YMMV / The Muppets Mayhem

• Awesome Music: The show's theme song "Rock On" is extremely catchy and will stay in your head for days. Truly, the Electric Mayhem are back.
• Just Here for Godzilla: Fans and Critics praise the stuff with the band and don’t care for the human characters.
• Memetic Mutation: Meet the Feebles is now Disney canon.^Explanation  In the guest appearance by Peter Jackson, it’s casually (albeit understandably uncomfortably) stated that the gang had previously encountered Jackson while working with the Feebles, puppet characters that engaged in murder, drug use, and BDSM, among other ghastly activities, and that two unnamed Feebles are in witness protection after that night while the rest are unsurprisingly in prison. It’s a darkly hilarious moment, but it’s definitely surprising for those in the know that Disney would choose to acknowledge such a controversial and adult parody on a family program.
• One-Scene Wonder: After years of his only appearance with the Muppets being a magazine shoot with Fozzie Bear, "Weird Al" Yankovic finally makes a proper appearance with the Muppets in the form of a scene in episode 5 where Floyd hallucinates talking to him like Mufasa in a parody of The Lion King. And it is GLORIOUS.
• Romantic Plot Tumor: The Love Triangle between Nora, Moog, and JJ is rather unanimously considered the weakest part of the show among the fanbase, due to being a time-stealing and confusing-to-follow romantic subplot between humans that takes the spotlight away from the Muppets.
• The Scrappy: In a show where the human characters have caused plenty of Broken Base between those who dislike them on default for being humans in a Muppet production and those who admit they are, for the most part, actually quite likable this time around, JJ stands out as having practically no fans. He is widely considered a Jerkass Karma Houdini that the story seems to be unable to decide whether he is supposed to be likable or an antagonist, and he also is heavily associated with the show's widely panned Romantic Plot Tumor Love Triangle between Nora, Moog, and JJ as unlike the other two, he has very few scenes outside of it.
• Signature Scene: The flashback in episode 3 of Floyd taking in Animal as a Doorstep Baby is possibly the mostly famous scene in the show due to its sheer heartwarming nature.
• Squick: There's an excessive amount of focus on Penny Waxman's feet, to the point where it felt almost fetishistic to some (though not as extreme as anything by Dan Schneider). Particularly infamous within the Muppet fandom is a scene in episode 4 where Doctor Teeth is behind her desk and he tells her that he's going to "show [her] what happened to the little piggy that stayed home", which the camera very mercifully cuts away from before we see what the two puppets do next.