History YMMV / WhattheFuckisWrongwithyou

* ArchivePanic: The live show has been running almost every single week for close to ten years, with episodes running from thirty minutes to an hour, totaling somewhere over 300 episodes as of March 2017.

** The logical end point of any discussion Nash, Tara and the Radio Dead Air chatroom share in trying to understand how one of the bizarre stories they encounter could have possibly happened and the results that occur when [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome reality ensues]].

* TheWoobie: Stick Boy. During "Tainted Love", he has a crush on WebVideo/ObscurusLupa...only for her to reject him, and then get threatened by WebVideo/ToddInTheShadows.

* AcceptableTargets:
** While often very quick to jump on Tara for [[PoliticallyIncorrectHero "upsetting geographical locations"]] Nash himself has a particular penchant for [[YellowPeril mocking the Chinese]].
** Tara has demonstrated a talent for [[ThoseWackyNazis offending Nazis]].
** [[OnlyInFlorida Florida]] is a common source of consternation and mockery.

** The first story for the show on 9/23/2019: [[spoiler: Blaze hits bull artificial insemination facility, causing a ''massive semen explosion'']]! Nash, [[WebVideo/RockedReviews Luke]], and the chat reacted exactly how'd you'd expect.

** In one episode, Tara suggests Disney buy the rights to the Film/XMenFilmSeries for a YaoiFangirl related joke. Disney took her advice UpToEleven in late 2018, since they bought Fox in it's entirety.

** Taken UpToEleven when somebody has sex ''with a dead squid.'' Which, as theorized by Nash, will spawn '''[[EldritchAbomination CTHULHU.]]'''

** When Nash played ''VideoGame/XCOM2'' again in late 2017/early 2018, he discovered Igor's successor: Wilhelm Vos, a soldier who started his career in a pair of [[WhoWearsShortShorts hotpants]] and developed into a badass Sniper for the ages. Needless to say, once he earned his nickname, Nash immediately changed it to "Hotpants"[[note]]Though sadly, once he developed advanced armors the hotpants were no longer available as a clothing option[[/note]].

* '''{{Squick}}''': The stories featured on the show tend to be... kind of gross at best, and absolutely horrifying at worst.

* TheWoobie: Stick Boy. During "Tainted Love", he has a crush on WebVideo/ObscurusLupa...only for her to reject him, and then get threatened by WebVideo/ToddInTheShadows.
** Nash himself following him losing his job and Jesu Otaku cheating on then breaking up with him in the same week. Seriously, the guy looks like he needs more hugs and puppies then Doug does when he's depressed. Some fans have noted that 2013 just ''sucked'' for the guy.
*** Especially since he's now suffering from insomnia.
*** And now his dad has died as well.
----

* WhatAnIdiot: The standard reaction to the stories on the show.

** Nash himself following him losing his job and he and Hope cheating on then breaking up with him in the same week. Seriously, the guy looks like he needs more hugs and puppies then Doug does when he's depressed. Some fans have noted that 2013 just ''sucked'' for the guy.

* FunnyAneurysmMoment:

* HarsherInHindsight: During the 12/10/12 show, they had a story where something bad happens to a child in Connecticut. There's a moment of realization for Tara that it happened in Connecticut (because she lives there) and Nash laughs at that. But for anyone watching when it was posted later, after a certain tragic event that happened in Connecticut... Nash's laugh might have seemed inappropriate. (The comments on Blip and TGWTG were quick to point this out.)

* SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped: WTFIWWY may tend to feel a bit {{Anvilicious}} at times, since Nash and Tara will often repeat certain morals multiple times throughout an episode... But it's completely justified because most of those morals are things that should be common knowledge or common sense. However, the staggering amount of idiots who do stupid or dangerous things proves that, yes, those morals bear repeating.

* CrazyAwesome: William Todd from "Walmart Chemical Warfare," a man who committed 11 felonies in Nashville, Tennessee. Including, but not limited to, jacking a Slaughterhouse (a gun shop), two cabbies, four people leaving a bar, a Canadian couple and ransacking a law firm. [[RefugeInAudacity All in NINE HOURS]]. It's the frickin' RealLife ''VideoGame/GrandTheftAuto''!

** Florida is a common source of consternation and mockery.

** In fact, Nash has a knack for choosing appropriate music for the situation at hand, which is understandable given his line of work. A crowning example of this would be in his ''Top Classic Doctors'' review, where he managed to choose perfect songs to represent each Doctor [[note]] "The Man Comes Around" by Music/JohnnyCash for Creator/WilliamHartnell; "Road to Nowhere" by Music/TalkingHeads for Creator/PatrickTroughton; "Secret Agent Man" by Music/JohnnyWinters for Creator/JonPertwee; "Magical Mystery Tour" by Music/TheBeatles for Creator/TomBaker; "Goody Two Shoes" by Music/AdamAnt" for Creator/PeterDavison; "Cruel to Be Kind" by Music/NickLowe for Creator/ColinBaker; and "No More Mister Nice Guy" by Music/AliceCooper for Creator/SylvesterMcCoy[[/note]].

** In fact, Nash has a knack for choosing appropriate music for the situation at hand, which is understandable given his line of work. A crowning example of this would be in his ''Top Classic Doctors'' review, where he managed to choose perfect songs to represent each Doctor.

* ArchivePanic: The live show has been running almost every single week for close to seven years, with episodes running from thirty minutes to an hour, totaling somewhere over 300 episodes as of March 2017.

*** There's also the infamous real life [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hello_Kitty_murder Hello Kitty murder]], which is so vile that it's frequently mistaken for an urban legend.