Follow TV Tropes

Following

History AlternativeCharacterInterpretation / LiveActionTV

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**What about Odo and his kind? Reject from his species that has developed affinity to humanoids and a paranoid race of shapeshifters that hate everything? Or an individualist rebel that favours his own plots to rule the federation over a species that have achieved a truly transhumanist utopia through genetic engineering? I mean, really, say what you want but the dominion's members never killed each other until Odo killed one of them and the races that serve them are willing to do so.

Added: 155

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


****** Also, does Rory's love for Amy border on LovingAShadow? She's (on the surface at least) a beautiful and funny young woman, and Rory is clearly amazed by his good fortune but at times seems completely blind to her flaws. And then he waited 2000 years for her, and that's got to be hard to live up to.

to:

****** Also, does Rory's love for Amy border on LovingAShadow? She's (on the surface at least) a beautiful and funny young woman, and Rory is clearly amazed by his good fortune but at times seems completely blind to her flaws. And then he waited 2000 years for her, and that's got to be hard to live up to. to.
***you kidding me everyone has to have flaw's it makes us human! and also the fact if Rory just left Amy cuz he had to wait that would make him a big jerk!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
she does love Rory.

Added DiffLines:

***though the fact that she kissed him onetime and the othertime was only for work also she does love Rory watch vampire of venice amy choice cold blood the pandorica opens and the bing bang.

Changed: 245

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Howling Mad Murdock of TheATeam: Genuinely crazy to the point of institutionalization, or a talented, eccentric actor with a guaranteed meal ticket?

to:

* Howling Mad Murdock of TheATeam: Genuinely crazy to the point of institutionalization, or a talented, eccentric actor with a guaranteed meal ticket?ticket? Interestingly enough, the [[Film/TheATeam film]] portrays him as perfectly sane during the trial, and the next time we see him, it's in a mental institution. So he was deemed fit to stand trail, but is suddenly unfit during sentencing? Curious.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** I think she did. I half-remember a quote about "Lord, he can be dumb sometimes," but I may be confusing canon with fanfic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Or alternatively yet ''again'', he does feel emotions, but they're purely psychological and he has no way of realizing that he has them. Meaning, he is incapable of identifying a feeling he has as love, anger, sadness, etc., because he has no instinctive physiological reaction when he feels them, and he can't deduce that he can feel emotions either, because he always acts in a logical manner, even if the true motivations for his actions are not logical. Kind of like Spock trying to rationalize caring for Kirk as solely logical interest in the captain's safety, even though it's obvious that the real reason is that he ''likes'' Kirk. Except, of course, that Spock is actively trying to scrounge up a logical excuse for his actions because he doesn't want to admit that he feels emotions, whereas Data can't find any ''illogical'' excuse for his actions, being unable to recognize his emotions when he has them. So the emotion chip just allowed Data's body/sensory system to react to his emotions, it didn't actually give them to him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The episode where Reese gets his own apartment really points to the latter. When he lives on his own he completely turns around, other than mishandling his money (which had nothing to do with his good school performance) and given his nonchalant attitude about the subject with his parent, it seems to be their fault that they neglected to teach him anything about money management in the first place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** The whole reason he was able to do that though was because of inside information about the buy-out provided by Jim because of his relationship with Pam. And the reason Dunder Mifflin wanted to buy them out was because of he took the client list and many of the clients. The client list was a result of Michael's corporate espionage, and essential to taking the clients themselves was Ryan's accounting error which let them think they could charge lower prices. While Michael's is shown being used before to help the company before, those things still don't have much to do with the Michael's ability to manage the branch.

to:

