Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / TheChangelingOfTheGuard

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


As of September 2015, ''The Changeling of the Guard'' is #1 on Website/FimfictionDotNet!

to:

As of September 2015, ''The Changeling of the Guard'' is #1 on Website/FimfictionDotNet!
Platform/FimfictionDotNet!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just For Pun has been disambiguated.


Idol and Topaz have a CharacterBlog, [[JustForPun "Out of Idol Curiosity"]], which can be found [[http://out-of-idol-curiosity.tumblr.com/ here]].

to:

Idol and Topaz have a CharacterBlog, [[JustForPun [[{{Pun}} "Out of Idol Curiosity"]], which can be found [[http://out-of-idol-curiosity.tumblr.com/ here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope has been merged with Played For Laughs.


* ExtremeOmnivore: Idol Hooves naturally. Besides the fact that he [[EmotionEater feeds on emotions]] he has no problem eating meat as well as vegetation and he's not picky about the meat either, whether it be snakes, scorpions or insects. During his guard training he eats six [[MasochistsMeal MREs]] and asked for more, to the sheer disbelief of his commanding officers and fellow trainees. Later still he eats a stew that Topaz made for him that had crushed egg shells in it by mistake without seeing any problems with it and in the morning is shown to have no problem drinking said stew while it was boiling hot ([[HilarityEnsues Topaz, on the other hoof...]]). [[spoiler: Then of course there's him suggesting that he and Shining Armor ''eat'' a timber woof's "heart" to keep it from regenerating (noted to taste almost like meat with the texture of wood)]]. When he's questioned on the subject by Topaz he admits that his only standard for food is that it's edible and doesn't make him ill.

to:

* ExtremeOmnivore: Idol Hooves naturally. Besides the fact that he [[EmotionEater feeds on emotions]] he has no problem eating meat as well as vegetation and he's not picky about the meat either, whether it be snakes, scorpions or insects. During his guard training he eats six [[MasochistsMeal MREs]] and asked for more, to the sheer disbelief of his commanding officers and fellow trainees. Later still he eats a stew that Topaz made for him that had crushed egg shells in it by mistake without seeing any problems with it and in the morning is shown to have no problem drinking said stew while it was boiling hot ([[HilarityEnsues Topaz, on the other hoof...]]).hot. [[spoiler: Then of course there's him suggesting that he and Shining Armor ''eat'' a timber woof's "heart" to keep it from regenerating (noted to taste almost like meat with the texture of wood)]]. When he's questioned on the subject by Topaz he admits that his only standard for food is that it's edible and doesn't make him ill.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentalHarem: Through sheer cluelessness, Idol Hooves unwittingly manages to attract the romantic attentions of Mothchaser (a thestral in the Night Guard), and even ''Maud Pie''. At the least, Pinkie Pie believes Maud's interest in Idol goes beyond "pen pals", and she ''did'' apply pumice perfume to her latest letter to him...

to:

* AccidentalHarem: Through sheer cluelessness, Idol Hooves unwittingly manages to attract the romantic attentions of his pegasus landlady Topaz Showers, Mothchaser (a thestral in the Night Guard), and even ''Maud Pie''. At the least, Pinkie Pie believes Maud's interest in Idol goes beyond "pen pals", and she ''did'' apply pumice perfume to her latest letter to him...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Idol straight up tells [[spoiler: [[MadGod Discord]], upon him being freed ]]to behave himself, and unintentionally applies ReversePsychology to get him to agree.

to:

** Idol straight up tells [[spoiler: [[MadGod Discord]], upon him being freed ]]to freed]] to behave himself, and unintentionally applies ReversePsychology to get him to agree.



