:

* PsychopathicManchild: Goeth. He has tantrums like a child, does things on a whim, and likes to break his toys. Unfortunately, in this case, his toys are human beings being starved and worked to death, who he kills on the merest whim. Accent on the "merest" part.part (e.g., because they exist).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheApocalypseBringsOutTheBestInPeople: Happens to Schindler, who as the death tolls and dangers increase, becomes continuously more concerned with preserving human life and trying his hardest to keep people alive. Schindler himself believes - ironically - in the opposite, that war brings out the worst in people, and that if the war had not happened, [[HorribleJudgeOfCharacter Amon Goeth would be generally a really nice guy]]. The movie itself suggests that war brings out the truth in people i.e. Goeth is really a CompleteMonster, and Schindler is really a good guy.

to:

* TheApocalypseBringsOutTheBestInPeople: Happens to Schindler, who begins the film as a serial adulterer and war profiteer, but as the death tolls and dangers increase, becomes continuously more concerned with preserving human life and trying his hardest to keep people alive. Schindler himself believes - ironically - in the opposite, that war brings out the worst in people, and that if the war had not happened, [[HorribleJudgeOfCharacter Amon Goeth would be generally a really nice guy]]. The movie itself suggests that war brings out the truth in people i.e. Goeth is really a CompleteMonster, and Schindler is really a good guy.

Changed: 430

Removed: 273

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GraveMarkingScene: The final scene of the film shows the actual Schindler Jews visiting the grave of the actual Schindler

to:

* GraveMarkingScene: The final scene of the film shows the actual Schindler Jews visiting the grave of the actual SchindlerSchindler. They each leave a stone on the grave to mark their visit, as per Jewish custom, leaving every inch of the grave covered in the stones of the Jews he'd saved.



* LittleDeadRidingHood: The only color shown in the movie (aside from a candle at the beginning, the Blauschein stamp, and the ending scene) is a girl in a red coat, shown hiding from the Nazis. [[spoiler:Later in the film, she is seen in passing again as one of a stack of corpses, only recognizable because the red coat is again the only color shown.]]
** Steven Spielberg wanted to use red because of the association with blood, and because Oskar Schindler really did see a toddler (Roma Ligocka) dressed in red - apparently she actually survived, and later wrote her own memoir titled ''The Girl in the Red Coat: A Memoir''.

to:

* LittleDeadRidingHood: The only color shown in the movie (aside from a candle at the beginning, the Blauschein stamp, and the ending scene) is a girl in a red coat, shown hiding from the Nazis. [[spoiler:Later in the film, she is seen in passing again as one of a stack of corpses, only recognizable because the red coat is again the only color shown.]]
**
]] Steven Spielberg wanted to use red because of the association with blood, and because Oskar Schindler really did see a toddler (Roma Ligocka) dressed in red - apparently she actually survived, and later wrote her own memoir titled ''The Girl in the Red Coat: A Memoir''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ItGotWorse: Jews several times remark that "it can't get any worse!" This leads to an IronicEchoCut:

to:

* ItGotWorse: Jews several times remark that "it "[[RockBottom it can't get any worse!" worse!]]" This leads to an IronicEchoCut:



* TemptingFate: At every stage of the Jews' predicament, someone comments that things can not get worse, or that they are now in a pretty good position (as workers that is). Justified of course, given this was barbarity on an unimaginable scale.

to:

* TemptingFate: At every stage of the Jews' predicament, someone comments that [[RockBottom things can not get worse, worse]], or that they are now in a pretty good position (as workers that is). Justified of course, given this was barbarity on an unimaginable scale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Schindler's List'' is a 1993 film directed by StevenSpielberg, shot almost entirely in black and white. Loosely based on real events from WorldWarII, the film won seven Oscars; it holds a [[http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/schindlers_list/# 97% Fresh]] from RottenTomatoes. The film is based on the book ''Schindler's Ark'' -- which in turn is based on the actions of a man named Oskar Schindler.

