I am you
Would, in your opinion, the interaction of Ahsoka and Sabine qualify as Ho Yay and would Baylan and Shin be Evil Is Cool?
Hide / Show Replies
I got a response and complaint from simonarwas reminding me trope descriptions before adding examples over my Unintentionally Unsympathetic post regarding Sabine's behavior involving handing Baylon the Map, refusing to tell Ezra the truth about that factor and not showing enough regret over her actions. My bad. I should remember to consult before editing, that way there would be no problems. Please excuse me, I'm new at this and I need to learn my way around here. Hopefully next time, I'll ask premision before I do anything. That way, everything will be fine and hopefully there would be no problems in the future.
This example, added by me, was hidden:
- Questionable Casting: Ariana Greenblatt as Young Ahsoka. Her voice sounds nothing like that of Ashley Eckstein. As for her physical appearance: she was 14–15 years old during filming, the same as Ahsoka at the beginning of the Clone Wars, so her portrayal Siege-of-Mandalore Ahsoka (age 17) looked very strange and uncanny.
- Style/tone of writing
- Vocal dissonance is to be expected
- Physical appearance dissonance may be intentional, to support Child Soldier depiction
- Many entries on this wiki are written in a less-neutral tone. See [1]
for a list of examples.
- This series (and for that matter, Dave Filoni Star Wars as a whole) contains several characters carried between animation and live action. All of them – Adult Ahsoka, Sabine, Hera – do a far better job with the voices than Young Ahsoka.
- There is no direct evidence to suggest that the physical-appearance dissonance was intentional.
Is Anakin's digital de-aging really an Improved Second Attempt? I'm checking the reactions on social media and they seem mixed, with some loving it but others criticizing the quality of the CGI or finding it unnecessary.
Hide / Show Replies
I mean while people are debating it most seem to agree that it is better than it was before in my experience.
Fan-Preferred Couple cleanup thread
Yeah, that's what I saw as well. It's mixed, but a few more people seem to like the deaged Anakin.
Trust no one.
I had deleted the example, but in this case I'll put it back. I will point out that the reactions remain mixed, but still lean more towards the positive.
Now that 6 months have passed any ideas for Broken Base or Base-Breaking Character entries