Changed w/o discussion: Mistaken Identity

It was added with images of episode 3 of Osomatsu-san. While I think it illustrates the trope well, we can do with the middle 2 panels alone.

Agreed, or the first three; I'm good with either pending other options.

The middle two work just fine.

Seconded.

Middle two.

While not the greatest image, the top and bottom don't add anything of worth.

Personally not a fan of current. What was the original?

There's not one in the page history. I think the thread was meant to be under "Poor image."

Sorry, I don't know where "added without discussion" is supposed to go under.

It's not a thread reason because technically, Image Pickin' is not mandatory, though it is strongly advised to find the best image.

Any other opinions?

Btw, this trope is meant to be Played for Laughs which current is lacking.

That isn't showing a mistaken identity, though, since the other guy clearly knows that he's not Mega Man. And I'm not convinced that Played for Laughs is a necessary requirement for this trope.

Agreed all around.

I'm still going with the OP's suggestion.

edited 12th Nov '15 5:38:22 AM by TheUnsquished

^ Likewise.

Not really a fan of the OP/current. The text is kind of small, the green light is too prominent, and it relies entirely on the dialogue without showing any meaningful facial expressions like surprise. I say we find a comic to replace it because it's honestly really bad.

^ Concur

Any of this Sinfest strip, then?

1 + 3 might work.

Doing a tally (May change):

First three photos: 1 First two photos: 2 Second/Third photos: 1 First/Third photos: 1

Agreed, 1+3 is the best choice from that.

Something like this?

Yup.