Who to be the image: The Scrappy.Western Animation

Okay, so the WA Scrappy page needs an image. I can't find a good one that would work here, but I recommend we use DW from Arthur.

Blast it, I can't figure out what you were trying to tag since the things that came to mind were all blank. Since I don't care about the Scrappy pages, I'm leaving.

I do wish you hadn't made this thread, we're trying to clear out the old ones.

The thread is made, so we might as well give it a shot.

I really, really hate it when people do the thread contrarian thing, but I will now for the sake of discussion.

Who is DW and why do we hate her? (Yes, I do know. Show me anyway.)

Courtesy link to Western Animation Scrappy

edited 9th Jun '11 8:34:11 PM by Zikiel

I vote imagless. This page and all the other Scrappy subpages.

Actually I would like to remove the JAFAAC Image of the trope namer on the mainpage too

Why not the Trope Namer? I thought that in certain cases, JAFAAC is acceptable (such as The Wesley image).

I think Eddie said the main page image is staying. I honestly think that having pictures for most audience reaction pages is a bad idea.

I'm inclined to agree.

I think it's possible, but only if we have a parody image, like say from a Web Comic.

Scrappy Doo is up on The Scrappy by admin fiat. I don't think this subpage needs an image anyway.

Honestly, I think it would be good policy not to have character interpretation images without a lampshade of some kind. It's going to encourage bickering.

I'm voting Imageless on the grounds of Not Necessary. Do we really need an image for every single sub-page?

Not to mention remembering how long the original The Scrappy IP was.

edited 12th Jun '11 2:53:32 PM by Mattonymy

Seconding that vote.

I'm voting imageless for now as well.

I think that we don't need a page image either. The pic of Scrappy-Doo himself on the main page is enough.

I forget which thread it was, but Eddie said that he'd prefer main trope pages to be imageless with pics on media-specific subpages. I dunno if we should do that with this specific one, though...

edited 22nd Aug '11 2:18:10 AM by Willbyr

I think it was Five-Man Band the live action one.

Yes, it was; however, in thinking about this some more, I think it'd be better to leave the Scrappy pic on the main page and leave this one without an image. Any serious yeas/nays before this gets locked?

I think it'd be better to use Scrappy-doo for the western animation page, and panel 7 of this VG Cats strip for the main Scrappy image as it shows a character's scrappy status being discussed.

Personally, I think we've been relying too much on comic strips lately.

I agree to keep the subpage imageless and use the Trope Namer on the main page.

edited 22nd Sep '11 2:31:41 PM by redhed311

The reliance is for a REASON. Namely that it's for tropes that need dialog to show them.

But that strip is bad because it would fit live action films, not western animation.

That`s why I suggested it for the main Scrappy page, not the western animation section.

Oops. Missed that. But the relevant panel doesn't really focus on the hate enough to show the trope well. Plus just mentioning a name is the other extreme of just a face and a caption, but no better.

Agreed. Clock set.

Clock's up; locking for inactivity/lack of consensus. No action is to be taken based on this thread.

Unlocking so it can be relocked and properly Morgued.