Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanon / LiveActionTV

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Kaoru is somehow related to Shun from ''DenjiSentaiMegaranger''. Both he and Kaoru's father are played by Masaya Matsukaze.



* BlakesSeven: Vila is not dead. He fell backwards, therefore he is still alive.

to:

* BlakesSeven: Vila is not dead. He fell backwards, therefore he is still alive.alive.
* ''KamenRider'':
** ''KamenRiderDouble'': Shotaro was a petty criminal in the past. This is based on a flashback in one of the Jewel Dopant episodes to him running from Jinno when Jinno was a beat cop.
*** [[KamenRiderRyuki Ren Akiyama]] is the father of the little girl featured in episodes 5-6, because the doll her father gave her resembles Kamen Rider Knight.
** ''KamenRiderKuuga'': Yuusuke Godai is dead. Possibly a theory to explain his absence from ''KamenRiderDecade'', where the Riders who appeared in the movies were all implied to be the originals, except for Kuuga, replaced by his AU counterpart Yuusuke Onodera. This is because Godai's actor now considers Kamen Rider an OldShame and does not want to be associated with the franchise.
** ''KamenRiderOOO'': Chiyoko Shiraishi is related to Mako Shiraishi from ''SamuraiSentaiShinkenger'', or (since ''Decade'' states that the Shinkengers' world has never had a Kamen Rider) is some kind of AU counterpart to Mako or her family. Both OOO and Shinkenger were written by Yasuko Kobayashi.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Billy Idol copying his look from Spike is actual canon.


* ''{{Buffy}}'' fandom reacted badly to Andrew being seen heading off for a night on the town with two attractive women, since he's "obviously" gay. (It's actually [[AmbiguouslyGay more ambiguous]] with hints of [[BiTheWay possibly bisexuality]].) Joss Whedon has since stated that [[http://whedonesque.com/comments/15286#207889 Andrew was supposed to be headed off for a night on the town with a mixed-sex group]]. Remember, it's Italy.
** Of course, there's the fanon that Billy Idol got the hair style from Spike.
*** There's also the fanon that Spike absolutely hates his last name, Pratt. Admittedly, since he never mentions it and goes by William The Bloody, which was actually an insult, before going by Spike, it's logical.

to:

* ''{{Buffy}}'' fandom ''{{Buffy}}:''
** Fandom
reacted badly to Andrew being seen heading off for a night on the town with two attractive women, since he's "obviously" gay. (It's actually [[AmbiguouslyGay more ambiguous]] with hints of [[BiTheWay possibly bisexuality]].) Joss Whedon has since stated that [[http://whedonesque.com/comments/15286#207889 Andrew was supposed to be headed off for a night on the town with a mixed-sex group]]. Remember, it's Italy.
** Of course, there's the fanon that Billy Idol got the hair style from Spike.
***
There's also the fanon that Spike absolutely hates his last name, Pratt. Admittedly, since he never mentions it and goes by William The Bloody, which was actually an insult, before going by Spike, it's logical.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Confirmed in a deleted scene from the first season; it may or may not still be canon. There is mention in the online comics that HRG and Sandra could not conceive a child.

to:

*** Confirmed in a deleted scene from the first season; it may or may not still be canon. There is mention in the The online comics also mention that HRG and Sandra could not conceive a child.



** Mohinder went to boarding school in England, hence the accent. Or to university. It's also common fanon that his native language is Tamil (which makes sense, since this is the primary language spoken in Chennai, where he grew up) and that he is an atheist (arguably implied in the comic "Monsters") and a vegetarian.

to:

** Mohinder went to boarding school or to university in England, hence the accent. Or to university.accent. It's also common fanon that his native language is Tamil (which makes sense, since this is the primary language spoken in Chennai, where he grew up) and that he is an atheist (arguably implied in the comic "Monsters") and a vegetarian.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Confirmed in a deleted scene from the first season; it may or may not still be canon.

to:

*** Confirmed in a deleted scene from the first season; it may or may not still be canon. There is mention in the online comics that HRG and Sandra could not conceive a child.



