List of requests for The Nostalgia Critic

ADVENTURES OF AMERICAN RABBIT

SECONDING

And thirding for good measure.

Just, nobody tell him about that movie's biggest fan.

Looney Tunes Back In Action and Osmosis Jones.

The Flintstones in Viva Rock Vegas

Osmosis Jones is awesome, dude.

Anyway, Freddy Got Fingered would be fine. I know Nostalgia Chick reviewed it, but I didn't like that review anyway. Nostalgia Critic would just fit that movie better.

I would imagine the "don't do anything Chick has done" (X Men is slightly different because different focus) rule is still in effect.

edited 2nd Feb '13 7:46:18 PM by emeriin

Old Nostalgia Critic would fit it, This is Newer Wiser and Fresher NC!

Doug and Lindsey tend to be pretty good at not overlapping each other, its not really a rule more like a courtesy.

Him and Brad should team up and reveiw... The most Nostalgic of Pornos!

edited 2nd Feb '13 7:50:23 PM by FrozenWolf

Adding to that, a Cartoon Network special in which he picks five Cartoon Cartoons and reviews them would kick ass. Also, for December, Christmas With The Kranks.

Didn't Film Brain trash that extensively?

Yeah back in 09

He should Do Step Monster for Nostalgia Ween...

Yeah!!

edited 2nd Feb '13 7:53:29 PM by FrozenWolf

Reviewer dibs IS NOT A THING. Can we please stop saying "X already did that"? It's really old. The whole point of media criticism is to give an informed opinion and to point out things the audience may not get on a first watching, so there's no reason why two critics can't review the same piece of media if they have different things to say about it.

"Oh geez, Roger Ebert already reviewed this movie! Guess I have nothing worthwhile to say about it!"

edited 2nd Feb '13 8:08:40 PM by Filby

I'd also be interested in hearing what he thinks of Scooby Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed.

And I agree with Filby. There is nothing wrong with overlapping a bit.

Nash's put it best, They'll review something if they think they have something new to say about it

edited 2nd Feb '13 8:11:06 PM by FrozenWolf

Precisely.

The TGWTG crew themselves have addressed "reviewer dibs" so many times, there's no point in even talking about it at all.

On the subject of weird old animated features, I think Doug could do a lot with Felidae, a German cartoon (with an English dub) that looks like a cute movie about cats, but features grisly murders and a graphic sex scene. That's easy to make fun of in the same way as Watership Down ("I thought it was a movie about happy bunnies!").

But Felidae's good...

So's Watership Down for that matter.

edited 3rd Feb '13 1:17:55 PM by kalel94

Don't forget The Plague Dogs film.

edited 3rd Feb '13 1:19:31 PM by brb1006

He said he wouldn't do Watership Down because it's not bad, it was just dark.

He can still do funny reviews of good movies.

Maybe that Raggedy Ann and Andy movie? He alluded to how freaky it was in his "Nostalgic Mindfucks" video, but I think it could be stretched out to a full-length review.

Also the Rankin-Bass Return of the King. "Where There's a Whip There's a Way", etc.

ETA: Also, I just now discovered Adventures in Dinosaur City. Now that looks good and stupid.

edited 3rd Feb '13 1:47:49 PM by Filby

Meet the Deedles?

I wanna see The Last Starfighter.

"Mac and Me" ought to get a lot of laughs. He should do that.

I'm surprised he hasn't reviews that movie yet. Heck, he it mentioned the movie years ago!