Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ContrastingSequelAntagonist / Literature

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
renamed to Clone Angst


** ''Literature/TheThrawnTrilogy'' notably frames Grand Admiral Thrawn and Joruus C'baoth as {{Foil}}s of Emperor Palpatine and Darth Vader, respectively, making it clear that the series wouldn't simply be a retread of the Original Trilogy. While Palpatine was an ominous black-cloaked [[CardCarryingVillain card-carrying]] human villain known for his sadism and his mastery of the Dark Side, Thrawn is an impeccably [[WickedCultured cultured]] OfficerAndAGentleman known for his [[TheChessmaster tactical brilliance]] and his love of art, as well as a HumanAlien who habitually dresses in well-tailored [[LightIsNotGood white military regalia]]. Likewise, while Vader was a tragically corrupted Dark Jedi known for his stoicism and physical discipline, and he ultimately turned against Palpatine in a HeelFaceTurn, C'baoth is the insane [[CloningBlues clone]] of a legendary Jedi Master who's brought down by his own mental instability, and Thrawn turns against ''him'' when it becomes clear that he can't be controlled.

to:

** ''Literature/TheThrawnTrilogy'' notably frames Grand Admiral Thrawn and Joruus C'baoth as {{Foil}}s of Emperor Palpatine and Darth Vader, respectively, making it clear that the series wouldn't simply be a retread of the Original Trilogy. While Palpatine was an ominous black-cloaked [[CardCarryingVillain card-carrying]] human villain known for his sadism and his mastery of the Dark Side, Thrawn is an impeccably [[WickedCultured cultured]] OfficerAndAGentleman known for his [[TheChessmaster tactical brilliance]] and his love of art, as well as a HumanAlien who habitually dresses in well-tailored [[LightIsNotGood white military regalia]]. Likewise, while Vader was a tragically corrupted Dark Jedi known for his stoicism and physical discipline, and he ultimately turned against Palpatine in a HeelFaceTurn, C'baoth is the insane [[CloningBlues clone]] clone of a legendary Jedi Master who's brought down by his own mental instability, and Thrawn turns against ''him'' when it becomes clear that he can't be controlled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Franchise/StarWarsTheHighRepublic: [[Literature/StarWarsLightOfTheJedi Light of the Jedi]]'': The Nihil are entirely different from any other major enemies in ''Star Wars'' to date. They're not Force-wielders like the various Darksiders, they're not religious fanatics like the Sith cultists, they're not an enemy nation, and they're not even high-level criminals like the Hutts or the Shadow Collective. They are basically just a random band of marauders who lucked into a huge technological advantage. Even then, it's repeatedly made clear that the only reason they are a real threat to the Republic is because it's an unprecedented era of peace and there's barely any military presence in the Galaxy.

to:

* ''Franchise/StarWarsTheHighRepublic: [[Literature/StarWarsLightOfTheJedi Light of the Jedi]]'': The Nihil are entirely different from any other major enemies in ''Star Wars'' to date. They're not Force-wielders like the various Darksiders, they're not religious fanatics like the Sith cultists, they're not an enemy nation, and they're not even high-level criminals like the Hutts or the Shadow Collective. They are basically just a random band of marauders who lucked into a huge technological advantage. Even then, it's repeatedly made clear that the only reason they are a real threat to the Republic is because it's an unprecedented era of peace and there's barely any military presence in the Galaxy. [[spoiler:By the end of Phase I, they've destroyed Starlight Beacon, walled off the Republic from the Outer Rim with a wall of a hyperspace mines and taken it over, and have Nameless creatures that prey on Jedi at their disposal.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** IronLady Natasi Daala was part of the BigBadEnsemble of the ''Literature/JediAcademyTrilogy'' and the secondary antagonist of ''Literature/FateOfTheJedi'' who was designed to serve as this trope to Thrawn. Both were former Imperial admirals with GalacticConquerer ambitions, but while Thrawn was a cold, calculating chessmaster, Daala was emotional and hot-headed with a "shoot first, ask questions later" attitude. Ironically, despite this she ultimately came closer than Thrawn did to complete dominance over the galaxy as she briefly became a PresidentEvil.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/BazilBroketail'': The general of the Padmasan armies in book three -- General Lukash -- was [[StupidEvil pointlessly cruel]], an [[GeneralFailure incompetent leader]], treating the entire campaign as a chance at venting his personal frustrations on the world and killing people for fun. General Kreegsbrok, on the other hand, is a professional who remains focused on his job and never does anything without a purpose.

