Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Expy / Comicbooks

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When JackKirby and Joe Simon took over DC's ''Sandman'' book, they immediately made him more like their old assignment (Captain America), right down to giving him an Expy of Bucky in "Sandy the Golden Boy."
* During the Golden Age, GreenArrow was given many similarities to {{Batman}}, right down to the Arrow-Car, Arrow-Cave, and a teen sidekick in Speedy (who is really just like Robin).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Witchfire from ''AlphaFlight'' is a terribly obvious example, ripping off the concept of the ''NewMutants'' character Magik (except that she's the actual daughter of Belasco), as well as aspects of DC's Raven. It's hard to tell which character she's directly ripping off more, but it's clear that writer James Hudnall just wanted to write those characters, but wasn't allowed to at the time.

Added: 186

Changed: 731

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the sixties, {{DCComics}} published a blatantly obvious [[ArchieComics Archie]] expy called ''Binky''. The main difference was that Binky had dark hair, not red, [[BettyAndVeronica and he dated a hotter version of Betty while a Veronica clone tried to get his attention]]. Even though it was very dated and inferior to the original, Binky reprint comic books were published in Scandinavia for decades.
** There were several Archie expies from several publishers.

to:

* [[ArchieComics Archie]] was a smash hit for ArchieComics, and inspired many Expies:
**
In the sixties, {{DCComics}} published a blatantly obvious [[ArchieComics Archie]] expy called ''Binky''. The main difference was that Binky ''Binky'', who had dark hair, not red, [[BettyAndVeronica and he dated a hotter version of Betty while a Veronica clone tried to get his attention]]. Even though it was very dated and inferior to the original, Binky reprint comic books [[GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff were published in Scandinavia for decades.
decades]].
** There were several ArchieComics even had its own Expies of Archie, including ''That Wilkin Boy'' and ''Wilbur''.
** ''Fast Willie Jackson'' was an African-American
Archie expies Expy from several publishers.Fitzgerald Publishing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the sixties, {{DCComics}} published a blatantly obvious [[ArchieComics Archie]] expy called ''Binky''. The main difference was that Binky had dark hair, not red, [[BettyAndVeronica and he dated a hotter version of Betty while a Veronica clone tried to get his attention]]. Even though it was very dated and inferior to the original, [[GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff Binky reprint comic books were published in Scandinavia for decades]].

to:

* In the sixties, {{DCComics}} published a blatantly obvious [[ArchieComics Archie]] expy called ''Binky''. The main difference was that Binky had dark hair, not red, [[BettyAndVeronica and he dated a hotter version of Betty while a Veronica clone tried to get his attention]]. Even though it was very dated and inferior to the original, [[GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff original, Binky reprint comic books were published in Scandinavia for decades]].decades.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''SpiderMan'' villain Sergei Kravinoff AKA Kraven the Hunter is an expy of General Zaroff of ''TheMostDangerousGame''. While HuntingTheMostDangerousGame has become a widespread trope, it's no coincidence that the comic book villain shares the Russian aristocrat background of the original.
** In a further case of literary expiness, The Chameleon was revealed as Kraven's illegtimate brother, and was given the name Dmitri Smerdyakov- taken from two of the siblings of ''TheBrothersKaramazov'', and like Smerdyakov of the novel, Chameleon is [[BastardBastard illegitimate]] and a ManipulativeBastard.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Similarly, ''FinalCrisis: Superman Beyond 3D'' features Captain Adam, an alternate universe version of CaptainAtom who's a clear Expy of Dr Manhattan, ''Watchmen'''s CaptainAtom Expy.

Changed: 83

Removed: 172

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Non-YMMV trope


* [[JetDream Jet Dream and her Stunt-Girl Counterspies]] are Expies of [[{{Goldfinger}} Pussy Galore and her Flying Circus]] and/or {{Gender Flip}}ped {{Blackhawk}} Expies.



