Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Characters / GoneWithTheWindTara

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The first half of the story's ending and the entire second half of the story is built upon this, as just before the reconstruction of the South, in outrage and defiance, she makes the promise to herself and to God:

to:

** The first half of the story's ending and the entire second half of the story is built upon this, as just before the reconstruction of the South, in outrage and defiance, she makes the now fabled promise to herself and to God:God...

Added: 376

Removed: 363

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixes


* StoppedCaring: She is soft-spoken, shy, obedient and frail, both physically and emotionally, and never loses these traits after the war. After the deaths of her mother, father and beau, she becomes increasingly withdrawn and ends up a nun.



* WomenAreDelicate: She is soft-spoken, shy, obedient and frail, both physically and emotionally, and never loses these traits after the war. After the deaths of her mother, father and beau, she becomes increasingly withdrawn and ends up a nun.



* FoolishHusbandResponsibleWife: Not as prideful as her husband and doesn't see picking cotton as beneath her during times of hardship.



* WomenAreWiser: Not as prideful as her husband and doesn't see picking cotton as beneath her during times of hardship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheReliableOne: Scarlett and the other people in Tara increasingly rely on him during his convalescence, and eventually Scarlett hires him as the nee overseer when she moves to Atlanta. Even the neighbors appreciate his competence and common sense

to:

* TheReliableOne: Scarlett and the other people in Tara increasingly rely on him during his convalescence, and eventually Scarlett hires him as the nee new overseer when she moves to Atlanta. Even the neighbors appreciate his competence and common sense
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*HereditaryWeddingDress: Taking the novel's detail of Scarlett marrying Charles Hamilton in haste and in her mother's wedding dress, costume designer Walter Plunkett went the extra mile by designing a gown twenty years older than the story's 1861 setting, made it to fit Barbara O'Neil (who plays Scarlet's mother Ellen) then altered it to fit Creator/VivienLeigh.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

!!Pork
!!!'''Played By:''' Oscar Polk

Added: 397

Changed: 241

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!Gerald O'Hara



->'''Played by:''' Creator/ThomasMitchell

to:

->'''Played by:''' Creator/ThomasMitchell
!!!'''Played By:''' Creator/ThomasMitchell

The patriarch of the O'Hara family.
----



!!Ellen O'Hara



->'''Played by:''' Barbara [=O'Neil=]

to:

->'''Played by:''' !!!'''Played By:''' Barbara [=O'Neil=]
[=O'Neil=]

The matriach of the O'Hara clan.
----



[[folder:Katie Scarlett O'Hara]]

to:

[[folder:Katie [[folder:Scarlett O'Hara]]
!!Katie
Scarlett O'Hara]]O'Hara



->'''Played by:''' Creator/VivienLeigh

to:

->'''Played by:''' !!!'''Played By:''' Creator/VivienLeigh



[[folder:Susan Elinor "Suellen" O'Hara]]

to:

[[folder:Susan [[folder:Suellen O'Hara]]
!!Susan
Elinor "Suellen" O'Hara]]



->'''Played by:''' Evelyn Keyes

to:

->'''Played by:''' !!!'''Played By:''' Evelyn Keyes



[[folder:Caroline Irene "Carreen" O'Hara]]

to:

[[folder:Caroline [[folder:Carreen O'Hara]]
!!Caroline
Irene "Carreen" O'Hara]]O'Hara



->'''Played by:''' Ann Rutherford

to:

->'''Played by:''' !!!'''Played By:''' Ann Rutherford



->'''Played by:''' Fred Crane

to:

->'''Played by:''' !!Brent Tarleton
!!!'''Played By:'''
Fred Crane






->'''Played by:''' Creator/GeorgeReeves

to:

->'''Played by:''' !!Stuart Tarleton
!!!'''Played By:'''
Creator/GeorgeReeves






!!Mammy



->'''Played by:''' Creator/HattieMcDaniel

to:

->'''Played by:''' !!!'''Played By:''' Creator/HattieMcDaniel






!!Dilcey






!!Prissy



-->'''Played by:''' Thelma 'Butterfly' [=McQueen=]

to:

-->'''Played by:''' !!!'''Played By:''' Thelma 'Butterfly' [=McQueen=]


Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

!!Cookie


Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

!!Jonas Wilkerson
!!!'''Played By:''' Creator/VictorJory


Added DiffLines:

!!Emmie Slattery


Added DiffLines:

!!!'''Played By:''' Isabel Jewell


Added DiffLines:

----


Added DiffLines:

!!Tom Slattery


Added DiffLines:

----


Added DiffLines:

!!Big Sam
!!!'''Played BY:''' Everett Brown


Added DiffLines:

!!Will Benteen

Added: 419

Changed: 103

Removed: 78

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Played by:''' Butterfly [=McQueen=]

to:

-->'''Played by:''' Butterfly Thelma 'Butterfly' [=McQueen=]



* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: After Tony Fontaine murders Jonas for supporting the African-Americans of the South, we never read anything about the recently widowed Emmie's fate. Also counts as some form of KarmaHoudini for not receiving punishment for the death of Ellen.
Well, no, it would be awful to punish for a death she really has no blame for.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: After Tony Fontaine murders Jonas for supporting the African-Americans of the South, we never read anything about the recently widowed Emmie's fate. Also counts as some form of KarmaHoudini for not receiving punishment for the death of Ellen.\nWell, no, it would be awful to punish for a death she really has no blame for.


Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

* DeadpanSnarker: Shows this from time to time.
-->'''Field Hand:''' Quittin' time! Quittin' time!\\
'''Big Sam:''' Who says it's quittin' time?\\
'''Field Hand:''' ''I'' says it's quittin' time!\\
'''Big Sam:''' ''I's'' the foreman. ''I's'' the one who says when it's quittin' time at Tara. ''*{{Beat}}*'' Quittin' time!
* LargeAndInCharge: He's notably larger and more muscular than virtually every other male cast member.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdvertisedExtra: The film's 1998 VHS cover, 2004 four-disc DVD cover, and promotional material throughout the years features an image of a silhouetted couple standing on a hilltop gazing down at Tara plantation. Those either unfamiliar or only vaguely familiar with the film proper are prone to mistakenly conclude that this is a depiction of two lovers - of Scarlett and either Rhett Butler or Ashley Wilkes - when in fact this is an image taken directly from a shot in the film - panning out away from the shadows of Gerald O'Hara and Scarlett overlooking Tara after giving her his speech about land being "the only thing that lasts."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LieBackAndThinkOfEngland: Before that certain night with Rhett, Scarlett never enjoyed sex; she viewed it as "servitude to inexplicable male madness, unshared by females".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ObliviousToLove: Much to Scarlett's irritation, Careen doesn't notice Will's regard for her, nor does the thought of marriage ever occur to her.


Added DiffLines:

* HypercompetantSidekick: He defers to Scarlett as the head of the house while proving much better at farming and trading than her. His coming to Tara relieves a lot of the burden of sustaining the household from Scarlett.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WomanAreDelicate: She is soft-spoken, shy, obedient and frail, and never loses these traits after the war.

to:

* WomanAreDelicate: WomenAreDelicate: She is soft-spoken, shy, obedient and frail, both physically and emotionally, and never loses these traits after the war.war. After the deaths of her mother, father and beau, she becomes increasingly withdrawn and ends up a nun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WomanAreDelicate: She is soft-spoken, shy, obedient and frail, and never loses these traits after the war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IWantMyMommy: After Atlanta is besieged and Scarlett is left to fend for herself and care for Melanie during her long and painful labour, she finally breaks down before Rhett and screams and cries to go home to Tara and Ellen.
--> '''Scarlett:''' "I will go home! You can't stop me! I will go home! I want my mother! I'll kill you if you try to stop me! I will go home!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

->'''Played by:''' Barbara [=O'Neil=]


Added DiffLines:

->'''Played by:''' Evelyn Keyes


Added DiffLines:

->'''Played by:''' Ann Rutherford


Added DiffLines:

->'''Played by:''' Fred Crane


Added DiffLines:

->'''Played by:''' Creator/GeorgeReeves
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* DeterminedWidow: Somewhat different than the usual case in that she ''is'' the hero, and purposely using the inherent sympathy of her situation to manipulate others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Scarlett promised Ashley to take care of Mellie during her pregnancy. Despite Scarlett's various amoral behavior, she does have a warped moral code that she takes very seriously, mostly the result of her upbringing; making a promise is very Serious Business and she prides herself on keeping her word.

to:

** Scarlett promised Ashley to take care of Mellie during her pregnancy. Despite Scarlett's various amoral behavior, she does have a warped moral code that she takes very seriously, mostly the result of her upbringing; making a promise is very Serious Business SeriousBusiness and she prides herself on keeping her word.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ambiguous Disorder is not a trope anymore, but a redirect to a YMMV entry.


* AmbiguousDisorder: She possesses many of the traits of narcissism and also seems to develop post-partum depression after Wade's birth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BookDumb: She is actively stupid in areas that should be common knowledge to her (considering her class, era, and gender). Rhett and Ashley often reference and quote classical works of literature, which fall utterly flat on her.

to:

* BookDumb: She Thanks to her disinterest, she is actively stupid in areas that should be common knowledge to her (considering her class, era, and gender). Rhett and Ashley often reference and quote classical works of literature, which fall utterly flat on her.her--in an early scene, even Charles is embarrassed by her ignorance and hurriedly tries to cover for her. Ironically, she is conversely very adept in things that were considered unladylike at the time, such as mathematics, this time embarrassing Frank--"A woman has no business even knowing what a mortgage is!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralityPet: While she usually treats her fellows white people like trash, she treats black people far more decently, even to the point that Pork, her father's personal servant, told her when she gave him Gerald's watch as a present that if she would have treated white people like that, her life would have been much more pleasant.

to:

* MoralityPet: While she usually treats her fellows fellow white people like trash, she treats black people far more decently, even to the point that Pork, her father's personal servant, told her when she gave him Gerald's watch as a present that if she would have treated white people like that, her life would have been much more pleasant.



