* AngstWhatAngst: Evil Eb is more annoyed than angry about The Man With No Name killing all of his friends; [[spoiler: they even become drinking buddies after their duel.]]
* BigLippedAlligatorMoment:
** The cutscene where the Clint Eastwood expy asks the Creator/LeeVanCleef expy if he can give him the time. The latter looks at his poorly drawn stopwatch with a creepy real-life photo of a girl for about 20 seconds while loud organ music plays before saying "no".
** Since all gang members except for Wild Card [=McVee=] are encountered by simply entering and exiting any building, the majority of things The Man With No Name does are amusing yet practically pointless in the long run.
* BileFascination: The game attracts a lot of people wanting to see the DerangedAnimation, the {{Jerkass}} tendencies of the The Man With No Name, and the generally bizarre things that happen.
* CrossesTheLineTwice: The Man With No Name killing a child for getting his name wrong while smiling and being on a train that then goes to space at warp speed. And that's the bad ending.
* DesignatedHero: The Man With No Name barely does anything that can be considered heroic. Most of time, he just dicks around doing nothing and doesn't even look for his sister, which is the reason why he is in The Town With No Name in the first place. He is a jackass to everyone he meets in the game and he even has the option to ''[[TooDumbToLive try to kill the Clint Eastwood expy]]''. And when you get the bad ending, he kills a child for [[{{Film/Shane}} getting his name wrong]].
* MemeticMutation
** The bartender squinting angrily for some reason when the Man with No Name asks for a drink.
** Also the Undertaker, AKA [[{{WebVideo/Retsupurae}} "Retard Abraham Lincoln"]].
** [[{{WouldHurtAChild}} "My name's not Shane, kid"]]
* ScrappyMechanic: The [[{{Permadeath}} lack of checkpoints]] makes playing it all over a chore, since the cutscenes bar the intro aren't skippable and each scene loads between each other.
* SoBadItsGood: For a game trying to parody the Western and have comedic elements in it, it fails so hard that it somehow warps back to being hysterical.
* ThatOneBoss: Wildcard Mc Vee for being the cheapest in the game. You can only fight him after beating him in a card game [[note]][[GuideDangIt after defeating Crafty Clint; your opponent is the Bartender if you play the card game beforehand]][[/note]], after which he challenges you to a duel outside. [[spoiler: He's lying and will instead immediately shoot you dead unless after winning the card game you immediately gun him down ''before'' he finishes making his offer for a duel. [[GuideDangIt There's no way to know this in advance.]]]]
* UncannyValley: Some of the Man With No Name's (and everyone else's) facial expressions are unsettling.
* WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs: Certainly has that feeling with random surreal elements such as the priest that floats to heaven or the train that goes to space in one of the endings.