* Volstagg of the Warriors Three from ''TheMightyThor'' is heavily based on {{Shakespeare}}'s Falstaff. The Warriors Three as an ensemble can also be seen as expies of TheThreeMusketeers.

to:

* Volstagg of the Warriors Three from ''TheMightyThor'' is heavily based on {{Shakespeare}}'s Falstaff. The Warriors Three as an ensemble can also be seen as expies of TheThreeMusketeers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
spelling correction only


* In the ''[[{{ComicBook/Catwoman}} Catwoman]]'' story "Selina's Big Score", Stark is a blatant Expy of Parker, VillainProtagonist of a series of crime novels by Richard Stark. He also [[ComicBookFantasyCasting looks like]] Lee Marvin, who played Parker (renamed Walker) in the film adaptation of the first novel, ''[[{{Film/PointBlank}} Point Blank]]''. (Darwyn Cook, who wrote and drew the story, later went on to officially adapt the Parker novels to the comic medium.)

to:

* In the ''[[{{ComicBook/Catwoman}} Catwoman]]'' story "Selina's Big Score", Stark is a blatant Expy of Parker, VillainProtagonist of a series of crime novels by Richard Stark. He also [[ComicBookFantasyCasting looks like]] Lee Marvin, who played Parker (renamed Walker) in the film adaptation of the first novel, ''[[{{Film/PointBlank}} Point Blank]]''. (Darwyn Cook, Cooke, who wrote and drew the story, later went on to officially adapt the Parker novels to the comic medium.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the ''[[{{ComicBook/Catwoman}} Catwoman]]'' story "Selina's Big Score", Stark is a blatant Expy of Parker, VillainProtagonist of a series of crime novels by Richard Stark. He also [[ComicBookFantasyCasting looks like]] Lee Marvin, who played Parker (renamed Walker) in the film adaptation of the first novel, ''[[{{Film/PointBlank}} Point Blank]]''. (Darwyn Cook, who wrote and drew the story, later went on to officially adapt the Parker novels to the comic medium.)

Added: 264

Changed: 41

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Not too long ago, during Marvel's Dark Reign event, the "Sinister Spider-Man" title(Mac Gargan's Venom posing as Spider-Man) introduced us to Doctor Everything, a pretty blatant expy of Watchmen's Dr. Manhattan, right down to his....disturbing penchant for nudity.

to:

* Not too long ago, during Marvel's Dark Reign event, the "Sinister Spider-Man" title(Mac Gargan's Venom posing as Spider-Man) introduced us to Doctor Everything, a pretty blatant expy of Watchmen's Dr. Manhattan, right down to his....[[FanDisservice disturbing penchant penchant]] [[FullFrontalAssault for nudity.nudity]].


Added DiffLines:

* Happened all the way back during the creation of the XMen by [[StanLee Stan "The Man" Lee himself]]. When creating the original team of five, Lee decided he wanted to re-use the character of [[FantasticFour the Human Torch]], but with ice powers instead of fire.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Not sure whether this belongs here or in CaptainErsatz, but I can't believe either page hasn't yet mentioned how similar [[{{Batman}} Kirk "Man-Bat" Langstrom]] is to [[{{Spiderman}} Curt "The Lizard" Connors]]. Really, regardless of where each character ended up, the only difference between their origins is the specific ailment they were trying to cure and the specific animal they were working on. The issue is that they were created within three years of each other (Man-Bat actually came first), so it's unclear how much of this was intentional or whether it was more like some of the ambiguous DuelingMovies cases.

to:

* Not sure whether this belongs here or in CaptainErsatz, but I can't believe either page hasn't yet mentioned how similar [[{{Batman}} Kirk "Man-Bat" Langstrom]] is to [[{{Spiderman}} Curt "The Lizard" Connors]]. Really, regardless of where each character ended up, the only difference between their origins is the specific ailment they were trying to cure and the specific animal they were working on. The issue is that they were created within three years of each other (Man-Bat actually came first), so it's unclear how much of this was intentional or whether it was more like some of the ambiguous DuelingMovies cases.

Added: 104

Changed: 193

Removed: 93

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved from Captain Ersatz.


* DC's ''{{All-Star Squadron}}'' featured the Young All-Stars, who were meant to replace the [[TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks Golden Age]] versions of Superman (Iron Munro), Wonder Woman (The Fury), Batman (Flying Fox), Aquaman (Neptune Perkins, Tsunami), and Green Arrow (Tigress) Post-Crisis, because they, you know, weren't active back then anymore. They had Nazi-created evil counterparts called Axis Amerika to contend with, which were ''also'' retrofitted Expies of the vanished Earth-2 heroes: Ubermensch (Superman), Gudra the Valkyrie (Wonder Woman), Grösshorn Eule and Fledermaus (Batman and Robin), Usil (Green Arrow) and Sea Wolf (Aquaman). Part of the reasoning was that, metaphysically speaking, iconic characters like Superman and Wonder Woman were "too big" to be replaced by just ''one'' new (and inevitably "lesser") character.
** The TokenJapanese member of Axis Amerika, Kamikaze was an expy of Fawcett's {{Bulletman}}.

to:

