Markup View

Author: WaterBlap

Mar 24th 2017 at 3:51:52 PM

Added a bomb because:
# TropeNamerSyndrome and NeedsABetterName: FiveVictimEnsemble is much better than the list.  Furthermore, the TNS is even in the ''types.''  That is poor description writing, which leads me to...
# NeedsABetterDescription and Administrivia/TypeLabelsAreNotExamples: The "types" need to be changed, regardless of the example format.  However, FiveManBand is a terrible ZeroContextExample magnet just like this one already is.  "The Scholar: Bob.  The Fool: Alice."  These are ZCEs and poor example writing.
# The type labels are confusing.  "The Fool" here (the label) is not TheFool (the trope).

I suggest removing the type labels completely.  Use the tropes we already have.  Then, ''inside'' the description, give an entry example.  Insist that ExampleIndentation rules require that we do not use subbullets.

I don't think that would solve the problem outright, but it is better than nothing.

I think we could take a look at other EnsembleTropes, such as FourElementEnsemble or FourPhilosophyEnsemble, rather than FiveManBand (which has just one or two lines of description for each role).