Suggestion: Spontaneous Weapon Creation

This could use a good picture, plenty of ideas but the first one that comes to mind was Edward Elric's spear transmutation◊

Blurry and doesn't convey "spontaneous".

[1]◊ [2]◊ [3]◊ [4]◊ [5]◊ [6]◊ [7]◊ [8]◊ [9]◊ [10]◊ [11]◊

Stoneforge Mystic

edited 9th Apr '12 3:48:25 PM by Scardoll

That sequence works well enough...how's it look at 250 px?

Were you referring to me? If so then here (they are JP Gs though I can get PN Gs if ya want.)

Lets try this again, Manga panel version!◊

That looks good.

That's decent...something that shows the transmutation a little more clearly would be better.

I'll see what else I can find and the sequence is good but it looks a bit to much like Summon to Hand to me, which could us the picture if that is the case.

EDIT Here is one of Ed making a knife◊ and one of Al making a spear◊

edited 10th Apr '12 1:43:37 PM by lycropath

Could something be done with this image from this page of Strays?

edited 18th May '12 4:11:31 AM by MCE

I really like the bottom two "panels" of ; I think they show the trope very well. #1 and #7 don't show the spontanwous part. #3/#6 could do without one of the first two panels, but are otherwise very good. #4 looks fairly spontaneous, but it isn't instant like the others are. Neither in #9 are clear to me.

I like that best of everything so far...how's it look at wiki size?

Like this; it's my favourite as well. Text could be better:

edited 18th May '12 7:35:35 AM by Telcontar

Nice. Can you fit in the first conjuring panel above those, just for comparison's sake?

Sure thing; his grin is great!

edited 18th May '12 7:51:45 AM by Telcontar

Perfect.

Awesome.

So Cool Its Awesome

I support this suggestion.

Best of the bunch by far.

A couple more votes and we can run with it.

I'm a bit indifferent, but it's not bad.

That's six votes, counting mine. At least one more would do just nicely.

That's actually closer to nine votes, counting yours; it's on the page. Caption or no?

No, no, mine is just half a vote.

edited 23rd Jun '12 7:35:28 AM by Feather7603