Changed without discussion.: Playing A Tree

The page image was replaced without discussion. This was the previous image:

I like either one, but seeing as I putted up the original image I support that one.

edited 11th Oct '11 5:02:41 PM by shark33

I like the current one, because the character dressed up as a tree looks annoyed and there are other actors onstage.

I could go with either.

I prefer the new one for the same reasons as .

Like the new one, shows a taller character with more emphasis that she's a tree.

I like the previous one better. There's too much emphasis on the other characters in the current one.

Oddly enough I don't mind the current for the same sort of reason: it emphasizes their relegation to the background. But maybe I'm too primed by seeing the old image first.

Crowner between the two, or just let a few more votes come in?

I could go either way, but I'm leaning towards the new one due to the fact that it has that "relegated to the background" element.

I think crowner would be the best.

However, what about this:

edited 16th Oct '11 10:48:14 AM by shark33

That's pretty good.

LOVE IT!

I like the quieter one better. Almost all of that text is unnecessary, and I find it distracting. The current pic conveys all of the same information, but more concisely. Show, Don't Tell.

I'm neutral on the Fate pic...it's the cleanest of the three options art-wise, but the others get the point across more quickly.

I'm ambivalent on the old pic versus the current pic, but the suggested one uses a lot of words when we've got good ones that do just fine without.

Crowner then?

Dammit to hell, I clicked the clock button again instead of the crowner. *sigh* The crowner's up; disregard the clock.

EDIT: Gotta say, after reading the description, I'm liking the Nanoha pic more and more.

edited 16th Oct '11 8:40:19 PM by Willbyr

Bumping for more votes.

This one's decisive enough that we can call it. The page is tagged, and the Image Links page is up. Locking up.