Markup View

Author: Bakazuki

Oct 30th 2012 at 4:45:42 PM

The original YKTTW sponsor of said trope here. The sponsor of ''this'' YKTTW went ahead and initiated on the prospect of merging without any real okay on it save for the few people above, so I felt like I need to say my piece here.

I'm not exactly opposed to a merging of this into LastDisrespects, but I do have few concerns as to what this will mean for the trope should it come to fruition. By merging, would this change the scope of the trope? I created LastDisrespects with the intention of it being a funeral trope, while it has expanded from its original narrow scope of "rude/mean-spirited things people say at funerals" to "rude/mean-spirited things people say ''and do'' at funerals," contrary to my expectations, it still remained in funerals.

A lot of these examples here do ''not'', though, and that's what's troubling me. I can understand the examples taking places at grave sites in lieu of funerals fitting in LastDisrespects, but the rest are related a little too tangentially for my comfort. A lot of them are people doing heinous things to person's corpse after they've successfully killed them, and that sounds like another trope altogether.

But that's my opinion, anyway. I'm certainly not going to argue if you guys ''really'' feel that they should be merged together. Assuming that you guys do, I'd feel like it'd necessitate an entire rewrite of the description (rather than just a copy-and-paste of this into that). So far, what JDogindy wrote in doesn't exactly fit in well with what was there before.