The trouble is that austerity is feeding the rise of right- and left-wing parties and accelerating the decline of mainstream parties.
And how does austerity tie into the increasing threat of Russia — does Vladimir Putin see austerity as a sign of the economic and political weakness of Western Europe?
Keep Rolling OnPutin doesn't appear to understand economic inflation and some of the things he's done have really hurt the Russian economy for no good reason. I wouldn't be surprised if he turned out to be all for austerity, if only because he doesn't quite get what it is.
edited 22nd Feb '15 4:47:31 PM by Zendervai
Not Three Laws compliant.Greek debt crisis: German MPs back bailout extension
The extension - approved by creditors last week in exchange for a series of Greek government reforms - needs to be ratified by Eurozone members. Some MPs had expressed doubts about the deal and there is substantial public scepticism but the vote passed easily.
It comes after police and protesters clashed during anti-government demonstrations in Athens on Thursday. They were the first such disturbances since Greece's leftist Syriza was sworn in as the main government party exactly a month ago. Dozens of activists hurled petrol bombs and stones at police and set cars alight after a march involving hundreds of protesters.
Syriza swept to power in January by promising to renegotiate the country's debt and end austerity.
As the dominant economic power in the EU, Germany's approval was regarded as crucial - and on Friday the overwhelming majority of M Ps granted it. A total of 542 voted for the proposals, with 32 voting against and 13 abstentions. German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble spoke in favour of the deal, telling parliament: "We Germans should do everything possible to keep Europe together as much as we can."
"We're not talking about new billions for Greece... rather it's about providing or granting extra time to successfully end this programme," he insisted.
There has been a chorus of scepticism about the deal inside Germany - with Thursday's edition of the largest tabloid, Bild, emblazoned with the word "No!", adding "No more billions for the greedy Greeks!''
Hawkish elements within Mrs Merkel's CDU (Christian Democratic Union) and its Bavarian sister party, the CSU (Christian Social Union), have portrayed the extension deal as leniency for Greece. Mr Schaeuble himself has expressed doubt about the Greek government's commitment to reform.
But German legislators felt they had no choice but to pass the vote, as a eurozone breakup could prove even more expensive than the bailouts and potentially undermine the credibility of the euro, reports the BBC's Berlin correspondent Damien Mc Guinness.
In Greece, the proposed bailout extension has also triggered dissent within the governing party.
Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras has defended it, but some on the hard left have accused Syriza of going back on pre-election pledges. Meanwhile, even if the bailout extension goes through Greece still faces the formidable task of trying to service its debt obligations. It will need to flesh out its reform programme in detail by April and prove that reforms are bedding in before receiving a final disbursement of 7.2bn euros.
But in the meantime Greece has to repay several billion euros in maturing debts, including about 2bn euros to the IMF in March, and 6.7bn in European Central Bank bonds maturing in July and August.
Looks like this deal isn't entirely popular in both Germany and Greece.
edited 27th Feb '15 3:43:22 AM by Greenmantle
Keep Rolling OnBasically the non-brown right end of the CDU-CSU hate it because its too "lenient" and the left end of the greek government hate it because its too "cowing"?
Ah. Politics. The original Unpleasable Fanbase.
"You can reply to this Message!"Let's not even get started with the public.
It is sometimes an appropriate response to reality to go insane.One of the Golden Rules of Politics: You can never please everyone, because even in the best-case scenario, there will be a tiny minority, no matter how infinitesimal, who are fanatical ideologues, complete nutcases, or just utterly corrupt criminals/lawbreakers/anarchists that refuse to accept anything other than exactly what's on their mind.
edited 27th Feb '15 5:01:43 AM by MarqFJA
Fiat iustitia, et pereat mundus.He suggests that to constructively reduce the surplus, Germany should consider
- Investments in public infrastructure at a time when the quality of German infrastructure is on the decline.
- Raise the wages of German workers, something that in theory should be doable.
- Germany could encourage domestic spending via reforms such as tax incentives for private domestic investment, removing the barriers to building new homes, reforms in the retail and services industries, and review financial regulations potentially biasing German banks to invest overseas rather than home.
[Insert Comment Here How None Of This Is Viable Due To EU Treaties, Probably]
Some of that stuff is actually viable. Merkel's government, being right-wing, simply doesn't want to hear about spending or making reforms that may benefit the whole of the EU in the long run.
May a pox be cast upon her government that German roads have giant pot holes and that German sewer pipes rot, then.
