Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Analysis / MakenKi

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Near the end, the girls take turns smacking Takeru around the room, causing him to repeatedly change gender each time [[AccidentalKiss he kisses one of them]][[note]]In the manga, the only who hit him was Haruko, in retaliation for molesting her[[/note]].

to:

** Near the end, the girls take turns smacking Takeru around the room, causing him to repeatedly change gender each time [[AccidentalKiss he kisses one of them]][[note]]In the manga, the only who hit him was Haruko, in retaliation for molesting her[[/note]].her[[/note]].
**It ends with Haruko kissing Takeru on the cheek to change him back, once the other girls are gone. Though {{the stinger}} reveals Usui had also been affected by Celia's Inversion and is still a girl[[note]]The manga version ends with the girls finding Takeru and Usui the next morning, after the Inversion has worn off. Since they were all drunk the night before, they're shocked to see them [[http://www.mangatown.com/manga/maken_ki/c037/16.html still wearing the bras and panties Celia had given them]][[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Celia uses Inversion on Takeru in a fit of jealousy, after catching him on the couch with Ms. Aki[[note]]This scene is the biggest change from the manga version. Celia changed Takeru and Usui into girls [[http://www.mangatown.com/manga/maken_ki/c037/11.html for fun]], after they drunkenly barged in on the girls' private get-together at the beach house. And Aki was absent from the chapter, meaning, there was no such scene on the couch[[/note]].

to:

** Celia uses Inversion on Takeru in a fit of jealousy, after catching him on the couch with Ms. Aki[[note]]This scene is the biggest change from the manga version. Celia changed Takeru and Usui into girls [[http://www.mangatown.com/manga/maken_ki/c037/11.html for fun]], after they drunkenly barged in on the girls' private get-together at the beach house. And Aki was absent from the chapter, with Minori, meaning, there was no such scene on the couch[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Near the end, the girls take turns smacking Takeru around the room, causing him to repeatedly change gender each time [[AccidentalKiss he kisses one of them]][[note]]In the manga, the only who hits him was Haruko, in retaliation for molesting her[[/note]].

to:

** Near the end, the girls take turns smacking Takeru around the room, causing him to repeatedly change gender each time [[AccidentalKiss he kisses one of them]][[note]]In the manga, the only who hits hit him was Haruko, in retaliation for molesting her[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The OVA makes the following changes:
** Celia uses Inversion on Takeru in a fit of jealousy, after catching him on the couch with Ms. Aki[[note]]This scene is the biggest change from the manga version, Celia changed Takeru and Usui into girls [[http://www.mangatown.com/manga/maken_ki/c037/11.html for fun]], after they drunkenly barged in on the girls' private get-together at the beach house. And Aki was absent from the chapter, meaning, there was no such scene on the couch[[/note]].

to:

* The OVA loosely adapts the same story, but makes the following changes:
** Celia uses Inversion on Takeru in a fit of jealousy, after catching him on the couch with Ms. Aki[[note]]This scene is the biggest change from the manga version, version. Celia changed Takeru and Usui into girls [[http://www.mangatown.com/manga/maken_ki/c037/11.html for fun]], after they drunkenly barged in on the girls' private get-together at the beach house. And Aki was absent from the chapter, meaning, there was no such scene on the couch[[/note]].

Changed: 333

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Celia uses Inversion on Takeru in a fit of jealousy, after catching him on the couch with Ms. Aki[[note]]Aki was absent from the manga verion, and there was no such scene on the couch[[/note]].
** Adds a bath scene[[note]]the girls had already bathed in chapter 33, which takes place minutes prior to chapter 37[[/note]]
** Changes how Celia's Inversion works, by requiring a girl to kiss Takeru to undo the effect[[note]]This contradicts the manga, since Celia plainly said [[http://www.mangatown.com/manga/maken_ki/c049/7.html the effect wears off on its own, after 30min.]][[/note]]
** Near the end, the girls take turns smacking Takeru around the room, causing him to repeatedly change gender each time [[AccidentalKiss he kisses one of them]][[note]]The only who hits him, is Haruko. Also, {{justified}} since it was in retaliation for molesting her[[/note]].

to:

** Celia uses Inversion on Takeru in a fit of jealousy, after catching him on the couch with Ms. Aki[[note]]Aki Aki[[note]]This scene is the biggest change from the manga version, Celia changed Takeru and Usui into girls [[http://www.mangatown.com/manga/maken_ki/c037/11.html for fun]], after they drunkenly barged in on the girls' private get-together at the beach house. And Aki was absent from the manga verion, and chapter, meaning, there was no such scene on the couch[[/note]].
** Adds a bath scene[[note]]the girls had already bathed in chapter 33, which takes place minutes prior to chapter 37[[/note]]
37[[/note]].
** Changes how Celia's Inversion works, by requiring a girl to kiss Takeru to undo the effect[[note]]This contradicts the manga, since Celia plainly said [[http://www.mangatown.com/manga/maken_ki/c049/7.html the effect wears off on its own, after 30min.]][[/note]]
]][[/note]].
** Near the end, the girls take turns smacking Takeru around the room, causing him to repeatedly change gender each time [[AccidentalKiss he kisses one of them]][[note]]The them]][[note]]In the manga, the only who hits him, is Haruko. Also, {{justified}} since it him was Haruko, in retaliation for molesting her[[/note]].

Changed: 866

Removed: 514

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** '''OVA:''' Celia uses Inversion on Takeru in a fit of jealousy, after catching him on the couch with Ms. Aki.
** '''Manga:''' 1.) Celia used Inversion for fun, when the guys walked in. 2.) Aki was absent from the chapter, 3.) there is no such scene on the couch.
** '''OVA:''' Adds a bath scene.
** '''Manga:''' No bath scene, since the girls had already bathed in chapter 33, which takes place minutes prior to chapter 37.
** '''OVA:''' Changes how Celia's Inversion works, by requiring a girl to kiss Takeru to undo the effect.
** '''Manga:''' Celia says [[http://www.mangatown.com/manga/maken_ki/c049/7.html it wears off on its own, after 30min.]]
** '''OVA:''' Near the end, the girls take turns smacking Takeru around the room, causing him to repeatedly change gender each time [[AccidentalKiss he kisses one of them.]]
** '''Manga:''' The only who hits him, is Haruko. Also, {{justified}} since it was in retaliation for molesting her.

to:

** '''OVA:''' Celia uses Inversion on Takeru in a fit of jealousy, after catching him on the couch with Ms. Aki.
** '''Manga:''' 1.) Celia used Inversion for fun, when the guys walked in. 2.) Aki
Aki[[note]]Aki was absent from the chapter, 3.) manga verion, and there is was no such scene on the couch.
couch[[/note]].
** '''OVA:''' Adds a bath scene.
** '''Manga:''' No bath scene, since the
scene[[note]]the girls had already bathed in chapter 33, which takes place minutes prior to chapter 37.
** '''OVA:''' Changes
37[[/note]]
**Changes
how Celia's Inversion works, by requiring a girl to kiss Takeru to undo the effect.
** '''Manga:'''
effect[[note]]This contradicts the manga, since Celia says plainly said [[http://www.mangatown.com/manga/maken_ki/c049/7.html it the effect wears off on its own, after 30min.]]
** '''OVA:''' Near
]][[/note]]
**Near
the end, the girls take turns smacking Takeru around the room, causing him to repeatedly change gender each time [[AccidentalKiss he kisses one of them.]]
** '''Manga:''' The
them]][[note]]The only who hits him, is Haruko. Also, {{justified}} since it was in retaliation for molesting her.her[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** '''OVA:''' Celia usses Inversion on Takeru in a fit of jealousy, after catching him on the couch with Ms. Aki.

to:

** '''OVA:''' Celia usses uses Inversion on Takeru in a fit of jealousy, after catching him on the couch with Ms. Aki.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Manga:''' In chapter 53, Himegami reveals that Takeru's Blood Pointer ability is proof that he's [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/53/6/ distantly related to her father and brother]], who also possessed it.

to:

* '''Manga:''' In chapter 53, Himegami reveals that Takeru's Blood Pointer ability is proof that he's [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/53/6/ [[http://www.mangatown.com/manga/maken_ki/c053/6.html distantly related to her father and brother]], who also possessed it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Anime:''' The OVA makes the following changes:

to:

* '''Anime:''' The *The OVA makes the following changes:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Anime:''' The entire arc is replaced by a 2-episode finale, in which Haruko is abducted by Otohime Yamato. After being rescued by the Venus Unit, they open a portal for her so she can hurry back to the Academy in order to save it from Takeru, who'd become possessed by his Blood Pointer ability.

to:

* '''Anime:''' The entire arc is replaced by a 2-episode finale, in which Haruko is abducted by Otohime Yamato. After being rescued by the Venus Unit, they open a portal for her so she can hurry back to the Academy in order to save it from Takeru, who'd become possessed by his Blood Pointer ability.ability.

