Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Webcomic / Homestuck

Go To

[009] SamMax Current Version
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
*\
to:
*\\\"This is contradicted by Professor E. Gadd\\\'s appearance in \\\'\\\'Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time\\\'\\\', making reference to \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion\\\'\\\', as well as references between \\\'\\\'{{Super Mario Sunshine}}\\\'\\\', \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion}}, and \\\'\\\'{{Super Mario World}}\\\'\\\'. Also, a Hammer Bro in \\\'\\\'Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door\\\'\\\' mentions his grandfather being in World 7-1 of \\\'\\\'Super Mario Bros.\\\'\\\'
*** A character in a spin-off who was also in a main game doesn\\\'t make the spin-off canon. If that was true, Mario would be the most obvious indicator, not E. Gadd. The Hammer Bro mentioning World 7-1 doesn\\\'t make the game canon either. It\\\'s like saying PM is canon because one of Mario\\\'s main attacks is jumping on enemies like he did in the canonical games.\\\"

As he pointed out, a character appearing in the main games \\\'\\\'and\\\'\\\' the spinoff games does not really make it canon. Neither do references to past games. Still needed to be removed because of the {{Natter}}, though.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
*\
to:
*\\\"This is contradicted by Professor E. Gadd\\\'s appearance in \\\'\\\'Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time\\\'\\\', making reference to \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion\\\'\\\', as well as references between \\\'\\\'{{Super Mario Sunshine}}\\\'\\\', \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion}}, and \\\'\\\'{{Super Mario World}}\\\'\\\'. Also, a Hammer Bro in \\\'\\\'{{Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door}}\\\'\\\' mentions his grandfather being in World 7-1 of \\\'\\\'{{Super Mario Bros.}}\\\'\\\'
*** A character in a spin-off who was also in a main game doesn\\\'t make the spin-off canon. If that was true, Mario would be the most obvious indicator, not E. Gadd. The Hammer Bro mentioning World 7-1 doesn\\\'t make the game canon either. It\\\'s like saying PM is canon because one of Mario\\\'s main attacks is jumping on enemies like he did in the canonical games.\\\"

As he pointed out, a character appearing in the main games \\\'\\\'and\\\'\\\' the spinoff games does not really make it canon. Neither do references to past games. Still needed to be removed because of the {{Natter}}, though.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
*\
to:
*\\\"This is contradicted by Professor E. Gadd\\\'s appearance in \\\'\\\'Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time\\\'\\\', making reference to \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion\\\'\\\', as well as references between \\\'\\\'{{Super Mario Sunshine}}\\\'\\\', \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion}}, and \\\'\\\'{{Super Mario World}}\\\'\\\'. Also, a Hammer Bro in \\\'\\\'{{Paper Mario}}: The Thousand-Year Door\\\'\\\' mentions his grandfather being in World 7-1 of \\\'\\\'{{Super Mario Bros.}}\\\'\\\'
*** A character in a spin-off who was also in a main game doesn\\\'t make the spin-off canon. If that was true, Mario would be the most obvious indicator, not E. Gadd. The Hammer Bro mentioning World 7-1 doesn\\\'t make the game canon either. It\\\'s like saying PM is canon because one of Mario\\\'s main attacks is jumping on enemies like he did in the canonical games.\\\"

As he pointed out, a character appearing in the main games \\\'\\\'and\\\'\\\' the spinoff games does not really make it canon. Neither do references to past games. Still needed to be removed because of the {{Natter}}, though.
Changed line(s) 2 from:
n
*\
to:
*\\\"This is contradicted by Professor E. Gadd\\\'s appearance in \\\'\\\'{{Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time}}\\\'\\\', making reference to \\\'\\\'{{Luigi\\\'s Mansion}}\\\'\\\', as well as references between \\\'\\\'{{Super Mario Sunshine}}\\\'\\\', \\\'\\\'{{Luigi\\\'s Mansion}}\\\'\\\', and \\\'\\\'{{Super Mario World}}\\\'\\\'. Also, a Hammer Bro in \\\'\\\'Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door\\\'\\\' mentions his grandfather being in World 7-1 of \\\'\\\'{{Super Mario Bros.}}\\\'\\\'
*** A character in a spin-off who was also in a main game doesn\\\'t make the spin-off canon. If that was true, Mario would be the most obvious indicator, not E. Gadd. The Hammer Bro mentioning World 7-1 doesn\\\'t make the game canon either. It\\\'s like saying PM is canon because one of Mario\\\'s main attacks is jumping on enemies like he did in the canonical games.\\\"

As he pointed out, a character appearing in the main games \\\'\\\'and\\\'\\\' the spinoff games does not really make it canon. Neither do references to past games. Still needed to be removed because of the {{Natter}}, though.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I removed this from the article due to the {{Natter}} going on. Paste it back if you must.
*\
to:
I removed this from the article due to the {{Natter}} going on. Paste it back if you must. Oh, and this is in regards to whether or not the spinoff games of the {{Super Mario}} series are canon.
*\\\"This is contradicted by Professor E. Gadd\\\'s appearance in \\\'\\\'Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time\\\'\\\', making reference to \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion\\\'\\\', as well as references between \\\'\\\'Super Mario Sunshine\\\'\\\', \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion\\\'\\\', and \\\'\\\'Super Mario World\\\'\\\'. Also, a Hammer Bro in \\\'\\\'Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door\\\'\\\' mentions his grandfather being in World 7-1 of \\\'\\\'Super Mario Bros.\\\'\\\'
*** A character in a spin-off who was also in a main game doesn\\\'t make the spin-off canon. If that was true, Mario would be the most obvious indicator, not E. Gadd. The Hammer Bro mentioning World 7-1 doesn\\\'t make the game canon either. It\\\'s like saying PM is canon because one of Mario\\\'s main attacks is jumping on enemies like he did in the canonical games.\\\"