** Mohinder went to boarding school in England, hence the accent. Or to university. It's also common fanon that his native language is Tamil.

to:

** Mohinder went to boarding school in England, hence the accent. Or to university. It's also common fanon that his native language is Tamil.Tamil (which makes sense, since this is the primary language spoken in Chennai, where he grew up) and that he is an atheist (arguably implied in the comic "Monsters") and a vegetarian.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** T'Pol being in Stafleet before Spock could be integrated into the Spock was first fanon if instead of first Vulcan in Starfleet, he was the first Vulcan to enter Starfleet Academy

to:

** T'Pol being in Stafleet Starfleet before Spock could be integrated into the Spock was first fanon if instead of first Vulcan in Starfleet, he was the first Vulcan to enter Starfleet Academy
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mohinder went to boarding school in England, hence the accent.
** Nathan is eleven years older than Peter (his exact age is unknown).

to:

** Mohinder went to boarding school in England, hence the accent.
accent. Or to university. It's also common fanon that his native language is Tamil.
** Nathan is eleven years older than Peter (his exact age is unknown).unknown, but presumably he's at least 35 in the "Five Years Gone" alternate future to make him legally eligible for the U.S. Presidency; Peter is stated to be 26 as of Volume 1).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There's a widely accepted explanation for why the presidential election years in TWW are two years off from when they are in real life: that in the show's universe, when Nixon resigned, instead of Ford succeeding him, there was a special election, the winner served a full four-year term, and things carried on as normal from there. This fits in neatly since no nonfictional presidents more recent than Nixon are mentioned on the show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Kurt's middle name has never been mentioned onscreen - but you wouldn't know it from reading fanfic, where ''every single fic'' seems to give it as "Elizabeth."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** IDW's The Forgotten comic (Issue 5, for the pedantic) gives us this lovely line: "I once convinced my most-hated enemy that I was half-human with nothing more than a wide-eyed expression, a few words and a half-broken Chameleon Arch."

to:

**** IDW's The Forgotten comic (Issue 5, for the pedantic) gives us this lovely line: "I once convinced my most-hated enemy that I was half-human with nothing more than a wide-eyed expression, a few words and a half-broken Chameleon Arch."" (Writer Tony Lee, a PromotedFanboy, is very definitely OneOfUs.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Some of the more popular bits of fanon are:
*** Billy's last name (he was never given one in-show, but the fans made it up, and when the official website was put together, they just [[ThrowItIn threw it in.]])
*** After the death of actress Thuy Trang in 2001, the fandom has generally agreed that her character Trini Kwan passed away as well.
*** Z Delgado of SPD is the daughter of Danny Delgado of Wild Force.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Spock himself was capable of pulling some fast ones back then, too. The plots of ''The Menagerie'' and ''The Enterprise Incident'' depend entirely upon Spock's ability to lie directly to his friends and comrades and violate multiple regulations in the process. His actions in both episodes at minimum risked the loss of the Enterprise and at worst full-scale war. Spock's character is redeemed in the first instance by a desire to help the permanently-crippled Captain Pike and in the second instance by acting upon higher orders ([[GreyAndGreyMorality although those orders were themselves questionable]]...[[FridgeLogic and why not at least brief the entire senior staff?]] If both Kirk and Spock are both caught and killed by the Romulans, Scotty is left with no contingency plan to get the ship and the crew out of there!)

to:

*** Spock himself was capable of pulling some fast ones back then, too. The plots of ''The Menagerie'' and ''The Enterprise Incident'' depend entirely upon Spock's ability to lie directly to his friends and comrades and violate multiple regulations in the process. His actions in both episodes at minimum risked the loss of the Enterprise and at worst full-scale war. Spock's character is redeemed in the first instance by a desire to help the permanently-crippled Captain Pike and in the second instance by acting upon higher orders ([[GreyAndGreyMorality although those orders were themselves questionable]]...[[FridgeLogic and why not at least brief the entire senior staff?]] If both Kirk and Spock are both caught and killed by the Romulans, Scotty is left with Scotty--just as out of the loop as McCoy was and now in command--has no contingency plan to get the ship and the crew out of there!)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** And then there's T'Pring...evidence ''within TOS'' that Vulcans could use their logic to be cunning backstabbers. Spock himself was capable of pulling some fast ones back then, too (the plots of ''The Menagerie'' and ''The Enterprise Incident'' depend entirely upon Spock's ability to lie to his friends and comrades, to their faces).