Changed: 825

Removed: 2298

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The villains from each Harry Potter book are more like arc villains.


* ''Literature/HarryPotter'':
** The series has Lord Voldemort as the consistent BigBad, but each individual book also has its own secondary antagonist whose nature and motivations often say much about the themes and conflict at the heart of each installment. ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndThePhilosophersStone The Philosopher's Stone]]'' has [[TheRenfield Quirinus Quirrel]], the frail and cowardly servant of the crippled Voldemort; ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheChamberOfSecrets The Chamber of Secrets]]'' has "[[FromNobodyToNightmare Tom Riddle]]", the ghostly echo of Voldemort's former self; ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndThePrisonerOfAzkaban The Prisoner of Azkaban]]'' has [[spoiler: [[EvilFormerFriend Peter Pettigrew]]]], the confidant of the Potters who betrayed his friends out of cowardice; ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheGobletOfFire The Goblet of Fire]]'' has [[spoiler: [[WellDoneSonGuy Barty Crouch, Jr.]]]], the troubled young Death Eater initiate who remains faithful to Voldemort in the wake of his downfall; ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix The Order of the Phoenix]]'' has [[TyrantTakesTheHelm Dolores Umbridge]], the corrupt Ministry bureaucrat who denies Voldemort's return; and ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince The Half-Blood Prince]]'' has [[TheRival Draco Malfoy]] and [[spoiler: [[TheAtoner Severus Snape]]]], who finally openly join Voldemort after six years of lurking in the background at Hogwarts.
** The ''Film/FantasticBeastsAndWhereToFindThem'' franchise has Gellert Grindelwald, the world's most powerful Dark Wizard before Voldemort. Voldemort goes by an alias, while Grindelwald uses his real name. Voldemort was a model student at Hogwarts, and hid his true nature from most people, while Grindelwald was known as a troublemaker and expelled from Durmstrang. The Dark Arts twisted Voldemort's appearance, while Grindelwald looks like [[Creator/JohnnyDepp his actor]]. Voldemort kept his reign of terror focused on Britain, [[spoiler: while Grindelwald expanded all across Europe, and into America. As a polar opposite of Voldemort, in this regard, Grindelwald studiously ''avoided'' attacking Britain out of fear of Dumbledore]]. Additionally, Grindelwald lacks Voldemort's FantasticRacism, instead hating {{Muggle}}s purely for forcing wizards into hiding.

to:

