[001]
173.48.237.100
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
\
to:
\\\"Just because their respective trope pages are gone doesn\\\'t mean they have to be as well.\\\"
That was the precedent set for removal back with Rance and Kengo Inui.
Plus, that doesn\\\'t address my point that Rose\\\'s reintroduction undermines Ebony\\\'s ascension to Archmage. It also feels like AnonFangeekGirl doesn\\\'t really care much for what others had established before, as none of what she wrote about Rose matches what she originally was before her removal.
* 1. Her titles: Rose was originally Goddess of CanonDefilement, NewPowersAsThePlotDemands (Now belonging to the kind of forced Leif), and [[NewPowersAsThePlotDemands Unnecessary Nudity]] none of which were kept in the transition.
* 2. Her power level. Pre-banishment she was an Overdeity within her own Temple and had to be contained in that temple to allow her powers to be siphoned. Now she\\\'s just a Demigoddess with no reference to stripping her power from her. In fact, she\\\'s now being use to depower OTHER dieties
* 3. Enemies: Baffling is that she chose Ron and Hermione despite the fact that TGWL is the probably the least Harmonian thing I can remember. Meanwhile, pre-banishment her enemies including ALL HP characters, Rowling and the PPC.
* 4. The Flavor Text: The older flavor text used a lot more details from the fic, bringing up her understandings of \\\"love\\\" and just how dangerous the Druids were. Along with that, her nicknames were actually there.
* 5. Ebony: Again, her and Ebony were both Mages and when she got banished, Ebony took full power. Not only does having her come back undermine Ebony\\\'s position, it also undermines the fact that Rose was hinted at betraying Ebony at some point to gain power.
As for Edfred, he feels like a less than ideal choice for God of MarySueHunters. Ronan\\\'s gone so he doesn\\\'t have much point in that role and really, he was a one-chapter Deus Ex Machina while the PPC are a full-blown organization of Agents with clearly defined rules and regulations for capture and killing, and were the ones who codified it.
That was the precedent set for removal back with Rance and Kengo Inui.
Plus, that doesn\\\'t address my point that Rose\\\'s reintroduction undermines Ebony\\\'s ascension to Archmage. It also feels like AnonFangeekGirl doesn\\\'t really care much for what others had established before, as none of what she wrote about Rose matches what she originally was before her removal.
* 1. Her titles: Rose was originally Goddess of CanonDefilement, NewPowersAsThePlotDemands (Now belonging to the kind of forced Leif), and [[NewPowersAsThePlotDemands Unnecessary Nudity]] none of which were kept in the transition.
* 2. Her power level. Pre-banishment she was an Overdeity within her own Temple and had to be contained in that temple to allow her powers to be siphoned. Now she\\\'s just a Demigoddess with no reference to stripping her power from her. In fact, she\\\'s now being use to depower OTHER dieties
* 3. Enemies: Baffling is that she chose Ron and Hermione despite the fact that TGWL is the probably the least Harmonian thing I can remember. Meanwhile, pre-banishment her enemies including ALL HP characters, Rowling and the PPC.
* 4. The Flavor Text: The older flavor text used a lot more details from the fic, bringing up her understandings of \\\"love\\\" and just how dangerous the Druids were. Along with that, her nicknames were actually there.
* 5. Ebony: Again, her and Ebony were both Mages and when she got banished, Ebony took full power. Not only does having her come back undermine Ebony\\\'s position, it also undermines the fact that Rose was hinted at betraying Ebony at some point to gain power.
As for Edfred, he feels like a less than ideal choice for God of MarySueHunters. Ronan\\\'s gone so he doesn\\\'t have much point in that role and really, he was a one-chapter Deus Ex Machina while the PPC are a full-blown organization of Agents with clearly defined rules and regulations for capture and killing, and were the ones who codified it.