* LiteralMinded: Sort of like a Changeling version of [[Film/GuardiansOfTheGalaxy Drax]], Idol tends to have trouble understanding metaphors and figures of speech. There are quite a few [[ExpospeakGag Expospeak Gags]] relating to phrases he finds confusing, some of which are very subtle. There are hints that, even by changeling standards, he's pretty literal-minded.

to:

* LiteralMinded: Sort of like a Changeling version of [[Film/GuardiansOfTheGalaxy [[Film/GuardiansOfTheGalaxy2014 Drax]], Idol tends to have trouble understanding metaphors and figures of speech. There are quite a few [[ExpospeakGag Expospeak Gags]] {{Expospeak Gag}}s relating to phrases he finds confusing, some of which are very subtle. There are hints that, even by changeling standards, he's pretty literal-minded.



* PaperThinDisguise: Chapter 1 of "Changeling Perspectives", "The Nurse", reveals that Idol Hooves' personalized pony form maintains the ''exact same color scheme'' as his normal changeling form. The only differences are, of course, the physical traits - presence or absence of holes, horn shape, wings and so forth. [[JustifiedTrope Its justified]] in that most ponies believe Changelings are a myth and wouldn't spot the comparison, and it means that a quick glance at Idol undisguised can be excused as their eyes playing tricks on them

to:

* PaperThinDisguise: Chapter 1 of "Changeling Perspectives", "The Nurse", reveals that Idol Hooves' personalized pony form maintains the ''exact same color scheme'' as his normal changeling form. The only differences are, of course, the physical traits - presence or absence of holes, horn shape, wings and so forth. [[JustifiedTrope Its It's justified]] in that most ponies believe Changelings are a myth and wouldn't spot the comparison, and it means that a quick glance at Idol undisguised can be excused as their eyes playing tricks on themthem.

Changed: 15

Removed: 115

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS disambig


** Upon a visit to Manehatten, he fails to realize that the apple souvenirs are actually made of wood and not supposed to be eaten... even ''after'' taking bite out of one and finding it thoroughly inedible. [[spoiler:Then again, it is [[CallBack not the first time]] he [[AlienLunch ate something wooden]].]]

to:

** Upon a visit to Manehatten, he fails to realize that the apple souvenirs are actually made of wood and not supposed to be eaten... even ''after'' taking bite out of one and finding it thoroughly inedible. [[spoiler:Then again, it is [[CallBack not the first time]] he [[AlienLunch ate something wooden]].wooden.]]



* AlienLunch: The [[spoiler:giant timberwolf heart]], of which Shining reluctantly admits he kind of wants seconds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* IsThatWhatTheyreCallingItNow: "Manticore attack".

Added: 404

Removed: 496

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Now a disambiguation.


* CriticalResearchFailure: An in-universe version of this explains why Chrysalis did such a ''bad'' job of impersonating Cadence during the invasion of Canterlot -- she essentially knew absolutely ''nothing'' about Cadence and was doing her best to wing it until she could just overrun Canterlot with her drones, as the entire invasion was mostly an act of impulse. She didn't even know Cadence was the ''bride'' at first; she originally believed Cadence was just going to officiate at a wedding!


Added DiffLines:

* InUniverseFactoidFailure: Why Chrysalis did such a ''bad'' job of impersonating Cadence during the invasion of Canterlot -- she essentially knew absolutely ''nothing'' about Cadence and was doing her best to wing it until she could just overrun Canterlot with her drones. She didn't even know Cadence was the ''bride'' at first; she originally believed Cadence was just going to officiate at a wedding!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EmptyShell: What happens when a Changeling feeds on somepony's emotions too much. [[spoiler:Idol does this to poor Topaz by ''accident'', just by feeding on her interest. She can barely walk, speak, or eat until he manages to snap her out of it. He also mentions that this has happened on occasion to the parents of hatchlings in TheHive... [[AdultFear their own children can consume them if they feed them too much love]].]]

to:

* EmptyShell: What happens when a Changeling feeds on somepony's emotions too much. [[spoiler:Idol does this to poor Topaz by ''accident'', just by feeding on her interest. She can barely walk, speak, or eat until he manages to snap her out of it. He also mentions that this has happened on occasion to the parents of hatchlings in TheHive... [[AdultFear their own children can consume them if they feed them too much love]].love.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