* ''Literature/HarryPotter'':
** The series has Lord Voldemort as the consistent BigBad, but each individual book also has its own secondary antagonist whose nature and motivations often say much about the themes and conflict at the heart of each installment. ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndThePhilosophersStone The Philosopher's Stone]]'' has [[TheRenfield Quirinus Quirrel]], the frail and cowardly servant of the crippled Voldemort; ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheChamberOfSecrets The Chamber of Secrets]]'' has "[[FromNobodyToNightmare Tom Riddle]]", the ghostly echo of Voldemort's former self; ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndThePrisonerOfAzkaban The Prisoner of Azkaban]]'' has [[spoiler: [[EvilFormerFriend Peter Pettigrew]]]], the confidant of the Potters who betrayed his friends out of cowardice; ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheGobletOfFire The Goblet of Fire]]'' has [[spoiler: [[WellDoneSonGuy Barty Crouch, Jr.]]]], the troubled young Death Eater initiate who remains faithful to Voldemort in the wake of his downfall; ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix The Order of the Phoenix]]'' has [[TyrantTakesTheHelm Dolores Umbridge]], the corrupt Ministry bureaucrat who denies Voldemort's return; and ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince The Half-Blood Prince]]'' has [[TheRival Draco Malfoy]] and [[spoiler: [[TheAtoner Severus Snape]]]], who finally openly join Voldemort after six years of lurking in the background at Hogwarts.
** The
Grindelwald from ''Film/FantasticBeastsAndWhereToFindThem'' franchise has Gellert Grindelwald, the world's most powerful Dark Wizard before Voldemort.franchise, contrasts to Voldemort from ''Literature/HarryPotter''. Voldemort goes by an alias, while Grindelwald uses his real name. Voldemort was a model student at Hogwarts, and hid his true nature from most people, while Grindelwald was known as a troublemaker and expelled from Durmstrang. The Dark Arts twisted Voldemort's appearance, while Grindelwald looks like [[Creator/JohnnyDepp his actor]]. Voldemort kept his reign of terror focused on Britain, [[spoiler: while Grindelwald expanded all across Europe, and into America. As a polar opposite of Voldemort, in this regard, Grindelwald studiously ''avoided'' attacking Britain out of fear of Dumbledore]]. Additionally, Grindelwald lacks Voldemort's FantasticRacism, instead hating {{Muggle}}s purely for forcing wizards into hiding.

Added: 2159

Changed: 292

Removed: 1769

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''Literature/TheChroniclesOfNarnia:'' Going by publishing order, [[Literature/TheLionTheWitchAndTheWardrobe the first book]] has a non-human sorceress who bans all humans from Narnia. [[Literature/PrinceCaspian The second]] has a human {{Muggle}} who bans all magical creatures from Narnia.
* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'': The villains in the first two City Watch books both want to restore the Ankh-Morpork monarchy, but the one in ''Literature/GuardsGuards'' is an opportunist who just wants to be the trusted advisor to some idiot who looks good in a crown, and the one in ''Literature/MenAtArms'' is a true believer monarchist who wants to see the ''rightful'' king on the throne. Both of them have supernatural help that they discover they don't control, but the dragon is a physically powerful classic monster, while the gonne is an animist mechanical device which can't physically do anything without being operated by a person, but can influence its wielder's mind.
* The Franchise/HannibalLecter series has several examples:
** Jame "Buffalo Bill" Gumb of ''Film/TheSilenceOfTheLambs'' is as much the direct opposite of Francis "the Tooth Fairy" Dolarhyde of ''Literature/RedDragon'' as he is his parallel. While both killers seek to transform themselves through their killing, Dolarhyde's goal is to transform himself in spirit and become the culmination of his present state by empowering his "Great Red Dragon" alter, while Gumb's goal is to transform himself in body and become the antithesis of his present state by fashioning a GenuineHumanHide suit that would, in his eyes, enable him to become a completely different person.
** Mason Verger of ''Film/{{Hannibal}}'' bears this relationship to Gumb. Gumb is a handsome raving lunatic from a lower-class background who kills on impulse, and has only the most tenuous personal connection to Hannibal Lecter; he also spends most of the movie as the target of a nationwide manhunt after kidnapping a US Senator's daughter. By contrast, Verger is a wealthy, [[WickedCultured cultured]] psychopath with [[NightmareFace gruesome facial mutilations]] who [[TheChessmaster calmly plans his every move]], and he's driven by his desire for revenge against Hannibal Lecter, being one of his previous victims; he's also a textbook VillainWithGoodPublicity who successfully manages to hide his depravities from most of the public, and gets off with community service the one time that he's discovered.



