Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / BlackNarcissus

Go To

OR

Added: 548

Removed: 548

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
J and K come before L


* JunglesSoundLikeKookaburras: The kookaburra can be heard in the bamboo forests of Himalayan foothills.
* KubrickStare: The signal that [[spoiler: Sister Ruth is really starting to come unglued comes when she shoots a really, really [[http://www.popoptiq.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Black-Narcissus-Sister-Ruth-Unstable.jpg unsettling Kubrick Stare]] at Sister Clodagh right after Sister Clodagh suggests that Ruth is getting too fond of Mr. Dean. Ruth does this several more times over the course of the movie as she gets crazier and crazier.]]



* JunglesSoundLikeKookaburras: The kookaburra can be heard in the bamboo forests of Himalayan foothills.
* KubrickStare: The signal that [[spoiler: Sister Ruth is really starting to come unglued comes when she shoots a really, really [[http://www.popoptiq.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Black-Narcissus-Sister-Ruth-Unstable.jpg unsettling Kubrick Stare]] at Sister Clodagh right after Sister Clodagh suggests that Ruth is getting too fond of Mr. Dean. Ruth does this several more times over the course of the movie as she gets crazier and crazier.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ambiguous Disorder has been renamed and now belongs in YMMV.


* AmbiguousDisorder: Sister Ruth is just said to be ill or troubled, and she latches on to Mr Dean simply because he speaks kindly to her a couple of times. But she also is very narrow-minded and displays casual racism and prejudice - suggesting she could just have had a sheltered upbringing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sister Clodagh is still called Clodagh in the flashbacks to her pre-convent life. Nuns always take a new name when first taking their vows. Of course, since the flashbacks are framed from her subjective impression, and are done in a very stylized manner (as noted by Scorsese and Powell on the Criterion commentary), it might be that Clodagh has retrofitted her post-vocational name back to her pre-vocation life. In the miniseries she reveals to Mr. Dean that her name was originally [[spoiler: Katherine]] as [[spoiler: the nuns leave]].

to:

** Sister Clodagh is still called Clodagh in the flashbacks to her pre-convent life. Nuns almost always take a new name when first taking their vows.vows (in the last fifty years or so, this rule has relaxed depending on the religious order, but at the time of the film and book it was de rigeur to do so). Of course, since the flashbacks are framed from her subjective impression, and are done in a very stylized manner (as noted by Scorsese and Powell on the Criterion commentary), it might be that Clodagh has retrofitted her post-vocational name back to her pre-vocation life. In the miniseries she reveals to Mr. Dean that her name was originally [[spoiler: Katherine]] as [[spoiler: the nuns leave]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FanDisservice: Done very stealthily with Kathleen Byron, one of the most beautiful women in the history of cinema. First she's given a pale face, chapped lips and red-rimmed eyes; then over time they make the only character in the film who's visibly sweaty; then, as she abandons the veil and starts to wear make-up, she clearly has bad skin under the makeup on her forehead; until by the end she pretty much looks like an [[https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0039192/mediaviewer/rm3252912129/ actual corpse]].

to:

* FanDisservice: Done very stealthily with Kathleen Byron, one of the most beautiful women in the history of cinema. First she's given a pale face, chapped lips and red-rimmed eyes; then over time they make her the only character in the film who's visibly sweaty; then, as she abandons the veil and starts to wear make-up, she clearly has bad skin under the makeup on her forehead; until by the end she pretty much looks like an [[https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0039192/mediaviewer/rm3252912129/ actual corpse]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FanDisservice: Done very stealthily with Kathleen Byron, one of the most beautiful women in the history of cinema. First she's given a pale face, chapped lips and red-rimmed eyes; then over time they make the only character in the film who's visibly sweaty; then, as she abandons the veil and starts to wear make-up, she clearly has bad skin under the makeup on her forehead; until by the end she pretty much looks like an actual corpse.

to:

* FanDisservice: Done very stealthily with Kathleen Byron, one of the most beautiful women in the history of cinema. First she's given a pale face, chapped lips and red-rimmed eyes; then over time they make the only character in the film who's visibly sweaty; then, as she abandons the veil and starts to wear make-up, she clearly has bad skin under the makeup on her forehead; until by the end she pretty much looks like an [[https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0039192/mediaviewer/rm3252912129/ actual corpse.corpse]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FanDisservice: Done very stealthily with Kathleen Byron, one of the most beautiful women in the history of cinema. First she's given a pale face, chapped lips and red-rimmed eyes; then over time they make the only character in the film who's visibly sweaty; then, as she abandons the veil and starts to wear make-up, she clearly has bad skin under the makeup on her forehead; until by the end she pretty much looks like an actual corpse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Asexuality is now a disambiguation page.


