Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / Arrow

Go To

[001] Johnpit Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
TheScrappy section has gotten pretty big and I feel it needs some trimming. I've made it a discussion item rather than outright changing it because I anticipate that some will disagree with whom is or isn't a Scrappy.
to:
TheScrappy section has gotten pretty big and I feel it needs some trimming. I\'ve made it a discussion item rather than outright changing it because I anticipate that some will disagree with whom is or isn\'t a Scrappy.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
*The Huntress: she hasn't been seen since Season 2 and all of her appearances in the show can be counted on one hand. If what is written under VindicatedByHistory is accurete, the fans are willing to give this incarnation of Huntress another chance.
*The FBI lady: Yeah, she's a bitch. But we're not supposed to like her either. Trope for characters like this are InspectorJavert and HateSink.
*The Olicity shipping neighbors: I don't like them either, but they've only made very few appearances that I cannot even count them as real characters.
to:
*The Huntress: she hasn\'t been seen since Season 2 and all of her appearances in the show can be counted on one hand. If what is written under VindicatedByHistory is accurete, the fans are willing to give this incarnation of Huntress another chance.
*The FBI lady: Yeah, she\'s a bitch. But we\'re not supposed to like her either. Trope for characters like this are InspectorJavert and HateSink.
*The Olicity shipping neighbors: I don\'t like them either, but they\'ve only made very few appearances that I cannot even count them as real characters.
Changed line(s) 10 from:
n
Felicity: Is there a way to simplify the current paragraphs?
Ra's al Ghul: he had potential, but BadassDecay set in.
William: he's a living plot device than an actual character.
Dinah: I do not hate her personally, but she is a ReplacementScrappy and the writers poor attempt at damage control for Laurel's death.
to:
*Felicity: Is there a way to simplify the current paragraphs?
*Ra\'s al Ghul: he had potential, but BadassDecay set in.
*William: he\'s a living plot device than an actual character.
*Dinah: I do not hate her personally, but she is a ReplacementScrappy and the writers poor attempt at damage control for Laurel\'s death.
Changed line(s) 16 from:
n
Andy: his character was off putting because of how inconsistent the writers were. John and his family spoke of him as a really cool and amazing person back in season 1. What we got onscreen in season 4 wasn't and his evil deeds came across as narmy. In the end, the viewers weren't meant to mourn him.
Rene: he was a Scrappy in early season 5, then redeemed, and back again come mid season 6 until he and Oliver reconcile. Where does he stand now?
Curtis: his Scrappy status was a package deal when the team split. Now that season 6 is over, is he still a Scrappy?
to:
*Andy: his character was off putting because of how inconsistent the writers were. John and his family spoke of him as a really cool and amazing person back in season 1. What we got onscreen in season 4 wasn\'t and his evil deeds came across as narmy. In the end, the viewers weren\'t meant to mourn him.
*Rene: he was a Scrappy in early season 5, then redeemed, and back again come mid season 6 until he and Oliver reconcile. Where does he stand now?
*Curtis: his Scrappy status was a package deal when the team split. Now that season 6 is over, is he still a Scrappy?
Top