* DC's ''{{All-Star Squadron}}'' featured the Young All-Stars, who were meant to replace the [[TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks Golden Age]] versions of Superman (Iron Munro), Wonder Woman (The Fury), Batman (Flying Fox), Aquaman (Neptune Perkins, Tsunami), and Green Arrow (Tigress) Post-Crisis, because they, you know, weren't active back then anymore. They had Nazi-created evil counterparts called Axis Amerika to contend with, which were ''also'' retrofitted Expies of the vanished Earth-2 heroes: Ubermensch (Superman), Gudra the Valkyrie (Wonder Woman), Grösshorn Eule and Fledermaus (Batman and Robin), Usil (Green Arrow) and Sea Wolf (Aquaman). Part of the reasoning was that, metaphysically speaking, iconic characters like Superman and Wonder Woman were "too big" to be replaced by just ''one'' new (and inevitably "lesser") character.
**
character. The TokenJapanese [[TokenMinority Token Japanese]] member of Axis Amerika, Kamikaze was an expy of Fawcett's {{Bulletman}}.



* Volstagg of the Warriors Three from ''TheMightyThor'' is heavily based on {{Shakespeare}}'s Falstaff.

to:

* Volstagg of the Warriors Three from ''TheMightyThor'' is heavily based on {{Shakespeare}}'s Falstaff. The Warriors Three as an ensemble can also be seen as expies of TheThreeMusketeers.
* Maximum Press characters Law and Order bear a strong resemblance to Marvel's Comicbook/CloakAndDagger.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Volstagg of the Warriors Three from ''TheMightyThor'' is heavily based on {{Shakespeare}}'s Falstaff.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mocked by Zeus himself. Hulk's reason for confronting him was that he wanted Zeus to help his family. As Zeus comments "Sacrificing yourself to save others? Wrong religion." *[[CurbStompBattle bitchslaps]]*

to:

** Mocked by Zeus himself. Hulk's reason for confronting him was that he wanted Zeus to help his family. As Zeus comments "Sacrificing "Offering yourself to save others? as a sacrifice. Dying for other people's sins. Wrong religion." *[[CurbStompBattle bitchslaps]]*
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mocked by Zeus himself. Hulk's reason for confronting him was that he wanted Zeus to help his family. As Zeus comments "Sacricing yourself to save others? Wrong religion." *[[CurbStompBattle bitchslaps]]*

to:

** Mocked by Zeus himself. Hulk's reason for confronting him was that he wanted Zeus to help his family. As Zeus comments "Sacricing "Sacrificing yourself to save others? Wrong religion." *[[CurbStompBattle bitchslaps]]*
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Not too long ago, during Marvel's Dark Reign event, the "Sinister Spider-Man" title(Mac Gargan's Venom posing as Spider-Man) introduced us to Doctor Everything, a pretty blatant expy of Watchmen's Dr. Manhattan, right down to his....disturbing penchant for nudity.

Added: 207

Changed: 92

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In a rather unusual example, in Marvel's ''incredible Hercules'' and later, in ''Incredible Hulks'', Zeus served as an expy for God. That is, the Judaeo-Christian God. Zeus, previously portrayed as distinctly unimpressive, especially next to his intelligent and scheming wife, became considerably more imperious - and when put on trial, threw the "angry at God" argument back into the faces of his accusers. When the Hulk confronted Zeus, the context was somewhat awkward if Zeus is taken as himself, but perfectly logical when read as God. Of course, a Hellenistic pagan might raise his eyebrows at this, since to him Zeus = God.

to:

* In a rather unusual example, in Marvel's ''incredible ''Incredible Hercules'' and later, in ''Incredible Hulks'', Zeus served as an expy for God. That is, the Judaeo-Christian God. Zeus, previously portrayed as distinctly unimpressive, especially next to his intelligent and scheming wife, became considerably more imperious - and when put on trial, threw the "angry at God" argument back into the faces of his accusers. When the Hulk confronted Zeus, the context was somewhat awkward if Zeus is taken as himself, but perfectly logical when read as God. Of course, a Hellenistic pagan might raise his eyebrows at this, since to him God.
** Mocked by
Zeus = God.himself. Hulk's reason for confronting him was that he wanted Zeus to help his family. As Zeus comments "Sacricing yourself to save others? Wrong religion." *[[CurbStompBattle bitchslaps]]*
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When the teen supervillain Kid Karnevil attempted to infiltrate the JusticeSocietyOfAmerica, he did so by posing as a patriotic superhero named the All-American Kid. All-American Kid's costume and backstory were extremely similar to those of Bucky, the sidekick of CaptainAmerica.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The TokenJapanese member of Axis Amerika, Kamikaze was an expy of Fawcett's {{Bulletman}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Marvin, a supporting character for ''MillieTheModel'', had much the same characterization as ArchieComics' Jughead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved from Captain Ersatz.