* ''Literature/TheChroniclesOfNarnia:'' Going by publishing order, [[Literature/TheLionTheWitchAndTheWardrobe the first book]] has a non-human sorceress who bans all humans from Narnia. [[Literature/PrinceCaspian The second]] has a human {{Muggle}} who bans all magical creatures from Narnia.
* The Franchise/HannibalLecter series has several examples:
** Jame "Buffalo Bill" Gumb of ''Film/TheSilenceOfTheLambs'' is as much the direct opposite of Francis "the Tooth Fairy" Dolarhyde of ''Literature/RedDragon'' as he is his parallel. While both killers seek to transform themselves through their killing, Dolarhyde's goal is to transform himself in spirit and become the culmination of his present state by empowering his "Great Red Dragon" alter, while Gumb's goal is to transform himself in body and become the antithesis of his present state by fashioning a GenuineHumanHide suit that would, in his eyes, enable him to become a completely different person.
** Mason Verger of ''Film/{{Hannibal}}'' bears this relationship to Gumb. Gumb is a handsome raving lunatic from a lower-class background who kills on impulse, and has only the most tenuous personal connection to Hannibal Lecter; he also spends most of the movie as the target of a nationwide manhunt after kidnapping a US Senator's daughter. By contrast, Verger is a wealthy, [[WickedCultured cultured]] psychopath with [[NightmareFace gruesome facial mutilations]] who [[TheChessmaster calmly plans his every move]], and he's driven by his desire for revenge against Hannibal Lecter, being one of his previous victims; he's also a textbook VillainWithGoodPublicity who successfully manages to hide his depravities from most of the public, and gets off with community service the one time that he's discovered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Franchise/StarWarsTheHighRepublic: [[Literature/StarWarsLightOfTheJedi Light of the Jedi]]'': The Nihil are entirely different from any other major enemies in ''Star Wars'' to date. They're not Force-wielders like the various Darksiders, they're not religious fanatics like the Sith cultists, they're not an enemy nation, and they're not even high-level criminals like the Hutts or the Shadow Collective. They are basically just a random band of marauders who lucked into a huge technological advantage. Even then, it's repeatedly made clear that the only reason they are a real threat to the Republic is because it's an unprecedented era of peace and there's barely any military presence in the Galaxy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The various villains in ''Franchise/{{Mistborn}}'' tend to contrast.
** [[TheEmpire The Final Empire]] and its enforcers were the primary antagonists of the first ''Literature/{{Mistborn}}'' book, and the main characters were thieves trying to take them down. The Empire's main strength was mainly resources: better trained soldiers, weapons, fortified positions, etc. The rebel thieves can't fight them directly due to lack of manpower, and so sabotage by sowing chaos and fostering a mythic reputation. In ''Literature/AlloyOfLaw'', the first book of the sequel series ''Literature/WaxAndWayne'', the antagonistic Vanishers are a group of thieves aiming to take down the nobles of Elendel, which they do by sowing chaos and fostering a mythic reputation. It's most apparent when Wax, Wayne, and Marasi [[CurbStompBattle kill and capture around thirty]] of them during a botched robbery; where the Final Empire could just throw more troops or koloss, the Vanishers lament that it's over for them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jame "Buffalo Bill" Gumb of ''Film/TheSilenceOfTheLambs'' is as much the direct opposite of Francis "the Tooth Fairy" Dolarhyde of ''Literature/RedDragon'' as he is his parallel. While both killers seek to transform themselves through their killing, Dolarhyde's goal is to transform himself in spirit and become the culmination of his present state by empowering his "Great Red Dragon" alter, while Bill's goal is to transform himself in body and become the antithesis of his present state by fashioning a GenuineHumanHide suit that would, in his eyes, enable him to become a completely different person.

to:

