Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Amen

Go To

OR

Added: 227

Changed: 867

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


2002 German/French/Romanian film directed by Costa-Gavras which explores the links between UsefulNotes/NaziGermany and [[UsefulNotes/VaticanCity the Vatican]] through the eyes of two characters - the RealLife [[ThoseWackyNazis Waffen-SS]] Officer Kurt Gerstein, and a fictional young Jesuit priest named Riccardo Fontana.

In 1942, Kurt Gerstein of the [=SS=] Hygiene Institute travels to Poland to instruct the troops in the safe storage and purification of water, and to observe the use of the new form of the chemical Zyklon B he has developed to eradicate typhus. However, accompanied by a sinister [=SS=] Doctor, he is taken to the newly established Belzec extermination camp to witness his creation being put to its true, grisly use. A [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone horrified]] Gerstein returns to Germany and, despite having been sworn to secrecy, he begins desperately attempting to inform the international community of the massacres. Mindful of the successful campaign against the Aktion [=T4=] programme spearheaded by the Catholic Church, he tries to convey the message to the Vatican, but finds his local bishops unmoved.

to:

2002 German/French/Romanian film directed by Costa-Gavras which explores the links between UsefulNotes/NaziGermany and [[UsefulNotes/VaticanCity the Vatican]] through the eyes of two characters - the RealLife [[ThoseWackyNazis Waffen-SS]] Officer officer Kurt Gerstein, and a fictional young Jesuit priest named Riccardo Fontana.

In 1942, Kurt Gerstein of the [=SS=] Hygiene Institute travels to Poland to instruct the troops in the safe storage and purification of water, and to observe the use of the new form of the chemical Zyklon B he has developed to eradicate typhus. However, accompanied by a sinister [=SS=] Doctor, doctor, he is taken to the newly established Belzec extermination camp to witness his creation being put to its true, grisly use. A [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone horrified]] Gerstein returns to Germany and, despite having been sworn to secrecy, he begins desperately attempting to inform the international community of the massacres. atrocities. Mindful of the successful campaign against the Aktion [=T4=] programme program spearheaded by the Catholic Church, he tries to convey the message to the Vatican, but finds his local bishops unmoved.



* MercyKill: The Doctor is shown complaining over the fact that the Catholic Church is ignorant about euthanasia after Archbishop von Galen helped get Aktion T4 halted, and justifies having gassed mental patients on this basis.



* NaziProtagonist: Kurt Gerstein did join the Nazi party in 1933, but disagreed with a lot of their more extreme positions, and was actually expelled in 1936 for distributing anti-Nazi material - he was however a member of the [=SS=], the principal perpetrators of the Holocaust.

to:

* NaziProtagonist: Kurt Gerstein did join is in the Nazi party in 1933, but disagreed with a lot of their more extreme positions, [=SS=], and was actually expelled in 1936 for distributing anti-Nazi material - he was however a member of the [=SS=], Nazi Party. He was expelled from the principal perpetrators party in 1936, before the events of the Holocaust.film, due to protesting its anti-Christian rhetoric, and had even been arrested multiple times, but then readmitted in 1939. In a letter to his wife, Gerstein said he did so it as an agent of the Confessing Church (the dissident Lutheran movement) and hoped that their crimes could be exposed. He joined the SS for the same reasons. It has also been said that the murder of his sister-in-law during the Nazis' Aktion T4 "euthanasia" program motivated him (while the movie makes her his niece). The movie portrays him as turning on the SS and Nazi Party after learning about their crimes, contrary to this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KarmaHoudini: [[spoiler: The Doctor finds a safe haven in the Vatican before finding a ship bound for Argentina.]]

to:

* KarmaHoudini: [[spoiler: The Doctor finds a safe haven in the Vatican before finding a ship bound for Argentina. Also, the many people Gerstein tried to warned, but vehemently disbelieved him and remained ignorant of the then-impeding Holocaust were never seen punished neither.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InterserviceRivalry: Karl turns against his ex-friend Gerstein because of this between Karl's Wehrmacht membership and Gerstein's SS membership, however Karl is also an irrational and petty {{Hypocrite}} when he threatens Gerstein to sic the [[StateSec Gestapo]] (another SS organization) on him if he doesn't get off his back.

