History FandomRivalry / Music

24th Apr '16 5:43:21 AM aye_amber
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Whilst the bands both have considerable shared fans, there is something of a rivalry between FaithNoMore fans and MrBungle fans. MrBungle fans often say MrBungle's progressive structures and [[NeoclassicalPunkZydecoRockabilly genre mixing]] represents the true genius of Mike Patton, and that FaithNoMore are a dumbed down poppy equivalent. Conversely, there are FaithNoMore fans who say that MrBungle's frequent switching of genres in song is a gimmick that hides the fact they can't write complete songs, and feel that Faith No More's songwriting is catchier and more focused in comparison. Fans of both do tend to like the album "King For A Day, Fool For A Lifetime", since it features MrBungle's Trey Spruance on guitar and features the most varied selection of genres the band produced.
** In the FaithNoMore fanbase there are MikePatton vs Chuck Mosley fans. Most people who like Chuck like Patton too, but a lot of people who like Patton tend to talk about how much Chuck sucks. This is not the only fanbase where something like this is the case though, many IronMaiden fans who like Paul Di'Anno are frustrated by the BruceDickinson fans who post how much better Bruce is on every Youtube video of a Paul era song.

to:

** Whilst the bands both have considerable shared fans, there is something of a rivalry between FaithNoMore Music/FaithNoMore fans and MrBungle Music/MrBungle fans. MrBungle Music/MrBungle fans often say MrBungle's Music/MrBungle's progressive structures and [[NeoclassicalPunkZydecoRockabilly genre mixing]] represents the true genius of Mike Patton, and that FaithNoMore Music/FaithNoMore are a dumbed down poppy equivalent. Conversely, there are FaithNoMore Music/FaithNoMore fans who say that MrBungle's Music/MrBungle's frequent switching of genres in song is a gimmick that hides the fact they can't write complete songs, and feel that Faith No More's songwriting is catchier and more focused in comparison. Fans of both do tend to like the album "King For A Day, Fool For A Lifetime", since it features MrBungle's Music/MrBungle's Trey Spruance on guitar and features the most varied selection of genres the band produced.
** In the FaithNoMore Music/FaithNoMore fanbase there are MikePatton Music/MikePatton vs Chuck Mosley fans. Most people who like Chuck like Patton too, but a lot of people who like Patton tend to talk about how much Chuck sucks. This is not the only fanbase where something like this is the case though, many IronMaiden Music/IronMaiden fans who like Paul Di'Anno are frustrated by the BruceDickinson Music/BruceDickinson fans who post how much better Bruce is on every Youtube video of a Paul era song.
24th Apr '16 5:40:09 AM aye_amber
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* MarilynManson and The Spooky Kids fans vs. Marilyn Manson fans vs. fans of certain eras. And you have the ones that just want Manson to make more albums like ''Music/AntichristSuperstar''. Daisy Berkowitz himself, the epicenter for the Spooky Kids vs. Manson fight, is much more relaxed on the subject, since it's 20 years old now. Manson doesn't talk about it at all. The main fan forum before Provider Module, which was The Heriophant, had to be shut down due to Cease and Decist orders because of the multitude of hate and death threats being posted against Manson for his changing style and look. This was the fan forum. Oddly enough, there's not much fighting between NineInchNails fans and Manson fans, although Trent and Manson still bitch about each other occasionally. [[YokoOhNo Dita Von Teese and Evan Rachel-Wood are hated in part of the fandom due to the ex thing]]. And Motionless in White is the most hated of all by all the fans, as well as by longtime allies, the Rammstein fans.

to:

* MarilynManson Music/MarilynManson and The Spooky Kids fans vs. Marilyn Manson fans vs. fans of certain eras. And you have the ones that just want Manson to make more albums like ''Music/AntichristSuperstar''. Daisy Berkowitz himself, the epicenter for the Spooky Kids vs. Manson fight, is much more relaxed on the subject, since it's 20 years old now. Manson doesn't talk about it at all. The main fan forum before Provider Module, which was The Heriophant, had to be shut down due to Cease and Decist orders because of the multitude of hate and death threats being posted against Manson for his changing style and look. This was the fan forum. Oddly enough, there's not much fighting between NineInchNails fans and Manson fans, although Trent and Manson still bitch about each other occasionally. [[YokoOhNo Dita Von Teese and Evan Rachel-Wood are hated in part of the fandom due to the ex thing]]. And Motionless in White is the most hated of all by all the fans, as well as by longtime allies, the Rammstein fans.
23rd Apr '16 2:50:41 PM Laevatein
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Viga of ''WebVideo/IdolsOfAnime has referred to the 2010s as the "[[IdolSinger Idol]] [[UsefulNotes/SengokuPeriod Sengoku Jidai]]", which encompasses both RL (MorningMusume, {{AKB48}}, MomoiroCloverZ, etc) and anime/game (''Anime/TheIdolmaster'', ''Anime/LoveLive'', ''VideoGame/{{Aikatsu}}'', ''VideoGame/PriPara'') idol groups.