** Jame "Buffalo Bill" Gumb of ''Film/TheSilenceOfTheLambs'' is as much the direct opposite of Francis "the Tooth Fairy" Dolarhyde of ''Literature/RedDragon'' as he is his parallel. While both killers seek to transform themselves through their killing, Dolarhyde's goal is to transform himself in spirit and become the culmination of his present state by empowering his "Great Red Dragon" alter, while Bill's Gumb's goal is to transform himself in body and become the antithesis of his present state by fashioning a GenuineHumanHide suit that would, in his eyes, enable him to become a completely different person.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The Franchise/HannibalLecter series has several examples:
** Jame "Buffalo Bill" Gumb of ''Film/TheSilenceOfTheLambs'' is as much the direct opposite of Francis "the Tooth Fairy" Dolarhyde of ''Literature/RedDragon'' as he is his parallel. While both killers seek to transform themselves through their killing, Dolarhyde's goal is to transform himself in spirit and become the culmination of his present state by empowering his "Great Red Dragon" alter, while Bill's goal is to transform himself in body and become the antithesis of his present state by fashioning a GenuineHumanHide suit that would, in his eyes, enable him to become a completely different person.
** Mason Verger of ''Film/{{Hannibal}}'' bears this relationship to Gumb. Gumb is a handsome raving lunatic from a lower-class background who kills on impulse, and has only the most tenuous personal connection to Hannibal Lecter; he also spends most of the movie as the target of a nationwide manhunt after kidnapping a US Senator's daughter. By contrast, Verger is a wealthy, [[WickedCultured cultured]] psychopath with [[NightmareFace gruesome facial mutilations]] who [[TheChessmaster calmly plans his every move]], and he's driven by his desire for revenge against Hannibal Lecter, being one of his previous victims; he's also a textbook VillainWithGoodPublicity who successfully manages to hide his depravities from most of the public, and gets off with community service the one time that he's discovered.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheChroniclesOfNarnia:'' Going by publishing order, [[Literature/TheLionTheWitchAndTheWardrobe the first book]] has a non-human sorceress who bans all humans from Narnia. [[Literature/PrinceCaspian The second]] has a human {{Muggle}} who bans all magical creatures from Narnia.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** ''Literature/TheThrawnTrilogy'' notably frames Grand Admiral Thrawn and Joruus C'baoth as {{Foil}}s of Emperor Palpatine and Darth Vader, respectively, making it clear that the series wouldn't simply be a retread of the Original Trilogy. While Palpatine was an ominous black-cloaked [[CardCarryingVillain card-carrying]] human villain known for his sadism and his mastery of the Dark Side, Thrawn is an impeccably [[WickedCultured cultured]] OfficerAndAGentleman known for his [[TheChessmaster tactical brilliance]] and his love of art, as well as a HumanAlien who habitually dresses in well-tailored [[ManInWhite white military regalia]]. Likewise, while Vader was a tragically corrupted Dark Jedi known for his stoicism and physical discipline, and he ultimately turned against Palpatine in a HeelFaceTurn, C'baoth is the insane [[CloningBlues clone]] of a legendary Jedi Master who's brought down by his own mental instability, and Thrawn turns against ''him'' when it becomes clear that he can't be controlled.

to:

** ''Literature/TheThrawnTrilogy'' notably frames Grand Admiral Thrawn and Joruus C'baoth as {{Foil}}s of Emperor Palpatine and Darth Vader, respectively, making it clear that the series wouldn't simply be a retread of the Original Trilogy. While Palpatine was an ominous black-cloaked [[CardCarryingVillain card-carrying]] human villain known for his sadism and his mastery of the Dark Side, Thrawn is an impeccably [[WickedCultured cultured]] OfficerAndAGentleman known for his [[TheChessmaster tactical brilliance]] and his love of art, as well as a HumanAlien who habitually dresses in well-tailored [[ManInWhite [[LightIsNotGood white military regalia]]. Likewise, while Vader was a tragically corrupted Dark Jedi known for his stoicism and physical discipline, and he ultimately turned against Palpatine in a HeelFaceTurn, C'baoth is the insane [[CloningBlues clone]] of a legendary Jedi Master who's brought down by his own mental instability, and Thrawn turns against ''him'' when it becomes clear that he can't be controlled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It's story arcs, not a sequel


