History AlternativeCharacterInterpretation / DoctorWho

16th May '17 6:24:08 AM SorPepita
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* The [[MissingEpisode rejected book]] ''Campaign'' exploits this for {{Metafiction}}. Various versions of Ian, Barbara and Susan appear, sometimes even using different names (such as Cliff, Lola and Mandy, or Susan English, or "Dr. Who") or with different professions (one Ian is not a science teacher but a physicist, another Barbara is an art teacher, one Susan is a rocker girl who had a teenage pregnancy, chain-smokes, wears a lot of leather and insists on being called "Sue", and "Tony" and "Amy" are (incestuous) brother and sister. Even within the narrative itself, there are elements of this - for instance, some of the members of the TARDIS crew remember Ian fighting alongside Alexander the Great, genociding innocent people, and have difficulty reconciling this with his usual noble personality. [[MindScrew It's a weird book.]]

to:

* The [[MissingEpisode rejected book]] ''Campaign'' exploits this for {{Metafiction}}. Various versions of Ian, Barbara and Susan appear, sometimes even using different names (such as Cliff, Lola and Mandy, or Susan English, or "Dr. Who") or with different professions (one Ian is not a science teacher but a physicist, another Barbara is an art teacher, one Susan is a rocker girl who had a teenage pregnancy, chain-smokes, wears a lot of leather and insists on being called "Sue", and "Tony" and "Amy" are (incestuous) brother and sister.sister). Even within the narrative itself, there are elements of this - for instance, some of the members of the TARDIS crew remember Ian fighting alongside Alexander the Great, genociding innocent people, and have difficulty reconciling this with his usual noble personality. [[MindScrew It's a weird book.]]
3rd Apr '17 4:07:22 PM CumbersomeTercel
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Regarding Davros: Are the heartfelt conversations in "The Witch's Familiar" between him and the Doctor ''just'' a ruse to trick the Doctor or were there some hints that at least some of them was genuine?

to:

* Regarding Davros: Are the heartfelt conversations in "The "[[Recap/DoctorWhoS35E2TheWitchsFamiliar The Witch's Familiar" Familiar]]" between him and the Doctor ''just'' a ruse to trick the Doctor or were there some hints that at least some of them was genuine?
6th Feb '17 6:41:43 AM Doug86
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** It is confirmed he is the real Rassilon in the novel [[Recap/NewSeriesAdventuresEnginesOfWar "Engines of War"]] though. Although since this is technically part of the DoctorWhoExpandedUniverse and not the television series proper, this one can depend on whether you view the novels as 'canon' or not.

to:

*** It is confirmed he is the real Rassilon in the novel [[Recap/NewSeriesAdventuresEnginesOfWar "Engines of War"]] though. Although since this is technically part of the DoctorWhoExpandedUniverse Franchise/DoctorWhoExpandedUniverse and not the television series proper, this one can depend on whether you view the novels as 'canon' or not.
5th Feb '17 3:40:01 AM Soulreaverdan
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Are Ten's offers of "stop or I'll have to stop you" a genuine attempt to resolve a situation peacefully, or a simple excuse for any future actions that can be waved off with "I gave them a choice"?
24th Jan '17 4:03:15 AM DoctorNemesis
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*** The show itself nods to this interpretation in subsequent episodes; his next incarnation refers to the Tenth Doctor as having "vanity issues" and, notably, faces his own regeneration[=/=]death with much more equanimity.
12th Jan '17 2:32:41 PM skidoo23
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Was the Fourth Doctor asexual or just only into Gallifreyans?

to:

* Was the Fourth Doctor asexual or just only into Gallifreyans?
Gallifreyans? In "City of Death", he made the uncertain statement re: a human woman, "You're a beautiful woman, probably."[[note]]The original script, however, has the Doctor stating this without uncertainty.[[/note]] Yet, in "The Pirate Planet" he unambiguously referred to Romana as being attractive.
14th Dec '16 5:02:45 AM project13Kr
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*** According to [[http://www.warpedfactor.com/2016/12/doctor-who-sympathy-for-devil.html?m=1 this article]], Rassilon may not be a bad guy or at least not as bad as the Doctor would like us to believe.
11th Nov '16 8:43:29 AM HighCrate
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* This carries on with another of Eleven's major companions, River Song. Is she an egotistical psychopath who cares more about herself and the Doctor than doing what's good? Should she be pitied because of his twisting path and timeline which has blasted every possibility of a normal life from her? Is she too dependent on the Doctor to the point where he's her only reason for being, and if that's true, should we interpret this as just part of her character, or [[GirlsNeedRoleModels a bad thing]]? Or considering that she teaches at a university and willingly breaks in and out of prison, is she ''independent'' and free to do as she likes, which occasionally involves the Doctor?

