Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ComicBook / TheSculptor

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InformedJudaism: Both David are Meg are secular Jews. It doesn't effect their lives much, except that they celebrate Passover and Hanukkah.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LoveAtFirstSight: David falls in love with Meg the minute she descends from the heavens on angel wings (as a piece of performance art but still). Made problematic as (1) she's already in a relationship and (2) she can't stand being objectified. And even when she does end up returning David's feelings, David realizes that his inevitable death would end up breaking her heart.

to:

* LoveAtFirstSight: David falls in love with Meg the minute she descends from the heavens on angel wings (as a piece of performance art but still). Made problematic as (1) she's already in a relationship and (2) she can't stand being objectified.David objectifying her. And even when she does end up returning David's feelings, David realizes that his inevitable death would end up breaking her heart.

Changed: 206

Removed: 64

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LoveAtFirstSight: David falls in love with Meg the minute she descends from the heavens on angel wings (as a piece of performance art but still). Made problematic as (1) she's already in a relationship, (2) she has her own career to look after and (3) [[spoiler: suffers from bipolar disorder]]. And even if the
(3) David is dying, meaning that a successful relationship would

to:

* LoveAtFirstSight: David falls in love with Meg the minute she descends from the heavens on angel wings (as a piece of performance art but still). Made problematic as (1) she's already in a relationship, (2) she has her own career to look after and (3) [[spoiler: suffers from bipolar disorder]]. And even if the
(3) David is dying, meaning that a successful
relationship and (2) she can't stand being objectified. And even when she does end up returning David's feelings, David realizes that his inevitable death would end up breaking her heart.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LoveAtFirstSight: David falls in love with Meg the minute she descends from the heavens on angel wings (as a piece of performance art but still). Made problematic as (1) she's already in a relationship, (2) she has her own career to look after and (3) [[spoiler: suffers from bipolar disorder]]. And even if the
(3) David is dying, meaning that a successful relationship would
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigApplesauce: Most of the story takes place in and around New York City.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KubrickStare: Death. All the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
changed trope link


* MyLifeFlashedBeforeMyEyes: See ChekhovsSkill above.

to:

* MyLifeFlashedBeforeMyEyes: See ChekhovsSkill DyingDream above.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Simplified my Dont Fear The Reaper writeup


* DontFearTheReaper: Death took over the body and personality of David's late uncle Harry after the real Harry died in the war. As a result, he has human compassion. He can feel the weight of every human life he takes, though only as long as Harry still has family in the world. Once David dies, Harry will finally fade from living memory, sending Death back to being an unfeeling force of nature.

to:

* DontFearTheReaper: Death took over the body and personality of David's late uncle Harry after the real Harry died in the war. As a result, he Death-as-Harry has human compassion. He compassion, and he can feel the weight of every human life he takes, though takes. However, this will only last as long as Harry still has family in the world. Once David dies, Harry will finally fade from living memory, sending and Death will go back to being an unfeeling force of nature.

Added: 913

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GayMoment: The hug:
-->'''David''': I love you, Ollie.\\
[{{beat panel}}]]\\
'''David''': In a... strictly, non-sexual... ''manly'' way.\\
'''Ollie''': [crying] ''[[HypocriticalHumor Homo.]]''
* {{Gayngst}}: [[spoiler:Ollie, who admits he doesn't care Finn is using him to further his career because he finds the alternative is DyingAlone.]]
* ItsAllAboutMe: [[spoiler:Ollie screws over a roster of artists, including David ''his oldest friend'', so he can give an exhibition to Finn, the talentless hack Ollie's having sex with. David reminds Ollie he overheard Finn admitting he's using him, before David learns Ollie knows but is tired of being alone.]]



* MagicalQueer: Ollie, David's oldest friend, is a gay character who serves to advise him on his career and manage him. [[spoiler:Later {{subverted}} when it turns out he's clueless enough to sell out David and his integrity for the chance at a relationship.]]



* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Beyond a mention near the ending, [[spoiler:the Russian landlord never reappears after threatening David. Justified in that his presence acts as a plot device to push David into moving in with Meg.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Beyond a mention near the ending, [[spoiler:the Russian landlord never reappears after threatening David. Justified in that his presence acts as a plot device to push David into moving in with Meg.
Meg.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''David''': (beat) I'd give my life.]]

to:

'''David''': (beat) I'd give my life.]]
life.