* Near-future epic thriller ''Literature/{{Victoria}}'''s two major story arcs can be roughly divided into "Before the Apocalypse" and "After". The villains are quite different.
** In the first, The heroes fight against the dystopian US federal government, which is immensely powerful in theory, but terminally crippled by corruption, mismanagement, InsaneTrollLogic economic policies and every conceivable sort of PoliticalCorrectnessGoneMad. As far as the raw resources available go, they can easily crush the rebelling states on paper, but given how dysfunctional and increasingly fractured the country is becoming, they can only ever mobilize a fraction of their available forces against them, and often not make effective use even of those due to lack of will, political meddling or passive-aggressive sabotage from within.
** Then, in the post-American chaos, the newly formed free Confederation faces various enemies, but the most serious threats are [[ANaziByAnyOtherName Leader von Braun's]] neo-Nazi Midwestern state, and then the West Coast's [[PeoplesRepublicOfTyranny Democratic Republic of Azania]], which becomes the ultimate "villain" faction. The former is basically the Confederation's own dark mirror image, which takes its Second-Amendment-and-Apple-Pie RightWingMilitiaFanatic style much too far and straight into unambiguously evil (though [[RepressiveButEfficient efficient]]) extremes; the latter, meanwhile, is its ultimate ideological antithesis, a transhumanist LadyLand that spits on Americanism and Christianity. Whereas the Feds were (with some exceptions) usually either incompetent or corrupt, these enemies are rather leaner and meaner, more of the NoNonsenseNemesis and EliteArmy variety, though each in turn in its own way: the Nazis have a truly excellent old-school military establishment, with well-organized logistics, good officers and doctrine and first-rate troops, while Azania has the most advanced systems-integrated military technology in the setting, employing drones, guided missiles, AI assistance for the staff and various other gadgets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

%%%
%%
%% This page has been alphabetized. Please add new examples in the correct order.
%%
%%%
{{Contrasting Sequel Antagonist}}s in literature.
----