to:

* This carries on with another of Eleven's major companions, River Song. Is she an egotistical psychopath who cares more about herself and the Doctor than doing what's good? Should she be pitied because of his twisting path and timeline which has blasted every possibility of a normal life from her? Is she too dependent on the Doctor to the point where he's her only reason for being, and if that's true, should we interpret this as just part of her character, or [[GirlsNeedRoleModels a bad thing]]? thing? Or considering that she teaches at a university and willingly breaks in and out of prison, is she ''independent'' and free to do as she likes, which occasionally involves the Doctor?
10th Nov '16 2:18:21 AM Sapphirea2
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Given all of the above issues, in Series 8 the Twelfth Doctor seems to be looking back at the Seventh Doctor, who, whether or not you consider him a chessmaster or a joker, certainly was more manipulative and a bit darker than other Doctors. It might be a Scottish thing. He's still a good (as good as the Doctor can get) man, and he still goes to save other planets, etc. but he doesn't have as many qualms about other people's feelings. Truthfully, when the Twelfth Doctor agonizes about whether or not he's a 'good man,' it almost seems like he remembers the times he manipulated other people, ("The Curse of Fenric", anyone?) -- and is terrified he'll end up becoming that again.

to:

* ** Given all of the above issues, in Series 8 the Twelfth Doctor seems to be looking back at the Seventh Doctor, who, whether or not you consider him a chessmaster or a joker, certainly was more manipulative and a bit darker than other Doctors. It might be a Scottish thing. He's still a good (as good as the Doctor can get) man, and he still goes to save other planets, etc. but he doesn't have as many qualms about other people's feelings. Truthfully, when the Twelfth Doctor agonizes about whether or not he's a 'good man,' it almost seems like he remembers the times he manipulated other people, ("The Curse of Fenric", anyone?) -- and is terrified he'll end up becoming that again.


Added DiffLines:

** In the same episode, the denouement has Clara's life saved because [[spoiler: the boy Davros was taught the concept of mercy by the Doctor rescuing him]]. When the Doctor [[spoiler: returns to the past to make that happen]], he says he's doing what he's doing to save his friend. Does he mean Clara, which would fit into his Series 9 actions in general, or [[spoiler: Davros himself]], an interpretation that is foreshadowed by the Doctor's own dialogue in the shorts "Prologue" and "The Doctor's Meditation"? For bonus points, in the course of the episode it's revealed that Dalek language and thought is so limited that "I love you" is one of many phrases that just comes out as "Exterminate". So [[spoiler: when the Doctor says that just before he blasts the handmines]]...
10th Nov '16 2:09:44 AM Sapphirea2
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Series 9: Is his choice in "The Girl Who Died" to save Ashildr in a way that makes her immortal a selfish outgrowth of self-pity, guilt, and grief over all the loss he's experienced in his lives (companions who inevitably leave him, one-shot characters who die in the course of his adventures -- often via helping him...)? Or is it a noble effort to rise above his PragmaticHero tendencies seen most recently in "Before the Flood" (the previous episode), in which he takes special trouble to save a companion but not a one-shot character -- a rescue that's truly holding himself to his chosen title, proving he sees the preciousness of every life and resents the cruel laws of nature that keep striking them down? Or is the act a bit of both motivations?

to:

** Series 9: Is his choice in "The Girl Who Died" to save Ashildr in a way that makes her immortal a selfish outgrowth of self-pity, guilt, and grief self-pity over all the loss he's experienced in his lives (companions who inevitably leave him, one-shot characters who die in the course of his adventures -- often via helping him...)? Or is it him); borne of genuine affection, grief, and guilt for her specifically; '''and/or''' a noble effort to rise above his PragmaticHero tendencies seen most recently in "Before the Flood" (the previous episode), in which he takes special trouble to save a companion but not a one-shot character -- a rescue that's truly holding himself to his chosen title, proving he sees the preciousness of every life and resents the cruel laws of nature that keep striking them down? Or is the act a bit of both motivations?down?



