Discussion BrokenBase / Persona5

I know I asked this before but would the Third Semester as a whole count? Not necessarily active in the fandom but I’ve seen divide on people who think it’s the best that adds emotion to the story and those who think it’s badly written that doesn’t fit the game’s theme.

I’m not nearly as active in the fandom but would the Third Semester overall count? I’ve seen some people dislike it for supposedly undermining what the Phatom Thieves stand for (Such as letting Akechi rejoin the team, despite the fact that he murdered people) along with others sayin that it doesn’t fit the story and is cash grabbing while another group says they like the story for being interesting, emotional and relatable.