to:

''Schindler's List'' is a 1993 film directed by StevenSpielberg, shot almost entirely in black and white. Loosely based on real events from WorldWarII, the film won seven Oscars; it holds a [[http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/schindlers_list/# 97% Fresh]] from RottenTomatoes. The film is based on the book ''Schindler's Ark'' by Australian author Thomas Keneally -- which in turn is based on the actions of a man named Oskar Schindler.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StolenMacGuffinReveal
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "The worst is over... now we are workers!"
** Schindler's female workers are seen happily boarding a train that will supposedly take them to Schindler's plant. [[spoiler:They get shipped to Auschwitz instead.]]

to:

** "The worst is over... now we are workers!"
workers now!"
** Schindler's female workers are seen happily boarding a train that will supposedly take them to Schindler's plant. [[spoiler:They get shipped to end up at Auschwitz instead.by mistake, but he gets them out safely with a well-placed bribe.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SplashOfColor: The little girl in the red coat; the Sabbath candles; the Blauschein stamp.

to:

* SplashOfColor: The little girl in the red coat; coat (probably the most iconic example in a modern work); the Sabbath candles; the Blauschein stamp.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Schindler's wife allegedly once said that Schindler himself did nothing remarkable before or after the war -- WorldWarII, that is. He was a businessman in Nazi-controlled Germany who, while trying to profit from the German invasion of Poland, ended up running a factory using enslaved Polish Jews as the workforce. As the Nazis started to send captured Jews to the concentration camps, Schindler resisted their actions. The movie's title comes from the "lists" he kept of skilled workers that he could not afford to lose...which just so happened to be every worker in the factory. At the cost of any sort of financial security -- he was bankrupt by the time the war ended -- Schindler ended up saving over a thousand people from being killed in concentration camps.

to:

Schindler's wife allegedly once said that Schindler himself did nothing remarkable before or after the war -- WorldWarII, that is. He was a businessman in Nazi-controlled Germany who, while trying to profit from the German invasion of Poland, ended up running a factory using enslaved Polish Jews as the workforce. As the Nazis started to send captured Jews to the concentration camps, Schindler resisted their actions. The movie's title comes from the "lists" he kept of skilled workers that he could not afford to lose... which just so happened to be every worker in the factory. At the cost of any sort of financial security -- he was bankrupt by the time the war ended -- Schindler ended up saving over a thousand people from being killed in concentration camps.



* TheApocalypseBringsOutTheBestInPeople: Happens to Schindler, who as the death tolls and dangers increase, becomes continuously more concerned with preserving human life and trying his hardest to keep people alive. Schindler himself believes - ironically - in the opposite, that war brings out the worst in people, and that if the war had not happened, [[HorribleJudgeOfCharacter Amon Goeth would be generally a really nice guy]]. The movie itself suggests that war brings out the truth in people i.e. Goeth is really a Complete Monster, and Schindler is really a good guy.

to:

* TheApocalypseBringsOutTheBestInPeople: Happens to Schindler, who as the death tolls and dangers increase, becomes continuously more concerned with preserving human life and trying his hardest to keep people alive. Schindler himself believes - ironically - in the opposite, that war brings out the worst in people, and that if the war had not happened, [[HorribleJudgeOfCharacter Amon Goeth would be generally a really nice guy]]. The movie itself suggests that war brings out the truth in people i.e. Goeth is really a Complete Monster, CompleteMonster, and Schindler is really a good guy.



** Schindler's female workers are seen happily boarding a train that will supposedly take them to Schindler's plant. They get shipped to Auschwitz instead.

to:

** Schindler's female workers are seen happily boarding a train that will supposedly take them to Schindler's plant. They [[spoiler:They get shipped to Auschwitz instead.]]



* VillainousCrush: Geoth has one on Helen Hirsch, his Jewish maid.

to:

* VillainousCrush: Geoth Goeth has one on Helen Hirsch, his Jewish maid.

Top