to:

* InterserviceRivalry: Karl turns against his ex-friend Gerstein because of this between Karl's Wehrmacht membership and Gerstein's SS membership, however Karl is also an irrational and petty {{Hypocrite}} when he threatens Gerstein to sic the [[StateSec Gestapo]] (another SS organization) on him if he doesn't get off his back.

Added: 433

Changed: 15

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BerserkButton: Like a flick of a switch after just being warm and fuzzily friendly towards him, hearing his friend Kurt Gerstein to be a SS member really ''blindly enrages'' Wehrmacht clerk Karl who NeverLiveItDown and bordered on BlackAndWhiteInsanity on vehemently refusing to acknowledge the actual good in Gerstein despite his membership.

to:

* BerserkButton: Like a flick of a switch after just being warm and fuzzily friendly towards him, hearing his friend Kurt Gerstein to be a SS member really ''blindly enrages'' Wehrmacht clerk Karl who NeverLiveItDown and bordered on BlackAndWhiteInsanity on vehemently and myopically refusing to acknowledge the actual good in Gerstein despite his membership.


Added DiffLines:

* FourEyesZeroSoul: Karl when he nearly bite Gerstein's head off after learning about his SS membership.


Added DiffLines:

* InterserviceRivalry: Karl turns against his ex-friend Gerstein because of this between Karl's Wehrmacht membership and Gerstein's SS membership, however Karl is also an irrational and petty {{Hypocrite}} when he threatens Gerstein to sic the [[StateSec Gestapo]] (another SS organization) on him if he doesn't get off his back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BerserkButton: Like a flick of a switch after just being warm and fuzzily friendly towards him, hearing his friend Kurt Gerstein to be a SS member really ''blindly enrages'' Wehrmacht clerk Karl who NeverLiveItDown and bordered on BlackAndWhiteInsanity on vehemently refusing to acknowledge the actual good in Gerstein despite his membership.

Added: 207

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSocialDarwinist: The Doctor, who in one scene shows up at Kurt's house with chocolates to celebrate Darwin's birthday. By gifting his children with an ape's skull made out of swiss chocolate, with a note inside containing a message about EvolutionaryLevels.

to:

* TheSocialDarwinist: The Doctor, who in one scene shows up at Kurt's house with chocolates to celebrate Darwin's birthday. By gifting birthday by giving his children with an ape's skull made out of swiss chocolate, with a note inside containing a message about EvolutionaryLevels.


Added DiffLines:

* TurbulentPriest: Bishop von Galen is part of the effort to stop the Aktion T-4 euthanasia program. Father Fontana later attempts to reveal and stop the Holocaust, aiding dissident SS officer Kurt Gerstein.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheSociopath: The Doctor can make himself appear charming, but he's more or less just mimicing the emotions of those around him. He genuinely doesn't see any problem with exterminating millions of people--even his AboveGoodAndEvil speech to Gerstein seems rehearsed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArgentinaIsNaziland: The film's final scene.

to:

* ArgentinaIsNaziland: The film's final scene.scene, where [[spoiler:The Doctor]] is preparing to catch a boat to Argentina with help from a Vatican cardinal.

Added: 4

Changed: 138

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheSocialDarwinist: The Doctor, who in one scene shows up at Kurt's house with chocolates to celebrate Darwin's birthday.

to:

* TheSocialDarwinist: The Doctor, who in one scene shows up at Kurt's house with chocolates to celebrate Darwin's birthday. By gifting his children with an ape's skull made out of swiss chocolate, with a note inside containing a message about EvolutionaryLevels.