* SexlessMarriage: Rhett and Scarlett's marriage becomes this after Bonnie is born, as Scarlett doesn't want anymore children in order to stay looking young and thin for Ashley, and Rhett decides to seek company elsewhere, and then just stays for Bonnie.

to:

* SexlessMarriage: Rhett and Scarlett's marriage becomes this after Bonnie is born, as Scarlett doesn't want anymore any more children in order to stay looking young and thin for Ashley, and Rhett decides to seek company elsewhere, and then just stays for Bonnie.

Added: 144

Changed: 29

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheBabyOfTheBunch: The youngest and the smallest of his five brothers, all of who were at least six foot, while Gerald is only five foot four.



* OneHeadTaller: Described as such in the novel.

to:

* OneHeadTaller: Described as such when compared to her husband in the novel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ProperLady: She is very patient and understanding and was seen as the paragon of what a Southern lady ought to be. Scarlett aspires to be like Ellen someday but ends up discarding her ladylike teachings after the yankees invade and she finds that all the values her mother encouraged such as modesty and gentleness are useless in the new post-war world.

to:

* ProperLady: She is very patient and understanding and was seen as the paragon of what a Southern lady ought to be. Scarlett aspires to be like Ellen someday but ends up discarding her ladylike teachings after the yankees invade and she finds that all the modest and gentle values her mother encouraged such as modesty and gentleness are useless in the new post-war world.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ProperLady: She is very patient and understanding. Scarlett admired her and saw her as the paragon of what a Southern lady ought to be. Deconstrued after the yankees invade and she finds that all the values Ellen encouraged such as modesty and gentleness are useless in the new post-war world.

to:

* ProperLady: She is very patient and understanding. Scarlett admired her understanding and saw her was seen as the paragon of what a Southern lady ought to be. Deconstrued Scarlett aspires to be like Ellen someday but ends up discarding her ladylike teachings after the yankees invade and she finds that all the values Ellen her mother encouraged such as modesty and gentleness are useless in the new post-war world.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CorporalPunishment: When Prissy is complaining about having to pick cotton, Dilcey seizes a cotton stalk and whips her with it. After that Prissy stops complaining quite so much.
* LikeFatherUnlikeSon: She's capable, stoic and dignified whereas Prissy is generally unhelpful, shrill and flighty (though in fairness, Prissy is just a teenager at this time).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ProperLady: She is very patient and understanding. Scarlett saw her as the paragon of what a Southern lady ought to be and aspired to be like her but lacked the motivation to sacrifice her own comfort for others. Deconstrued after the yankees invade and she finds that all the values Ellen encouraged such as modesty and honesty are useless in the face of the collapse of civilisation as she knew it.

to:

* ProperLady: She is very patient and understanding. Scarlett admired her and saw her as the paragon of what a Southern lady ought to be and aspired to be like her but lacked the motivation to sacrifice her own comfort for others. be. Deconstrued after the yankees invade and she finds that all the values Ellen encouraged such as modesty and honesty gentleness are useless in the face of the collapse of civilisation as she knew it.new post-war world.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ProperLady: She is very patient and understanding.

to:

* ProperLady: She is very patient and understanding. Scarlett saw her as the paragon of what a Southern lady ought to be and aspired to be like her but lacked the motivation to sacrifice her own comfort for others. Deconstrued after the yankees invade and she finds that all the values Ellen encouraged such as modesty and honesty are useless in the face of the collapse of civilisation as she knew it.

Changed: 69

Removed: 300

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhiteMansBurden: Believed in the paternalistic racism shared by Melanie that white owners were responsible for the darkies in their care.
--> "Always remember, dear," Ellen had said, "you are responsible for the moral as well as the physical welfare of the darkies God has intrusted to your care. You must realize that they are like children and must be guarded from themselves like children, and you must always set them a good example."

to:

* WhiteMansBurden: Believed in the paternalistic racism shared by Melanie that white owners were responsible for the darkies in their care.
--> "Always remember, dear," Ellen had said, "you are responsible for the moral as well as the physical welfare of the darkies God has intrusted
care, comparing them to your care. You must realize that they are like children and that must be guarded from themselves like children, and you must always set them led by a good moral example."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhiteMan'sBurden: Believed in the paternalistic racism shared by Melanie that white owners were responsible for the darkies in their care.

to:

* WhiteMan'sBurden: WhiteMansBurden: Believed in the paternalistic racism shared by Melanie that white owners were responsible for the darkies in their care.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhiteMan'sBurden: Believed in the paternalistic racism shared by Melanie that white owners were responsible for the darkies in their care.
--> "Always remember, dear," Ellen had said, "you are responsible for the moral as well as the physical welfare of the darkies God has intrusted to your care. You must realize that they are like children and must be guarded from themselves like children, and you must always set them a good example."

Top