* BettyAndVeronica: With Mr Dean as the Archie, the demure Sister Clodagh as the Betty and the psychopath Sister Ruth as the Veronica. But it veers into deconstruction - Sister Clodagh refuses to act on any of her inner feelings, Mr Dean is hinted to be {{Asexual}} and uninterested in any relationships, and Sister Ruth [[spoiler: goes mad after being rejected.]]

to:

* BettyAndVeronica: With Mr Dean as the Archie, the demure Sister Clodagh as the Betty and the psychopath Sister Ruth as the Veronica. But it veers into deconstruction - Sister Clodagh refuses to act on any of her inner feelings, Mr Dean is hinted to be {{Asexual}} asexual and uninterested in any relationships, and Sister Ruth [[spoiler: goes mad after being rejected.]]

Added: 482

Changed: 980

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguousSituation: It's not confirmed what the result of the Young General's tryst with Kanchi is. He references the story of 'The Prince and the Beggar Maid', which ends with the prince marrying said beggar.



* ArtisticLicenseReligion: Sister Clodagh is still called Clodagh in the flashbacks to her pre-convent life. Nuns always take a new name when first taking their vows. Of course, since the flashbacks are framed from her subjective impression, and are done in a very stylized manner (as noted by Scorsese and Powell on the Criterion commentary), it might be that Clodagh has retrofitted her post-vocational name back to her pre-vocation life.
** In the miniseries she reveals to Mr. Dean that her name was originally [[spoiler: Katherine]] as [[spoiler: the nuns leave]].

to:

* ArtisticLicenseReligion: ArtisticLicenseReligion:
**
Sister Clodagh is still called Clodagh in the flashbacks to her pre-convent life. Nuns always take a new name when first taking their vows. Of course, since the flashbacks are framed from her subjective impression, and are done in a very stylized manner (as noted by Scorsese and Powell on the Criterion commentary), it might be that Clodagh has retrofitted her post-vocational name back to her pre-vocation life. \n** In the miniseries she reveals to Mr. Dean that her name was originally [[spoiler: Katherine]] as [[spoiler: the nuns leave]].leave]].
** The original American release had a title card referring to the nuns as Anglicans. They're part of the Servants of Mary, which is a Roman Catholic order. This may have been necessary by the Catholic Legion of Decency protesting against the movie being shown otherwise.



** Sister Clodagh says of her former beau Conn "I had already shown that I loved him", which seems to imply that they had premarital sex. As she is Irish, it's possible Clodagh fled the Magdalene Laundries where she could have been sent as punishment.

to:

** Sister Clodagh says of her former beau Conn "I had already shown that I loved him", which seems to imply that they had premarital sex. As she is Irish, it's possible Clodagh fled the Magdalene Laundries where she could have been sent as punishment.punishment (or worse yet, been sent there anyway and became a nun that way).



* SceneryPorn: Despite being accomplished by elaborate sets and matte paintings. The whole film was shot in England, mostly Creator/PinewoodStudios.

to:

* SceneryPorn: Despite being accomplished by elaborate sets and matte paintings. The whole film was shot in England, mostly Creator/PinewoodStudios. Apparently several Indian residents sent letters claiming to recognise the locations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Evil Makeover is being dewicked, existing examples can be relocated under its sub-tropes


* EvilMakeover: [[spoiler: Sister Ruth putting on her makeup in front of Sister Clodagh.]]

to:

* EvilMakeover: ExcessiveEvilEyeshadow: A variant occurs with [[spoiler: Sister Ruth putting on her makeup in front of Sister Clodagh.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YoungAndInCharge: Mother Dorothea mentions that Sister Clodagh is exceptionally young to be in charge of a convent. [[{{Deconstruction}} Deconstructed]] since [[RealityEnsues she can't handle the responsibility,]] especially with the HostileWeather and isolation driving everyone out of their wits, and the nuns eventually have to leave.

to:

* YoungAndInCharge: Mother Dorothea mentions that Sister Clodagh is exceptionally young to be in charge of a convent. [[{{Deconstruction}} Deconstructed]] since [[RealityEnsues she can't handle the responsibility,]] responsibility, especially with the HostileWeather and isolation driving everyone out of their wits, and the nuns eventually have to leave.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->And that for stealing in my house! That for stealing a brass chain which is only worth two annas! That for stealing it in such a silly way! And that...is for getting found out!

to:

-->And -->"And that for stealing in my house! That for stealing a brass chain which is only worth two annas! That for stealing it in such a silly way! And that...is for getting found out!out!"