[[AC: Chapter 37]]
*'''Anime:''' The OVA makes the following changes:
**'''OVA:''' Celia usses Inversion on Takeru in a fit of jealousy, after catching him on the couch with Ms. Aki.
**'''Manga:''' 1.) Celia used Inversion for fun, when the guys walked in. 2.) Aki was absent from the chapter, 3.) there is no such scene on the couch.
**'''OVA:''' Adds a bath scene.
**'''Manga:''' No bath scene, since the girls had already bathed in chapter 33, which takes place minutes prior to chapter 37.
**'''OVA:''' Changes how Celia's Inversion works, by requiring a girl to kiss Takeru to undo the effect.
**'''Manga:''' Celia says [[http://www.mangatown.com/manga/maken_ki/c049/7.html it wears off on its own, after 30min.]]
**'''OVA:''' Near the end, the girls take turns smacking Takeru around the room, causing him to repeatedly change gender each time [[AccidentalKiss he kisses one of them.]]
**'''Manga:''' The only who hits him, is Haruko. Also, {{justified}} since it was in retaliation for molesting her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC: Usui]]
* '''Manga:''' He develops a crush on Himegami and spends the majority of the series alternating between perving on her, and trying to woo her.
* '''Anime:''' His interaction with Himegami is minimal and he regards her no differently than any of the other females.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Anime:''' Takeru is changed to being the reincarnation of Himegami's brother.

to:

* '''Anime:''' Takeru is changed to being the reincarnation of Himegami's brother.
brother (episode 4).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Anime:''' She has no plot relevancy, her past is never revealed, and has little involvement with Usui.

to:

* '''Anime:''' She has no plot relevancy, her past is never revealed, and she has little involvement with Usui.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Manga:''' Himegami eventually reveals that Takeru's Blood Pointer ability is proof that he's distantly related to her father and brother, who also possessed it.

to:

* '''Manga:''' In chapter 53, Himegami eventually reveals that Takeru's Blood Pointer ability is proof that he's [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/53/6/ distantly related to her father and brother, brother]], who also possessed it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC: Takeru]]
*'''Manga:''' Himegami eventually reveals that Takeru's Blood Pointer ability is proof that he's distantly related to her father and brother, who also possessed it.
*'''Anime:''' Takeru is changed to being the reincarnation of Himegami's brother.

Added: 28

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!character specific changes



!!Plot related changes

to:

!!Plot !!plot related changes

Added: 817

Changed: 326

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Anime:''' She has no plot relevancy, and has little involvement with Usui.

to:

* '''Anime:''' She has no plot relevancy, her past is never revealed, and has little involvement with Usui.



!!Plot related changes
[[AC: Chapter 8]]
*'''Manga:''' Yuuka prevents Azuki and Yan-Min from fighting by proposing they settle their dispute with a game instead. So she sets up a hockey match in the pool to manipulate both teams into cleaning it. Then set the rules to ensure the match ended in a draw.
*'''Anime:''' They settle it with an indoor volleyball match instead, which served no purpose other than to show off both team's level of power. It ends with Yuuka declaring it a draw, once the gym roof gets destroyed.