[[caption-width-right:350:Not your ordinary [[VoluntaryShapeshifting Change]][[BeePeople ling]].]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:Not your ordinary [[VoluntaryShapeshifting Change]][[BeePeople ling]].Changeling.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OhMyGods: Idol Hooves has a tendency to invoke Order as a higher-power when making oaths or cursing. Shining Armor lampshades it at one point in chapter 38, and notes that it's quite unusual; ponies swear by Harmony or Celestia ([[ContinuityNod which they have been doing throughout the fic]]), griffons by deity, minotaurs by land, and dragons by the dragonlord. [[spoiler:In chapter 62, one of the minor oddities of Idol's behavior is that he swears by Harmony.]]

to:

* OhMyGods: Idol Hooves has a tendency to invoke Order as a higher-power when making oaths or cursing. Shining Armor lampshades it at one point in chapter 38, and notes that it's quite unusual; ponies swear by Harmony or Celestia ([[ContinuityNod which they have been doing throughout the fic]]), griffons by deity, minotaurs by land, and dragons by the dragonlord. [[spoiler:In chapter 62, one of the minor oddities of Idol's behavior is that he swears by Harmony.Order.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Idol Hooves:''' You ''broke into the castle?!''

to:

-->'''Idol Hooves:''' *To Cersus* You ''broke into the castle?!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheGuardsMustBeCrazy: In chapter 69, when Cersus tries to break into the castle and impersonate Princess Celestia, despite [[EpicFail clearly not knowing what she looks like]], she meets not nearly enough resistance:
-->'''Princess Celestia:''' Really, now? You can’t explain why one of my guards woke me up in the dead of night to inform me that I had walked in, declared an emergency session, and demanded that Idol Hooves be released to my care?
-->'''Idol Hooves:''' You ''broke into the castle?!''
-->'''Cersus:''' I didn’t break in! They let me in! They even opened the doors for me!
-->'''Idol Hooves:''' *Glares at throne room guards*
-->'''Guard 1:''' It’s late, man, it’s been a whole day, I mean, it looks like Celestia, just… she’s pink, and not huge! I thought for like, half a second, that it was some weird fusion thing of Celestia and Cadance and that was all the longer I needed to open the door! After, yeah, it was ''really'' obvious!
-->'''Guard 2:''' I ''told'' you those neighponese comics were rotting your brain.
-->'''Guard 1:''' You should have stopped me!
-->'''Guard 2:''' Oh sure, ''I’ve'' been trained on what to do if the Princess comes in looking like she got shrunk in the wash with a red sock!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:Not your ordinary [[VoltunaryShapeshifting Change]][[BeePeople ling]].]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:Not your ordinary [[VoltunaryShapeshifting [[VoluntaryShapeshifting Change]][[BeePeople ling]].]]



''[[http://www.fimfiction.net/story/174129/the-changeling-of-the-guard The Changeling of the Guard]]'' is a ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' fanfic by [=VDrake77=]. It is the story of Idol Hooves, a very unusual [[VoltunaryShapeshifting changeling]].

to:

''[[http://www.fimfiction.net/story/174129/the-changeling-of-the-guard The Changeling of the Guard]]'' is a ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' fanfic by [=VDrake77=]. It is the story of Idol Hooves, a very unusual [[VoltunaryShapeshifting [[VoluntaryShapeshifting changeling]].

Added: 288

Changed: 45

Removed: 283

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:350:Not your ordinary [[ShapeShifter Change]][[BeePeople ling]].]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350:Not your ordinary [[ShapeShifter [[VoltunaryShapeshifting Change]][[BeePeople ling]].]]