* BettyAndVeronica: With Mr Dean as the Archie, the demure Sister Clodagh as the Betty and the psychopath Sister Ruth as the Veronica. But it veers into deconstruction - Sister Clodagh refuses to act on any of her inner feelings, Mr Dean is hinted to be {{Asexual}} and uninterested in any relationships, and Sister Ruth [[spoiler: goes mad after being rejected.]]/

to:

* BettyAndVeronica: With Mr Dean as the Archie, the demure Sister Clodagh as the Betty and the psychopath Sister Ruth as the Veronica. But it veers into deconstruction - Sister Clodagh refuses to act on any of her inner feelings, Mr Dean is hinted to be {{Asexual}} and uninterested in any relationships, and Sister Ruth [[spoiler: goes mad after being rejected.]]/]]



* {{Brownface}}: Of the major Indian characters, only the Young General is played by an actual Indian actor, [[Film/TheThiefOfBagdad1940 Sabu]]. The others are whites in makeup, most obviously the very very white Jean Simmons. Averted with the background characters, many of whom were Indian Nationals who were working at the Rotherhithe docks.

to:

* {{Brownface}}: Of the major Indian characters, only the Young General is played by an actual Indian actor, [[Film/TheThiefOfBagdad1940 Sabu]]. The others are whites in makeup, most obviously the very very white Jean Simmons. Averted with the background characters, many of whom were Indian Nationals nationals who were working at the Rotherhithe docks.



** Sister Ruth is shown aggressively taking a parcel from Joseph, trying to stop him from letting Sister Clodagh see it. [[spoiler: Turns out to be a red dress]].

to:

** Sister Ruth is shown aggressively taking a parcel from Joseph, trying to stop him from letting Sister Clodagh see it. [[spoiler: Turns [[spoiler:Turns out to be a red dress]].



* EveryoneCallsHimBarkeep: The Young General's name, Philip, is said once before he arrives, but he's referred to as General by the others. In a meta example, synopses and reviews usually call him Young General too.

to:

* EveryoneCallsHimBarkeep: The Young General's name, Philip, Dilip, is said once before he arrives, but he's referred to as General by the others. In a meta example, synopses and reviews usually call him Young General too.

Added: 1105

Changed: 292

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%% * GettingCrapPastThe Radar: Due to overwhelming and persistent misuse, GCPTR is on-page examples only until 01 June 2021. If you are reading this in the future, please check the trope page to make sure your example fits the current definition.

to:

%% * GettingCrapPastThe Radar: Due GettingCrapPastTheRadar: This movie is rife with [[https://www.bbfc.co.uk/education/students-guide/bbfc-history/1912-1949 the kind of innuendo the BBFC was not OK with in 1947]]:
** The Old General mentions importing plenty of sausages for the nuns
to overwhelming eat.
** When the nuns first meet Mr Dean, Sister Clodagh says she wants to talk to him on business. He responds "I don't suppose you want to talk to me about anything else", prompting an offended look from Sister Briony.
** Mr Dean says of the Old General "he too is a superior being", again getting a scandalised look from the nuns.
** When Mr Dean asks Clodagh to take in Kanchi
and persistent misuse, GCPTR is on-page examples only until 01 June 2021. If you are reading this in the future, please check nun is studying the trope page to make young woman, he watches the pair of them with barely disguised amusement and almost lasciviously asks "You're sure your example fits there's no question you're ''dying'' to ask me?" practically daring Clodagh to demand whether Kanchi is his lover. She refuses to ask, so the current definition.viewer never finds out either way.
** The Young General mistakenly says he'll study physics "with the physical sister".
** Sister Clodagh says of her former beau Conn "I had already shown that I loved him", which seems to imply that they had premarital sex. As she is Irish, it's possible Clodagh fled the Magdalene Laundries where she could have been sent as punishment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YoungAndInCharge: Mother Dorothea mentions that Sister Clodagh is exceptionally young to be in charge of a convent. [[{{Deconstruction}} Deconstructed]] since [[RealityEnsues she can't handle the responsibility,]] especially with the HostileWeather and isolation driving everyone out of their wits, and the nuns eventually have to leave.

