History EnsembleDarkHorse / Supernatural

* The unnamed Crossroads Demon who appears in Seasons 2 and 3 is rather popular with fans, for her [[spoiler: [[DealWithTheDevil rather important role]] in Dean's storyline]], as well as other reasons.

* Jenny Klein, the cupcake baking SexySecretary from the episode with Creator/CharismaCarpenter and Creator/JamesMarsters, was considered a scene stealer by many (and brought back in a minor way for a later episode) for her humorous FreakOut reaction to signs of magic, and (in a nice BaitAndSwitch manner) endearing confusion about the idea that anyone would think she was having an affair with her boss (who has a record of womanizing and she bakes cupcakes for). Jenny only appears in three scenes, but some fans consider her to be a highlight of that episode, even with Franchise/{{Buffyverse}} alums Creator/JamesMarsters and Creator/CharismaCarpenter having more substantial guest roles. Plenty of fans consider her to be one of the most likable victims Sam and Dean rescue from paranormal harm without her even having any romantic chemistry with the brothers.

* The unnamed Crossroads Demon who appears in Seasons 2 and 3 is rather popular with fans, for her [[spoiler: [[DealWithTheDevil rather important role]] in Dean's storyline]], as well as [[EvilIsSexy other reasons]].

* The unnamed Crossroads Demon who appears in Seasons 2 and 3 is rather popular with fans, for her [[DealWithTheDevil rather important role]] in Dean's storyline and [[EvilIsSexy other reasons]].

* [[KnightTemplar Gordon]] [[HeWhoFightsMonsters Walker]].

* [[ButNotTooBlack Mixed race]] light witch hunter siblings Max and Alicia Banes have their fans.

* Alton and Serena, Mick's colleagues from [[Recap/SupernaturalS12E14TheRaid The Raid]] are somewhat well-liked (as far as minor characters go) for being competent, but not infallible, and able to accept that they weren't infallible, qualities which were unfortunately rare among the faction as a whole.

* Jenny Klein, the cupcake baking SexySecretary from the episode with Creator/CharismaCarpenter and Creator/JamesMarsters, was considered a scene stealer by many (and brought back in a minor way for a later episode) for her humorous FreakOut reaction to signs of magic, and (in a nice BaitAndSwitch manner) endearing confusion about the idea that anyone would think she was having an affair with her boss (who has a record of womanizing and she bakes cupcakes for). Jenny only appears in three scenes, but some fans consider her to be a highlight of that episode, even with Franchise/{{Buffyverse}} alums Creator/JamesMarsters and Creator/CharismaCarpenter having more substantial guest roles. Plenty of fans consider her to be one of the most likable victims they rescue from paranormal harm without having any romantic chemistry with the brothers.

* Jenny Klein, the cupcake baking SexySecretary from the episode with Creator/CharismaCarpenter and Creator/JamesMarsters, was considered a scene stealer by many (and brought back in a minor way for a later episode) for her humorous FreakOut reaction to signs of magic, and (in a nice BaitAndSwitch manner) endearing confusion about the idea that anyone would think she was having an affair with her boss (who has a record of womanizing and she bakes cupcakes for). Jenny only appears in three scenes, but some fans consider her to be a highlight of that episode, even with Franchise/{{Buffyverse}} alums Creator/JamesFrampton and Creator/CharismaCarpenter having more substantial guest roles. Plenty of fans consider her to be one of the most likable victims they rescue from paranormal harm without having any romantic chemistry with the brothers.

* Castiel. He was only supposed to be in a handful of episodes and killed off, allowing Anna to become the boys' angel guide and Dean's love interest. The writers recognized his popularity and chemistry with Dean, [[spoiler: so it was Anna who was eventually killed]] and Cas was [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/HoYay/Supernatural given her story]]. Since then, his popularity within the fandom causes many new viewers to be surprised he was ever an ensemble dark horse.

* Fans reaction to Abaddon since her promotion to part of the BigBadEnsemble of season nine has been quite positive.
* Benny the badass FriendlyNeighborhoodVampire [[spoiler:[[EscapedFromHell from Purgatory]]]], who teams up with Dean and calls him "brother". Being one of the show's latest [[TheWoobie woobies]] only sealed the deal.
* [[TheCutie Heaven's most adorable angel]] AKA Samandriel has the quite the devote fanbase as well. [[spoiler:His death only increased it]].

* JeanneDeArchetype Angel Anna Milton is liked for some providing some novelty among the early Angel characters and good chemistry with the brothers.
* Linda Tran has quite a large fanbase, who are clamoring for [[spoiler:her off-screen death in Season 8]] to be revealed to be fake. [[spoiler:[[SavedByTheFans Their voices have been heard!]]]]

* Mick Davies is viewed as the bright spot of the often-maligned Men of Letters arc, being a competent, engaging TokenGoodTeammate to the group (a few WeHardlyKnewYe character aside) with a distinct arc. [[spoiler: his abrupt death was seen as cause for mourning, and was when the popularity of Men of Letters and their plot line took a nosedive]].
** Alton and Serena, Mick's colleagues from [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Recap/SupernaturalS12E14TheRaid The Raid]] are somewhat well-liked (as far as minor characters go) for being competent, but not infallible, and able to accept that they weren't infallible, qualities which were unfortunately rare among the faction as a whole.

* The Special Children as a group are liked with Andy being appreciated for his combination of humor, resourcefulness and pathos, while Jake and Ava are well-acted [[spoiler: FallenHero's]] with interesting powers, with all of them being characters occasionally mentioned as ones fans wouldn't mind seeing again.

* Jenny Klein, the cup-cake baking SexySecretary from the episode with Creator/CharismaCarpenter and Creator/JamesMarsters was considered a scene stealer by many (and brought back in a minor way for a later episode) for her humorous FreakOut reaction to signs of magic, and (in a nice BaitAndSwitch manner) endearing confusion about the idea that anyone would think she was having an affair with her boss (who has a record of womanizing and she bakes cupcakes for). Jenny only appears in three scenes, but some fans consider her to be a highlight of that episode, even with Franchise/{{Buffyverse}} alums Creator/JamesFrampton and Creator/CharismaCarpenter having more substantial guest roles. Plenty of fans consider her to be one of the most likable victims they rescue from paranormal harm without having any romantic chemistry with the brothers.

* Emma, Dean's half-Amazon daughter, for being a formidable opponent with a [[AntagonisticOffspring unique dynamic with the brothers]] and playing the role in a manner that makes it difficult to tell whet she's a TragicMonster who could have been better, or a ManipulativeBitch even after her role is over.

---

* Jenny Klein, the cup-cake baking SexySecretary from the episode with Creator/CharismaCarpenter and Creator/JamesMarsters was considered a scene stealer by many (and brought back in a minor way for a later episode) for her humorous FreakOut reaction to signs of magic, and (in a nice BaitAndSwitch manner) endearing confusion about the idea that anyone would think she was having an affair with her boss (who has a record of womanizing and she bakes cupcakes for).