* ''Literature/HarryPotter'':
** The series has Lord Voldemort as the consistent BigBad, but each individual book also has its own secondary antagonist whose nature and motivations often say much about the themes and conflict at the heart of each installment. ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndThePhilosophersStone The Philosopher's Stone]]'' has [[TheRenfield Quirinus Quirrel]], the frail and cowardly servant of the crippled Voldemort; ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheChamberOfSecrets The Chamber of Secrets]]'' has "[[FromNobodyToNightmare Tom Riddle]]", the ghostly echo of Voldemort's former self; ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndThePrisonerOfAzkaban The Prisoner of Azkaban]]'' has [[spoiler: [[EvilFormerFriend Peter Pettigrew]]]], the confidant of the Potters who betrayed his friends out of cowardice; ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheGobletOfFire The Goblet of Fire]]'' has [[spoiler: [[WellDoneSonGuy Barty Crouch, Jr.]]]], the troubled young Death Eater initiate who remains faithful to Voldemort in the wake of his downfall; ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix The Order of the Phoenix]]'' has [[TyrantTakesTheHelm Dolores Umbridge]], the corrupt Ministry bureaucrat who denies Voldemort's return; and ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince The Half-Blood Prince]]'' has [[TheRival Draco Malfoy]] and [[spoiler: [[TheAtoner Severus Snape]]]], who finally openly join Voldemort after six years of lurking in the background at Hogwarts.
** The ''Film/FantasticBeastsAndWhereToFindThem'' franchise has Gellert Grindelwald, the world's most powerful Dark Wizard before Voldemort. Voldemort goes by an alias, while Grindelwald uses his real name. Voldemort was a model student at Hogwarts, and hid his true nature from most people, while Grindelwald was known as a troublemaker and expelled from Durmstrang. The Dark Arts twisted Voldemort's appearance, while Grindelwald looks like [[Creator/JohnnyDepp his actor]]. Voldemort kept his reign of terror focused on Britain, [[spoiler: while Grindelwald expanded all across Europe, and into America. As a polar opposite of Voldemort, in this regard, Grindelwald studiously ''avoided'' attacking Britain out of fear of Dumbledore]]. Additionally, Grindelwald lacks Voldemort's FantasticRacism, instead hating {{Muggle}}s purely for forcing wizards into hiding.
* ''Literature/{{Redwall}}'':
** Chronologically speaking, Martin the Warrior's first enemy was Badrang the Tyrant (BigBad of ''Martin the Warrior'') while his second was Tsarmina Greeneyes (BigBad of ''Mossflower''). They make a solid contrast with one another: where Badrang's a jumped-up corsair who wants to be treated like an aristocrat, and whose fearsome reputation as a fighter is belied by his actual record in combat, Tsarmina's a seemingly prissy princess who degenerates into a slavering berserker and gives Martin the fight of his life.
** Mariel, Dandin, and her father Joseph faced, chronologically, Gabool the Wild and then Urgan Nagru the Foxwolf. Gabool was the rightful King of the Searats, was based out of Terramort, far to the northwest, and [[OrcusOnHisThrone never left his island]], spending his time killing his captains and [[SanitySlippage losing his mind]] until the protagonists caught up with him. Foxwolf, conversely, was the usurper king of Southsward, and a far more proactive villain, constantly leading his rats on forays, and trying to put down revolts with his own paws.
** Cluny the Scourge of ''Redwall'' was a conquering warlord who moved across the country like a pestilence, eventually attempting to besiege the titular Abbey and make it into his new fortress before being stopped by Matthias. Slagar the Cruel, of ''Mattimeo'', was a thief and a slaver who stole into the Abbey, kidnapped several of their children, and then ran as fast as he could in the other direction, leaving Matthias to pursue him.
* ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'':
** ''Literature/TheThrawnTrilogy'' notably frames Grand Admiral Thrawn and Joruus C'baoth as {{Foil}}s of Emperor Palpatine and Darth Vader, respectively, making it clear that the series wouldn't simply be a retread of the Original Trilogy. While Palpatine was an ominous black-cloaked [[CardCarryingVillain card-carrying]] human villain known for his sadism and his mastery of the Dark Side, Thrawn is an impeccably [[WickedCultured cultured]] OfficerAndAGentleman known for his [[TheChessmaster tactical brilliance]] and his love of art, as well as a HumanAlien who habitually dresses in well-tailored [[ManInWhite white military regalia]]. Likewise, while Vader was a tragically corrupted Dark Jedi known for his stoicism and physical discipline, and he ultimately turned against Palpatine in a HeelFaceTurn, C'baoth is the insane [[CloningBlues clone]] of a legendary Jedi Master who's brought down by his own mental instability, and Thrawn turns against ''him'' when it becomes clear that he can't be controlled.