to:

*** And then there's T'Pring...evidence ''within TOS'' that Vulcans could use their logic to be cunning backstabbers. Spock ***Spock himself was capable of pulling some fast ones back then, too (the too. The plots of ''The Menagerie'' and ''The Enterprise Incident'' depend entirely upon Spock's ability to lie directly to his friends and comrades, comrades and violate multiple regulations in the process. His actions in both episodes at minimum risked the loss of the Enterprise and at worst full-scale war. Spock's character is redeemed in the first instance by a desire to their faces).help the permanently-crippled Captain Pike and in the second instance by acting upon higher orders ([[GreyAndGreyMorality although those orders were themselves questionable]]...[[FridgeLogic and why not at least brief the entire senior staff?]] If both Kirk and Spock are both caught and killed by the Romulans, Scotty is left with no contingency plan to get the ship and the crew out of there!)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Up until Kurt [[{{Jossed}} mentioned]] in ''The Sue Sylvester Bowl Shuffle'' that he still lived at home, it was generally accepted across the fandom that Dalton Academy was a boarding school.

to:

** Up until Kurt [[{{Jossed}} mentioned]] in ''The Sue Sylvester Bowl Shuffle'' that he still lived at home, it was generally accepted across the fandom generally assumed that Dalton Academy was a boarding school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Up until Kurt [[{{Jossed}} mentioned]] in ''The Sue Sylvester Bowl Shuffle'' that he still lived at home, it was generally accepted across the fandom that Dalton Academy was a boarding school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** From the perspective of Vulcans, who are canonically described as having much longer lifespans than humans (Spock's father lives until the middle of TNG, and Spock himself much longer than that) 200 years isn't all that long. And given the corruption of Surak's teachings described in ''Enterprise'' it's plausible that a generation or two was needed to overcome bigotry to the point that Vulcans felt comfortable in Starfleet in large numbers, with Spock leading the way. Even he had to overcome the generation gap between himself and his father (who was progressive enough among Vulcans to take a human wife). Also, Starfleet as a ''fully-integrated'' entity may be a relatively new thing during TOS--prior to that, the humans, Vulcans, Andorians, etc. maintained separate space fleets (Kirk refers to 'UESPA'--United Earth Space Probe Agency--in an early episode; he may have been a holdover from the Earth contingent incorporated into the Federation's Starfleet). There are any number of ways, alone or in combination, that canon and fanon can be reconciled believeably on this point.

to:

*** From the perspective of Vulcans, who are canonically described as having much longer lifespans than humans (Spock's father lives until the middle of TNG, and Spock himself much longer than that) 200 years isn't all that long. And given the corruption of Surak's teachings described in ''Enterprise'' it's plausible that a generation or two was needed to overcome bigotry to the point that Vulcans felt comfortable in Starfleet in large numbers, with Spock leading the way. Even he had to overcome the generation gap between himself and his father (who was progressive enough among Vulcans to take a human wife). Also, Starfleet as a ''fully-integrated'' entity may be a relatively new thing during TOS--prior to that, the humans, Vulcans, Andorians, etc. maintained separate space fleets (Kirk refers to 'UESPA'--United Earth Space Probe Agency--in an early episode; he may have been a holdover from the Earth contingent incorporated into the Federation's Starfleet).Starfleet. And we know from ''Enterprise'' that the Vulcans and Andorians--at the time bitter enemies--had separate space fleets). There are any number of ways, alone or in combination, that canon and fanon can be reconciled believeably on this point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** From the perspective of Vulcans, who are canonically described as having much longer lifespans than humans (Spock's father lives until the middle of TNG, and Spock himself much longer than that) 200 years isn't all that long. And given the corruption of Surak's teachings described in ''Enterprise'' it's plausible that a generation or two was needed to overcome bigotry to the point that Vulcans felt comfortable in Starfleet in large numbers, with Spock leading the way. Even he had to overcome the generation gap between himself and his father (who was progressive enough among Vulcans to take a human wife). Also, Starfleet as a ''fully-integrated'' entity may be a relatively new thing during TOS--prior to that, the humans, Vulcans, Andorians, etc. maintained separate space fleets. There are any number of ways, alone or in combination, that canon and fanon can be reconciled believeably on this point.