**** The whole reason he was able to do that get their jobs back though was because of inside information about the buy-out provided by Jim because of his relationship with Pam. And the reason Dunder Mifflin wanted to buy them out was because of he took the client list and many of the clients. The client list was a result of Michael's corporate espionage, and essential to taking the clients themselves was Ryan's accounting error which let them think they could charge lower prices. While Michael's is shown being used before to help the company before, those things still don't have much to do with the Michael's ability to manage the branch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** The whole reason he was able to do that though was because of inside information about the buy-out provided by Jim because of his relationship with Pam. And the reason Dunder Mifflin wanted to buy them out was because of he took the client list and many of the clients. The client list was a result of Michael's corporate espionage, and essential to taking the clients themselves was Ryan's accounting error which let them think they could charge lower prices. While Michael's is shown being used before to help the company before, those things still don't have much to do with the Michael's ability to manage the branch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Howling Mad Murdock of TheATeam: Genuinely crazy to the point of institutionalization, or a talented, eccentric actor with a guaranteed meal ticket?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* There are good arguments that both [[HogansHeroes Colonel Klink and Sgt Schultz]] are not as quite as idiotic as they appear. This is especially true for Schultz, who clearly is well aware of some of the activities Hogan's crew is carrying out and actively assists them in some cases.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** From what Bobby said about the John/Sam rift in the fourth season finale, maybe he doesn't have that high of an opinion of John's parenting either.
** Ruby: Before she [[spoiler: died along with Dean in the third season finale]] and came back in the fourth, was she really planning all that stuff in the fourth season [[with Lilith]] since the beginning? Or when [[spoiler: she died]] her personality took a 360 in the middle of seasons 3 & 4? And her relaitonship with Sam; Was she really in love with him or just using him?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Yeah, the key difference there seems to be the POV - person who has to turn into a new man vs the new man he turned into...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Peter Wingfield played Methos, the world's oldest Immortal on the ''Highlander'' TV show. In an interview given shortly before the end of the series' run, he commented that it would make total sense if it were to be revealed that every single thing his character had ever done on the show had been a manipulation to get Duncan MacLeod into a position where he could kill him. Wingfield added that he didn't personally believe this to be the case, but noted that it would fit perfectly with [[MagnificentBastard what we know]] [[RetiredCompleteMonster of the character]], and that he'd have no problem playing such a scene if the writers decided to go that route. In a seperate interview, one of the staff writers claims that the character of Methos was not originally intended to be quite so dark, that Wingfield played the character as having his own agenda, and the writers decided to run with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Kirk''': Mr. Scott, have you always multiplied your repair estimates by a factor of four?
-->'''Scotty''': Certainly sir; how else can I keep my reputation as a miracle worker?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Alternatively yet again, his 'desires' could simply be pre-programmed goals. Data may not feel any actual attachment to his friends, but when an opportunity to make and keep friends comes up, his programming dictates that he choses that option over others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****** Also, does Rory's love for Amy border on LovingAShadow? She's (on the surface at least) a beautiful and funny young woman, and Rory is clearly amazed by his good fortune but at times seems completely blind to her flaws. And then he waited 2000 years for her, and that's got to be hard to live up to.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***** Then on top of that, the show throws the possibility out there it was pure adrenaline and not in character for Amy. And this brings us to Rory- how much does he actually like his relationship with the openly-flirty Amy? Is he just willing to put up with it because he loves her ''that much'', or does he not mind much as long as it stays at the flirting level? In general, series 5 is... ''debatable''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This one actually goes a long way towards explaining Mulder and Scully's tendency to switch believer-skeptic roles when confronted with cases that have a religious basis (unless we just assume that Mulder's skepticism towards Christianity is a combination of being AmbiguouslyJewish and having a DeadLittleSister). One omniscient creator god actually fits much better into Scully's objective reality than it does to Mulder's subjective, anything-weird-goes reality. IIRC, that unofficial fanguide came out long before Agent Doggett showed up, but you could view him as a Subjective Skeptic. Unlike Scully's objective, science-based skepticism, his skepticism is based largely on his personal view of the world combined with his desperate need to believe that [[spoiler: he did all he could to save his kidnapped son and calling in psychics wouldn't have helped save his boy's life./]] If Doggett's skepticism came across at times as more obnoxious and pig-headed than Scully's, that's because it had a deeper personal base. Unfortunately, the writers didn't take pains to establish Reyes as an objectivist believer, which might really have redeemed the character...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/news/tv/la-et-draper-devil-20100723,0,691089.story This "Los Angeles Times" article]] makes a case for [[MadMen Don Draper]] [[EveryoneIsJesusInPurgatory actually being]] ''{{Satan}}''.