Added: 2283

Changed: 2091

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:350:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/d067183b9a9db4de1931b605e6d2a267.png]]

->'''Death''': You kids, you're so spoiled! Y'know, billions would kill for a life like that. So what if the art thing didn't work out? Is it really that important?\\
'''David''': It's all I have.\\
'''Death''': [[BeatPanel (beat)]] What would you give for your art, David?\\
'''David''': (beat) I'd give my life.]]



But just as things are at their darkest, David, inadvertently at first, makes a deal with Death itself: to have the ability to sculpt anything he can imagine with his bare hands. Of course, such a deal comes with a price: namely, David will die in exactly 200 days.

to:

But just as things are at their darkest, David, inadvertently David (inadvertently at first, first) makes a deal with Death itself: to have the ability to sculpt anything he can imagine with his bare hands. Of course, such a deal comes with a price: namely, David will die in exactly 200 days.



* AFormYouAreComfortableWith: Death appears as David's great-uncle Harry, as he took over his life when he died in a war and lived a mortal life through him. When he shows David non-existence, however, this falters and his [[GlamourFailure real, skeletal hand can be seen.]]
* AffablyEvil: Death, who is both friendly and comforting to David even though he's a (mostly) unfeeling force, and probably the closest to the story's BigBad.
* BookEnds: [[spoiler:The opening pages act as a FlashForward to David's DyingDream.]]



* DontFearTheReaper: Death took over the body and personality of David's late uncle Harry after the real Harry died in the war. As a result, he has human compassion. He can feel the weight of every human life he takes, though only as long as Harry still has family in the world. Once David dies, Death will go back to being an unfeeling force of nature.
* [[{{EverybodysDeadDave}} Everybody's Dead, David]]: David lost his entire family before the beginning of the story.

to:

* DontFearTheReaper: Death took over the body and personality of David's late uncle Harry after the real Harry died in the war. As a result, he has human compassion. He can feel the weight of every human life he takes, though only as long as Harry still has family in the world. Once David dies, Harry will finally fade from living memory, sending Death will go back to being an unfeeling force of nature.
* [[{{EverybodysDeadDave}} Everybody's Dead, David]]: DownerEnding: Since the premise involves David capping his life at 200 days, you know it isn't going to end well.
* DyingDream: InUniverse, Death indulges that when he has to kill a person, he learns everything there is to know about the soon-to-be-deceased. This operates both ways, giving the dying person a [[MyLifeFlashedBeforeMyEyes full, final look through their life]]
* EmpathicEnvironment: The dramatic thunderstorm for the ending.
* EverybodysDeadDave:
David lost his entire family before the beginning of the story.story.
* LampshadeHanging: There's occasionally chunks of MediumAwareness worked in with Death, such as Death telling David not to become a superhero.
-->'''David''': Hey, if I win a game [of chess], can I live forever and run around saying "I beat death"?\\
'''Death''': No. Though, if it makes you feel better, you can put it on your tombstone.



* ManicPixieDreamGirl: [[{{Reconstruction}} Reconstructed]]. David falls in love in a girl named Meg when she appears to literally fly out of the sky on angel wings to give him hope. The event turns out to be a flash mob prank, but Meg sincerely cares for David after hearing about his problems. While Meg resembles the trope in that she is often energetic, has many random quirks, and is devoted to David's wellbeing, she avoids the trope's pitfalls through being fleshed out. Meg has made a job for herself in helping the homeless, is not flawless, [[spoiler:suffers from depression (made worse by not taking her medication)]], and has her own life with friends outside of David. This is best demonstrated in a speech she gives him towards the end of the comic, where she promises David she'll help make his name great ''but'' she wants her own name great too.\\
\\
Much of Meg's traits that resemble MPDG quirks [[https://twitter.com/ivyratafia/status/567548867109867521 are actually are based on traits of McCloud's own wife Ivy]]. He also responded to the criticism in several interviews, mirroring Nathan Rabin's response that the problem isn't quirky female characters, it's female characters who are nothing but quirks.

to:

* MagicallyBindingContract: David can bend any material with his bare hands and sculpt whatever he can imagine, but on two conditions; firstly, he has no more than 200 days left to live; and secondly, [[spoiler:every time he tells someone about the deal, he loses a further three days off the deal.]]
* ManicPixieDreamGirl: [[{{Reconstruction}} Reconstructed]]. David falls in love in a girl named Meg when she appears to literally fly out of the sky on angel wings to give him hope. The event turns out to be a flash mob prank, but Meg sincerely cares for David after hearing about his problems. While Meg resembles the trope in that she is often energetic, has many random quirks, and is devoted to David's wellbeing, she avoids the trope's pitfalls through being fleshed out. Meg has made a job for herself in helping the homeless, is not flawless, [[spoiler:suffers from depression (made worse by not taking her medication)]], and has her own life with friends outside of David. This is best demonstrated in a speech she gives him towards the end of the comic, where she promises David she'll help make his name great ''but'' she wants her own name great too.\\
\\
too.
**
Much of Meg's traits that resemble MPDG quirks [[https://twitter.com/ivyratafia/status/567548867109867521 are actually are based on traits of McCloud's own wife Ivy]]. He also responded to the criticism in several interviews, mirroring Nathan Rabin's response that the problem isn't quirky female characters, it's female characters who are nothing but quirks.



* NotAfraidToDie: David will do *anything* for his art, and doesn't care that he only has 200 days to live. [[spoiler: He has second thoughts after Meg teaches him how to live life.]]
* OhCrap: David (and most likely the reader's) reaction when he realizes the WhamLine below.

to:

* NotAfraidToDie: David will do *anything* ''anything'' for his art, and doesn't care that he only has 200 days to live. [[spoiler: He has second thoughts after Meg teaches him how to live life.]]
* OhCrap: David (and most likely the reader's) David's reaction when he realizes the WhamLine below.below.
* VillainsOutShopping: Every thousand years, Death takes a semi-vacation by stepping into a dead person's life when they die. Continuing to act as a cosmic force whilst developing human feelings, he keeps this up until the life he took fades from memory; in the case of the story, David is the only living person who knew the real Harry, so Death remains as long as David lives.



-->'''Death''': I've never been to that theater, David. ... [[spoiler: I have an appointment with her in ten minutes at fifty-third and ninth.]]

to:

-->'''Death''': I've [[spoiler:I've never been to that theater, David. ... [[spoiler: I have an appointment with her in ten minutes at fifty-third and ninth.]]]]
* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Beyond a mention near the ending, [[spoiler:the Russian landlord never reappears after threatening David. Justified in that his presence acts as a plot device to push David into moving in with Meg.

----

Added: 353

Removed: 353

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DontFearTheReaper: Death took over the body and personality of David's late uncle Harry after the real Harry died in the war. As a result, he has human compassion. He can feel the weight of every human life he takes, though only as long as Harry still has family in the world. Once David dies, Death will go back to being an unfeeling force of nature.



* DontFearTheReaper: Death took over the body and personality of David's late uncle Harry after the real Harry died in the war. As a result, he has human compassion. He can feel the weight of every human life he takes, though only as long as Harry still has family in the world. Once David dies, Death will go back to being an unfeeling force of nature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NotAfraidToDie: David will do *anything* for his art, and doesn't care that he only has 200 days to live. [[spoiler: He has second thoughts after Meg teaches him how to live life.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DontFearTheReaper: Death took over the body and personality of David's late uncle Harry after the real Harry died in the war. As a result, he has human compassion. He can feel the weight of every human life he takes, though only as long as Harry still has family in the world. Once David dies, Death will go back to being an unfeeling force of nature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Addin\' tropes


* MyLifeFlashedBeforeMyEyes: Death reveals that in the moment someone dies, he takes all their memories and gives them back in chronological order, all at once. [[spoiler: And at the instant of David's death, all of his memories come flooding back, beginning with the moment of his birth and ending with a conversation he had with Meg a few days prior.]]

to:

* MyLifeFlashedBeforeMyEyes: Death reveals that in the moment someone dies, he takes all their memories and gives them back in chronological order, all at once. [[spoiler: And at the instant of David's death, all of his memories come flooding back, beginning with the moment of his birth and ending with a conversation he had with Meg a few days prior.]]See ChekhovsSkill above.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MyLifeFlashedBeforeMyEyes: Death reveals that in the moment someone dies, he takes all their memories and gives them back in chronological order, all at once. [[spoiler: And at the instant of David's death, all of his memories come flooding back, beginning with the moment of his birth and ending with a conversation he had with Meg a few days prior.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[{{EverybodysDeadDave}} Everybody's Dead, David]]: David lost his entire family before the beginning of the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Death''': I've never been to that theater, David. ... [[spoiler: I have an appointment with her in 20 minutes.]]

to:

-->'''Death''': I've never been to that theater, David. ... [[spoiler: I have an appointment with her in 20 minutes.ten minutes at fifty-third and ninth.]]