''[[http://www.fimfiction.net/story/174129/the-changeling-of-the-guard The Changeling of the Guard]]'' is a ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' fanfic by [=VDrake77=]. It is the story of Idol Hooves, a very unusual [[ShapeShifter changeling]].

to:

''[[http://www.fimfiction.net/story/174129/the-changeling-of-the-guard The Changeling of the Guard]]'' is a ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' fanfic by [=VDrake77=]. It is the story of Idol Hooves, a very unusual [[ShapeShifter [[VoltunaryShapeshifting changeling]].



* AlcoholInducedStupidity: During Idol's pub crawl after becoming a full-fledged royal guard, a drunk Idol shows his {{Shapeshifting}} powers in public to the patrons and his fellow guards... who fortunately are all just as drunk as he is.

to:

* AlcoholInducedStupidity: During Idol's pub crawl after becoming a full-fledged royal guard, a drunk Idol shows his {{Shapeshifting}} VoluntaryShapeshifting powers in public to the patrons and his fellow guards... who fortunately are all just as drunk as he is.



* {{Shapeshifter}}s: The changelings, obviously. Idol explains the mechanics and technical aspects of shapeshifting quite thoroughly. [[spoiler:He can even take on the form of an alicorn, though not without rather serious consequences... see WithGreatPowerComesGreatInsanity below.]]


Added DiffLines:

* VoluntaryShapeshifting: The changelings, obviously. Idol explains the mechanics and technical aspects of shapeshifting quite thoroughly. [[spoiler:He can even take on the form of an alicorn, though not without rather serious consequences... see WithGreatPowerComesGreatInsanity below.]]

Added: 525

Changed: 625

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeroOfAnotherStory: If WordOfGod is to be believed, when the story catches up to [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS2E25ACanterlotWeddingPart1 A Canterlot Wedding]], we'll see what happens in that episode from Idol's perspective. He might even visible in the episode as one of the background Royal Guards...

to:

* HeroicRROD: Idol can take on many forms, but there are some forms that are extremely dangerous, [[spoiler: especially his alicorn form.]] The first time he tries, he almost loses his mind. The second time he tries [[spoiler: when attempting to rescue Cadence from Chrysalis, the strain is so great that Idol's body literally melts. Chrysalis has to perform some emergency surgery to stop Idol's body and mind from turning to liquid, including [[AnArmAndALeg grafting new limbs onto Idol's body.]]]]
* HeroOfAnotherStory: If WordOfGod is to be believed, when the story catches up to [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS2E25ACanterlotWeddingPart1 A Canterlot Wedding]], we'll see what happens in that episode from Idol's perspective. He might even visible in the episode as one of the background Royal Guards...


Added DiffLines:

* HumbleGoal: Idol finds satisfaction in keeping order as a Royal Guard. [[spoiler: After the changeling invasion, [[DreamWalker Princess Luna]] finds that most of his dreams are him performing his guard duties.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BreakingTheFellowship: [[spoiler: A few chapters after the WhamEpisode of chapters 62 and 63, Shining is sent to the Crystal Empire and Mothchaser is reassigned to Shady Oaks]].

to:

* BreakingTheFellowship: [[spoiler: A few chapters after the WhamEpisode of chapters 62 and 61 through 63, Shining is sent to the Crystal Empire and Mothchaser is reassigned to Shady Oaks]].

Added: 881

Changed: 303

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrickJoke: During chapter 29 [[spoiler: Shining Armor says that if Idol could find a just cause to jump off a bridge he'd join him. In the next chapter he attempts to go through with his word, when Idol jumps off a bridge to arrest a thief.]]

to:

* BreakingTheFellowship: [[spoiler: A few chapters after the WhamEpisode of chapters 62 and 63, Shining is sent to the Crystal Empire and Mothchaser is reassigned to Shady Oaks]].
* BrickJoke: During chapter 29 29, [[spoiler: Shining Armor says that if Idol could find a just cause to jump off a bridge he'd join him. In the next chapter he attempts to go through with his word, when Idol jumps off a bridge to arrest a thief.]] Further, during chapter 68, [[spoiler: Celestia's mental expert worries about Idol's self-Geas to Celestia's orders, asking what if she ordered him to jump off a cliff; Idol points out that it wouldn't actually kill him.]]