to:

* DC's ''{{All-Star Squadron}}'' featured the Young All-Stars, who were meant to replace the [[TheGoldenAgeOfComicBooks Golden Age]] versions of Superman (Iron Munro), Wonder Woman (The Fury), Batman (Flying Fox), Aquaman (Neptune Perkins, Tsunami), and Green Arrow (Tigress) Post-Crisis, because they, you know, weren't active back then anymore. They had Nazi-created evil counterparts called Axis Amerika to contend with, which were ''also'' retrofitted Expies of the vanished Earth-2 heroes: Ubermensch (Superman), Gudra the Valkyrie (Wonder Woman), Grösshorn Eule and Fledermaus (Batman and Robin), Usil (Green Arrow) and Sea Wolf (Aquaman). Part of the reasoning was that, metaphysically speaking, iconic characters like Superman and Wonder Woman were "too big" to be replaced by just ''one'' new (and inevitably "lesser") character.

Changed: 360

Removed: 148

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:





* ''{{Planetary}}'' by WarrenEllis contains a large number of [[CaptainErsatz Captains Ersatz]], but the minor character of Jack Carter undergoes a remarkable transformation during the story in which he appears. He is initially introduced as a CaptainErsatz for [[{{Hellblazer}} John Constantine]] (who Ellis had written but did not create), but in the final panels of the story mutates into a true Expy of Spider Jerusalem from Ellis's ''{{Transmetropolitan}}''.
** Who himself is an expy of HunterSThompson.

to:

* ''{{Planetary}}'' by WarrenEllis contains a large number of [[CaptainErsatz Captains Ersatz]], but the minor character of Jack Carter undergoes a remarkable transformation during the story in which he appears. He is initially introduced as a CaptainErsatz for [[{{Hellblazer}} John Constantine]] (who Ellis had written but did not create), but in the final panels of the story mutates into a true Expy of Spider Jerusalem from Ellis's ''{{Transmetropolitan}}''.
** Who
''{{Transmetropolitan}}'' (who himself is an expy a NoCelebritiesWereHarmed of HunterSThompson.HunterSThompson).
** Credit for this actually goes to the artist, John Cassaday. According to [[WordOfGod Ellis]], he only told Cassaday to draw Jack Carter with a shaved head and tattoos, and it was Cassaday who decided to draw him *exactly* like Spider Jerusalem. This makes Carter one of the rare Expies created as a prank.



* In his last series of ThePunisher, GarthEnnis nails the looks and personality of the Colonel who captures him after none other than MorganFreeman.

Changed: 373

Removed: 173

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This belongs to the western animation page. And Expy not means \"have the same role\" but yes \"is similar\"-only be one woman in the same team not turns someone one Expy.


* When created for the ''{{Spider-Man}} and his Amazing Friends'' cartoon, Firestar's civilian identity bore a resemblance to Mary Jane Watson. The resemblance was actually remarked upon in the comics some time later. Likewise, her superhero powers make her a clear Expy of The Human Torch, the only difference being the gender swap to give Spidey an Amazing Female Friend.
** Additionally, the cartoon portrayed Firestar as a former member of the X-Men, and she replaced Jean Grey for TheSmurfettePrinciple in that continuity. Triple Expy Action!

to:

* When created for the ''{{Spider-Man}} and his Amazing Friends'' cartoon, Firestar's civilian identity bore a resemblance to Mary Jane Watson. The resemblance was actually remarked upon in the comics some time later. Likewise, her superhero powers make her a clear Expy of The Human Torch, the only difference being the gender swap to give Spidey an Amazing Female Friend.
** Additionally, the cartoon portrayed Firestar as a former member of the X-Men, and she replaced Jean Grey for TheSmurfettePrinciple in that continuity. Triple Expy Action!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In a rather unusual example, in Marvel's ''incredible Hercules'' and later, in ''Incredible Hulks'', Zeus served as an expy for God. That is, the Judaeo-Christian God. Zeus, previously portrayed as distinctly unimpressive, especially next to his intelligent and scheming wife, became considerably more imperious - and when put on trial, threw the "angry at God" argument back into the faces of his accusers. When the Hulk confronted Zeus, the context was somewhat awkward if Zeus is taken as himself, but perfectly logical when read as God.
Of course, a Hellenistic pagan might raise his eyebrows at this, since to him Zeus = God.

to:

* In a rather unusual example, in Marvel's ''incredible Hercules'' and later, in ''Incredible Hulks'', Zeus served as an expy for God. That is, the Judaeo-Christian God. Zeus, previously portrayed as distinctly unimpressive, especially next to his intelligent and scheming wife, became considerably more imperious - and when put on trial, threw the "angry at God" argument back into the faces of his accusers. When the Hulk confronted Zeus, the context was somewhat awkward if Zeus is taken as himself, but perfectly logical when read as God.
God. Of course, a Hellenistic pagan might raise his eyebrows at this, since to him Zeus = God.