to:

* YoungAndInCharge: Mother Dorothea mentions that Sister Clodagh is exceptionally young to be in charge of a convent. [[{{Deconstruction}} Deconstructed]] since [[RealityEnsues she can't handle the responsibility,]] especially with the HostileWeather and isolation driving everyone out of their wits, and the nuns eventually have to leave.leave.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TagAlongKid: Joseph Anthony lives in the convent to act as an interpreter for the nuns.

to:

* TagAlongKid: TagalongKid: Joseph Anthony lives in the convent to act as an interpreter for the nuns.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AndThisIsFor: As Angu Ayah is whipping Kanchi:
-->And that for stealing in my house! That for stealing a brass chain which is only worth two annas! That for stealing it in such a silly way! And that...is for getting found out!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtImitatesArt: Director of Photography Jack Cardiff said that the lighting and color palette of this movie was inspired by the works of seventeenth century Dutch painter Johannes Vermeer. A tribute to him can be seen in the opening scene when the Mother Superior is reading a letter while facing a window. An image used by Vermeer in some of his most famous paintings.


Added DiffLines:

* ColorMotifs: For the costumes, Alfred Junge, the art director, had three main colour schemes. The nuns were always in the white habits that he designed from a medley of medieval types. These white robes of heavy material stressed the nuns' other-worldliness amid the exotic native surroundings. The chief native characters were robed in brilliant colours, particularly the generals in jewels and in rich silks. Other native characters brought into the film for "atmosphere" were clad in more sombre colours with the usual native dress of the Nepalese, Bhutanese and Tibetan peoples toned down to prevent overloading the eye with brilliance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BeautyInversion: Kathleen Byron is one of the {{Trope Maker}}s here. Sister Ruth undergoes SanitySlippage and her make-up gets steadily creepier, to the point where she looks like she's wearing a corpselike mask in the finale.

Changed: 223

Removed: 1107

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GettingCrapPastTheRadar: The film is dripping with innuendos.
** The Old General mentions importing plenty of sausages for the nuns to eat.
** When the nuns first meet Mr Dean, Sister Clodagh says she wants to talk to him on business. He responds "I don't suppose you want to talk to me about anything else" - prompting an offended look from Sister Briony.
** Mr Dean says of the Old General "he too is a superior being" - again getting a scandalised look from the nuns.
** When Mr Dean asks Clodagh to take in Kanchi and the nun is studying the young woman, he watches the pair of them with barely disguised amusement and almost lasciviously asks "You're sure there's no question you're ''dying'' to ask me?" practically daring Clodagh to demand whether Kanchi is his lover. She refuses to ask, so the viewer never finds out either way.
** The Young General mistakenly says he'll study physics "with the physical sister".
** Sister Clodagh says of her former beau Conn "I had already shown that I loved him", which seems to imply that they had premarital sex. As she is Irish, it's possible Clodagh fled the Magdalene Laundries where she could have been sent as punishment.

to:

%% * GettingCrapPastTheRadar: The film GettingCrapPastThe Radar: Due to overwhelming and persistent misuse, GCPTR is dripping with innuendos.
** The Old General mentions importing plenty of sausages for
on-page examples only until 01 June 2021. If you are reading this in the nuns to eat.
** When
future, please check the nuns first meet Mr Dean, Sister Clodagh says she wants trope page to talk to him on business. He responds "I don't suppose you want to talk to me about anything else" - prompting an offended look from Sister Briony.
** Mr Dean says of the Old General "he too is a superior being" - again getting a scandalised look from the nuns.
** When Mr Dean asks Clodagh to take in Kanchi and the nun is studying the young woman, he watches the pair of them with barely disguised amusement and almost lasciviously asks "You're
make sure there's no question you're ''dying'' to ask me?" practically daring Clodagh to demand whether Kanchi is his lover. She refuses to ask, so your example fits the viewer never finds out either way.
** The Young General mistakenly says he'll study physics "with the physical sister".
** Sister Clodagh says of her former beau Conn "I had already shown that I loved him", which seems to imply that they had premarital sex. As she is Irish, it's possible Clodagh fled the Magdalene Laundries where she could have been sent as punishment.
current definition.

Top