Follow TV Tropes

Reviews Literature / The Wise Mans Fear

Go To

phylos Since: Nov, 2013
01/10/2016 06:14:47 •••

Entirely too much of fairy dalliances and european tai chi.

When Kvothe said in the first book that he had spent a night with Felurian and walked away with his life and his sanity I sure as hell didn't expect that "night" to be so boring. How did Rothfuss manage to make endless sex with a fairy goddess boring anyway? Now that's a question.

When Kvothe said in the first book that he had learned to fight with the Adem I sure as hell didn't expect the Adem to be such insufferable morons. Why did Rothfuss try to present as perfect a group of idiots full of backwards-thinking? Now that's a question.

The chase of the bandits dragged on a bit too, but it gets a pass because it culminated with the best moment of the series so far.

Amusingly, of this book's side quests the one I found most compelling was the one that seemed most boring on paper: Kvothe navigating the intricacies of a court. Maybe a testament to my sensibilities.

Still, all of the subplots mostly unrelated to the main plot are a detriment to the book's pacing. For all of his skills at myth building, Rothfuss's world building is not quite smooth. While The Name of the Wind is a breeze to read, this one feels like a chore at times.

Anyways, as with TNOTW, this book's best asset continues to be the inner mythology, which thankfully gets expanded quite a bit here. Mostly Iax and the Cthaeh's deals.

Hopefully, the lack of anything happening in this one means that the third one will be a thrill ride. One can dream.

And, hey, that pest Bast got slapped twice and it was cathartic. That's something.

HappyMan (4 Score & 7 Years Ago)
01/10/2016 00:00:00

The part with Felurian was just unneccesarily long and boring. But the part with the Adem...dear Tehlu, that had to be the single worst part of both books. Basically, Mary Suetopia plus Can't Argue with Elves completely Up to Eleven. Not to mention that their "perfect society" makes absolutely no sense.

And people complained about the romantic subplot with Denna...


Leave a Comment:

Top