* YourApprovalFillsMeWithShame: Kurt is frequently praised for his effective "disinfection" techniques by high-ranking members of the [=SS=]. He himself finds the crimes he unwittingly helped to commit horrific.

to:

* YourApprovalFillsMeWithShame: Kurt is frequently praised for his effective "disinfection" techniques by high-ranking members of the [=SS=]. He himself finds the crimes he unwittingly helped to commit horrific.horrific.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RaisedCatholic: The Doctor claims to be "a bit Catholic".

to:

* RaisedCatholic: The Doctor claims to be "a bit Catholic". It's unclear if he's just being sarcastic, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ImpliedDeathThreat: Rudolf Hoess expresses his annoyance with delays in shipments of Zyklon-B to the death camps by stating that industrialists who assist the SS with the killing of "undesirables" for reasons of profit while falsely espousing Nazi ideology have reason to fear: "We can always aryanize the aryanizers".[[note]]"Aryanization" was the Nazi term for ethnic cleansing through mass murder.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MorallyAmbiguousDoctorate: "The Doctor".

to:

* MorallyAmbiguousDoctorate: "The Doctor". He personally selects mental patients to be killed early in the war and later participates in the Holocaust.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RageWithinTheMachine

to:

* RageWithinTheMachineRageWithinTheMachine: Kurt Gerstein unwittingly becomes one of the chief organizers of the Holocaust when his chemical supplies start to be used for killing people instead of typhus. He subtly tries to undermine the actions of his colleagues by delaying shipments of Zyklon-B, but it's entirely too little to make much of a dent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* [[ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight Screw the Rules, He's Doing What's Right!]]: When one of the cardinals expresses outrage that Riccardo has requested a papal audience for a man who is not only an [=SS=] officer, but a traitor to his country, Riccardo replies;

to:

* [[ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight Screw the Rules, He's Doing What's Right!]]: ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: When one of the cardinals expresses outrage that Riccardo has requested a papal audience for a man who is not only an [=SS=] officer, but a traitor to his country, Riccardo replies;
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cut natter.


** According to Wiki/{{Wikipedia}}, it had always been Gerstein's intention to sabotage the Nazi regime from within and expose everything he found; only what he found was ''way'' beyond his darkest expectations. Also, anyone expelled from the NSDAP was automatically blacklisted in Germany: re-joining the party was his only chance at getting anything like a [[{{Irony}} decent]] job.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* UsefulNotes/ThePope: Specifically, Pope Pius [=XII=].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved to the YMMV page.


* NightmareFuel: What, exactly, did Gerstein see through the peep-hole?... Just seconds before all inside were dead?

Added: 569

Changed: 565



* DespairEventHorizon: The film opens with one of these, when the Jewish journalist Stephan Lux walks into the League of Nations and publicly shoots himself in protest against Nazi persecution and the world's silence. Later, when the Nazis occupy Rome, [[spoiler: Riccardo dons a yellow star and boards the transport headed for a death camp. On his arrival, the Doctor discovers that he is a Catholic priest and places him in the ''Sonderkommando'', the unit responsible for burning bodies of the murdered. Gerstein finds him starved, weak, and utterly broken by what he has witnessed.]]

to:

* DespairEventHorizon: DespairEventHorizon:
**
The film opens with one of these, when the Jewish journalist Stephan Lux walks into the League of Nations and publicly shoots himself in protest against Nazi persecution and the world's silence. silence.
**
Later, when the Nazis occupy Rome, [[spoiler: Riccardo Riccardo]] dons a yellow star and boards the transport headed for a death camp. On his arrival, the Doctor discovers that he is a Catholic priest and places him in the ''Sonderkommando'', the unit responsible for burning bodies of the murdered. Gerstein finds him starved, weak, and utterly broken by what he has witnessed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NightmareFuel: What, exactly, did Gerstein see through the peep-hole?... Just seconds before all inside were dead?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlackAndGreyMorality: The horrific evil of Nazi atrocities is condemned in no uncertain terms, but on the other hand, the film explores the uncomfortable reality that, in terms of concrete action, the Allies were fairly ambivalent towards the suffering of the Jews, Gypsies, and others. The Swedish diplomat Göran von Otter tells Kurt that his efforts to get the Americans to accept 2,000 Jewish children have been in vain, and several times the Doctor at Auschwitz remarks, "German cities are bombarded every night, but here the heavens are clear."