to:

*** From the perspective of Vulcans, who are canonically described as having much longer lifespans than humans (Spock's father lives until the middle of TNG, and Spock himself much longer than that) 200 years isn't all that long. And given the corruption of Surak's teachings described in ''Enterprise'' it's plausible that a generation or two was needed to overcome bigotry to the point that Vulcans felt comfortable in Starfleet in large numbers, with Spock leading the way. Even he had to overcome the generation gap between himself and his father (who was progressive enough among Vulcans to take a human wife). Also, Starfleet as a ''fully-integrated'' entity may be a relatively new thing during TOS--prior to that, the humans, Vulcans, Andorians, etc. maintained separate space fleets.fleets (Kirk refers to 'UESPA'--United Earth Space Probe Agency--in an early episode; he may have been a holdover from the Earth contingent incorporated into the Federation's Starfleet). There are any number of ways, alone or in combination, that canon and fanon can be reconciled believeably on this point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** And then there's T'Pring...evidence ''within TOS'' that Vulcans could use their logic to be cunning backstabbers. Spock himself was capable of pulling some fast ones back then, too (the plots of ''The Menagerie'' and ''The Romulan Incident'' depend entirely upon Spock's ability to lie to his friends and comrades, to their faces).

to:

*** And then there's T'Pring...evidence ''within TOS'' that Vulcans could use their logic to be cunning backstabbers. Spock himself was capable of pulling some fast ones back then, too (the plots of ''The Menagerie'' and ''The Romulan Enterprise Incident'' depend entirely upon Spock's ability to lie to his friends and comrades, to their faces).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** And then there's T'Pring...evidence ''within TOS'' that Vulcans could use their logic to be cunning backstabbers. Spock himself was capable of pulling some fast ones back then, too (the plots of ''The Menagerie'' and ''The Romulan Incident'' depend entirely upon Spock's ability to lie to his friends and comrades, to their faces).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** From the perspective of Vulcans, who are canonically described as having much longer lifespans than humans (Spock's father lives until the middle of TNG, and Spock himself much longer than that) 200 years isn't all that long. And given the corruption of Surak's teachings described in ''Enterprise'' it's plausible that a generation or two was needed to overcome bigotry to the point that Vulcans felt comfortable in Starfleet in large numbers, with Spock leading the way. Even he had to overcome the generation gap between himself and his father (who was progressive enough among Vulcans to take a human wife). Also, Starfleet as a ''fully-integrated'' entity may be a relatively new thing during TOS--prior to that, the humans, Vulcans, Andorians, etc. maintained separate space fleets. There are any number of ways, alone or in combination, that canon and fanon can be reconciled believeably on this point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlakesSeven: Vila is not dead. He fell backwards, therefore he is still alive.(?)

to:

* BlakesSeven: Vila is not dead. He fell backwards, therefore he is still alive.(?)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''TensouSentaiGoseiger'': The Goseigers are ReallySevenHundredYearsOld. WordOfGod gives them ages between 17 (Moune) and 24 (Hyde.)

to:

** ''TensouSentaiGoseiger'': The Goseigers are ReallySevenHundredYearsOld. WordOfGod gives them ages between 17 (Moune) and 24 (Hyde.))
* BlakesSeven: Vila is not dead. He fell backwards, therefore he is still alive.(?)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** She was an attractive woman, tied up in an all-male camp of violent terrorists who enjoyed hurting and torturing her, and saw her as less than human. It's not exactly jumping far to get to that conclusion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Blaine, as well.
** Warblers Wes and David are more or less crazy. Sometimes, they are also utter failures when it comes to matchmaking.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Buffy}}'' fandom reacted badly to Andrew being seen heading off for a night on the town with two attractive women, since he's "obviously" gay. Joss Whedon has since stated that [[http://whedonesque.com/comments/15286#207889 Andrew was supposed to be headed off for a night on the town with a mixed-sex group.]] Remember, it's Italy.

to:

* ''{{Buffy}}'' fandom reacted badly to Andrew being seen heading off for a night on the town with two attractive women, since he's "obviously" gay. (It's actually [[AmbiguouslyGay more ambiguous]] with hints of [[BiTheWay possibly bisexuality]].) Joss Whedon has since stated that [[http://whedonesque.com/comments/15286#207889 Andrew was supposed to be headed off for a night on the town with a mixed-sex group.]] group]]. Remember, it's Italy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Sheldon of the ''{{BigBangTheory}}'' displays classic signs of Asperger's Syndrome, but the creators have shot down that idea. It doesn't stop the fans from making this guess though.

to:

* Sheldon of the ''{{BigBangTheory}}'' ''BigBangTheory'' displays classic signs of Asperger's Syndrome, but the creators have shot down that idea. It doesn't stop the fans from making this guess though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** So basically you're saying that for almost 200 hundred years, (from the time of the twenty first century scenes in the motion picture First Contact to the time of The Original Series), no Vulcan served in Starfleet despite the fact that Earth and Vulcan were allies for such a long period of time. [[FridgeLogic Think.About.That]]

to:

*** So basically you're saying that for almost 200 hundred years, (from the time of the twenty first century scenes in the motion picture First Contact to the time of The Original Series), no Vulcan served in Starfleet despite the fact that Earth and Vulcan were allies for such a long period of time. [[FridgeLogic Think.About.That]] About. That.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** The TVM was supposed to have a line revealing they were brothers, but thankfully this was cut. Interestingly enough, another fan pet theory (one going way back to the Seventies) insists the Doctor and the Master are exes (or that the Master at the very least has an [[FoeYay unrequited, bitter crush on the Doctor]]) has been hinted at in the new series. David McIntee and Paul Cornell have both speculated on this possibility.

to:

**** The TVM was supposed to have a line revealing they were brothers, but thankfully this was cut. Interestingly enough, another fan pet theory (one going way back to the Seventies) insists the Doctor and the Master are exes (or that the Master at the very least has an [[FoeYay unrequited, bitter crush on the Doctor]]) has been hinted at in the new series. David McIntee [=McIntee=] and Paul Cornell have both speculated on this possibility.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's commonly suggested (often taken as fact) that {{Voyager}}'s bio-neural gel packs, which arrange information in a similar manner to the human brain, are the reason Voyager's holograms had a tendency to become sentient (while those on the Enterprise-D did not). However, it was never stated on the show.
*** It's easy to see why people believe this. The gel packs were described in the pilot episode, so the [[LawOfConservationOfDetail Law of Conservation of Detail]] suggests they should become important later on (though, canonically, [[WhatHappenedToTheMouse they did not]]). And this theory plausibly explains something that was otherwise quite implausible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Of course, there's the fanon that Billy Idol got the hair style from Spike.
*** There's also the fanon that Spike absolutely hates his last name, Pratt. Admittedly, since he never mentions it and goes by William The Bloody, which was actually an insult, before going by Spike, it's logical.


Added DiffLines:

*** S8 makes it a little less debatable since Willow grills Satsu on what Buffy's like in bed (including how she sounds when she orgasms). [[BlatantLies Then denies ever having a crush on Buffy]] to Buffy. Likewise, Buffy denies having one on her, acting identical to Willow, who we know is lying, is acting. Hmmmm......

Top