** The ''Literature/NewJediOrder'' series frames the Yuuzhan Vong as the antithesis of the Galactic Empire, since it was one of the first series that took place after the New Republic and the Empire signed a peace treaty. The Empire was a technologically advanced [[FantasticRacism human supremacist]] military juggernaut that wanted to impose order on the Galaxy, but was largely staffed by {{Punch Clock Villain}}s, despite being (initially) led by a powerful Sith Lord and his apprentice. By contrast, the Yuuzhan Vong are a race of violent, xenophobic ''aliens'' from outside the Galaxy who view technology as an abomination, preferring to use genetically engineered organic weapons of war; rather than wanting to impose order on the Galaxy, they actively want to slaughter all non-Vong lifeforms and terraform the Galaxy's planets to make new colonies. Rather than being aligned with the Dark Side, they're said to exist outside the Force entirely. And while the Imperials prided themselves on their stoicism and strict military discipline, the Vong are a species of wild-eyed religious fanatics who traditionally practice gruesome self-mutilation as an act of devotion.
*** The Vong's leader, [[GodEmperor Supreme Overlord Shimrra]], also contrasts with Palpatine, as is explicitly pointed out by Luke when he and Shimrra meet. Palpatine is a withered old man, while Shimrra is a [[LargeAndInCharge towering warrior in his physical prime]]; Palpatine has a [[DarkIsEvil darkness motif]] while Shimrra has a [[LightIsNotGood rainbow motif]]; Palpatine was the ruler of the Galaxy Far Far Away while Shimrra rules an outside force trying to take it over; Palpatine came to power by guile, while Shimrra came to power via military coup; Palpatine subverted the Republic to create the Empire, while Shimrra is merely the latest in a thousand-year dynasty of tyrannical Supreme Overlords; Palpatine chiefly relies on his cunning and the power of the Dark Side, while Shimrra is a physically powerful warrior whose enhanced powers come from BioAugmentation rather than the Force and has no problem getting his own hands dirty; Palpatine is well-known to the people of the galaxy as ruler of the Empire, while most non-Vong have barely heard of Shimrra until relatively late in the war; Palpatine spends most of his encounter with Luke trying to turn him to his side, while Shimrra and Luke just duel. [[spoiler: Oh, and Palpatine's actually the Big Bad of the original trilogy, while Shimrra's just a decoy for the ''real'' Big Bad of the New Jedi Order]].
** In ''Literature/LegacyOfTheForce'', Darth Caedus (formerly Jacen Solo) and the Galactic Alliance Guard are deliberately designed to contrast Darth Vader and the Imperial military in the Original Trilogy. Most obviously, Jacen is the hero's ''son'' rather than his father, and the final confrontation is between brother and sister instead of father and son. Caedus also falls to the Dark Side ''after'' [[DividedWeFall a Civil War splits the Galactic Alliance in half]], whereas Darth Vader declared war on the Rebels after he became a Sith Lord. Caedus' private military force, the GAG, are an elite Black Ops squad who do morally questionable work behind the scenes for an otherwise benevolent government; they're more akin to the American NSA than [[PuttingOnTheReich the Nazi military]], which served as the Empire's primary inspiration. Unlike Emperor Palpatine, Caedus' EvilMentor (Lumiya) is a lone Sith warrior who remains separate from the Galactic Alliance, and [[spoiler: she is killed off midway through the series while Caedus' power continues to grow]]. And unlike in the Original Trilogy, Caedus' defeat signals the ''salvation''--not the downfall--of the corrupted Galactic Alliance.
* Near-future epic thriller ''Literature/{{Victoria}}'''s two major story arcs can be roughly divided into "Before the Apocalypse" and "After". The villains are quite different.
** In the first, The heroes fight against the dystopian US federal government, which is immensely powerful in theory, but terminally crippled by corruption, mismanagement, InsaneTrollLogic economic policies and every conceivable sort of PoliticalCorrectnessGoneMad. As far as the raw resources available go, they can easily crush the rebelling states on paper, but given how dysfunctional and increasingly fractured the country is becoming, they can only ever mobilize a fraction of their available forces against them, and often not make effective use even of those due to lack of will, political meddling or passive-aggressive sabotage from within.
** Then, in the post-American chaos, the newly formed free Confederation faces various enemies, but the most serious threats are [[ANaziByAnyOtherName Leader von Braun's]] neo-Nazi Midwestern state, and then the West Coast's [[PeoplesRepublicOfTyranny Democratic Republic of Azania]], which becomes the ultimate "villain" faction. The former is basically the Confederation's own dark mirror image, which takes its Second-Amendment-and-Apple-Pie RightWingMilitiaFanatic style much too far and straight into unambiguously evil (though [[RepressiveButEfficient efficient]]) extremes; the latter, meanwhile, is its ultimate ideological antithesis, a transhumanist LadyLand that spits on Americanism and Christianity. Whereas the Feds were (with some exceptions) usually either incompetent or corrupt, these enemies are rather leaner and meaner, more of the NoNonsenseNemesis and EliteArmy variety, though each in turn in its own way: the Nazis have a truly excellent old-school military establishment, with well-organized logistics, good officers and doctrine and first-rate troops, while Azania has the most advanced systems-integrated military technology in the setting, employing drones, guided missiles, AI assistance for the staff and various other gadgets.

----

Top