to:

* BlackAndGreyMorality: BlackAndGrayMorality: The horrific evil of Nazi atrocities is condemned in no uncertain terms, but on the other hand, the film explores the uncomfortable reality that, in terms of concrete action, the Allies were fairly ambivalent towards the suffering of the Jews, Gypsies, and others. The Swedish diplomat Göran von Otter tells Kurt that his efforts to get the Americans to accept 2,000 Jewish children have been in vain, and several times the Doctor at Auschwitz remarks, "German cities are bombarded every night, but here the heavens are clear."



* BreakingSpeech: The Doctor gives a couple.

to:

* BreakingSpeech: BreakThemByTalking: The Doctor gives a couple.couple of breaking lectures.



* TheIdealist: Both protagonists sincerely believe in the power of public opinion and of the church to put a stop to the atrocities. [[DespairEventHorizon At first]].

to:

* TheIdealist: Both protagonists sincerely believe in the power of public opinion and of the church to put a stop to the atrocities. [[DespairEventHorizon At first]].first.]]



** According to TheOtherWiki, it had always been Gerstein's intention to sabotage the Nazi regime from within and expose everything he found; only what he found was ''way'' beyond his darkest expectations. Also, anyone expelled from the NSDAP was automatically blacklisted in Germany: re-joining the party was his only chance at getting anything like a [[{{Irony}} decent]] job.

to:

** According to TheOtherWiki, Wiki/{{Wikipedia}}, it had always been Gerstein's intention to sabotage the Nazi regime from within and expose everything he found; only what he found was ''way'' beyond his darkest expectations. Also, anyone expelled from the NSDAP was automatically blacklisted in Germany: re-joining the party was his only chance at getting anything like a [[{{Irony}} decent]] job.



* [[ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight Screw The Rules, He's Doing What's Right]]: When one of the cardinals expresses outrage that Riccardo has requested a papal audience for a man who is not only an [=SS=] officer, but a traitor to his country, Riccardo replies;

to:

* [[ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight Screw The the Rules, He's Doing What's Right]]: Right!]]: When one of the cardinals expresses outrage that Riccardo has requested a papal audience for a man who is not only an [=SS=] officer, but a traitor to his country, Riccardo replies;



* TitleDrop: The Doctor gives Riccardo a BreakingSpeech, claiming that the Nazis are the new "chosen people", to which the priest responds with a bitterly ironic "Amen!"

to:

* TitleDrop: The Doctor gives [[BreakThemByTalking breaks Riccardo a BreakingSpeech, by talking]], claiming that the Nazis are the new "chosen people", to which the priest responds with a bitterly ironic "Amen!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FauxAffablyEvil: The Doctor is quite handy with a [[SlasherSmile deceptively friendly smile]] or [[EvilHasABadSenseOfHumor a bad joke]], which makes his colleagues underestimate how nasty he really is. Heck, his CharacterEstablishingMoment has him smiling at a group of mentally handicapped children being led to their deaths.

to:

* FauxAffablyEvil: The Doctor is quite handy with a [[SlasherSmile deceptively friendly smile]] or [[EvilHasABadSenseOfHumor a bad joke]], which makes his colleagues underestimate how nasty he really is. Heck, his CharacterEstablishingMoment EstablishingCharacterMoment has him smiling at a group of mentally handicapped children being led to their deaths.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FauxAffablyEvil: The Doctor is quite handy with a [[SlasherSmile deceptively friendly smile]] or [[EvilHasABadSenseOfHumor a bad joke]], which makes his colleagues underestimate how nasty he really is. Heck, his CharacterEstablishingMoment has him smiling at a group of mentally handicapped children being led to their deaths.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