Added: 1406

Changed: 126

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ManicPixieDreamGirl: [[{{Reconstruction}} Reconstructed]]. David falls in love in a girl named Meg when she appears to literally fly out of the sky on angel wings to give him hope. The event turns out to be a flash mob prank, but Meg sincerely cares for David after hearing about his problems. While Meg resembles the trope in that she is often energetic, has many random quirks, and is devoted to David's wellbeing, she avoids the trope's pitfalls through being fleshed out. Meg has made a job for herself in helping the homeless, is not flawless, [[spoiler:suffers from depression (made worse by not taking her medication)]], and has her own life with friends outside of David. This is best demonstrated in a speech she gives him towards the end of the comic, where she promises David she'll help make his name great ''but'' she wants her own name great too.\\
\\
Much of Meg's traits that resemble MPDG quirks [[https://twitter.com/ivyratafia/status/567548867109867521 are actually are based on traits of McCloud's own wife Ivy]]. He also responded to the criticism in several interviews, mirroring Nathan Rabin's response that the problem isn't quirky female characters, it's female characters who are nothing but quirks.
-->'''[=McCloud=]''': I married the trope — what am I gonna do?



* WhamLine: [[spoiler: Death]]: I've never been to that theater, David. ... [[spoiler: I have an appointment with her in 20 minutes.]]

to:

* WhamLine: [[spoiler: Death]]: After his last chess game with David.
-->'''Death''':
I've never been to that theater, David. ... [[spoiler: I have an appointment with her in 20 minutes.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsSkill: Whenever someone is about to die, Death receives detailed information about the person's life. That way, they can see their life flash before their eyes before they die.



** After the protagonist becomes wanted by the law, the detective assigned to the case is... Detective David Smith. He admits that he was put on this case as a joke by his coworkers.

to:

** After the protagonist becomes wanted by the law, the detective assigned to the case is... Detective David Smith. He admits that he was put on this case as a joke by his coworkers.coworkers.
* OhCrap: David (and most likely the reader's) reaction when he realizes the WhamLine below.
* WhamLine: [[spoiler: Death]]: I've never been to that theater, David. ... [[spoiler: I have an appointment with her in 20 minutes.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CessationOfExistence: Death shows David this, represented as two pages of blank white paper.

to:

* CessationOfExistence: Death shows David this, represented as two pages of blank white paper. David is horrified by the vision, but all he saw was nothing, as his mortal mind can't comprehend itself the absence of itself.



* NamesTheSame:

to:

* NamesTheSame: [[invoked]]NamesTheSame:

Changed: 104

Removed: 302

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChessWithDeath: {{Subverted}} - Death's "vessel", David's late uncle Harry, liked chess, but Death isn't a fan.

to:

* ChessWithDeath: {{Subverted}} - Death's "vessel", David's late uncle Harry, liked chess, but Death isn't a fan. He's still pretty good at it, though, and beats David in every game, [[spoiler:except for their last.]]



* JerkassWoobie: David is an asshole when we first meet him, yelling at a waitress and saying her cousin is a "nobody", but on the other hand his life is more or less in shambles. He continues to be a bit of a dysfunctional jerk as the plot unravels, but still qualifies as this because he's ''dying''.