** Was the Doctor as ignorant of the outcome as he says, or did he know what would happen all along and pretended he didn't to pose a SecretTestOfCharacter? In the dialogue where he expresses his inability to see what will happen, he happens to namedrop the exact outcome (the Moon in the future being a different one), is this coincidence or a sign that he knows more than he says?
** Did Clara stop the countdown because she couldn't kill the Moon creature, or to save her own skin - seeing as the Doctor returned only after the bomb would have exploded?
* In [[Recap/DoctorWhoS34E8MummyOnTheOrientExpress "Mummy on the Orient Express"]], did the Doctor really save everyone? Or just Clara and Perkins? How exactly he managed to get everyone into the TARDIS is never shown, and he specifically asks Clara if it's easier to think of him as not heartless.
** His line "would you like to think of me that way? Would that make it easier?" could also be read as "would it be easier (to leave) if you had kept on thinking I'm heartless and do you want me to pretend?" Given Clara's change of heart, she takes it this way. He remembers the names of every person he couldn't save and recites them with emotion in his voice.
** This refers both to this point, the point about the 12th doctor's interpretation, and the Kill the Moon points. The 12th Doctor seems to be looking back at the 7th Doctor, who, whether or not you consider him a chess master or a joker, certainly was more manipulative and a bit darker than other Doctors. It might be a Scottish thing. He's still a good (as good as the Doctor can get) man, and he still goes to save other planets, etc. but he doesn't have as many qualms about other people's feelings.
*** And truthfully, when the 12th Doctor agonizes about whether or not he's a 'good man,' it almost seems like he remembers the times he manipulated other people, (Curse of Fenric, anyone?) and is terrified he'll end up becoming that again.

to:

** Was the Doctor as ignorant of the outcome as he says, or did he know what would happen all along and pretended he didn't to pose a SecretTestOfCharacter? In the dialogue where he expresses his inability to see what will happen, he happens to namedrop the exact outcome (the Moon in the future being a different one), one); is this coincidence or a sign that he knows more than he says?
** Did Clara stop the countdown because she couldn't kill the Moon moon creature, or to save her own skin - -- seeing as the Doctor returned only after the bomb would have exploded?
* In [[Recap/DoctorWhoS34E8MummyOnTheOrientExpress "Mummy on the Orient Express"]], did the Doctor really save everyone? Or just Clara and Perkins? How exactly he managed to get everyone into the TARDIS is never shown, and he specifically asks Clara if it's easier to think of him as not pretending to be heartless.
** His However, the line "would "Would you like to think of me that way? Would that make it easier?" could can also be read as "would "Would it be easier (to leave) leave me) if you had kept on thinking I'm heartless and do you want me to pretend?" Given Clara's change of heart, she takes it this way. He way. It helps that he remembers the names of every person he couldn't save in this story -- and recites them with emotion in his voice.
** This refers both to this point, * Given all of the point about above issues, in Series 8 the 12th doctor's interpretation, and the Kill the Moon points. The 12th Twelfth Doctor seems to be looking back at the 7th Seventh Doctor, who, whether or not you consider him a chess master chessmaster or a joker, certainly was more manipulative and a bit darker than other Doctors. It might be a Scottish thing. He's still a good (as good as the Doctor can get) man, and he still goes to save other planets, etc. but he doesn't have as many qualms about other people's feelings.
*** And truthfully,
feelings. Truthfully, when the 12th Twelfth Doctor agonizes about whether or not he's a 'good man,' it almost seems like he remembers the times he manipulated other people, (Curse ("The Curse of Fenric, Fenric", anyone?) -- and is terrified he'll end up becoming that again.



** Danny's final ReasonYouSuckSpeech - Correct, deserved, understandable bitterness in the face of death and betrayal, the former but [[MurderTheHypotenuse directed at the wrong person]] (in the sense that he should be upset at ''Clara'' for lying and not putting him first), or [[SoreLoser unnecessarily petty]]? Or intentionally being too harsh in an attempt to make the Doctor dial it back, for Clara's safety?

to:

** Danny's final ReasonYouSuckSpeech - -- Correct, deserved, understandable bitterness in the face of death and betrayal, the former but [[MurderTheHypotenuse directed at the wrong person]] (in the sense that he should be upset at ''Clara'' for lying and not putting him first), or [[SoreLoser unnecessarily petty]]? Or intentionally being too harsh in an attempt to make the Doctor dial it back, for Clara's safety?
This list shows the last 10 events of 165. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=AlternativeCharacterInterpretation.DoctorWho