to:

* Viga of ''WebVideo/IdolsOfAnime ''WebVideo/IdolsOfAnime'' has referred to the 2010s as the "[[IdolSinger Idol]] [[UsefulNotes/SengokuPeriod Sengoku Jidai]]", which encompasses both RL (MorningMusume, {{AKB48}}, MomoiroCloverZ, etc) and anime/game (''Anime/TheIdolmaster'', ''Anime/LoveLive'', ''VideoGame/{{Aikatsu}}'', ''VideoGame/PriPara'') idol groups.
23rd Apr '16 2:49:34 PM Laevatein
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Within the trance fandom itself, there's the weird, trippy and often [[DarkerAndEdgier darker-in-tone]] psychedelic trance (Astrix, Infected Mushroom, Liquid Soul) vs. the [[LighterAndSofter angelic and light]] uplifting trance (Armin van Buuren, Music/FerryCorsten, Aly& Fila). In fact, trance's BrokenBase may well make dubstep's broken fandom look mild by comparison.

to:

** Within the trance fandom itself, there's the weird, trippy and often [[DarkerAndEdgier darker-in-tone]] psychedelic trance (Astrix, Infected Mushroom, Liquid Soul) vs. the [[LighterAndSofter angelic and light]] uplifting trance (Armin van Buuren, Music/FerryCorsten, Aly& Fila). In fact, trance's BrokenBase may well make dubstep's broken fandom look mild by comparison.comparison.
* Viga of ''WebVideo/IdolsOfAnime has referred to the 2010s as the "[[IdolSinger Idol]] [[UsefulNotes/SengokuPeriod Sengoku Jidai]]", which encompasses both RL (MorningMusume, {{AKB48}}, MomoiroCloverZ, etc) and anime/game (''Anime/TheIdolmaster'', ''Anime/LoveLive'', ''VideoGame/{{Aikatsu}}'', ''VideoGame/PriPara'') idol groups.
1st Apr '16 10:45:44 AM Morgenthaler
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* LilKim vs. NickiMinaj. Two years after they wrote each other ReasonYouSuckSpeech /songs, their fans are still debating who's "fake"/"jealous"/"a sell out". To put it delicately.

to:

* LilKim Music/LilKim vs. NickiMinaj.Music/NickiMinaj. Two years after they wrote each other ReasonYouSuckSpeech /songs, their fans are still debating who's "fake"/"jealous"/"a sell out". To put it delicately.



* In the [[{{Music/ACDC}} AC/DC]] fandom there's fans of Bon Scott vs. fans of Brian Johnson. However there's a large amount of fans that love both.

to:

* In the [[{{Music/ACDC}} AC/DC]] Music/{{ACDC}} fandom there's fans of Bon Scott vs. fans of Brian Johnson. However there's a large amount of fans that love both.



* {{Queensryche}} Official fans vs Geoff Tate's Queensryche fans. So, so much. If certain members of these factions were to meet up in real life, the end result would likely involve several squadrons of riot police.
* LCDSoundsystem vs. Death from Above 1979. This rivalry started because DFA Records (full name Death from Above Records), the label of LCD Soundsystem frontman James Murphy, forced Death from Above 1979 (which had Death from Above as its name) to change its name. This battle can be defined as a draw, a result influenced by the fact that exist fans of both LCD Soundsystem and Death from Above 1979 and also by the SongAssociation: both bands appeared in the soundtracks of ''ProjectGothamRacing 3'' and ''SaintsRow2''.

to:

* {{Queensryche}} Music/{{Queensryche}} Official fans vs Geoff Tate's Queensryche fans. So, so much. If certain members of these factions were to meet up in real life, the end result would likely involve several squadrons of riot police.
* LCDSoundsystem Music/LCDSoundsystem vs. Death from Above 1979. This rivalry started because DFA Records (full name Death from Above Records), the label of LCD Soundsystem frontman James Murphy, forced Death from Above 1979 (which had Death from Above as its name) to change its name. This battle can be defined as a draw, a result influenced by the fact that exist fans of both LCD Soundsystem and Death from Above 1979 and also by the SongAssociation: both bands appeared in the soundtracks of ''ProjectGothamRacing 3'' and ''SaintsRow2''.
4th Mar '16 5:12:06 AM erforce
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Music/TangerineDream vs Music/JerryGoldsmith for the soundtrack of ''Film/{{Legend}}''. Tangerine Dream fans argue that TG gives the film a surreal dreamlike quality that makes the film unique and unlike other fantasy genre films. Goldsmith fans pan the pop/synth sensibilities of TG and feel that the Goldsmith score gives it the epic atmosphere that it should have. Notably, fans of the TG version see nothing to dislike about the Goldsmith score. They simply state that his score is too generic for this type of film.