to:

* [[http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/news/tv/la-et-draper-devil-20100723,0,691089.story This "Los Angeles Times" article]] makes a case for [[MadMen Don Draper]] [[EveryoneIsJesusInPurgatory actually being]] ''{{Satan}}''.''{{Satan}}'', "lowering everyone's standards a little at a time".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* We're supposed to see the main character of ''TheBigC'' as an uptight woman who becomes liberated by her impending death by incurable cancer; unfortunately quite a few critics see her as a selfish woman who cares so little about her family (ManChild husband and JerkAss [[TeensAreMonsters teen son]]; she doesn't have any friends) that she doesn't bother to explain her abrupt change in character. Everyone else is justified in thinking she's just an incredibly rude person.
* [[http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/news/tv/la-et-draper-devil-20100723,0,691089.story This "Los Angeles Times" article]] makes a case for [[MadMen Don Draper]] [[EveryoneIsJesusInPurgatory actually being]] ''{{Satan}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** In at least a few parts of the world, it was not recognised until the last few years. (I'm looking at you Hampshire, England)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The CharacterDerailment of Jordan's sister, Danni, happened after the death of her brother Ben. It's possible that she's just acting out to deal with her grief.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VeronicaMars'' is [[WildMassGuessing schizophrenic]]. Think about it: in "Kanes and Abel's," she, while fully awake and aware, sees and has an extended conversation with the long-dead Lily Kane. Seeing things and hearing voices is practically the definition of schizophrenia. And she has at least some of the symptoms of paranoia. Plus, she is in her late teens; that is generally the earliest schizophrenia manifests. Also, consider that schizophrenia can often be an inherited condition, and that her mother was an alcoholic. Maybe Lianne Mars was self-medicating for her own symptoms. Lastly, consider what Aaron Echolls says in the season one finale when he has Veronica trapped in the fridge: he goes on this whole rant about Joan of Arc and how the voices she heard were really symptoms of schizophrenia. Why would that occur to him? What if Veronica is a highly organized, high-functioning schizophrenic?

to:

* ''VeronicaMars'' is [[WildMassGuessing schizophrenic]]. Think about it: in "Kanes and Abel's," she, while fully awake and aware, sees and has an extended conversation with the long-dead Lily Lilly Kane. Seeing things and hearing voices is practically the definition of schizophrenia. And she has at least some of the symptoms of paranoia. Plus, she is in her late teens; that is generally the earliest schizophrenia manifests. Also, consider that schizophrenia can often be an inherited condition, and that her mother was an alcoholic. Maybe Lianne Mars was self-medicating for her own symptoms. Lastly, consider what Aaron Echolls says in the season one finale when he has Veronica trapped in the fridge: he goes on this whole rant about Joan of Arc and how the voices she heard were really symptoms of schizophrenia. Why would that occur to him? What if Veronica is a highly organized, high-functioning schizophrenic?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''VeronicaMars'' is [[WildMassGuessing schizophrenic]]. Think about it: in "Kanes and Abel's," she, while fully awake and aware, sees and has an extended conversation with the long-dead Lily Kane. Seeing things and hearing voices is practically the definition of schizophrenia. And she has at least some of the symptoms of paranoia. Plus, she is in her late teens; that is generally the earliest schizophrenia manifests. Also, consider that schizophrenia can often be an inherited condition, and that her mother was an alcoholic. Maybe Lianne Mars was self-medicating for her own symptoms. Lastly, consider what Aaron Echolls says in the season one finale when he has Veronica trapped in the fridge: he goes on this whole rant about Joan of Arc and how the voices she heard were really symptoms of schizophrenia. Why would that occur to him? What if Veronica is a highly organized, high-functioning schizophrenic?

