This is discussion archived from a time before the current discussion method was installed.
Working Title: The Ingenue/Horrible judge of character: From YKTTW
Laota: Taking this out, as it really doesn't apply in context:
- In the Pirates Of The Caribbean, Will seems to be the absolute worst judge of character when it comes to Jack.
Will: You cheated!Jack: Pirate.
It's not that Will's a bad judge of character — he knows he's dealing with a pirate and wants to kill Jack, or at least send him to the gallows. If anything, he's judging Jack too harshly in this, based on his understandable pirate-prejudice. But he's naive and rigid, and doesn't yet understand that the rules don't always apply. Will doesn't carry the Idiot Ball, he's just the guy who posed for it. *lol*
