YMMV / Seven Pounds

This film contains examples of:

  • Accidental Aesop: It's most likely unintentional, but the cause of the car crash was Tim checking his cell phone while driving. Talk about an unfair consequence.
  • Anvilicious: The two "good" people focused on in the film are vegetarian and one of them has forced her Great Dane to be. You need serious, in-depth work with a qualified vet to even attempt that, because dogs naturally want some meat and you'd have to carefully select the foods they get. Just broccoli and tofu would not cut it and the dog would die of malnutrition.
  • Berserk Button: For some viewers, the protaganist's plan, and the implied Aesop that comes with it were this, especially amongst viewers who knew someone who killed themselves. The movie seriously pissed off Film Brain for this very reason.
  • Critical Dissonance: In contrast of the negative critical reception, this film holds a 7.7/10 from over 245,000 votes on IMDb, putting it firmly in the Top 1000 list.
  • Critical Research Failure:
    • Death by jellyfish would result in your organs being totally unsuitable for transplantation. Also, you can't choose whom your organs will go to.
    • Also, there's Thomas having sex with a woman with heart failure. Clearly that could not have ended badly.
  • Designated Hero: Thomas' actions seem very stalkerish, bizarre, and just plain unsettling throughout the course of the movie. Not to mention that he committed two felonies and in the end killed himself.
  • Esoteric Happy Ending: The film attempting to portray Thomas' sacrifice by committing suicide so that he donates everything he has to people in need as a happy ending.
  • Family-Unfriendly Aesop: Killing yourself is good, if you donate your organs. Also, to make sure your organs go to the right people, impersonate a member of the IRS to stalk them. Preferably a family member so they do not report you to the police.
    • Not standing up to a torrent of abuse from a total stranger is unarguable evidence that you are a good person.
  • Fridge Horror: One of the people Thomas helps is a poor woman who has been suffering mistreatment at the hands of her abusive partner; he helps her by giving his fancy house next to the beach to her and her children to live in it. Thinking it a little bit through, he just left a big and expensive house to a person who very likely doesn't have the means to maintain it; worse, this woman already has a history of breaking up and returning with her abusive partner. Chances are this isn't going to end well.
  • Glurge: The movie tries to make suicide into a moral victory.
  • Narm: The ridiculous use of music in this movie, especially in the suicide scene itself which includes the over dramatic score.
  • Nightmare Fuel: Seriously, death by jellyfish.
  • They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot: The basic premise of a man using unconventional means to help the needy is a solid one. Too bad those means here are either illegal or not well-thought out.
  • What an Idiot!: You want to donate all your organs to charity, so you inject yourself with a natural neurotoxin. If any of your vital organs are functional after that, it's a damn miracle.