* Is omitted from the anime and replaced by a 2-part mini-arc, in which Haruko is abducted by Otohime Yamato. After being rescued by the Venus Unit, she uses a portal to return to Tenbi in order to save it from Takeru, who'd become possessed by his Blood Pointer ability.

to:

* Is omitted from *'''Manga:''' Akaya has the anime Twins capture Himegami, then uses her leverage to coerce Azuki, Haruko, Inaho, and Takeru, to battle the Venus Unit -- so he could assess the Tenbi students' level of ability.
*'''Anime:''' The entire arc is
replaced by a 2-part mini-arc, 2-episode finale, in which Haruko is abducted by Otohime Yamato. After being rescued by the Venus Unit, she uses they open a portal for her so she can hurry back to return to Tenbi the Academy in order to save it from Takeru, who'd become possessed by his Blood Pointer ability.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!Himegami

to:

!!Himegami[[AC: Himegami]]



!!Usui

to:

!!Usui[[AC: Usui]]



!!Takaki

to:

!!Takaki[[AC: Takaki]]



!!Uruchi

to:

!!Uruchi[[AC: Uruchi]]



!!Ms. Aki

to:

!!Ms. Aki[[AC: Ms. Aki]]



!!Otohime

to:

!!Otohime[[AC: Otohime]]



!!the Venus Arc (chapters 14-25)

to:

!!the [[AC: the Venus Arc (chapters 14-25)14-25)]]

Added: 290

Changed: 72

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Manga:''' She [[{{deuteragonist}} drives the plot]], complete with [[CharacterFocus her own character arc]][[note]]starting from the [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/33/25/ end of chapter 33]] and concludes by the start of [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/60/8/ chapter 60]][[/note]] and she's Usui's love interest.

to:

* '''Manga:''' She [[{{deuteragonist}} drives the plot]], plot, complete with [[CharacterFocus her own character arc]][[note]]starting arc[[note]]starting from the [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/33/25/ end of chapter 33]] and concludes by the start of [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/60/8/ chapter 60]][[/note]] and she's Usui's love interest.



* '''Manga:''' She became [[StraightGay a lesbian]] after suffering a traumatic event that left her androphobic.

to:

* '''Manga:''' She became [[StraightGay a lesbian]] lesbian after suffering a traumatic event that left her androphobic.



* '''Manga:''' Her heart (and her loins) are set firmly [[LustObject on Haruko.]]

to:

* '''Manga:''' Her heart (and her loins) are set firmly [[LustObject on Haruko.]]


Added DiffLines:

!!Ms. Aki
*'''Manga:''' She's fully aware of [[LustObject how the male students think of her]] and is shown to be [[IDidntMeanToTurnYouOn self-conscious]] because of it.
*'''Anime:''' Complete 180º, she has no idea -- even when they're blatantly staring at her chest, or looking up her skirt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Manga:''' She [[{{deuteragonist}} drives the plot]], complete with [[CharacterFocus her own character arc]][[note]]starting from the [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/32/25/ end of chapter 33]] and concludes by the start of [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/60/8/ chapter 60]][[/note]] and she's Usui's love interest.

to:

* '''Manga:''' She [[{{deuteragonist}} drives the plot]], complete with [[CharacterFocus her own character arc]][[note]]starting from the [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/32/25/ net/Maken-ki/33/25/ end of chapter 33]] and concludes by the start of [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/60/8/ chapter 60]][[/note]] and she's Usui's love interest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Manga:''' She [[{{deuteragonist}} drives the plot]], complete with [[CharacterFocus her own character arc]][[note]]starting from the [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/32/25/ end of chapter 32]] and concludes by the start of [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/60/8/ chapter 60]][[/note]].
* '''Anime:''' She has no plot relevancy and is simply another haremette.

to:

* '''Manga:''' She [[{{deuteragonist}} drives the plot]], complete with [[CharacterFocus her own character arc]][[note]]starting from the [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/32/25/ end of chapter 32]] 33]] and concludes by the start of [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/60/8/ chapter 60]][[/note]].
60]][[/note]] and she's Usui's love interest.
* '''Anime:''' She has no plot relevancy relevancy, and is simply another haremette.
has little involvement with Usui.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Manga:''' She [[{{deuteragonist}} drives the plot]], complete with [[CharacterFocus her own character arc]], starting from the end of chapter 32 and concludes by the start of chapter 60.

to:

* '''Manga:''' She [[{{deuteragonist}} drives the plot]], complete with [[CharacterFocus her own character arc]], starting arc]][[note]]starting from the [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/32/25/ end of chapter 32 32]] and concludes by the start of [[http://readpanda.net/Maken-ki/60/8/ chapter 60.60]][[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