Added: 354

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** In Eric's case though, Red sure isn't the greatest father, how would you take being called dumbass, overbearing and coddling mother and have a whore of a sister that's favored by your father everyday of your life?

to:

*** ** In Eric's case though, Red sure isn't the greatest father, how would you take being called dumbass, overbearing and coddling mother and have a whore of a sister that's favored by your father everyday of your life?life?
** One interpretation of Red is that he really cares about Eric, but he's unhappy with his own mediocre life and doesn't want Eric to turn out the way he did. When Eric wanted to marry Donna, Red kept interfering and making his life miserable. When Eric stood up to him, Red told him that it was a test, to see if Eric had the guts to stand on his own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**About House caring, Wilson claims from the first episode that the real reason House refuses to meet with patients is that, if he does, he'll begin to care about them as human beings, and then he'll hesitate when it comes to ordering the crazy dangerous treatments that are often the only chance to save their lives. About Wilson caring, in the fourth season episode "Frozen," the patient--a psychiatrist trapped in Antarctica and communicating via webcam--remarks on the oddity of Wilson's friendship with House, since the latter has such a bad reputation among his colleagues and the former has "a perfect score." When Wilson asks if she thinks House is secretly a lot nicer than he seems, she replies that she thinks Wilson is secretly a lot less nice than he seems. She qualifies, saying "indescriminate niceness is overrated," [[SoYeah but yeah]].

to:

**About House caring, Wilson claims from the first episode that the real reason House refuses to meet with patients is that, if he does, he'll begin to care about them as human beings, and then he'll hesitate when it comes to ordering the crazy dangerous treatments that are often the only chance to save their lives. About Wilson caring, in the fourth season episode "Frozen," the patient--a psychiatrist trapped in Antarctica and communicating via webcam--remarks on the oddity of Wilson's friendship with House, since the latter has such a bad reputation among his colleagues and the former has "a perfect score." When Wilson asks if she thinks House is secretly a lot nicer than he seems, she replies that she thinks Wilson is secretly a lot less nice than he seems. She qualifies, saying "indescriminate niceness is overrated," [[SoYeah but yeah]].yeah.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Except that he ''WAS'' special all along, he was one of Jacob's Candidates.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The characters on GilligansIsland are the manifestation of the Seven Deadly Sins. Supposedly, creator [[WordOfGod Sherwood Schwartz]] [[http://www.npr.org/blogs/incharacter/2008/01/your_turn_gilligan.html confirmed]] this ACI. Generally: Lust = Ginger, Greed = Mr Howell, Sloth = Mrs Howell, Pride = Professor, Envy = Maryann, Wrath = Skipper, and [[JustEatGilligan Gluttony = Gilligan]], though sometimes Skipper is both Wrath and Sloth or Mrs. Howell is Sloth and Gluttony, ''leaving Gilligan as the red-clad Satan whose Obfuscating Clumsiness keeps them imprisoned on the island!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** And this troper can't help but interpret her as a [[BitchInSheepsClothing horrible]] [[BrokenBird person]] due to that time she tried to seduce the Doctor the night before her wedding ''with her wedding dress hanging on the wardrobe.''

to:

**** And this troper can't help but interpret her as a [[BitchInSheepsClothing horrible]] [[BrokenBird person]] due to that time she tried to seduce the Doctor the night before her wedding ''with her wedding dress hanging on the wardrobe.'''' And does she really deserve Rory's UndyingLoyalty when it takes near-death experiances for her to show him affection, she had a terrible case of cold feet about the wedding and at the end of the series is pretty open to kissing the Doctor in front of him.

Top