However, when Father Fontana hears Gerstein's story, he vows to alert [[UsefulNotes/ThePope Pope Pius XII]] in person, as the two men are certain that a clear condemnation from the Holy Father will rouse German Catholics into action once again. Meanwhile, Gerstein returns to Poland to observe the mass murder and provide further testimony. He tells Father Fontana, "I will be the eyes of God in that hell." But he quickly finds himself unable to passively watch, and begins risking his life to sabotage and slow down the killing in any way he can.

to:

However, when Father Fontana hears Gerstein's story, he vows to alert [[UsefulNotes/ThePope Pope Pope]] [[UsefulNotes/PopePiusXII Pius XII]] in person, as the two men are certain that a clear condemnation from the Holy Father will rouse German Catholics into action once again. Meanwhile, Gerstein returns to Poland to observe the mass murder and provide further testimony. He tells Father Fontana, "I will be the eyes of God in that hell." But he quickly finds himself unable to passively watch, and begins risking his life to sabotage and slow down the killing in any way he can.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


However, when Father Fontana hears Gerstein's story, he vows to alert [[ThePope Pope Pius XII]] in person, as the two men are certain that a clear condemnation from the Holy Father will rouse German Catholics into action once again. Meanwhile, Gerstein returns to Poland to observe the mass murder and provide further testimony. He tells Father Fontana, "I will be the eyes of God in that hell." But he quickly finds himself unable to passively watch, and begins risking his life to sabotage and slow down the killing in any way he can.

to:

However, when Father Fontana hears Gerstein's story, he vows to alert [[ThePope [[UsefulNotes/ThePope Pope Pius XII]] in person, as the two men are certain that a clear condemnation from the Holy Father will rouse German Catholics into action once again. Meanwhile, Gerstein returns to Poland to observe the mass murder and provide further testimony. He tells Father Fontana, "I will be the eyes of God in that hell." But he quickly finds himself unable to passively watch, and begins risking his life to sabotage and slow down the killing in any way he can.



* ThePope: Specifically, Pope Pius [=XII=].

to:

* ThePope: UsefulNotes/ThePope: Specifically, Pope Pius [=XII=].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** According to TheOtherWiki, he joined the SS with the intention of exposing everything he found; only what he did find was way beyond his expectations. Also, anyone expelled from the Nazi party was automatically blacklisted in Germany: re-joining the party was his only chance at getting anything like a decent job.

to:

** According to TheOtherWiki, he joined the SS with the it had always been Gerstein's intention of exposing to sabotage the Nazi regime from within and expose everything he found; only what he did find found was way ''way'' beyond his darkest expectations. Also, anyone expelled from the Nazi party NSDAP was automatically blacklisted in Germany: re-joining the party was his only chance at getting anything like a decent [[{{Irony}} decent]] job.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** According to TheOtherWiki, he joined the SS with the intention of exposing everything he found; only what he did find was way beyond his expectations. Also, anyone expelled from the Nazi party was automatically blacklisted in Germany: re-joining the party was his only chance at getting anything like a decent job.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


2002 German/French/Romanian film directed by Costa-Gavras which explores the links between UsefulNotes/NaziGermany and the {{Vatican}} through the eyes of two characters - the RealLife [[ThoseWackyNazis Waffen-SS]] Officer Kurt Gerstein, and a fictional young Jesuit priest named Riccardo Fontana.

to:

2002 German/French/Romanian film directed by Costa-Gavras which explores the links between UsefulNotes/NaziGermany and [[UsefulNotes/VaticanCity the {{Vatican}} Vatican]] through the eyes of two characters - the RealLife [[ThoseWackyNazis Waffen-SS]] Officer Kurt Gerstein, and a fictional young Jesuit priest named Riccardo Fontana.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In 1942, Kurt Gerstein of the [=SS=] Hygiene Institute travels to Poland to instruct the troops in the safe storage and purification of water, and to observe the use of the new form of the chemical Zyklon B he has helped develop to eradicate typhus. However, accompanied by a sinister [=SS=] Doctor, he is taken to the newly established Belzec extermination camp to witness his creation being put to its true, grisly use. A [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone horrified]] Gerstein returns to Germany and, despite having been sworn to secrecy, he begins desperately attempting to inform the international community of the massacres. Mindful of the successful campaign against the Aktion [=T4=] programme spearheaded by the Catholic Church, he tries to convey the message to the Vatican, but finds his local bishops unmoved.

to:

In 1942, Kurt Gerstein of the [=SS=] Hygiene Institute travels to Poland to instruct the troops in the safe storage and purification of water, and to observe the use of the new form of the chemical Zyklon B he has helped develop developed to eradicate typhus. However, accompanied by a sinister [=SS=] Doctor, he is taken to the newly established Belzec extermination camp to witness his creation being put to its true, grisly use. A [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone horrified]] Gerstein returns to Germany and, despite having been sworn to secrecy, he begins desperately attempting to inform the international community of the massacres. Mindful of the successful campaign against the Aktion [=T4=] programme spearheaded by the Catholic Church, he tries to convey the message to the Vatican, but finds his local bishops unmoved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In 1942, Kurt Gerstein of the [=SS=] Hygiene Institute travels to Poland to instruct the troops in the safe storage and purification of water, and to observe the use of the chemical Zyklon B to eradicate typhus. However, accompanied by a sinister [=SS=] Doctor, he is taken to the newly established Belzec extermination camp to witness his creation being put to its true, grisly use. A [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone horrified]] Gerstein returns to Germany and, despite having been sworn to secrecy, he begins desperately attempting to inform the international community of the massacres. Mindful of the successful campaign against the Aktion [=T4=] programme spearheaded by the Catholic Church, he tries to convey the message to the Vatican, but finds his local bishops unmoved.

to:

In 1942, Kurt Gerstein of the [=SS=] Hygiene Institute travels to Poland to instruct the troops in the safe storage and purification of water, and to observe the use of the new form of the chemical Zyklon B he has helped develop to eradicate typhus. However, accompanied by a sinister [=SS=] Doctor, he is taken to the newly established Belzec extermination camp to witness his creation being put to its true, grisly use. A [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone horrified]] Gerstein returns to Germany and, despite having been sworn to secrecy, he begins desperately attempting to inform the international community of the massacres. Mindful of the successful campaign against the Aktion [=T4=] programme spearheaded by the Catholic Church, he tries to convey the message to the Vatican, but finds his local bishops unmoved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In 1942, Kurt Gerstein of the [=SS=] Hygiene Institute travels to Poland to instruct the troops in the safe storage and purification of water, and to observe the use of the chemical he has developed, Zyklon B, to eradicate typhus. However, accompanied by a sinister [=SS=] Doctor, he is taken to the newly established Belzec extermination camp to witness his creation being put to its true, grisly use. A [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone horrified]] Gerstein returns to Germany and, despite having been sworn to secrecy, he begins desperately attempting to inform the international community of the massacres. Mindful of the successful campaign against the Aktion [=T4=] programme spearheaded by the Catholic Church, he tries to convey the message to the Vatican, but finds his local bishops unmoved.

to:

In 1942, Kurt Gerstein of the [=SS=] Hygiene Institute travels to Poland to instruct the troops in the safe storage and purification of water, and to observe the use of the chemical he has developed, Zyklon B, B to eradicate typhus. However, accompanied by a sinister [=SS=] Doctor, he is taken to the newly established Belzec extermination camp to witness his creation being put to its true, grisly use. A [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone horrified]] Gerstein returns to Germany and, despite having been sworn to secrecy, he begins desperately attempting to inform the international community of the massacres. Mindful of the successful campaign against the Aktion [=T4=] programme spearheaded by the Catholic Church, he tries to convey the message to the Vatican, but finds his local bishops unmoved.

Top