to:

* Music/TangerineDream vs Music/JerryGoldsmith for the soundtrack of ''Film/{{Legend}}''.''Film/{{Legend 1985}}''. Tangerine Dream fans argue that TG gives the film a surreal dreamlike quality that makes the film unique and unlike other fantasy genre films. Goldsmith fans pan the pop/synth sensibilities of TG and feel that the Goldsmith score gives it the epic atmosphere that it should have. Notably, fans of the TG version see nothing to dislike about the Goldsmith score. They simply state that his score is too generic for this type of film.
17th Feb '16 9:44:41 PM KizunaTallis
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* The "{{Trance}} Family" has very intense rivalries with the HouseMusic, DrumAndBass (especially during TheNineties) and {{Dubstep}} fandoms, and the rivalry is largely mutual (the FriendlyFandom members notwithstanding). Not helping matters is that some of the scenes' [=DJs=] themselves have had feuds with one another.

to:

* The "{{Trance}} Family" has very intense rivalries with the HouseMusic, DrumAndBass (especially during TheNineties) and {{Dubstep}} fandoms, and the rivalry is largely mutual (the FriendlyFandom FriendlyFandoms members notwithstanding). Not helping matters is that some of the scenes' [=DJs=] themselves have had feuds with one another.
17th Feb '16 9:40:12 PM KizunaTallis
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** And IN the dubstep fandom, [[LighterAndSofter chillstep]] (e.g. Cahb, Benga, Music/{{Burial}}) vs. [[DarkerAndEdgier brostep]] (e.g. Flux Pavilion, Music/{{Excision}}, Music/{{Nero}}).

to:

** And IN [[BrokenBase within]] the dubstep fandom, [[LighterAndSofter chillstep]] (e.g. Cahb, Benga, Music/{{Burial}}) vs. [[DarkerAndEdgier brostep]] (e.g. Flux Pavilion, Music/{{Excision}}, Music/{{Nero}}).



* Music/ArminVanBuuren fans vs. Music/DavidGuetta fans (which mainly stems from the latter dethroning the former in the "Word's Number 1 DJ" poll in 2011). For the most part however, neither DJ seems to bear any ill will towards the other.

to:

* Music/ArminVanBuuren fans vs. Music/DavidGuetta fans (which mainly stems from the latter dethroning the former in the "Word's Number 1 DJ" poll in 2011). For the most part however, neither DJ seems to bear any ill will towards the other.other.
* The "{{Trance}} Family" has very intense rivalries with the HouseMusic, DrumAndBass (especially during TheNineties) and {{Dubstep}} fandoms, and the rivalry is largely mutual (the FriendlyFandom members notwithstanding). Not helping matters is that some of the scenes' [=DJs=] themselves have had feuds with one another.
** Within the trance fandom itself, there's the weird, trippy and often [[DarkerAndEdgier darker-in-tone]] psychedelic trance (Astrix, Infected Mushroom, Liquid Soul) vs. the [[LighterAndSofter angelic and light]] uplifting trance (Armin van Buuren, Music/FerryCorsten, Aly& Fila). In fact, trance's BrokenBase may well make dubstep's broken fandom look mild by comparison.
1st Feb '16 11:17:50 AM FF32
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* This trope is OlderThanSteam. In the early 1770s, Paris was a warzone between fans of two composers, the german Christoph Gluck and the Italian Niccolo Piccini. It went so far that people would introduce themselves with their preferred composer's name rather than their own, and street fights between Gluckists and Piccininists were common. Ironically, Gluck and Piccini were good friends. BenjaminFranklin, who was in Paris at the time, wrote home:

to:

* This trope is OlderThanSteam. In the early 1770s, Paris was a warzone between fans of two composers, the german Christoph Gluck and the Italian Niccolo Piccini. It went so far that people would introduce themselves with their preferred composer's name rather than their own, and street fights between Gluckists and Piccininists were common. Ironically, Gluck and Piccini were good friends. BenjaminFranklin, Creator/BenjaminFranklin, who was in Paris at the time, wrote home:
3rd Jan '16 10:14:13 AM Morgenthaler
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Though not as big as the above, there's also {{Wolfmother}} fans vs. fans of pretty much any MikePatton project: It can all be traced back to [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=THV23g3z5qU one interview with Patton]].

to:

** Though not as big as the above, there's also {{Wolfmother}} Music/{{Wolfmother}} fans vs. fans of pretty much any MikePatton project: It can all be traced back to [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=THV23g3z5qU one interview with Patton]].
This list shows the last 10 events of 147. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=FandomRivalry.Music