A Very Potter Musical back to reviews
Comments
They Look Like They're Having Fun. I'm Not.
Clearly a labour of love, by people who really enjoy the original Harry Potter source material, but also an extremely bland retrot of the original characters. The opening song was much more interesting in that Disney Hercules movie, the Americanitis is an acute case (though hardly their fault), but above all, it's just unrewarding to watch. Characters sing about how great Hogwarts is, but nothing funny happens, what few jokes there are seem phoned in or just really generic, and it seems to ride too heavily on recognition. I'm supposed to say "Oh, look, it's Draco, a character I know, and he's a girl now. That's hilarious!" but instead I feel like The Nostalgia Critic, bemused to find Yeardley Smith's voice in We're Back.

I can only advise people to stick to Potter Puppet Pals.
fuck you
165.234.180.5 27th Oct 09
Oh, that's mature...I may vehemently disagree with this review of an amazing show, but really "fuck you"?

Wow...are you really that threatened by a negative review?
67.10.196.218 7th Nov 09
Dude, the joke in Potter Puppet Pals is that Dumbledore gets naked and Harry's a prick. And you think that's much better than AVPM?
128.194.70.102 15th Nov 09
Okay, okay, settle down. Man without a body is entitled to hisopinion and has explained why he came to that descision. That's what a review is meant to do. If you like the potter musical you still fully entitled to do that too.
wellinever 15th Nov 09
back to reviews
Add a comment