YMMV / Smile HD

• Awesome Music: The only thing people can agree on about this video is that the Foozogz remix of "Smile, Smile, Smile" playing as background music is awesome.
• Crosses the Line Twice: First Pinkie kicks Twilight's head off and Rarity's brains out and starts beating Applejack senseless before being stopped by Rainbow Dash. Then she maxes out her Kill-O-Meter and starts handing out Ki Manipulation, the last of which blows up the entire planet.
• Hilarious in Hindsight: Many comments have been made comparing this fanvid to Dragon Ball Z. Cue Twilight's Kingdom, and a DBZ style fight against Tirek.
• Nightmare Fuel: The fact that Pinkie Pie violently kills her friends and destroys the Earth. Not helped by Fluttershy screaming in horror and then burning as Pinkie explodes the planet.
• Special Effect Failure: Most of the animation is stellar, but in one shot when Pinkie is seen from the back as she runs toward the picnic, her tail is noticeably flat and two-dimensional.
• Spoiled by the Format: Rainbow Dash flies down and throw a Sonic Rainboom-powered Diving Kick directly into Pinkie's face, seemingly saving the day...but the song is only halfway over.
• Tear Jerker: It can be particularly hard watching Applejack get beat up - you get a close up of her face as it's happening and she's clearly scared and crying. Then again, she deserved it, for appearing happy at Rarity getting her brains bashed out.

---