!!Himegami
*'''Manga:''' She [[{{deuteragonist}} drives the plot]], complete with [[CharacterFocus her own character arc]], starting from the end of chapter 32 and concludes by the start of chapter 60.
*'''Anime:''' She has no plot relevancy and is simply another haremette.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!The Venus arc (chapters 14-25)

to:

!!The !!the Venus arc Arc (chapters 14-25)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!The Venus arc (chapters 14-24)

to:

!!The Venus arc (chapters 14-24)14-25)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Manga:''' He develops a crush on Himegami, shortly after meeting her, and spends the majority of the series alternating between perving on her, and trying to woo her.

to:

* '''Manga:''' He develops a crush on Himegami, shortly after meeting her, Himegami and spends the majority of the series alternating between perving on her, and trying to woo her.



* '''Anime:''' Her phobia is {{downplayed}} to the point of being almost nonexistent, to have her develop a crush on Akaya. It's only referenced indirectly during episode 10 (season 2), in which Yuuka sets her up on a date with Azuki[[note]]who Takaki had [[ItMakesSenseInContext mistaken for a boy]][[/note]] to try to help Takaki face her fear.

to:

* '''Anime:''' Her phobia is {{downplayed}} to the point of being almost nonexistent, to have her develop a crush on instantly become smitten with Akaya. It's only referenced indirectly during episode 10 (season 2), in which Yuuka sets her up on a date with Azuki[[note]]who Takaki had [[ItMakesSenseInContext mistaken for a boy]][[/note]] to try to help Takaki face her fear.



* '''Manga:''' Her heart (and her loins) are firmly set on Haruko.
* '''Anime:''' During season 2, she comes to accept that Haruko is in love with Takeru and gives up trying to pursue her. This doesn't in the manga.

to:

* '''Manga:''' Her heart (and her loins) are set firmly set [[LustObject on Haruko.
Haruko.]]
* '''Anime:''' During season 2, she comes to accept that Haruko is in love with Takeru and gives up trying to pursue her. This doesn't in the manga.
her.



* '''Manga:''' Is indifferent towards Akaya.

to:

* '''Manga:''' Is She's indifferent towards Akaya.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Manga:''' Here, he develops a crush on Himegami, shortly after meeting her, and spends the majority of the series alternating between perving on her, and trying to woo her.

to:

* '''Manga:''' Here, he He develops a crush on Himegami, shortly after meeting her, and spends the majority of the series alternating between perving on her, and trying to woo her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Manga:'''Here, he develops a crush on Himegami, shortly after meeting her, and spends the majority of the series alternating between perving on her, and trying to woo her.

to:

* '''Manga:'''Here, '''Manga:''' Here, he develops a crush on Himegami, shortly after meeting her, and spends the majority of the series alternating between perving on her, and trying to woo her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

The anime differs from the manga, in the way certain characters are portrayed and by substituting filler arcs in place of some of the manga's key story events:
----
!!Usui
*'''Manga:'''Here, he develops a crush on Himegami, shortly after meeting her, and spends the majority of the series alternating between perving on her, and trying to woo her.
*'''Anime:''' His interaction with Himegami is minimal and he regards her no differently than any of the other females.

!!Takaki
*'''Manga:''' She became [[StraightGay a lesbian]] after suffering a traumatic event that left her androphobic.
*'''Anime:''' Her phobia is {{downplayed}} to the point of being almost nonexistent, to have her develop a crush on Akaya. It's only referenced indirectly during episode 10 (season 2), in which Yuuka sets her up on a date with Azuki[[note]]who Takaki had [[ItMakesSenseInContext mistaken for a boy]][[/note]] to try to help Takaki face her fear.

!!Uruchi
*'''Manga:''' Her heart (and her loins) are firmly set on Haruko.
*'''Anime:''' During season 2, she comes to accept that Haruko is in love with Takeru and gives up trying to pursue her. This doesn't in the manga.

!!Otohime
*'''Manga:''' Is indifferent towards Akaya.
*'''Anime:''' For reasons unknown, she's terrified of him.

!!The Venus arc (chapters 14-24)
*Is omitted from the anime and replaced by a 2-part mini-arc, in which Haruko is abducted by Otohime Yamato. After being rescued by the Venus Unit, she uses a portal to return to Tenbi in order to save it from Takeru, who'd become possessed by his Blood Pointer ability.

Top