Music Gotye Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics
 

blackcat
Topic
06:40:43 AM Nov 24th 2012
Moderator speaking I am moving this example here for purposes of discussion. Please note that as identified on the wiki YouTube Poop is currently described as a work. If you wish to change the definition you need to start a thread to discuss it on the forum. Continuing to edit war over this example will result in a suspension of edit privileges.

troacctid
11:08:55 AM Nov 24th 2012
  1. Youtube Poop is not a trope
  2. Gotye isn't the one making it

Definitely doesn't belong here. You could put it on the trope page for whoever made the Youtube Poop in question, but not on the trope page for the source material.
Akriloth2160
01:28:22 AM Nov 25th 2012
edited by Akriloth2160
I've had a short PM chat with the person who started reverting my edits, and yes, he's right. Although I still question the way the wiki treats Youtube Poop as a work, seeing as it doesn't have a set universe or creator (As well as the fact that I still think the whole "it has examples of tropes therefore it's a work" reason is a little arbitrary), I still own up to acting completely off-base with reverting those edits repeatedly. I understand now that it's a simple error, and I was wrong to act like that. Sorry!
Collapse/Expand Topics