Considering a lot of Europe's trade goes over German roads, that might be a problem.
Greece puts a figure [€279bn] on World War Two reparation claims from Germanynote
Greek governments and also private citizens have pushed for war damages from Germany for decades but the Greek government has never officially quantified its reparation claims.
A parliamentary panel set up by Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras's government started work last week, seeking to claim German debts, including war reparations, as well as the repayment of a so-called occupation loan that Nazi Germany forced the Bank of Greece to make and the return of stolen archaeological treasures.
Speaking at parliamentary committee, Deputy Finance Minister Dimitris Mardas said Berlin owed Athens 278.7 billion euros, according to calculations by the country's General Accounting Office. The occupation loan amounts to 10.3 billion euros.
The campaign for compensation has gained momentum in the past few years as Greeks have suffered hardship under austerity measures imposed by the European Union and International Monetary Fund in exchange for bailouts totaling 240 billion euros to save Greece from bankruptcy.
Tsipras has frequently blamed Germany for the hardship stemming from the imposition of austerity. He has angered Berlin by threatening to push for reparations in the middle of talks to unlock aid for Greece.
Germany has repeatedly rejected Greece's claims and says it has honored its obligations, including a 115 million deutschmark payment to Greece in 1960.
Looks like Greece is going for the Nazi approach.
Keep Rolling OnWell, it's going for the "you dirty Nazis still owe us" approach, as a counter to the "shifty Greeks" argument being made elsewhere. I doubt that it'll fly; it's more of a propaganda move.
"It's Occam's Shuriken! If the answer is elusive, never rule out ninjas!"What Greece should do is leave the EU, then re-apply for membership as a poor and corrupt Eastern European state. If you do that, the EU will give you lots of free money.
Schild und Schwert der ParteiMax System Munchkining.
What Greece should do is leave the EU. Period.
It is sometimes an appropriate response to reality to go insane.The EZ as it stands cannot survive. It must either adapt or dissolve. The EU is fine as a free trade zone, but as a monetary union, its Eurozone subgroup is in hospice, babbling in the throes of delirium.
edited 7th Apr '15 11:43:18 AM by Fighteer
"It's Occam's Shuriken! If the answer is elusive, never rule out ninjas!"We've been saying that since about 2009, never underestimate Europe's ability to muddle forward without fixing anything.
“And the Bunny nails it!” ~ Gabrael “If the UN can get through a day without everyone strangling everyone else so can we.” ~ CyranEconomist predicts that Tsipras is going to try to force the actual leftists out of his cabinet and implement Euro-sanctioned reforms. Hope he doesn't.
I highly doubt that Tsipras would do that. It would be a betrayal of everyone who voted for him.
"It's Occam's Shuriken! If the answer is elusive, never rule out ninjas!"So we're looking at a fifty-fifty chance then.
Yeah. We have seen a pattern of European governments riding in on reform tickets and then flipping the bird at their constituents.
However, in this case, if Tsipras tries something like this he will have to rebuild his coalition from scratch. Of course, if he doesn't, then we get a Greek default. Which would be good in some ways but far from ideal, despite being the clearest way to tell Europe "no, we were not elected to bow to your whim."
It might be interesting to see what effect a Greek Default might have on several Elections in EU Member States this year.
Keep Rolling On
Then again, most Greeks wanted to keep the Euro when they elected him... .
Either Tsirpas does what is necessary in order to keep the Euro or he'll leave. It is obvious that he doesn't react to anything but pressure so the other European governments should act accordingly.
Probably a beneficial one. If voters see that they can't just vote for populist movements and thus blackmail the creditors movements like Podemos will hopefully lose support and sanity prevails. I hope Merkel and Co. are keeping this in mind.
German politicians (others are guilty too) have been far too generous with Southern Europe. Now people believe that there is actually a third choice betwenn austerity and leaving the Euro. Time to set things straight, either you accept the conditions for bailing us out or not, is what needs to be conveyed.
edited 20th Apr '15 2:47:28 AM by Zarastro
He is a good ally for Merkel during the Ukraine crisis. And she did work close together with Sarkozy who might end up as a candidate for the next presidential elections.
Besides, there is not much you can do against the rise of right-wing parties, except of sticking to austerity and waiting for the economic recovery. Anything else would aid the Af D in Germany which would not be any better either.
edited 22nd Feb '15 2:59:11 PM by Zarastro