Added: 332

Changed: 679

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MagicalRealism: David has the power to mould ''concrete'' with his hands - people are more concerned about the damage to property than the fact he has superpowers.
* NamesTheSame: The first chapter is called "The Other David Smith". David gets confused with the ''other'' [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Smith_%28sculptor%29 David Smith]], RealLife Abstract Expressionist sculptor, and becomes quite irate with a waitress who mistakes him for the real-life David Smith, who ''also'' shares his name with her cousin...
** Then there's Detective David Smith. The two Davids discuss this trope briefly towards the end.

to:

* MagicalRealism: David has the power to mould mold ''concrete'' with his hands - people are more concerned about the damage to property than the fact he has superpowers.
* NamesTheSame: NamesTheSame:
**
The first chapter is called "The Other David Smith". David gets confused with the ''other'' [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Smith_%28sculptor%29 David Smith]], RealLife Abstract Expressionist sculptor, and becomes quite irate with a waitress who mistakes him for the real-life David Smith, who ''also'' shares his name with her cousin...
cousin.
** Then there's During David's darkest hour, he looks up his name in a phone book and sees ''dozens'' of David Smiths, making himself feel even more insignificant.
** After the protagonist becomes wanted by the law, the detective assigned to the case is...
Detective David Smith. The two Davids discuss He admits that he was put on this trope briefly towards the end.case as a joke by his coworkers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CessationOfExistence / TheNothingAfterDeath: Death shows David this, represented as two pages of blank white paper.

to:

* CessationOfExistence / TheNothingAfterDeath: CessationOfExistence: Death shows David this, represented as two pages of blank white paper.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NamesTheSame: The first chapter is called "The Other David Smith". David gets confused with the ''other'' [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Smith_%28sculptor%29 David Smith]], RealLife Abstract Expressionist sculptor, and becomes quite irate with a waitress who mistakes him for the real-life David Smith, who ''also'' shares his name with her cousin...

to:

* NamesTheSame: The first chapter is called "The Other David Smith". David gets confused with the ''other'' [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Smith_%28sculptor%29 David Smith]], RealLife Abstract Expressionist sculptor, and becomes quite irate with a waitress who mistakes him for the real-life David Smith, who ''also'' shares his name with her cousin...cousin...
** Then there's Detective David Smith. The two Davids discuss this trope briefly towards the end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MagicalRealism: David has the power to mould ''concrete'' with his hands - people are more concerned about the damage to property than the fact he has superpowers.

to:

* JerkassWoobie: David is an asshole when we first meet him, yelling at a waitress and saying her cousin is a "nobody", but on the other hand his life is more or less in shambles. He continues to be a bit of a dysfunctional jerk as the plot unravels, but still qualifies as this because he's ''dying''.
* MagicalRealism: David has the power to mould ''concrete'' with his hands - people are more concerned about the damage to property than the fact he has superpowers.superpowers.
* NamesTheSame: The first chapter is called "The Other David Smith". David gets confused with the ''other'' [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Smith_%28sculptor%29 David Smith]], RealLife Abstract Expressionist sculptor, and becomes quite irate with a waitress who mistakes him for the real-life David Smith, who ''also'' shares his name with her cousin...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DealWithTheDevil: David makes a deal with Death, though this example is unusual in that Death isn't really a "villainous" character - he seemingly operates on BlueAndOrangeMorality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CessationOfExistence / TheNothingAfterDeath: Death shows David this, represented as two pages of blank white paper.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


With this firm deadline, David struggles to make a name for himself with his art. But, between figuring out just what he wants to create and discovering the love of his life, David's final days will be filled with both success and heartbreak...

to:

With this firm deadline, David struggles to make a name for himself with his art. But, between figuring out just what he wants to create and discovering the love of his life, David's final days will be filled with both success and heartbreak...heartbreak...

!!This graphic novel contains examples of...
* ChessWithDeath: {{Subverted}} - Death's "vessel", David's late uncle Harry, liked chess, but Death isn't a fan.
* MagicalRealism: David has the power to mould ''concrete'' with his hands - people are more concerned about the damage to property than the fact he has superpowers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Figured I\'d start writing this one up, to pave the way for anybody else who wants to contribute

Added DiffLines:

''The Sculptor'' is a 2015 GraphicNovel written and illustrated by Creator/ScottMcCloud.

David Smith is a struggling sculptor living in New York City. In the past year, he has lost a major investor due to some disagreements (and David's own temper with other people), sold exactly zero sculptures, and is at risk of being kicked out of his cheap loft.

But just as things are at their darkest, David, inadvertently at first, makes a deal with Death itself: to have the ability to sculpt anything he can imagine with his bare hands. Of course, such a deal comes with a price: namely, David will die in exactly 200 days.

With this firm deadline, David struggles to make a name for himself with his art. But, between figuring out just what he wants to create and discovering the love of his life, David's final days will be filled with both success and heartbreak...

Top