Added DiffLines:

* TheBusCameBack: In chapter 68, Celestia brings in psychiatric help for Idol [[spoiler: after he admits to having been under the effects of Queen Chrysalis's Orders]], and he turns out to be the same expert from chapter 38.


Added DiffLines:

** Chapter 68: [[spoiler: Idol's mind is revealed to have been horrifically damaged by Queen Chrysalis in chapter 61. Also, Idol's clique of guards [[BreakingUpTheFellowship is split up]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Initially set a number of years before [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS1E1MareInTheMoon Luna's redemption]], the author promises that the story will eventually catch up to the events of [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS2E25ACanterlotWeddingPart1 A Canterlot Wedding]] and beyond.

to:

Initially set a number of years before [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS1E1MareInTheMoon Luna's redemption]], the author promises that the story will eventually catch caught up to the events of [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS2E25ACanterlotWeddingPart1 A Canterlot Wedding]] and beyond.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CastFromHitPoints: A psychological variant. [[spoiler:Per WordOfGod, Idol's [[DangerousForbiddenTechnique alicorn transformation]] in chapter 61 is fueled by his platonic love for Cadence... as in, he literally ''burns up'' his feelings for her to fuel the transformation. The side effects of this become apparent in chapter 65: Idol still remembers everything he and Cadence have ever experienced together, but all of the emotional background to those memories is ''gone''. He feels '''nothing''' for her that he should -- emotionally, she's a complete stranger to him, and all he finds himself feeling around here is simply hunger and a dash of awe. The disconnect between intellectual and emotional connections doesn't do much for Idol's stability.]]

to:

* CastFromHitPoints: A psychological variant. [[spoiler:Per WordOfGod, Idol's [[DangerousForbiddenTechnique alicorn transformation]] in chapter 61 is fueled by his platonic love for Cadence... as in, he literally ''burns up'' his feelings for her to fuel the transformation. The side effects of this become apparent in chapter 65: Idol still remembers everything he and Cadence have ever experienced together, but all of the emotional background to those memories is ''gone''. He feels '''nothing''' for her that he should -- emotionally, she's a complete stranger to him, and all he finds himself feeling around here her is simply hunger and a dash of awe. The disconnect between intellectual and emotional connections doesn't do much for Idol's stability.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrazyAwesome: In chapter 24, Idol comes up with a suggestion for dealing with a [[{{Planimal}} Timber Wolf]] that falls squarely into this: to stop it constantly [[HealingFactor reassembling itself]], [[spoiler: he and Shining Armor smash it to pieces and ''eat its heart'']]. InUniverse, everyone can't believe Idol actually managed to think up something like this.

to:

* CrazyAwesome: CrazyEnoughToWork: In chapter 24, Idol comes up with a suggestion for dealing with a [[{{Planimal}} Timber Wolf]] that falls squarely into this: to stop it constantly [[HealingFactor reassembling itself]], [[spoiler: he and Shining Armor smash it to pieces and ''eat its heart'']]. InUniverse, everyone can't believe Idol actually managed to think up something like this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FakingAmnesia: Part of Idol's cover story.
**[[spoiler: Played with, as Celestia ''knew'' Idol was faking, but the trope is an accepted part of Pony society, as it gives a chance for individuals to leave a life they are unhappy with and rediscover themselves. This meant that Celestia simply assumed that he was a regular pony running from his past.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Upon a visit to Manehatten, he fails to realize that the apple souvenirs are actually made of wood and not supposed to be eaten... even ''after'' taking bite out of one and finding it thoroughly inedible.

to:

** Upon a visit to Manehatten, he fails to realize that the apple souvenirs are actually made of wood and not supposed to be eaten... even ''after'' taking bite out of one and finding it thoroughly inedible. [[spoiler:Then again, it is [[CallBack not the first time]] he [[AlienLunch ate something wooden]].]]

Top