Changed: 388

Removed: 372

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In a rather unusual example, in Marvel's ''incredible Hercules'' and later, in ''Incredible Hulks'', Zeus served as an expy for God. That is, the Judaeo-Christian God.
Zeus, previously portrayed as distinctly unimpressive, especially next to his intelligent and scheming wife, became considerably more imperious - and when put on trial, threw the "angry at God" argument back into the faces of his accusers. When the Hulk confronted Zeus, the context was somewhat awkward if Zeus is taken as himself, but perfectly logical when read as God.

to:

* In a rather unusual example, in Marvel's ''incredible Hercules'' and later, in ''Incredible Hulks'', Zeus served as an expy for God. That is, the Judaeo-Christian God.
God. Zeus, previously portrayed as distinctly unimpressive, especially next to his intelligent and scheming wife, became considerably more imperious - and when put on trial, threw the "angry at God" argument back into the faces of his accusers. When the Hulk confronted Zeus, the context was somewhat awkward if Zeus is taken as himself, but perfectly logical when read as God.

Added: 461

Changed: 169

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In a rather unusual example, in Marvel's ''incredible Hercules'' and later, in ''Incredible Hulks'', Zeus served as an expy for God. That is, the Judaeo-Christian God.
Zeus, previously portrayed as distinctly unimpressive, especially next to his intelligent and scheming wife, became considerably more imperious - and when put on trial, threw the "angry at God" argument back into the faces of his accusers. When the Hulk confronted Zeus, the context was somewhat awkward if Zeus is taken as himself, but perfectly logical when read as God.
Of course, a Hellenistic pagan might raise his eyebrows at this, since to him Zeus = God.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
seem to have gotten his name wrong, in the future will fix in other examples


* In a probably deliberate example, since the character is a Redeeming Replacement for on of [[SpiderMan Spider-Man's]] worst enemies, but Phil Ulrich the heroic Green Goblin suggests an expy of Peter Parker. Ulrich is an UnluckyEverydude who works for the Daily Bugle and even has an Uncle Ben just like Peter (although Ulrich's doesn't get killed). In the ''SpiderGirl'' series, the two characters are close friends.

to:

* In a probably deliberate example, since the character is a Redeeming Replacement for on of [[SpiderMan Spider-Man's]] worst enemies, but Phil Ulrich Urich the heroic Green Goblin suggests an expy of Peter Parker. Ulrich is an UnluckyEverydude who works for the Daily Bugle and even has an Uncle Ben just like Peter (although Ulrich's doesn't get killed). In the ''SpiderGirl'' series, the two characters are close friends.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In a probably deliberate example, since the character is a RedeamingReplacement for on of Spider-Man's worst enemies, but Phil Ulrich the heroic Green Goblin suggests an expy of [[SpiderMan Peter Parker]]. Ulrich is an UnluckyEverydude who works for the Daily Bugle and even has an Uncle Ben just like Peter (although Ulrich's doesn't get killed). In the ''SpiderGirl'' series, the two characters are close friends.

to:

* In a probably deliberate example, since the character is a RedeamingReplacement Redeeming Replacement for on of Spider-Man's [[SpiderMan Spider-Man's]] worst enemies, but Phil Ulrich the heroic Green Goblin suggests an expy of [[SpiderMan Peter Parker]].Parker. Ulrich is an UnluckyEverydude who works for the Daily Bugle and even has an Uncle Ben just like Peter (although Ulrich's doesn't get killed). In the ''SpiderGirl'' series, the two characters are close friends.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In a probably deliberate example, since the character is a RedeamingReplacement for on of Spider-Man's worst enemies, but Phil Ulrich the heroic Green Goblin suggests an expy of [[SpiderMan Peter Parker]]. Ulrich is an UnluckyEverydude who works for the Daily Bugle and even has an Uncle Ben just like Peter (although Ulrich's doesn't get killed). In the ''SpiderGirl'' series, the two characters are close friends.

Top