These are what we call the 'YMMV items.' Things that some people find in this work. We call them 'your mileage might vary' because not everyone sees these things in the same way. This starts discussions in the trope lists, a thing we don't want. Please use the discussion page if you'd like to discuss any of these items.
"First Zod falls in love with Lana, now Bizarro? Is Brainiac next? Hey, I have an awesome idea, Al and Miles. Let's introduce Doomsday, but instead of being evil, he falls in love with Lana! I'm a fucking genius! I just wrote Season 8!"
Similarly, Sara M of the House recaps makes a sarcastic prediction for the finale which actually applies freakishly well to the real finale.
Also, a Gilmore Girls recap contained a reference to an "Unamed Jared Padalecki Project," (Supernatural, natch) and predicted it would be canceled quickly. Nine seasons later . . .
There is a school of former readers who felt that TWOP has, itself, Jumped the Shark after being sold to NBC (who runs it under the Bravo brand name), causing the site to quickly lose its teeth.
Others have complained that some recappers are more whiny than snarky, especially when they give up and begin flat-out hating the show they're recapping. Snark is funny, relentless loathing isn't. In particular, the forums are known for being filled with Hatedoms.
Know-Nothing Know-It-All: According to the rules, users aren't allowed to talk about shows unless they're airing. Since often mods don't bother watching the shows they're supposed to moderate comments on, this has led to said mods going on banning sprees several episodes into a new season, not realizing (or caring) that a new season has started, or that developments the commenters are talking about are actually happening on the show.
Lawful Stupid: The board moderation in general is highly stringent to begin with, but the rule about "no talking about the boards on the boards" has, in particular, led to many accusations (fair or otherwise) of moderating that is over-draconian, unfair and less-than-ethical.
Small Name, Big Ego: The site—or at least several of its key contributors—is also rather notorious for being unusually thin-skinned about criticism of itself (which, given the mission statement of the site, is a bit ironic).