As he pointed out, a character appearing in the main games \\\'\\\'\\\'and\\\'\\\'\\\' the spinoff games does not really make it canon. Still needed to be removed because of the unneded information though.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I removed this from the article due to what appears to be unneeded information for this article that does not add to much. Paste it back if you must. Oh, and this is about the Mario game canon in regard to the {{spinoff}} titles. Paste it back if you must.
to:
I removed this from the article due to the {{Natter}} going on. Paste it back if you must.
*\\\"This is contradicted by Professor E. Gadd\\\'s appearance in \\\'\\\'Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time\\\'\\\', making reference to \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion\\\'\\\', as well as references between \\\'\\\'Super Mario Sunshine\\\'\\\', \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion\\\'\\\', and \\\'\\\'Super Mario World\\\'\\\'. Also, a Hammer Bro in \\\'\\\'Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door\\\'\\\' mentions his grandfather being in World 7-1 of \\\'\\\'Super Mario Bros.\\\'\\\'
*** A character in a spin-off who was also in a main game doesn\\\'t make the spin-off canon. If that was true, Mario would be the most obvious indicator, not E. Gadd. The Hammer Bro mentioning World 7-1 doesn\\\'t make the game canon either. It\\\'s like saying PM is canon because one of Mario\\\'s main attacks is jumping on enemies like he did in the canonical games.\\\"
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
*\
to:
As he pointed out, a character appearing in the main games \\\'\\\'\\\'and\\\'\\\'\\\' the spinoff games does not really make it canon. Still needed to be removed because of the unneded information though.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I removed this from the article due to what appears to be unneeded for this article. that does not add to much. Paste it back if you must. Oh, and this is about the Mario game canon in regard to the {{spinoff}} titles. Paste it back if you must.
to:
I removed this from the article due to what appears to be unneeded information for this article that does not add to much. Paste it back if you must. Oh, and this is about the Mario game canon in regard to the {{spinoff}} titles. Paste it back if you must.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
*\
to:
*\\\"This is contradicted by Professor E. Gadd\\\'s appearance in \\\'\\\'Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time\\\'\\\', making reference to \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion\\\'\\\', as well as references between \\\'\\\'Super Mario Sunshine\\\'\\\', \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion\\\'\\\', and \\\'\\\'Super Mario World\\\'\\\'. Also, a Hammer Bro in \\\'\\\'Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door\\\'\\\' mentions his grandfather being in World 7-1 of \\\'\\\'Super Mario Bros.\\\'\\\'
*** A character in a spin-off who was also in a main game doesn\\\'t make the spin-off canon. If that was true, Mario would be the most obvious indicator, not E. Gadd. The Hammer Bro mentioning World 7-1 doesn\\\'t make the game canon either. It\\\'s like saying PM is canon because one of Mario\\\'s main attacks is jumping on enemies like he did in the canonical games.\\\"

As he pointed out, a character appearing in the main games \\\'\\\'\\\'and\\\'\\\'\\\' the spinoff games does not really make it canon. Still needed to be removed because of the unneded information though.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
\
to:
*\\\"This is contradicted by Professor E. Gadd\\\'s appearance in \\\'\\\'Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time\\\'\\\', making reference to \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion\\\'\\\', as well as references between \\\'\\\'Super Mario Sunshine\\\'\\\', \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion\\\'\\\', and \\\'\\\'Super Mario World\\\'\\\'. Also, a Hammer Bro in \\\'\\\'Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door\\\'\\\' mentions his grandfather being in World 7-1 of \\\'\\\'Super Mario Bros.\\\'\\\'
*** A character in a spin-off who was also in a main game doesn\\\'t make the spin-off canon. If that was true, Mario would be the most obvious indicator, not E. Gadd. The Hammer Bro mentioning World 7-1 doesn\\\'t make the game canon either. It\\\'s like saying PM is canon because one of Mario\\\'s main attacks is jumping on enemies like he did in the canonical games.\\\"

As he pointed out, a character appearing in the main games \\\'\\\'\\\'and\\\'\\\'\\\' the spinoff games does not really make it canon. Still needed to be removed because of the unneded information though.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
\
to:
\\\"*This is contradicted by Professor E. Gadd\\\'s appearance in \\\'\\\'Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time\\\'\\\', making reference to \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion\\\'\\\', as well as references between \\\'\\\'Super Mario Sunshine\\\'\\\', \\\'\\\'Luigi\\\'s Mansion\\\'\\\', and \\\'\\\'Super Mario World\\\'\\\'. Also, a Hammer Bro in \\\'\\\'Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door\\\'\\\' mentions his grandfather being in World 7-1 of \\\'\\\'Super Mario Bros.\\\'\\\'
*** A character in a spin-off who was also in a main game doesn\\\'t make the spin-off canon. If that was true, Mario would be the most obvious indicator, not E. Gadd. The Hammer Bro mentioning World 7-1 doesn\\\'t make the game canon either. It\\\'s like saying PM is canon because one of Mario\\\'s main attacks is jumping on enemies like he did in the canonical games.\\\"

As he pointed out, a character appearing in the main games \\\'\\\'\\\'and\\\'\\\'\\\' the spinoff games does not really make it canon. Still needed to be removed because of the unneded information though.
Top